CAT 2017 Slot 1 VARC Q19
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Science
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2017_SLOT1_VARC_Q19
Passage · questions 19–21
Scientists have long recognised the incredible diversity within a species. But they thought it reflected evolutionary changes that unfolded imperceptibly, over millions of years. That divergence between populations within a species was enforced, according to Ernst Mayr, the great evolutionary biologist of the 1940s, when a population was separated from the rest of the species by a mountain range or a desert, preventing breeding across the divide over geologic scales of time. Without the separation, gene flow was relentless. But as the separation persisted, the isolated population grew apart and speciation occurred.
In the mid-1960s, the biologist Paul Ehrlich author of The Population Bomb (1968) and his Stanford University colleague Peter Raven challenged Mayr's ideas about speciation. They had studied checkerspot butterflies living in the Jasper Ridge Biological Preserve in Califomia, and it soon became clear that they were not examining a single population. Through years of capturing, marking and then recapturing the butterflies, they were able to prove that within the population, spread over just acres of suitable checkerspot habitat, there were three groups that rarely interacted despite their very close proximity.
Among other ideas, Ehrlich and Raven argued in a now classic paper from that gene flow was not as predictable and ubiquitous as Mayr and his cohort maintained, and thus evolutionary divergence between neighbouring groups in a population was probably common. They also asserted that isolation and gene flow were less important to evolutionary divergence than natural selection (when factors such as mate choice, weather, disease or predation cause better-adapted individuals to survive and pass on their successful genetic traits). For example, Ehrlich and Raven suggested that, without the force of natural selection, an isolated population would remain unchanged and that, in other scenarios, natural selection could be strong enough to overpower gene flow.
Question 19
Which one of the following best sums up Ehrlich and Raven's argument in their classic 1969 paper?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
While a factor, isolation was not as important to speciation as natural selection
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Main Argument / Summarizing Thesis
-
Passage Reference:
"They also asserted that isolation and gene flow were less important to evolutionary divergence than natural selection (when factors such as mate choice, weather, disease or predation cause better-adapted individuals to survive and pass on their successful genetic traits). For example, Ehrlich and Raven suggested that, without the force of natural selection, an isolated population would remain unchanged and that, in other scenarios, natural selection could be strong enough to overpower gene flow."
Logical Deduction
The question asks for the overarching thesis of Ehrlich and Raven's landmark 1969 paper. In Paragraph 3, the author explicitly summarizes their core theoretical claim: "isolation and gene flow were less important to evolutionary divergence than natural selection." They posited that physical isolation alone could not alter a population without natural selection, and conversely, that natural selection could override gene flow even without physical barriers. An accurate summary must capture this primary theoretical hierarchy: isolation is secondary, while natural selection is the paramount driver of speciation.
Correct Answer: Option 3
- Option 3 directly encapsulates their central theoretical thesis as formulated in Paragraph 3: physical isolation, while playing a role, is subordinate to natural selection in driving evolutionary divergence and speciation.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Extreme Generalization): Overstates their stance; Ehrlich and Raven did not claim physical isolation plays zero role in divergence, but rather that it is "less important ... than natural selection" and insufficient on its own.
-
Option 2 (Incomplete Fact): Refers to the empirical case study and field observations conducted at Jasper Ridge (detailed in Paragraph 2), which served as the evidential basis rather than the broad theoretical argument of their 1969 paper.
-
Option 4 (Incomplete Fact): Highlights an intermediate premise regarding the erratic nature of gene flow, failing to encompass their primary conclusion that natural selection is the decisive evolutionary driver.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The passage details a major theoretical paradigm shift in evolutionary biology, contrasting Ernst Mayr's classical doctrine of allopatric speciation via prolonged geographic isolation with Ehrlich and Raven's groundbreaking framework, which demonstrates that natural selection—rather than geographic barriers—is the primary driver of speciation and genetic divergence.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Outlines Ernst Mayr's traditional 1940s model of speciation, which posited that species divergence requires persistent physical separation (such as mountain ranges or deserts) across geological epochs to halt relentless gene flow.
-
Paragraph 2: Introduces empirical field research by Paul Ehrlich and Peter Raven on checkerspot butterflies at Jasper Ridge, proving through capture-mark-recapture studies that distinct, non-interacting sub-populations can emerge across just 50 acres despite immediate geographic proximity.
-
Paragraph 3: Elaborates on Ehrlich and Raven's 1969 theoretical conclusions, asserting that gene flow is neither predictable nor omnipresent, and establishing that natural selection is the decisive evolutionary mechanism capable of driving divergence or overpowering gene flow even without physical isolation.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Expository, and Objective.
-
Author's Perspective: The author maintains a neutral, scholarly stance, methodically tracing how empirical field evidence challenged long-standing biological orthodoxy and refined the scientific understanding of speciation mechanisms.
Other questions in this set
- Q20. All of the following statements are true according to the passage EXCEPT
- Q21. The author discusses Mayr, Ehrlich and Raven to demonstrate that
Science questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q13
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q14
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q15
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q16
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q6
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc