CAT 2018 Slot 2 VARC Q23

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Science
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT2_VARC_Q23

Passage · questions 21–24

Grove snails as a whole are distributed all over Europe, but a specific variety of the snail, with a distinctive white-lipped shell, is found exclusively in Ireland and in the Pyrenees mountains that lie on the border between France and Spain. The researchers sampled a total of 423423 snail specimens from 3636 sites distributed across Europe, with an emphasis on gathering large numbers of the white-lipped variety. When they sequenced genes from the mitochondrial DNA of each of these snails and used algorithms to analyze the genetic diversity between them, they found that a distinct lineage (the snails with the whitelipped shells) was indeed endemic to the two very specific and distant places in question.

Explaining this is tricky. Previously, some had speculated that the strange distributions of creatures such as the white-lipped grove snails could be explained by convergent evolution in which two populations evolve the same trait by coincidence but the underlying genetic similarities between the two groups rules that out. Alternately, some scientists had suggested that the white-lipped variety had simply spread over the whole continent, then been wiped out everywhere besides Ireland and the Pyrenees, but the researchers say their sampling and subsequent DNA analysis eliminate that possibility too. "If the snails naturally colonized Ireland, you would expect to find some of the same genetic type in other areas of Europe, especially Britain. We just don't find them," Davidson, the lead author, said in a press statement.

Moreover, if they'd gradually spread across the continent, there would be some genetic variation within the white-lipped type, because evolution would introduce variety over the thousands of years it would have taken them to spread from the Pyrenees to Ireland. That variation doesn't exist, at least in the genes sampled. This means that rather than the organism gradually expanding its range, large populations instead were somehow moved en mass to the other location within the space of a few dozen generations, ensuring a lack of genetic variety.

"There is a very clear pattern, which is difficult to explain except by involving humans," Davidson said. Humans, after all, colonized Ireland roughly 9,000 years ago, and the oldest fossil evidence of grove snails in Ireland dates to roughly the same era. Additionally, there is archaeological evidence of early sea trade between the ancient peoples of Spain and Ireland via the Atlantic and even evidence that humans routinely ate these types of snails before the advent of agriculture, as their burnt shells have been found in Stone Age trash heaps.

The simplest explanation, then? Boats. These snails may have inadvertently traveled on the floor of the small, coast-hugging skiffs these early humans used for travel, or they may have been intentionally carried to Ireland by the seafarers as a food source. "The highways of the past were rivers and the ocean-as the river that flanks the Pyrenees was an ancient trade route to the Atlantic, what we're actually seeing might be the long lasting legacy of snails that hitched a ride as humans travelled from the South of France to Ireland 8,000 years ago," Davidson said.

Question 23

All of the following evidence supports the passage's explanation of sea travel/trade EXCEPT:

  1. A

    archaeological evidence of early sea trade between the ancient peoples of Spain and Ireland via the Atlantic Ocean.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    the coincidental existence of similar traits in the white-lipped grove snails of Ireland and the Pyrenees because of convergent evolution.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    absence of genetic variation within the white-lipped grove snails of Ireland and the Pyrenees, whose genes were sampled.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    the oldest fossil evidence of white-lipped grove snails in Ireland dates back to roughly 9,000 years ago, the time when humans colonised Ireland.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

the coincidental existence of similar traits in the white-lipped grove snails of Ireland and the Pyrenees because of convergent evolution.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Negative Detail / 'EXCEPT' Question

  • Passage Reference:

"Previously, some had speculated that the strange distributions of creatures such as the white-lipped grove snails could be explained by convergent evolution in which two populations evolve the same trait by coincidence but the underlying genetic similarities between the two groups rules that out."

"This means that rather than the organism gradually expanding its range, large populations instead were somehow moved en mass to the other location within the space of a few dozen generations, ensuring a lack of genetic variety."

"Humans, after all, colonized Ireland roughly 9,000 years ago, and the oldest fossil evidence of grove snails in Ireland dates to roughly the same era. Additionally, there is archaeological evidence of early sea trade between the ancient peoples of Spain and Ireland via the Atlantic..."

Logical Deduction

The author builds a cumulative evidentiary case for sea travel/trade using three key pillars:

  1. Archaeological evidence of early Atlantic sea trade routes connecting Spain and Ireland (validating Option 1).

  2. Population genetics showing a complete lack of genetic variation, proving rapid en masse transport across the ocean rather than gradual terrestrial dispersal (validating Option 3).

  3. Fossil records demonstrating that grove snails first appeared in Ireland ~9,000 years ago, perfectly coinciding with the arrival of the first human settlers (validating Option 4).

Conversely, convergent evolution is an alternative hypothesis that the author explicitly refutes. Convergent evolution assumes independent, coincidental adaptation without physical contact or trade, directly contradicting the sea travel theory.

Correct Answer: Option 2

  • Option 2 does NOT support the sea travel explanation; convergent evolution is a rival hypothesis explicitly rejected by the author because genetic data proves a shared, transported lineage.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Factual Distortion / True Evidence - Falsifies 'EXCEPT'): Explicitly cited in Paragraph 4 as archaeological proof supporting maritime communication and trade between Spain and Ireland.

  • Option 3 (Factual Distortion / True Evidence - Falsifies 'EXCEPT'): Explicitly cited in Paragraph 3 as genetic proof that snails were moved en masse over a few generations rather than evolving gradually.

  • Option 4 (Factual Distortion / True Evidence - Falsifies 'EXCEPT'): Explicitly cited in Paragraph 4 as chronological proof linking the arrival of humans with the appearance of grove snails in Ireland.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The passage investigates the anomalous disjunct geographical distribution of white-lipped grove snails—found exclusively in Ireland and the Pyrenees—and demonstrates through mitochondrial DNA analysis and archaeological evidence that this pattern cannot be explained by natural colonization or convergent evolution, but rather by human-mediated transport via prehistoric maritime trade routes.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Establishes the biological puzzle: white-lipped grove snails inhabit only two geographically isolated regions (Ireland and the Pyrenees); mitochondrial DNA testing confirms they share a distinct, identical genetic lineage.

  • Paragraph 2: Refutes two classical evolutionary hypotheses: convergent evolution is eliminated due to deep genetic identity, and natural continental gradual spread followed by widespread extinction is disproved by the total absence of this genetic type in intervening regions like Britain.

  • Paragraph 3: Details why gradual overland dispersal is genetically impossible: the snails exhibit a total lack of internal genetic variation, proving they were translocated en masse within a narrow window of a few dozen generations.

  • Paragraph 4: Introduces the anthropogenic hypothesis, correlating the 9,000-year-old arrival of humans in Ireland with the oldest snail fossils, supported by archaeological evidence of ancient Atlantic maritime trade and snail consumption in Stone Age middens.

  • Paragraph 5: Concludes that early humans transported the snails by boat—either inadvertently on the floors of skiffs or intentionally as provisions—linking Pyrenean river routes, the Atlantic, and prehistoric maritime travel to modern biogeography.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Academic, Scientific, Inquisitive, and Deductive.

  • Author's Perspective: The author endorses Davidson’s multidisciplinary research, integrating population genetics and archaeology to construct a compelling empirical case for anthropogenic introduction.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q21. Which one of the following makes the author eliminate convergent evolution as a probable explanation for why…
  2. Q22. The passage outlines several hypotheses and evidence related to white-lipped grove snails to arrive at the most…
  3. Q24. In paragraph 4, the evidence that "humans routinely ate these types of snails before the advent of agriculture" can be…

Science questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q13
    Which one of the options below best summarises the passage?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q14
    The passage suggests that contact tracing apps could inadvertently raise risky interactions by altering…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q15
    All of the following inferences are supported by the passage EXCEPT that:
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q16
    Which one of the following observations would most strengthen the passage’s claim that a first-order tail…
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q6
    On the basis of the information in the passage, what is the most likely function of carotenoids in Mexican…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc