Free CAT library

Equal Installments & Loan Repayment Annuities

Master loan repayment through Equated Periodic Installments under Compound Interest (discounted cash flow annuities) and Simple Interest (debt discharge models).

1. The Story & Mental Model: Slicing the Mountain of Debt

When a corporation borrows ₹10,00,00010,00,000, it is handed a mountain of capital today. It cannot repay this debt through five annual payments of ₹2,00,0002,00,000. Why? Because for every year the borrower holds the lender's money, that unpaid principal balance incurs interest.

To amortize (kill) the debt fairly, the parties agree on an Equated Periodic Installment (XX). But how that installment is computed depends fundamentally on which of two legal frameworks governs the contract:

  1. Compound Interest (The Real-World Banking Annuity):

    The Present Value of all your future installment payments, discounted back to the loan origination date (t=0t = 0), must exactly equal the principal borrowed today.

    P=∑t=1nX(1+r100)tP = \sum_{t=1}^n \frac{X}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^t}

  2. Simple Interest (The Exam Debt Discharge Model):

    The total accumulated debt DD due at maturity (t=nt = n) is liquidated because each installment payment paid along the way sits in an escrow account earning simple interest until the maturity date.

    D=∑t=1nVtD = \sum_{t=1}^n V_t


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Dual Installment Dialects

Exam setters deliberately exploit the vocabulary differences between CI and SI installment questions:

  • Dialect 1: CI Equated Annual Installments (Annuity)

    • Standard Phrasing: "A loan of ₹PP is borrowed at r%r\% p.a. compound interest and repaid in nn equal annual installments..."

    • Governing Equation: Equate borrowed principal PP to the sum of discounted cash flows.

  • Dialect 2: SI Debt Discharge Installments

    • Standard Phrasing: "What annual installment will discharge a debt of ₹DD due in nn years at r%r\% simple interest?"

    • Governing Equation: Equate total due debt DD to the sum of forward-accumulated installment values.

  • Dialect 3: The Down Payment Nuance

    • Standard Phrasing: "An asset costs ₹CC. A down payment of ₹DPDP is made, and the balance is repaid in installments..."

    • Trap: Never calculate installments on the full cost CC. The financed principal is strictly P=C−DPP = C - DP.


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Closed-Form Installment Engines

A. Compound Interest Installments (Annuity Framework):

Let v=11+r/100=kmv = \frac{1}{1 + r/100} = \frac{k}{m} (where 1+r/100=m/k1 + r/100 = m/k).

1. Two Equal Annual Installments (n=2n = 2):

P=X1+r100+X(1+r100)2=X[km+k2m2]=X[k(m+k)m2]P = \frac{X}{1 + \frac{r}{100}} + \frac{X}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^2} = X \left[\frac{k}{m} + \frac{k^2}{m^2}\right] = X \left[\frac{k(m + k)}{m^2}\right]

X=P[m2k(m+k)]X = P \left[\frac{m^2}{k(m + k)}\right]

High-Frequency Exam Multipliers:

  • At r=5%r = 5\% p.a. (m/k=21/20m/k = 21/20):

    P=X[20(41)441]=X[820441]  ⟹  X=P×441820P = X \left[\frac{20(41)}{441}\right] = X \left[\frac{820}{441}\right] \implies X = P \times \frac{441}{820}

  • At r=10%r = 10\% p.a. (m/k=11/10m/k = 11/10):

    P=X[10(21)121]=X[210121]  ⟹  X=P×121210P = X \left[\frac{10(21)}{121}\right] = X \left[\frac{210}{121}\right] \implies X = P \times \frac{121}{210}

  • At r=20%r = 20\% p.a. (m/k=6/5m/k = 6/5):

    P=X[5(11)36]=X[5536]  ⟹  X=P×3655P = X \left[\frac{5(11)}{36}\right] = X \left[\frac{55}{36}\right] \implies X = P \times \frac{36}{55}

2. Three Equal Annual Installments (n=3n = 3):

P=X[km+k2m2+k3m3]=X[k(m2+km+k2)m3]P = X \left[\frac{k}{m} + \frac{k^2}{m^2} + \frac{k^3}{m^3}\right] = X \left[\frac{k(m^2 + km + k^2)}{m^3}\right]

  • At r=5%r = 5\% (m/k=21/20m/k = 21/20):

    P=X[20(441+420+400)9261]=X[252209261]P = X \left[\frac{20(441 + 420 + 400)}{9261}\right] = X \left[\frac{25220}{9261}\right]

3. General Annuity Amortization Formula:

P=X[1−(1+r100)−nr/100]P = X \left[\frac{1 - \left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^{-n}}{r/100}\right]

B. Simple Interest Debt Discharge Engine:

To discharge a debt of ₹DD due at the end of nn years using equal annual installments XX:

  • Installment 1 (paid at end of Year 1) earns interest for (n−1)(n - 1) years: V1=X+X(n−1)r100V_1 = X + \frac{X(n - 1)r}{100}

  • Installment 2 (paid at end of Year 2) earns interest for (n−2)(n - 2) years: V2=X+X(n−2)r100V_2 = X + \frac{X(n - 2)r}{100}

  • …\dots

  • Installment nn (paid at end of Year nn) earns interest for 00 years: Vn=XV_n = X

Summing all accumulated values:

D=∑t=1nVt=nX+X⋅r100[(n−1)+(n−2)+⋯+1+0]D = \sum_{t=1}^n V_t = n X + \frac{X \cdot r}{100} \left[(n - 1) + (n - 2) + \dots + 1 + 0\right]

D=nX+X⋅r⋅n(n−1)200=X[n+r⋅n(n−1)200]D = n X + \frac{X \cdot r \cdot n(n - 1)}{200} = X \left[n + \frac{r \cdot n(n - 1)}{200}\right]

X=100D100n+r⋅n(n−1)2X = \frac{100 D}{100 n + \frac{r \cdot n(n - 1)}{2}}

Critical Distinction on Due Debt vs. Borrowed Sum:

  • If debt due at maturity is ₹DD, use DD directly.

  • If capital ₹PP is borrowed today under SI and settled via nn installments, the debt due at maturity is D=P(1+n⋅r100)D = P\left(1 + \frac{n \cdot r}{100}\right).


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Model Confusion Blunder:

Never apply the SI debt discharge formula to a bank loan problem that specifies Compound Interest!

  • Under CI: Equate sum of discounted cash flows to PP.
  • Under SI: Equate sum of forward-accumulated installments to DD.

Total Financing Cost Shortcut:

Across both systems:

Total Repaid=n×X\text{Total Repaid} = n \times X

Total Financing Interest=n×X−P\text{Total Financing Interest} = n \times X - P

This check immediately flags impossible options on multiple-choice exams.

Flat Rate vs. Reducing Balance APR Trap:

In consumer lending, lenders often quote a "flat interest rate". A flat rate of 10%10\% over nn periods corresponds to an effective reducing balance rate of roughly 1.7×1.7\times to 1.9×1.9\times the flat rate:

rreducing≈rflat×2nn+1r_{\text{reducing}} \approx r_{\text{flat}} \times \frac{2n}{n + 1}

Formulas

2-Period CI Installment Formula

P=X1+r/100+X(1+r/100)2=X[k(m+k)m2]P = \frac{X}{1 + r/100} + \frac{X}{(1 + r/100)^2} = X \left[\frac{k(m + k)}{m^2}\right]

Where (1 + r/100) = m/k; isolates installment X in two steps
3-Period CI Installment Formula

P=X[k(m2+km+k2)m3]P = X \left[\frac{k(m^2 + km + k^2)}{m^3}\right]

For 3 equal annual compound interest installments
General CI Loan Amortization

P=X[1−(1+r/100)−nr/100]P = X \left[\frac{1 - (1 + r/100)^{-n}}{r/100}\right]

Standard present value of an ordinary annuity formula
SI Debt Discharge Equation

D=nX+X⋅r⋅n(n−1)200D = n X + \frac{X \cdot r \cdot n(n - 1)}{200}

Total accumulated future values of n installments matching due debt D
SI Equal Annual Installment

X=100D100n+r⋅n(n−1)2X = \frac{100 D}{100 n + \frac{r \cdot n(n - 1)}{2}}

Installment required to discharge maturity debt D under simple interest
Reducing APR Rule of Thumb

rreducing≈rflat×2nn+1r_{\text{reducing}} \approx r_{\text{flat}} \times \frac{2n}{n + 1}

Estimates true reducing balance APR from quoted flat installment rate

Traps and tips

  • Model Differentiation: Under CI, discount installments back to t = 0 to equal principal P. Under SI, compound installments forward to t = n to equal debt D.
  • Deduct Down Payment: Always subtract cash down payment before calculating installments: P = Total Cost - Down Payment.
  • Financing Cost Sanity Check: Total installment payments nX must always exceed principal P; the difference nX - P is total interest paid.
  • Ratio Multiplier Shortcut: For CI at 5% (ratio 21/20), 2-year installment multiplier is P = X * (820 / 441). At 10% (11/10), P = X * (210 / 121).

Solved examples

Example 5.1: Enterprise Server Financing: 2 Equal CI Installments with Down Payment

A technology startup purchases AI cloud server infrastructure costing ₹5,10,0005,10,000. The startup pays ₹1,00,0001,00,000 as a cash down payment and finances the remaining balance through a credit line to be repaid in two equal annual installments at an interest rate of 5%5\% per annum compounded annually.

(i) Determine the value of each annual installment.

(ii) Calculate the total interest paid on the financing facility.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate outstanding principal PP.

P=Total Asset Cost−Down Payment=5,10,000−1,00,000=₹4,10,000P = \text{Total Asset Cost} - \text{Down Payment} = 5,10,000 - 1,00,000 = ₹4,10,000

Step 2: Set up the 2-installment Compound Interest equation.

P=X1+r100+X(1+r100)2P = \frac{X}{1 + \frac{r}{100}} + \frac{X}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{100}\right)^2}

Here r=5%  ⟹  1+r100=1+120=2120r = 5\% \implies 1 + \frac{r}{100} = 1 + \frac{1}{20} = \frac{21}{20} (so m=21,k=20m = 21, k = 20).

4,10,000=X(2021)+X(2021)2=X[2021+400441]4,10,000 = X \left(\frac{20}{21}\right) + X \left(\frac{20}{21}\right)^2 = X \left[\frac{20}{21} + \frac{400}{441}\right]

4,10,000=X[420+400441]=X[820441]4,10,000 = X \left[\frac{420 + 400}{441}\right] = X \left[\frac{820}{441}\right]

Step 3: Solve for installment XX.

X=4,10,000×441820X = \frac{4,10,000 \times 441}{820}

Notice that 4,10,000820=500\frac{4,10,000}{820} = 500:

X=500×441=₹2,20,500X = 500 \times 441 = ₹2,20,500

Each annual installment is ₹2,20,5002,20,500.

Step 4: Calculate total interest paid.

Total installment payments=2×2,20,500=₹4,41,000\text{Total installment payments} = 2 \times 2,20,500 = ₹4,41,000

Financing Interest=Total Paid−Principal=4,41,000−4,10,000=₹31,000\text{Financing Interest} = \text{Total Paid} - \text{Principal} = 4,41,000 - 4,10,000 = ₹31,000

(Total expenditure on servers = ₹1,00,000+₹4,41,000=₹5,41,0001,00,000 + ₹4,41,000 = ₹5,41,000).

Takeaway: In a 2-installment CI setup with rate r = 5% (multiplier 21/20), the formula simplifies cleanly to P = X (820 / 441), giving X immediately.

Example 5.2: Three Equal Annual Installments under CI with Fractional Ratio

An AI research laboratory borrows a capital expenditure loan of ₹2,52,2002,52,200 at 5%5\% per annum compound interest, to be repaid in 33 equal annual installments.

(i) Determine the value of each annual installment.

(ii) Find the total amount repaid and the total financing interest paid to the lender.

Show solution

Step 1: Set up the 3-installment annuity equation.

Let each annual installment be XX. Rate r=5%  ⟹  1+r100=2120r = 5\% \implies 1 + \frac{r}{100} = \frac{21}{20}.

P=X1.05+X(1.05)2+X(1.05)3=X[2021+(2021)2+(2021)3]P = \frac{X}{1.05} + \frac{X}{(1.05)^2} + \frac{X}{(1.05)^3} = X \left[\frac{20}{21} + \left(\frac{20}{21}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{20}{21}\right)^3\right]

P=X[2021+400441+8,0009,261]P = X \left[\frac{20}{21} + \frac{400}{441} + \frac{8,000}{9,261}\right]

Step 2: Consolidate terms over a common denominator (9,2619,261).

P=X[20×441+400×21+8,0009,261]=X[8,820+8,400+8,0009,261]P = X \left[\frac{20 \times 441 + 400 \times 21 + 8,000}{9,261}\right] = X \left[\frac{8,820 + 8,400 + 8,000}{9,261}\right]

P=X[25,2209,261]P = X \left[\frac{25,220}{9,261}\right]

Step 3: Solve for installment XX.

Given borrowed principal P=₹2,52,200P = ₹2,52,200:

2,52,200=X[25,2209,261]2,52,200 = X \left[\frac{25,220}{9,261}\right]

Notice that 2,52,20025,220=10\frac{2,52,200}{25,220} = 10:

X=10×9,261=₹92,610X = 10 \times 9,261 = ₹92,610

Each annual installment is ₹92,61092,610.

Step 4: Compute total payments and interest.

Total amount repaid=3×92,610=₹2,77,830\text{Total amount repaid} = 3 \times 92,610 = ₹2,77,830

Financing Interest=2,77,830−2,52,200=₹25,630\text{Financing Interest} = 2,77,830 - 2,52,200 = ₹25,630

Takeaway: For 3 installments at 5% CI, the ratio engine gives P = X (25,220 / 9,261); recognizing numerator-principal multiples saves tremendous calculation time.

Example 5.3: Loan Amortization Breakdown: Principal vs Interest Components

A startup founder borrows ₹2,10,0002,10,000 at 10%10\% per annum compound interest, to be repaid in 22 equal annual installments.

(i) Calculate the annual installment XX.

(ii) Construct the complete loan amortization schedule, breaking down each installment into its Principal Repayment component and Interest Service component.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate the annual installment XX.

Rate r=10%  ⟹  1+r100=1110r = 10\% \implies 1 + \frac{r}{100} = \frac{11}{10}.

P=X[1011+100121]=X[110+100121]=X[210121]P = X \left[\frac{10}{11} + \frac{100}{121}\right] = X \left[\frac{110 + 100}{121}\right] = X \left[\frac{210}{121}\right]

Given P=₹2,10,000P = ₹2,10,000:

2,10,000=X[210121]2,10,000 = X \left[\frac{210}{121}\right]

X=2,10,000×121210=1,000×121=₹1,21,000X = \frac{2,10,000 \times 121}{210} = 1,000 \times 121 = ₹1,21,000

Each installment is ₹1,21,0001,21,000.

Step 2: Construct the Year 1 Amortization Breakdown.

  • Opening Balance: ₹2,10,0002,10,000

  • Year 1 Interest Accrued: 10%10\% of 2,10,000=₹21,0002,10,000 = ₹21,000

  • Total Installment Paid: ₹1,21,0001,21,000

  • Principal Repaid in Year 1: 1,21,000−21,000=₹1,00,0001,21,000 - 21,000 = ₹1,00,000

  • Closing Principal Balance at end of Year 1: 2,10,000−1,00,000=₹1,10,0002,10,000 - 1,00,000 = ₹1,10,000

Step 3: Construct the Year 2 Amortization Breakdown.

  • Opening Balance: ₹1,10,0001,10,000

  • Year 2 Interest Accrued: 10%10\% of 1,10,000=₹11,0001,10,000 = ₹11,000

  • Total Installment Paid: ₹1,21,0001,21,000

  • Principal Repaid in Year 2: 1,21,000−11,000=₹1,10,0001,21,000 - 11,000 = ₹1,10,000

  • Closing Principal Balance at end of Year 2: 1,10,000−1,10,000=₹01,10,000 - 1,10,000 = ₹0 (Debt fully extinguished!)

Step 4: Analyze Amortization Dynamics.

  • Principal repaid: Year 1 = ₹1,00,0001,00,000; Year 2 = ₹1,10,0001,10,000.

  • Interest paid: Year 1 = ₹21,00021,000; Year 2 = ₹11,00011,000.

  • Notice that the principal repaid grew by exactly 10%10\% (1,00,000×1.10=1,10,0001,00,000 \times 1.10 = 1,10,000).

Takeaway: In any equal installment loan under CI, the principal repayment component expands geometrically at rate r% each year as the outstanding interest burden contracts.

Example 5.4: Corporate Debt Discharge: 4 Equal Annual SI Installments

A logistics company has a supplier obligation of ₹92,00092,000 due in 44 years. The company negotiates to discharge this entire liability by paying 44 equal annual installments, the first installment being paid at the end of the first year. If simple interest is calculated at 10%10\% per annum, determine the amount of each annual installment.

Show solution

Step 1: Understand the Simple Interest debt discharge structure.

Let each annual installment be XX.

Number of installments n=4n = 4, rate r=10%r = 10\% p.a., total due debt D=₹92,000D = ₹92,000.

Step 2: Accumulate each installment to the maturity date (end of Year 4).

  • Installment 1 (paid at end of Year 1) earns interest for 4−1=34 - 1 = 3 years:

    V1=X+X×3×10100=X+0.30X=1.30XV_1 = X + \frac{X \times 3 \times 10}{100} = X + 0.30 X = 1.30 X

  • Installment 2 (paid at end of Year 2) earns interest for 4−2=24 - 2 = 2 years:

    V2=X+X×2×10100=X+0.20X=1.20XV_2 = X + \frac{X \times 2 \times 10}{100} = X + 0.20 X = 1.20 X

  • Installment 3 (paid at end of Year 3) earns interest for 4−3=14 - 3 = 1 year:

    V3=X+X×1×10100=X+0.10X=1.10XV_3 = X + \frac{X \times 1 \times 10}{100} = X + 0.10 X = 1.10 X

  • Installment 4 (paid at end of Year 4) earns interest for 00 years:

    V4=X=1.00XV_4 = X = 1.00 X

Step 3: Equate the sum of accumulated values to total debt DD.

Vtotal=1.30X+1.20X+1.10X+1.00X=4.60XV_{\text{total}} = 1.30 X + 1.20 X + 1.10 X + 1.00 X = 4.60 X

4.60X=92,0004.60 X = 92,000

Step 4: Solve for XX.

X=92,0004.60=9,20,00046=₹20,000X = \frac{92,000}{4.60} = \frac{9,20,000}{46} = ₹20,000

Each annual installment is ₹20,00020,000.

(Verification: V1=26,000,V2=24,000,V3=22,000,V4=20,000  ⟹  Total=26,000+24,000+22,000+20,000=₹92,000V_1 = 26,000, V_2 = 24,000, V_3 = 22,000, V_4 = 20,000 \implies \text{Total} = 26,000 + 24,000 + 22,000 + 20,000 = ₹92,000).

Takeaway: Under Simple Interest debt discharge, installments paid earlier generate interest until the final maturity date; the accumulated values sum to n X + [X r n (n-1)/200] = D.

Example 5.5: Borrowed Capital Repaid via SI Installments (Borrowed Today vs Due at Maturity)

A small business owner borrows a principal sum of ₹64,50064,500 today from a credit society at 5%5\% per annum simple interest. The loan agreement stipulates that the debt must be repaid in 44 equal annual installments, beginning one year from today.

(i) Determine the total maturity debt DD due at the end of 4 years.

(ii) Calculate the value of each annual installment XX.

(iii) Compare the total amount paid across the 4 installments with the original borrowed principal.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate the total maturity debt DD due at end of Year 4.

Under Simple Interest, the principal of ₹64,50064,500 borrowed for 44 years at 5%5\% accumulates to a maturity obligation of:

D=P(1+n⋅r100)=64,500(1+4×5100)=64,500×1.20=₹77,400D = P \left(1 + \frac{n \cdot r}{100}\right) = 64,500 \left(1 + \frac{4 \times 5}{100}\right) = 64,500 \times 1.20 = ₹77,400

Step 2: Accumulate installments to maturity and equate to DD.

Using the SI installment accumulation engine for n=4n = 4 and r=5%r = 5\%:

D=X[n+r⋅n(n−1)200]D = X \left[n + \frac{r \cdot n(n - 1)}{200}\right]

77,400=X[4+5×4×3200]=X[4+60200]=X[4+0.30]=4.30X77,400 = X \left[4 + \frac{5 \times 4 \times 3}{200}\right] = X \left[4 + \frac{60}{200}\right] = X [4 + 0.30] = 4.30 X

Step 3: Solve for installment XX.

X=77,4004.30=7,74,00043X = \frac{77,400}{4.30} = \frac{7,74,000}{43}

Dividing 7,74,0007,74,000 by 4343:

X=₹18,000X = ₹18,000

Each annual installment is ₹18,00018,000.

Step 4: Analyze total cash outflow and financing interest.

Total paid across 4 installments=4×18,000=₹72,000\text{Total paid across 4 installments} = 4 \times 18,000 = ₹72,000

Notice that ₹72,000<₹77,40072,000 < ₹77,400! Because installments were paid earlier than maturity, their accumulated value discharged the ₹77,40077,400 debt with only ₹72,00072,000 of borrower cash.

Total interest paid=72,000−64,500=₹7,500\text{Total interest paid} = 72,000 - 64,500 = ₹7,500

Takeaway: When a sum is borrowed today under SI, first find the debt due at maturity D = P(1 + nr/100), then equate D to the accumulated installment engine X[n + r n (n-1)/200].

Example 5.6: Consumer Electronics Financing: Flat Rate vs Reducing APR Trap

A consumer purchases a smartphone priced at ₹60,00060,000. The store offers an installment financing scheme: Cash down payment of ₹12,00012,000, and the remaining balance of ₹48,00048,000 repaid in 66 equal monthly installments of ₹8,4008,400.

The retailer markets this as a "low flat interest rate of 10%10\% per annum".

(i) Calculate the total financing interest paid and verify the advertised flat rate.

(ii) Expose the consumer financing trap: explain why the true effective annual interest rate (reducing balance APR) is nearly double the flat rate.

(iii) Estimate the approximate true reducing annual interest rate using the rule-of-thumb formula rreducing≈rflat×2nn+1r_{\text{reducing}} \approx r_{\text{flat}} \times \frac{2n}{n+1}.

Show solution

Step 1: Verify the advertised flat interest rate.

  • Net loan principal: P=60,000−12,000=₹48,000P = 60,000 - 12,000 = ₹48,000

  • Total installment payments: 6×8,400=₹50,4006 \times 8,400 = ₹50,400

  • Total interest charged: 50,400−48,000=₹2,40050,400 - 48,000 = ₹2,400

  • Tenure: 6 months=0.5 years6 \text{ months} = 0.5 \text{ years}

Under a flat rate calculation, interest is computed on the initial ₹48,00048,000 for the entire 6 months:

Flat Interest=P⋅n⋅rflat100  ⟹  2,400=48,000×0.5×rflat100=240×rflat\text{Flat Interest} = \frac{P \cdot n \cdot r_{\text{flat}}}{100} \implies 2,400 = \frac{48,000 \times 0.5 \times r_{\text{flat}}}{100} = 240 \times r_{\text{flat}}

rflat=2,400240=10% p.a.r_{\text{flat}} = \frac{2,400}{240} = 10\% \text{ p.a.}

The retailer's advertised flat rate of 10%10\% is technically verified on paper.

Step 2: Unmask the consumer trap.

In reality, the borrower does NOT hold ₹48,00048,000 for the entire 6 months. Each monthly installment pays down a portion of the principal. By Month 6, the outstanding principal is nearly zero.

The average outstanding loan balance over the 6-month tenure is only approximately 48,000+8,0002≈₹28,000\frac{48,000 + 8,000}{2} \approx ₹28,000. Paying ₹2,4002,400 interest on an average capital base of ₹28,00028,000 represents a vastly higher annualized yield!

Step 3: Estimate the true reducing balance APR.

Using the standard financial rule of thumb for n=6n = 6 periods:

rreducing≈rflat×2nn+1r_{\text{reducing}} \approx r_{\text{flat}} \times \frac{2n}{n + 1}

rreducing≈10%×2×66+1=10%×127≈17.14% p.a.r_{\text{reducing}} \approx 10\% \times \frac{2 \times 6}{6 + 1} = 10\% \times \frac{12}{7} \approx 17.14\% \text{ p.a.}

The true economic cost of borrowing is approximately 17.14%17.14\% p.a., nearly double the advertised 10%10\% rate!

Takeaway: A quoted 'flat interest rate' is commercially deceptive because interest is charged on the initial principal rather than the reducing balance; the true APR is roughly 2n/(n+1) times the flat rate.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

A green energy startup takes a venture loan of ₹11,50,00011,50,000 at 10%10\% per annum compound interest, to be repaid in two annual installments. Under the structured repayment terms, the second installment is to be 20%20\% greater than the first installment. What is the value of the first annual installment?

  1. A

    ₹5,80,0005,80,000

  2. B

    ₹6,05,0006,05,000

  3. C

    ₹6,25,0006,25,000

  4. D

    ₹6,50,0006,50,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 6,05,000

Step 1: Let the first installment be X1X_1. Then the second installment is X2=1.20X1X_2 = 1.20 X_1.

Step 2: Discounting both cash flows to t=0t = 0 at 10%10\% CI gives P=X11.10+1.20X1(1.10)2=1.10X1+1.20X11.21=2.30X11.21P = \frac{X_1}{1.10} + \frac{1.20 X_1}{(1.10)^2} = \frac{1.10 X_1 + 1.20 X_1}{1.21} = \frac{2.30 X_1}{1.21}.

Step 3: Given borrowed principal P=₹11,50,000P = ₹11,50,000, we have 2.30X11.21=11,50,000\frac{2.30 X_1}{1.21} = 11,50,000.

Step 4: Solving yields X1=11,50,000×1.212.30=5,00,000×1.21=₹6,05,000X_1 = \frac{11,50,000 \times 1.21}{2.30} = 5,00,000 \times 1.21 = ₹6,05,000.

Step 5: Thus, the first annual installment is ₹6,05,0006,05,000 (and the second is ₹7,26,0007,26,000).

Question 2 · CAT Level

A logistics enterprise has a supplier obligation of ₹1,32,0001,32,000 due at the end of 55 years. The enterprise negotiates to discharge this entire debt liability through 33 equal annual installments paid at the end of the 3rd3^{\text{rd}}, 4th4^{\text{th}}, and 5th5^{\text{th}} years respectively. If simple interest is calculated at 10%10\% per annum, what is the amount of each annual installment?

  1. A

    ₹38,00,038,00,0

  2. B

    ₹40,00040,000

  3. C

    ₹42,00042,000

  4. D

    ₹44,00044,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 40,000

Step 1: Total due debt at maturity (t=5t = 5) is D=₹1,32,000D = ₹1,32,000.

Step 2: The 33 installments XX are paid at the end of Years 3, 4, and 5, earning 10%10\% SI until Year 5.

Step 3: Accumulated values are V1=X(1+0.20)=1.20XV_1 = X(1 + 0.20) = 1.20X, V2=X(1+0.10)=1.10XV_2 = X(1 + 0.10) = 1.10X, and V3=XV_3 = X.

Step 4: Sum of accumulated values is 1.20X+1.10X+1.00X=3.30X=1,32,0001.20X + 1.10X + 1.00X = 3.30X = 1,32,000.

Step 5: Solving yields X=1,32,0003.30=₹40,000X = \frac{1,32,000}{3.30} = ₹40,000.

Question 3 · CAT Level

A capital equipment loan is repaid in 33 equal annual installments of ₹66,55066,550 each at an interest rate of 10%10\% per annum compounded annually. What is the quantum of principal repaid strictly in the 2nd2^{\text{nd}} annual installment?

  1. A

    ₹50,00050,000

  2. B

    ₹55,00055,000

  3. C

    ₹58,00058,000

  4. D

    ₹60,50060,500

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 55,000

Step 1: Present value of the 33 equal installments (X=₹66,550X = ₹66,550 at 10%10\%) gives borrowed principal P=66,5501.10+66,550(1.10)2+66,550(1.10)3=60,500+55,000+50,000=₹1,65,500P = \frac{66,550}{1.10} + \frac{66,550}{(1.10)^2} + \frac{66,550}{(1.10)^3} = 60,500 + 55,000 + 50,000 = ₹1,65,500.

Step 2: Year 1 interest is 10%10\% of 1,65,500=₹16,5501,65,500 = ₹16,550. Principal repaid in Year 1 is 66,550−16,550=₹50,00066,550 - 16,550 = ₹50,000.

Step 3: Outstanding principal at start of Year 2 is 1,65,500−50,000=₹1,15,5001,65,500 - 50,000 = ₹1,15,500.

Step 4: Year 2 interest accrued is 10%10\% of 1,15,500=₹11,5501,15,500 = ₹11,550.

Step 5: Principal repaid in the 2nd2^{\text{nd}} installment is 66,550−11,550=₹55,00066,550 - 11,550 = ₹55,000.

Question 4 · CAT Level

A clinic purchases an MRI workstation priced at ₹10,00,00010,00,000. The clinic pays ₹3,38,0003,38,000 upfront as a cash down payment and finances the remaining balance through a credit line at 20%20\% per annum compounded semi-annually, to be repaid in 33 equal half-yearly installments. What is the amount of each half-yearly installment?

  1. A

    ₹2,45,0002,45,000

  2. B

    ₹2,66,2002,66,200

  3. C

    ₹2,75,4002,75,400

  4. D

    ₹2,82,0002,82,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 2,66,200

Step 1: Net financed principal is P=10,00,000−3,38,000=₹6,62,000P = 10,00,000 - 3,38,000 = ₹6,62,000.

Step 2: With 20%20\% p.a. compounded semi-annually, periodic rate is rp=10%r_p = 10\% per half-year over 33 periods.

Step 3: The annuity equation is P=X[1011+100121+1,0001,331]=X[3,3101,331]P = X \left[\frac{10}{11} + \frac{100}{121} + \frac{1,000}{1,331}\right] = X \left[\frac{3,310}{1,331}\right].

Step 4: Substituting P=6,62,000P = 6,62,000: 6,62,000=X×3,3101,331  ⟹  X=6,62,000×1,3313,3106,62,000 = X \times \frac{3,310}{1,331} \implies X = \frac{6,62,000 \times 1,331}{3,310}.

Step 5: Since 6,62,0003,310=200\frac{6,62,000}{3,310} = 200, each half-yearly installment is X=200×1,331=₹2,66,200X = 200 \times 1,331 = ₹2,66,200.

Question 5 · CAT Level

A merchant borrows a capital sum of ₹1,10,0001,10,000 for 22 years at an annual interest rate of 20%20\% p.a., to be repaid in 22 equal annual installments. Consider two alternative loan structures:

  • Scheme Alpha: Evaluated under Compound Interest (discounted cash flow annuity).

  • Scheme Beta: Evaluated under Simple Interest (where the maturity debt obligation is discharged by forward-accumulated installments).

What is the absolute difference between the annual installment under Scheme Alpha and that under Scheme Beta?

  1. A

    ₹1,5001,500

  2. B

    ₹2,0002,000

  3. C

    ₹2,5002,500

  4. D

    ₹3,0003,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 2,000

Step 1: Under Scheme Alpha (CI at 20%20\%), P=Xα[56+2536]=Xα[5536]  ⟹  Xα=1,10,000×3655=₹72,000P = X_\alpha \left[\frac{5}{6} + \frac{25}{36}\right] = X_\alpha \left[\frac{55}{36}\right] \implies X_\alpha = 1,10,000 \times \frac{36}{55} = ₹72,000.

Step 2: Under Scheme Beta (SI at 20%20\%), maturity debt is D=1,10,000[1+2(0.20)]=1,10,000×1.40=₹1,54,000D = 1,10,000 [1 + 2(0.20)] = 1,10,000 \times 1.40 = ₹1,54,000.

Step 3: Forward-accumulating the 22 installments under SI gives Xβ(1+0.20)+Xβ=2.20Xβ=1,54,000X_\beta (1 + 0.20) + X_\beta = 2.20 X_\beta = 1,54,000.

Step 4: Solving yields Scheme Beta installment Xβ=1,54,0002.20=₹70,000X_\beta = \frac{1,54,000}{2.20} = ₹70,000.

Step 5: The difference between installments is Xα−Xβ=72,000−70,000=₹2,000X_\alpha - X_\beta = 72,000 - 70,000 = ₹2,000.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library