Free CAT library

Present Value & Stream Discounting

Master time-value of money, discounting future cash obligations under Simple and Compound interest, True Discount mechanics, and Net Present Value (NPV) evaluation of staggered cash inflows.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Telescope into the Future

If someone offers you ₹1,00,0001,00,000 today or ₹1,00,0001,00,000 three years from today, you don't hesitate for a single microsecond—you seize the cash today. Why? Because you can deposit that ₹1,00,0001,00,000 in a fixed income asset earning 10%10\% and watch it blossom into ₹1,33,1001,33,100 three years later. Accepting ₹1,00,0001,00,000 deferred by three years means forfeiting ₹33,10033,100 of economic wealth.

Present Value (PVPV) is the optical telescope that looks backwards through time. It answers the core corporate finance question:

"How much capital must I deploy today at rate rr so that it accumulates precisely into the promised future obligation of XX?"

The future obligation XX shrinks as it is pulled back across the timeline into the present epoch (t=0t = 0). The quantum by which it shrinks is called the True Discount (TDTD):

X=PV+TD  ⟺  TD=X−PVX = PV + TD \iff TD = X - PV


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Temporal Illusion

CAT and IPMAT problems involving discounting and present value exploit three recurring vulnerabilities:

  1. The Nominal Addition Fallacy: A commercial contract offers milestone payments (C1,C2,C3C_1, C_2, C_3). The examiner tempts candidates to add nominal rupee amounts together (C1+C2+C3C_1 + C_2 + C_3) and compare against an upfront lump-sum offer. In reality, each cash flow must be discounted to t=0t = 0.

  2. True Discount (TDTD) vs. Banker's Discount (BDBD): The defining commercial distinction:

    • True Discount is the interest calculated on the Present Value (PVPV).

    • Banker's Discount is the interest calculated on the Face Value (XX).

  3. The Commercial Banker's Gain (BGBG): The lender's surplus profit arising from charging interest on the nominal face value rather than the true present value: BG=BD−TDBG = BD - TD.

  4. Deferred Settlement Negotiations: Comparing "Cash down payment now" against a "Higher nominal payment payable after mm months" at prevailing market rates.


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Discounting Toolkit

A. Present Value & True Discount under Simple Interest:

Under Simple Interest at rate r%r\% p.a. for nn years:

X=PV(1+n⋅r100)=PV(100+nr100)X = PV \left(1 + \frac{n \cdot r}{100}\right) = PV \left(\frac{100 + n r}{100}\right)

PV=100X100+nrPV = \frac{100 X}{100 + n r}

The Mechanics of True Discount (TDTD):

TD=X−PV=X⋅n⋅r100+nrTD = X - PV = \frac{X \cdot n \cdot r}{100 + n r}

TD=PV⋅n⋅r100TD = \frac{PV \cdot n \cdot r}{100}

Axiom: True Discount is the Simple Interest on the Present Value (PVPV), NOT on the Face Value (XX)!

B. Banker's Discount (BDBD) and Banker's Gain (BGBG):

In commercial banking, the bank deducts interest computed on the entire nominal Face Value XX:

  • Banker's Discount (BDBD):

    BD=X⋅n⋅r100BD = \frac{X \cdot n \cdot r}{100}

  • Banker's Gain (BGBG):

    BG=BD−TD=TD⋅n⋅r100=TD2PVBG = BD - TD = \frac{TD \cdot n \cdot r}{100} = \frac{TD^2}{PV}

Interconnecting Banker's Identities:

TD=PV×BGTD = \sqrt{PV \times BG}

X=BD×TDBD−TDX = \frac{BD \times TD}{BD - TD}

C. Present Value under Compound Interest (DCF Framework):

In corporate valuation and modern finance, cash flows are discounted exponentially:

PV=X(1+r100)n=X(1+r100)−nPV = \frac{X}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^n} = X \left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^{-n}

The factor (1+r/100)−n(1 + r/100)^{-n} is the Discount Factor (DFnDF_n).

D. Net Present Value (NPV) of Staggered Multi-Period Streams:

To evaluate a series of milestone cash flows C1,C2,…,CkC_1, C_2, \dots, C_k arriving at years 1,2,…,k1, 2, \dots, k:

PVstream=∑t=1kCt(1+r100)t=C11+r100+C2(1+r100)2+⋯+Ck(1+r100)kPV_{\text{stream}} = \sum_{t=1}^k \frac{C_t}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^t} = \frac{C_1}{1 + \frac{r}{100}} + \frac{C_2}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^2} + \dots + \frac{C_k}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^k}

  • If upfront lump sum P0>PVstream  ⟹  P_0 > PV_{\text{stream}} \implies choose upfront cash.

  • If PVstream>P0  ⟹  PV_{\text{stream}} > P_0 \implies choose the staggered milestone stream.

E. Indefinite Stream Capitalization (Perpetuity):

For an annual cash payment CC received forever into perpetuity at discount rate r%r\% p.a.:

PV∞=Cr/100PV_{\infty} = \frac{C}{r/100}

If the annual payment grows at constant rate g%g\% p.a. (Growing Perpetuity, where r>gr > g):

PV=C1r100−g100PV = \frac{C_1}{\frac{r}{100} - \frac{g}{100}}


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The True Discount Base Blunder:

A bill of ₹11,00011,000 is due in 11 year at 10%10\% simple interest. What is the True Discount?

  • The Trap: Computing 10%10\% of ₹11,000=₹1,10011,000 = ₹1,100. (This is Banker's Discount, not True Discount!)
  • The Reality: Present Value is PV=11,0001+0.10=₹10,000PV = \frac{11,000}{1 + 0.10} = ₹10,000.
  • The True Discount: TD=11,000−10,000=₹1,000TD = 11,000 - 10,000 = ₹1,000 (which is 10%10\% of PVPV).

The Master Banker's Formula Shortcut:

When a problem provides numerical values for both BDBD and TDTD:

X=BD×TDBD−TDX = \frac{BD \times TD}{BD - TD}

You can recover the Face Value XX in three seconds without ever finding the rate or time!

Formulas

Present Value under SI

PV=100X100+nrPV = \frac{100 X}{100 + n r}

X is due amount/face value, n is years, r is annual simple rate
True Discount under SI

TD=X⋅n⋅r100+nr=PV⋅n⋅r100TD = \frac{X \cdot n \cdot r}{100 + n r} = \frac{PV \cdot n \cdot r}{100}

Equal to simple interest on Present Value, not on Face Value
Banker's Gain Relation

BG=BD−TD=TD⋅n⋅r100=TD2PVBG = BD - TD = \frac{TD \cdot n \cdot r}{100} = \frac{TD^2}{PV}

Banker's Gain represents the simple interest on True Discount
Master Banker's Identity

X=BD×TDBD−TDX = \frac{BD \times TD}{BD - TD}

Recovers Face Value directly from Banker's and True Discount
Present Value under CI

PV=X(1+r100)nPV = \frac{X}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^n}

Exponential discounting across n compounding conversion cycles
Net Present Value of Cash Stream

PVstream=∑t=1kCt(1+r100)tPV_{\text{stream}} = \sum_{t=1}^k \frac{C_t}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^t}

Aggregated discounted cash flow across staggered time periods

Traps and tips

  • The True Discount Base Trap: Never calculate True Discount as r% of Face Value X. That yields Banker's Discount (BD). True Discount is strictly calculated on Present Value (PV).
  • Temporal Additivity Fallacy: You cannot compare financial options by directly adding nominal cash flows (₹50k in yr 1 + ₹50k in yr 2 ≠ ₹100k today). Every cash flow must be discounted to t = 0.
  • Discount Rate Sensitivity: Higher cost of capital r accelerates discount factor decay; under high interest rates, upfront liquidity is overwhelmingly superior to deferred cash.
  • Banker's Identity Shortcut: Remember the standard relationship X = (BD × TD) / (BD - TD). When BD and TD are given, Face Value X is computed in one arithmetic step.

Solved examples

Example 4.1: Fintech Invoice Discounting: True Discount vs Banker's Discount

A supply-chain invoice discounting platform evaluates a bill of exchange with a face value of ₹84,80084,800 due 99 months from today. The prevailing market discount rate is 8%8\% per annum simple interest.

(i) Determine the True Present Value (PVPV) to be disbursed to the supplier today.

(ii) Calculate the True Discount (TDTD).

(iii) Find the Banker's Discount (BDBD) and the Banker's Gain (BGBG).

Show solution

Step 1: Identify parameters.

Face Value X=₹84,800X = ₹84,800, Time n=912=34=0.75n = \frac{9}{12} = \frac{3}{4} = 0.75 years, Rate r=8%r = 8\% p.a.

Effective rate-tenure factor:

n⋅r=34×8=6%n \cdot r = \frac{3}{4} \times 8 = 6\%

Step 2: Calculate Present Value (PVPV).

PV=100X100+nr=100×84,800100+6=84,80,000106=₹80,000PV = \frac{100 X}{100 + n r} = \frac{100 \times 84,800}{100 + 6} = \frac{84,80,000}{106} = ₹80,000

The platform disburses ₹80,00080,000 to the supplier today.

Step 3: Calculate True Discount (TDTD).

TD=X−PV=84,800−80,000=₹4,800TD = X - PV = 84,800 - 80,000 = ₹4,800

(Verification: TD=PV⋅n⋅r100=80,000×6100=₹4,800TD = \frac{PV \cdot n \cdot r}{100} = \frac{80,000 \times 6}{100} = ₹4,800).

Step 4: Compute Banker's Discount (BDBD) and Banker's Gain (BGBG).

Banker's Discount is simple interest on the Face Value XX:

BD=X⋅n⋅r100=84,800×6100=848×6=₹5,088BD = \frac{X \cdot n \cdot r}{100} = \frac{84,800 \times 6}{100} = 848 \times 6 = ₹5,088

Banker's Gain (BGBG) is the commercial surplus:

BG=BD−TD=5,088−4,800=₹288BG = BD - TD = 5,088 - 4,800 = ₹288

(Verification: BG=TD⋅n⋅r100=4,800×6100=₹288BG = \frac{TD \cdot n \cdot r}{100} = \frac{4,800 \times 6}{100} = ₹288).

Takeaway: True Discount is interest on Present Value, whereas Banker's Discount is interest on Face Value; the surplus difference is Banker's Gain, which equals simple interest on True Discount.

Example 4.2: Recovering Face Value and Present Value from Banker's Metrics

On a commercial bill of exchange due in a certain time at a certain simple interest rate, the Banker's Discount is ₹720720 and the True Discount is ₹600600.

(i) Determine the Face Value (XX) of the bill.

(ii) Determine the Present Value (PVPV) of the bill.

(iii) If the annual interest rate is 10%10\% p.a., determine the time period until maturity in months.

Show solution

Step 1: Recover Face Value (XX) using the Master Banker's Formula.

X=BD×TDBD−TDX = \frac{BD \times TD}{BD - TD}

Substitute BD=720BD = 720 and TD=600TD = 600:

X=720×600720−600=4,32,000120=₹3,600X = \frac{720 \times 600}{720 - 600} = \frac{4,32,000}{120} = ₹3,600

Step 2: Determine Present Value (PVPV).

PV=X−TD=3,600−600=₹3,000PV = X - TD = 3,600 - 600 = ₹3,000

(Verification via Banker's Gain: BG=BD−TD=720−600=120BG = BD - TD = 720 - 600 = 120. Since BG=TD2PV  ⟹  120=6002PV=3,60,000PV  ⟹  PV=₹3,000BG = \frac{TD^2}{PV} \implies 120 = \frac{600^2}{PV} = \frac{3,60,000}{PV} \implies PV = ₹3,000. Exact match).

Step 3: Solve for tenure nn at r=10%r = 10\% p.a.

Using the True Discount formula TD=PV⋅n⋅r100TD = \frac{PV \cdot n \cdot r}{100}:

600=3,000×n×10100=300n600 = \frac{3,000 \times n \times 10}{100} = 300 n

n=600300=2 years=24 monthsn = \frac{600}{300} = 2 \text{ years} = 24 \text{ months}

Takeaway: When BD and TD are given, use X = (BD TD) / (BD - TD) to extract the Face Value instantly without solving simultaneous rate-time equations.

Example 4.3: Software IP Acquisition: Upfront Cash vs Staggered Milestone Stream

A tech conglomerate negotiates to acquire a patent portfolio from a research lab. The lab is offered two alternative payment contracts:

  • Contract A: An immediate upfront cash payment of ₹1,45,0001,45,000.

  • Contract B: Three annual milestone payments: ₹55,00055,000 at the end of Year 1, ₹60,50060,500 at the end of Year 2, and ₹66,55066,550 at the end of Year 3.

Assuming a cost of capital of 10%10\% per annum compounded annually, determine: (i) the Net Present Value (NPVNPV) of Contract B, and (ii) which contract is financially more lucrative for the research lab and by what present-value margin.

Show solution

Step 1: Evaluate the Present Value of Contract A.

Contract A is paid immediately at t=0t = 0:

PVA=₹1,45,000PV_A = ₹1,45,000

Step 2: Discount each cash inflow of Contract B at r=10%r = 10\% p.a.

  • Present Value of Year 1 payment (C1=₹55,000C_1 = ₹55,000):

    PV(C1)=55,0001+0.10=55,0001.10=₹50,000PV(C_1) = \frac{55,000}{1 + 0.10} = \frac{55,000}{1.10} = ₹50,000

  • Present Value of Year 2 payment (C2=₹60,500C_2 = ₹60,500):

    PV(C2)=60,500(1.10)2=60,5001.21=₹50,000PV(C_2) = \frac{60,500}{(1.10)^2} = \frac{60,500}{1.21} = ₹50,000

  • Present Value of Year 3 payment (C3=₹66,550C_3 = ₹66,550):

    PV(C3)=66,550(1.10)3=66,5501.331=₹50,000PV(C_3) = \frac{66,550}{(1.10)^3} = \frac{66,550}{1.331} = ₹50,000

Step 3: Aggregate the stream's Net Present Value.

PVB=PV(C1)+PV(C2)+PV(C3)=50,000+50,000+50,000=₹1,50,000PV_B = PV(C_1) + PV(C_2) + PV(C_3) = 50,000 + 50,000 + 50,000 = ₹1,50,000

Step 4: Financial comparison.

  • Contract B has an economic Present Value of ₹1,50,0001,50,000.

  • Contract A provides an immediate cash sum of ₹1,45,0001,45,000.

Contract B is financially superior by:

1,50,000−1,45,000=₹5,0001,50,000 - 1,45,000 = ₹5,000

Takeaway: Never evaluate commercial deals by simply adding future nominal cash flows (55k + 60.5k + 66.55k = 182.05k); always discount every deferred cash flow back to t = 0 using the cost of capital before making capital allocation decisions.

Example 4.4: Deferred Settlement Negotiation under Simple Interest

A heavy machinery dealer offers an industrial packaging unit under two alternative settlement terms:

  • Scheme Alpha: Immediate upfront cash payment of ₹2,45,0002,45,000.

  • Scheme Beta: Deferred payment of ₹2,64,0002,64,000 payable after 1010 months.

If the prevailing commercial cost of capital is 12%12\% per annum simple interest, determine: (i) the Present Value of Scheme Beta today, and (ii) which scheme is economically advantageous for the buyer, and by how much.

Show solution

Step 1: Identify Scheme Beta parameters.

  • Deferred obligation X=₹2,64,000X = ₹2,64,000

  • Tenure n=10 months12 months=56 yearsn = \frac{10 \text{ months}}{12 \text{ months}} = \frac{5}{6} \text{ years}

  • Annual simple interest rate r=12%r = 12\%

  • Effective rate-tenure factor:

    n⋅r=56×12=10%n \cdot r = \frac{5}{6} \times 12 = 10\%

Step 2: Calculate the Present Value of Scheme Beta.

PVβ=100X100+nr=100×2,64,000100+10=2,64,00,000110=₹2,40,000PV_{\beta} = \frac{100 X}{100 + n r} = \frac{100 \times 2,64,000}{100 + 10} = \frac{2,64,00,000}{110} = ₹2,40,000

Step 3: Compare both schemes for the buyer.

  • Under Scheme Alpha, the buyer pays ₹2,45,0002,45,000 out of pocket today.

  • Under Scheme Beta, the economic cost in today's terms is only ₹2,40,0002,40,000.

Scheme Beta is economically advantageous for the buyer by:

2,45,000−2,40,000=₹5,0002,45,000 - 2,40,000 = ₹5,000

(Insight: The buyer can deposit ₹2,40,0002,40,000 in a 10-month bank deposit at 12% SI, which matures to exactly ₹2,40,000+₹24,000=₹2,64,0002,40,000 + ₹24,000 = ₹2,64,000 to settle Scheme Beta, while saving ₹5,0005,000 of liquidity today).

Takeaway: In commercial debt settlements, comparing cash down with deferred payments requires discounting the deferred obligation to Present Value at the prevailing cost of capital.

Example 4.5: Multi-Period Asymmetric Cash Inflows with Cost of Capital

An angel investment syndicate evaluates an early-stage SaaS product requiring an initial seed funding outlay of ₹1,15,0001,15,000 today. The venture is projected to yield asymmetric free cash flows over three years: ₹36,00036,000 at the end of Year 1, ₹57,60057,600 at the end of Year 2, and ₹1,03,6801,03,680 at the end of Year 3. Assuming a hurdle discount rate of 20%20\% per annum compounded annually:

(i) Compute the discounted Present Value of each milestone cash inflow.

(ii) Calculate the Net Present Value (NPVNPV) of the investment.

(iii) Determine whether the syndicate should approve the investment.

Show solution

Step 1: Determine the discount multiplier.

With cost of capital r=20%r = 20\%:

M=1+r100=1.20=65M = 1 + \frac{r}{100} = 1.20 = \frac{6}{5}

  • Year 1 discount factor: (1.20)−1=56(1.20)^{-1} = \frac{5}{6}

  • Year 2 discount factor: (1.20)−2=2536(1.20)^{-2} = \frac{25}{36}

  • Year 3 discount factor: (1.20)−3=125216(1.20)^{-3} = \frac{125}{216}

Step 2: Discount each cash inflow.

  • Year 1 (C1=₹36,000C_1 = ₹36,000):

    PV(C1)=36,000×56=6,000×5=₹30,000PV(C_1) = 36,000 \times \frac{5}{6} = 6,000 \times 5 = ₹30,000

  • Year 2 (C2=₹57,600C_2 = ₹57,600):

    PV(C2)=57,600×2536=1,600×25=₹40,000PV(C_2) = 57,600 \times \frac{25}{36} = 1,600 \times 25 = ₹40,000

  • Year 3 (C3=₹1,03,680C_3 = ₹1,03,680):

    PV(C3)=1,03,680×125216=480×125=₹60,000PV(C_3) = 1,03,680 \times \frac{125}{216} = 480 \times 125 = ₹60,000

Step 3: Compute aggregate Present Value of cash inflows.

PVinflows=30,000+40,000+60,000=₹1,30,000PV_{\text{inflows}} = 30,000 + 40,000 + 60,000 = ₹1,30,000

Step 4: Calculate Net Present Value (NPVNPV) and make investment decision.

NPV=PVinflows−Initial Outlay=1,30,000−1,15,000=+₹15,000NPV = PV_{\text{inflows}} - \text{Initial Outlay} = 1,30,000 - 1,15,000 = +₹15,000

Since NPV>0NPV > 0, the investment creates ₹15,00015,000 of net economic value above the 20%20\% hurdle rate; the syndicate should approve the funding.

Takeaway: An investment is financially viable if and only if the Net Present Value (NPV = PV of inflows - Initial Outlay) is strictly positive at the given discount rate.

Example 4.6: Perpetuity & Endowment Fund Capitalization

A philanthropic foundation intends to establish an annual research grant of ₹1,50,0001,50,000 to be awarded at the end of each year indefinitely into perpetuity.

(i) If the foundation's endowment portfolio yields 6%6\% per annum compounded annually, calculate the lump sum corpus required to fund this ordinary perpetuity today.

(ii) If the grant amount must grow by 2%2\% each year to neutralize inflation, calculate the required initial corpus using the growing perpetuity model.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute corpus for an ordinary fixed perpetuity.

For a constant annual stream C=₹1,50,000C = ₹1,50,000 running indefinitely at yield r=6%r = 6\% p.a.:

PV∞=Cr/100=1,50,0000.06=1,50,00,0006=₹25,00,000PV_{\infty} = \frac{C}{r/100} = \frac{1,50,000}{0.06} = \frac{1,50,00,000}{6} = ₹25,00,000

The foundation must deposit an initial corpus of ₹25,00,00025,00,000.

Step 2: Compute corpus for an inflation-adjusted growing perpetuity.

For an annual cash flow starting at C1=₹1,50,000C_1 = ₹1,50,000 and growing at constant annual rate g=2%g = 2\% with discount rate r=6%r = 6\%:

PVgrowing=C1r100−g100=1,50,0000.06−0.02=1,50,0000.04PV_{\text{growing}} = \frac{C_1}{\frac{r}{100} - \frac{g}{100}} = \frac{1,50,000}{0.06 - 0.02} = \frac{1,50,000}{0.04}

PVgrowing=1,50,00,0004=₹37,50,000PV_{\text{growing}} = \frac{1,50,00,000}{4} = ₹37,50,000

Step 3: Analyze incremental capital requirement.

To insulate the grant against 2%2\% annual inflation forever, the foundation requires an additional capital endowment of:

37,50,000−25,00,000=₹12,50,00037,50,000 - 25,00,000 = ₹12,50,000

Takeaway: An ordinary perpetuity requires a corpus of C / (r/100), while a perpetuity growing at rate g requires C / [(r - g)/100].

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

A merchant holds a bill of exchange due in 88 months. A commercial bank discounts the bill at 12%12\% per annum simple interest. If the Banker's Gain realized by the bank on this transaction is ₹288288, what is the nominal Face Value (XX) of the bill?

  1. A

    ₹45,00045,000

  2. B

    ₹48,60048,600

  3. C

    ₹50,40050,400

  4. D

    ₹52,20052,200

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 48,600

Step 1: Tenure is n=812=23n = \frac{8}{12} = \frac{2}{3} years at r=12%r = 12\%, so the rate-tenure factor is n⋅r=23×12=8%n \cdot r = \frac{2}{3} \times 12 = 8\%.

Step 2: Banker's Gain is interest on True Discount: BG=TD⋅n⋅r100=0.08TDBG = \frac{TD \cdot n \cdot r}{100} = 0.08 TD.

Step 3: Given BG=₹288  ⟹  TD=2880.08=₹3,600BG = ₹288 \implies TD = \frac{288}{0.08} = ₹3,600.

Step 4: Present Value is PV=100×TDn⋅r=3,6000.08=₹45,000PV = \frac{100 \times TD}{n \cdot r} = \frac{3,600}{0.08} = ₹45,000.

Step 5: The Face Value of the bill is X=PV+TD=45,000+3,600=₹48,600X = PV + TD = 45,000 + 3,600 = ₹48,600.

Question 2 · CAT Level

A technology firm considers two competing acquisition buyout offers for its software portfolio:

  • Offer Alpha: An upfront cash payment of ₹15,00,00015,00,000 today (t=0t = 0), plus a deferred milestone payment of ₹24,20,00024,20,000 payable at the end of Year 2.

  • Offer Beta: Three milestone payments: ₹11,00,00011,00,000 at the end of Year 1, ₹14,52,00014,52,000 at the end of Year 2, and ₹15,97,20015,97,200 at the end of Year 3.

If the firm's opportunity cost of capital is 10%10\% per annum compounded annually, which offer is economically superior in Net Present Value terms, and by what margin?

  1. A

    Offer Beta by ₹2,29,2002,29,200

  2. B

    Offer Alpha by ₹1,00,0001,00,000

  3. C

    Offer Beta by ₹1,00,0001,00,000

  4. D

    Offer Alpha by ₹1,50,0001,50,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) Offer Alpha by ₹ 1,00,000

Step 1: At cost of capital r=10%r = 10\%, the annual discount factor is 1.101.10.

Step 2: For Offer Alpha: PVα=15,00,000+24,20,000(1.10)2=15,00,000+24,20,0001.21=15,00,000+20,00,000=₹35,00,000PV_\alpha = 15,00,000 + \frac{24,20,000}{(1.10)^2} = 15,00,000 + \frac{24,20,000}{1.21} = 15,00,000 + 20,00,000 = ₹35,00,000.

Step 3: For Offer Beta: PVβ=11,00,0001.10+14,52,000(1.10)2+15,97,200(1.10)3=10,00,000+12,00,000+12,00,000=₹34,00,000PV_\beta = \frac{11,00,000}{1.10} + \frac{14,52,000}{(1.10)^2} + \frac{15,97,200}{(1.10)^3} = 10,00,000 + 12,00,000 + 12,00,000 = ₹34,00,000.

Step 4: Comparing economic values: PVα−PVβ=35,00,000−34,00,000=₹1,00,000PV_\alpha - PV_\beta = 35,00,000 - 34,00,000 = ₹1,00,000.

Step 5: Thus, Offer Alpha is economically superior by ₹1,00,0001,00,000 in present value terms.

Question 3 · CAT Level

A luxury vehicle is priced at ₹18,00,00018,00,000 cash down payment. Under an installment scheme, the buyer can pay ₹6,00,0006,00,000 as upfront down payment and sign a promissory note agreeing to pay ₹13,34,00013,34,000 after 1616 months. If the buyer can deploy capital in the market at 12%12\% per annum simple interest, what is the net economic gain or loss to the buyer in present-value terms by choosing the installment scheme over the cash down payment?

  1. A

    Gain of ₹50,00050,000

  2. B

    Loss of ₹1,34,0001,34,000

  3. C

    Loss of ₹50,00050,000

  4. D

    Gain of ₹84,00084,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) Gain of ₹ 50,000

Step 1: Under the deferred scheme, tenure is n=1612=43n = \frac{16}{12} = \frac{4}{3} years at r=12%r = 12\% SI, giving n⋅r=43×12=16%n \cdot r = \frac{4}{3} \times 12 = 16\%.

Step 2: The Present Value of the promissory note is PV=100X100+nr=13,34,0001.16=₹11,50,000PV = \frac{100 X}{100 + n r} = \frac{13,34,000}{1.16} = ₹11,50,000.

Step 3: Total economic cost today of the installment scheme is Down Payment+PV=6,00,000+11,50,000=₹17,50,000\text{Down Payment} + PV = 6,00,000 + 11,50,000 = ₹17,50,000.

Step 4: The full upfront cash price is ₹18,00,00018,00,000.

Step 5: Net economic gain to the buyer =18,00,000−17,50,000=₹50,000= 18,00,000 - 17,50,000 = ₹50,000.

Question 4 · CAT Level

A merchant holds two commercial promissory notes with the exact same Face Value XX. Note AA is due in 11 year, while Note BB is due in 22 years. Both notes are discounted at a simple interest rate of 10%10\% per annum. If the True Discount on Note BB exceeds the True Discount on Note AA by ₹900900, what is the common Face Value XX of the notes?

  1. A

    ₹10,56010,560

  2. B

    ₹11,88011,880

  3. C

    ₹12,60012,600

  4. D

    ₹13,20013,200

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 11,880

Step 1: For Bill AA (n1=1,r=10%n_1 = 1, r = 10\%), TDA=X⋅(1×10)100+10=10X110=X11TD_A = \frac{X \cdot (1 \times 10)}{100 + 10} = \frac{10X}{110} = \frac{X}{11}.

Step 2: For Bill BB (n2=2,r=10%n_2 = 2, r = 10\%), TDB=X⋅(2×10)100+20=20X120=X6TD_B = \frac{X \cdot (2 \times 10)}{100 + 20} = \frac{20X}{120} = \frac{X}{6}.

Step 3: The difference is TDB−TDA=X6−X11=5X66TD_B - TD_A = \frac{X}{6} - \frac{X}{11} = \frac{5X}{66}.

Step 4: Given 5X66=900  ⟹  5X=59,400\frac{5X}{66} = 900 \implies 5X = 59,400.

Step 5: Solving yields common Face Value X=59,4005=₹11,880X = \frac{59,400}{5} = ₹11,880.

Question 5 · CAT Level

An educational endowment trust is established to fund research fellowships. The trust requires annual payouts of ₹5,00,0005,00,000 at the end of Year 1 and Year 2. Beginning from Year 3 and continuing annually into perpetuity, the annual payout expands to ₹7,42,0007,42,000. If the endowment corpus earns a steady return of 10%10\% per annum compounded annually, what lump-sum capital must be invested into the endowment fund today (t=0t = 0) to sustain these payouts indefinitely?

  1. A

    ₹65,00,00065,00,000

  2. B

    ₹70,00,00070,00,000

  3. C

    ₹74,20,00074,20,000

  4. D

    ₹75,00,00075,00,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 70,00,000

Step 1: Decompose the payout into a base perpetuity of ₹5,00,0005,00,000 starting at t=1t=1, and an incremental perpetuity of ₹2,42,0002,42,000 starting at t=3t=3.

Step 2: Present value of the base perpetuity is PVbase=5,00,0000.10=₹50,00,000PV_{\text{base}} = \frac{5,00,000}{0.10} = ₹50,00,000.

Step 3: The value of the incremental perpetuity at t=2t=2 is V2=2,42,0000.10=₹24,20,000V_2 = \frac{2,42,000}{0.10} = ₹24,20,000.

Step 4: Discounting V2V_2 to t=0t=0 gives PVincremental=24,20,000(1.10)2=24,20,0001.21=₹20,00,000PV_{\text{incremental}} = \frac{24,20,000}{(1.10)^2} = \frac{24,20,000}{1.21} = ₹20,00,000.

Step 5: Total required endowment capital today is PV=50,00,000+20,00,000=₹70,00,000PV = 50,00,000 + 20,00,000 = ₹70,00,000.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library