CAT 2019 Slot 1 DILR Q16
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2019_SLOT1_DILR_Q16
Data set · questions 13–16
A supermarket has to place 12 items (coded A to L) in shelves numbered 1 to 16. Five of these items are types of biscuits, three are types of candies and the rest are types of savouries. Only one item can be kept in a shelf. Items are to be placed such that all items of same type are clustered together with no empty shelf between items of the same type and at least one empty shelf between two different types of items. At most two empty shelves can have consecutive numbers.
The following additional facts are known.
- A and B are to be placed in consecutively numbered shelves in increasing order.
- I and J are to be placed in consecutively numbered shelves both higher numbered than the shelves in which A and B are kept.
- D, E and F are savouries and are to be placed in consecutively numbered shelves in increasing order after all the biscuits and candies.
- K is to be placed in shelf number 16.
- L and J are items of the same type, while H is an item of a different type.
- C is a candy and is to be placed in a shelf preceded by two empty shelves.
- L is to be placed in a shelf preceded by exactly one empty shelf.
Question 16
Which of the following statements is necessarily true?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
There are at least four shelves between items B and C.
Solution
Concept: Invariant Inter-Item Distance Verification, Modal Logic & Branch Robustness
Master State Table
| Shelf | Config 1 (Candies 1st) | Config 2 (Biscuits 1st) | Item Type / Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | [Empty] | [Empty] | Buffer Shelf |
| 2 | [Empty] | L | Empty / Biscuit |
| 3 | C | A | Candy / Biscuit |
| 4 | G / H | B | Candy / Biscuit |
| 5 | H / G | I / J | Candy / Biscuit |
| 6 | [Empty] | J / I | Buffer / Biscuit |
| 7 | L | [Empty] | Biscuit / Buffer |
| 8 | A | [Empty] | Biscuit / Buffer |
| 9 | B | C | Biscuit / Candy |
| 10 | I / J | G / H | Biscuit / Candy |
| 11 | J / I | H / G | Biscuit / Candy |
| 12 | [Empty] | [Empty] | Buffer (Invariantly Empty) |
| 13 | D | D | Savoury (Invariant) |
| 14 | E | E | Savoury (Invariant) |
| 15 | F | F | Savoury (Invariant) |
| 16 | K | K | Savoury (Fixed: Clue 4) |
Question Deduction
• Structural Sequence Framework:
• A statement is necessarily true if it holds across both valid macro configurations:
• Config 1: Candies at shelves 3–5, Biscuits at shelves 7–11, Savouries at shelves 13–16.
• Config 2: Biscuits at shelves 2–6, Candies at shelves 9–11, Savouries at shelves 13–16.
• Tracking Exact Positions of B and C:
• Item C: First in Candies (Clue 6) shelf 3 in Config 1; shelf 9 in Config 2.
• Item B: In any 5-biscuit block at shelf , positions are at (Clue 7), at , and at (Clue 1).
• Config 1 ($s=7$): B is at shelf $7 + 2 = 9$.
• Config 2 ($s=2$): B is at shelf $2 + 2 = 4$.
• Inter-Shelf Distance Analysis Between B and C:
• Shelves strictly between shelf and shelf is :
• **Config 1**: C at 3, B at 9 $\implies$ shelves $\{4, 5, 6, 7, 8\}$, giving $9 - 3 - 1 = 5$ shelves.
• **Config 2**: B at 4, C at 9 $\implies$ shelves $\{5, 6, 7, 8\}$, giving $9 - 4 - 1 = 4$ shelves.
• In both configurations, intervening shelves are .
• Thus, "There are at least four shelves between items B and C" is universally true.
• Option Matching & Distractor Elimination:
• Option 1: Necessarily true as proven (5 shelves in Config 1; 4 shelves in Config 2).
• Option 2: False in Config 1; only shelf 6 separates Candies and Biscuits.
• Option 3: False in Config 2; Biscuits precede Candies.
• Option 4: False in Config 1; Candies precede Biscuits.
• Confirms Option 1.
Topper Take
• Counterexample triage: Options 3 and 4 fail in alternate configurations. Option 2 fails in Config 1 (only shelf 6 is empty between them).
• Distance verification for Option 1: In Config 1, . In Config 2, . Minimum distance is 4, guaranteeing Option 1 instantly.
Other questions in this set
- Q13. In how many different ways can the items be arranged on the shelves?
- Q14. Which of the following items is not a type of biscuit?
- Q15. Which of the following can represent the numbers of the empty shelves in a possible arrangement?
Arrangements questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc