The Equal Selling Price Theorem (±x% Loss Formula)
Understand why selling two articles at the same selling price with identical percentage profit and loss guarantees an overall net loss of -(x/10)^2%, calculate exact rupee losses, and contrast with equal Cost Price.
1. The Story & Mental Model: The Twin Sales Illusion
Imagine an art curator who acquires two contemporary sculptures. At an auction, both sculptures sell for the exact same winning bid: ₹1,20,000 each.
On Sculpture A, the curator made a 20% profit. On Sculpture B, the curator suffered a 20% loss.
The curator cheerfully remarks: "Well, the twenty percent gain cancels out the twenty percent loss; I broke even!"
Is she right? Absolutely not!
-
For Sculpture A (which yielded +20% profit), the Cost Price was smaller: 1.201,20,000=₹1,00,000 (a gain of ₹20,000).
-
For Sculpture B (which suffered −20% loss), the Cost Price was much larger: 0.801,20,000=₹1,50,000 (a loss of ₹30,000)!
Overall, she spent ₹2,50,000 and received ₹2,40,000—a net loss of ₹10,000! Because the percentages acted on asymmetric Cost Price bases, the loss on the expensive item overpowered the profit on the cheaper item.
2. The CAT Question Blueprint: Equal SP vs. Equal CP
Exam setters relentlessly test candidates on this fundamental dichotomy:
-
Case 1: Equal Selling Prices (SP1=SP2=SP)
-
One sold at +x%, other at −x%.
-
Result: ALWAYS an overall net loss of (10x)2%.
-
Case 2: Equal Cost Prices (CP1=CP2=CP)
-
Case 3: Equal SP with Asymmetric Rates (+x% and −y%)
- Requires weighted calculation using individual cost prices.
3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Invariant Loss Formula
When two articles are sold at the SAME Selling Price (SP), one yielding a profit of x% and the other a loss of x%:
Overall Net %Δ=−(10x)2%=−100x2%
Absolute Rupee Loss Formula:
Let the selling price of each article be SP. Total revenue =2⋅SP.
Total Absolute Rupee Loss=10,000−x22⋅SP⋅x2
Derivation:
CP1=1+100xSP=100+x100⋅SP,CP2=1−100xSP=100−x100⋅SP
CPtotal=100⋅SP[100+x1+100−x1]=10,000−x220,000⋅SP
Loss=CPtotal−2⋅SP=2⋅SP[10,000−x210,000−1]=10,000−x22⋅SP⋅x2
4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut
The Equal CP vs Equal SP Confusion:
- If two items are bought for the same price and sold at +20%,−20%⟹ 0% Net Change (Breakeven).
- If two items are sold for the same price at +20%,−20%⟹ 4% Net Loss.
Direct Rupee Loss Shortcut:
If SP=₹9,900 and x=10%:
- Total SP=₹19,800, which represents 99% of total cost.
- Total CP=0.9919,800=₹20,000.
- Total loss is 20,000−19,800=₹200.
Formulas
| Equal SP Symmetrical Net Loss | Overall %Δ=−100x2%=−(10x)2% Holds strictly when Selling Prices are identical |
|---|
| Total Absolute Rupee Loss | Loss=10,000−x22⋅SP⋅x2 Where SP is the selling price of each individual article |
|---|
| Total Cost Price at Equal SP | CPtotal=10,000−x220,000⋅SP Sum of individual cost prices under identical selling prices |
|---|
| Equal CP Breakeven Rule | Overall %Δ=2x−x=0% When Cost Prices are identical, symmetrical rates cancel out perfectly |
|---|
Traps and tips
- Check the subject: Did the trader BUY them for equal prices, or SELL them for equal prices? That single word changes the answer from 0% to a loss.
- Never pick breakeven when SP is equal: Equal selling price with ±x% is guaranteed to be a net loss.
- The loss percentage is independent of the actual selling price: Whether SP is ₹10 or ₹10,00,000, ±20% always loses 4%.
- Individual cost gap: The item sold at a loss always had the higher Cost Price.
Solved examples
Example 2.3.1: Standard Benchmark Equal SP Transaction
An electronics dealer sells two identical-specification laptops for ₹24,000 each. On one laptop, the dealer makes a profit of 20%, while on the other, the dealer sustains a loss of 20%. Determine: (a) the overall percentage gain or loss, and (b) the total absolute rupee loss incurred on the transaction.
Show solution
Step 1: Compute overall net percentage change.
Since Selling Prices are identical and percentage shifts are symmetrical (x=20):
Overall %Δ=−(10x)2%=−(1020)2%=−4%
The transaction results in a net loss of 4%.
Step 2: Calculate total Selling Price and total Cost Price.
Total SP=2×₹24,000=₹48,000
Since total SP represents 96% (100%−4%) of total Cost Price:
Total CP=0.96₹48,000=₹50,000
Step 3: Calculate absolute rupee loss.
Absolute Loss=Total CP−Total SP=₹50,000−₹48,000=₹2,000
(Formula Check: 10,000−4002×24,000×400=9,60019,200,000=₹2,000).
Takeaway: When two articles are sold at the same price with ±20%, the transaction suffers a 4% loss, translating to a ₹2,000 deficit on a ₹48,000 turnover.
Example 2.3.2: Equal SP vs. Equal CP Contrast
Compare the financial outcomes of two commercial scenarios:
-
Scenario Alpha: A jeweler sells two gold bracelets for ₹1,200 each—one at a 25% profit and the other at a 25% loss.
-
Scenario Beta: The jeweler purchases two gold bracelets for ₹1,200 each—and sells one at a 25% profit and the other at a 25% loss.
Calculate the net rupee profit or loss for each scenario.
Show solution
Step 1: Evaluate Scenario Alpha (Equal Selling Price).
Total SP=2×1,200=₹2,400.
-
CP1=1.251,200=₹960
-
CP2=0.751,200=₹1,600
Total CPα=960+1,600=₹2,560.
Net Outcomeα=2,400−2,560=−₹160(Net Loss of ₹160)
Step 2: Evaluate Scenario Beta (Equal Cost Price).
Total CP=2×1,200=₹2,400.
-
SP1=1,200×1.25=₹1,500 (Profit =+₹300)
-
SP2=1,200×0.75=₹900 (Loss =−₹300)
Total SPβ=1,500+900=₹2,400.
Net Outcomeβ=2,400−2,400=₹0(Exact Breakeven)
Takeaway: Equal Cost Prices result in exact breakeven (₹0), whereas Equal Selling Prices produce a definite financial loss (-₹160).
Example 2.3.3: Asymmetric Rates at Equal Selling Price
A commercial real estate broker liquidates two retail office units at the same selling price of ₹60 lakh each. On Unit 1, the broker earns a profit of 20%. On Unit 2, the broker incurs a loss of 10%. Determine: (a) the individual cost prices of the two units, and (b) the overall percentage profit or loss on the combined transaction.
Show solution
Step 1: Compute individual Cost Prices.
-
Unit 1 (+20% profit):
CP1=1.20₹60 lakh=₹50 lakh
-
Unit 2 (−10% loss):
CP2=0.90₹60 lakh=9600=3200=₹66.67 lakh
Step 2: Compute aggregate Cost Price and Selling Price.
Total SP=60+60=₹120 lakh
Total CP=50+3200=3350≈₹116.67 lakh
Step 3: Determine overall net profit.
Net Profit=120−3350=3360−350=+310 lakh≈+₹3.33 lakh
% Profit=3350310×100%=35010×100%=351×100%=720%≈2.86%
The broker earns an overall profit of 2.86%.
Takeaway: When profit and loss percentages are asymmetric at equal SP, calculate individual cost prices directly to evaluate the combined outcome.
Example 2.3.4: Back-Calculating Individual Cost Prices
Two electric commuter scooters were sold for ₹42,000 each. The first scooter was sold at a profit of 25%, while the second scooter was sold at a loss of 25%. Find: (a) the cost price of each scooter, and (b) the difference between their cost prices.
Show solution
Step 1: Calculate Cost Price of the first scooter (CP1).
CP1=1+0.25₹42,000=1.2542,000=542,000×4=8,400×4=₹33,600
Step 2: Calculate Cost Price of the second scooter (CP2).
CP2=1−0.25₹42,000=0.7542,000=342,000×4=14,000×4=₹56,000
Step 3: Calculate the difference between their cost prices.
ΔCP=CP2−CP1=₹56,000−₹33,600=₹22,400
Takeaway: The losing item is significantly more expensive (₹56,000 vs ₹33,600), explaining why identical percentage swings fail to balance out.
Example 2.3.5: Fractional Rates at Equal Selling Price
An art dealer sells two rare sketches for ₹8,400 each. On the first sketch, he earns a profit of 16.67% (+61). On the second sketch, he suffers a loss of 12.5% (−81). Find the overall net rupee profit or loss across the two sales.
Show solution
Step 1: Express relationships using fractional multipliers.
-
Sketch 1: Profit =+61⟹SP=67CP1
CP1=76×8,400=6×1,200=₹7,200
-
Sketch 2: Loss =−81⟹SP=87CP2
CP2=78×8,400=8×1,200=₹9,600
Step 2: Calculate aggregate values.
Total CP=7,200+9,600=₹16,800
Total SP=2×8,400=₹16,800
Step 3: Determine net financial outcome.
Net Outcome=Total SP−Total CP=16,800−16,800=₹0
The dealer broke even exactly (0% net change).
Takeaway: When fractions align (+1/6 and -1/8 with equal SP), the gain of ₹1,200 on the first cancels the loss of ₹1,200 on the second perfectly.
Example 2.3.6: Back-Calculating Selling Price from Rupee Loss
A commercial printing vendor sells two laser printers at the exact same selling price, gaining 25% on the first and losing 25% on the second. If the vendor sustains an overall loss of ₹1,000 on the combined transaction, determine the selling price of each individual printer.
Show solution
Step 1: Compute overall net loss percentage.
With x=25:
Net Loss %=100252%=100625%=6.25%=161
Step 2: Relate rupee loss to Total Cost Price (CPtotal).
161 of CPtotal=₹1,000⟹CPtotal=16×1,000=₹16,000
Step 3: Compute Total Selling Price and individual Selling Price.
Total SP=CPtotal−Loss=₹16,000−₹1,000=₹15,000
Since both printers sell for the same price:
SPindividual=2₹15,000=₹7,500
Each printer was sold for ₹7,500.
Takeaway: A 6.25% loss is 1/16 of total cost. A loss of ₹1,000 implies total cost was ₹16,000, total revenue was ₹15,000, and individual SP was ₹7,500.
Practice questions
Question 1 · CAT Level
A merchant sells two luxury watches at the exact same selling price. On the first watch, he earns a profit of 3331%. On the second watch, he incurs a loss such that on the combined transaction he breaks even exactly (0% net profit or loss). If the absolute difference between the cost prices of the two watches is ₹1,800, what was the common selling price of each watch?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) ₹ 3,600
Let the common selling price of each watch be SP.
For the first watch, SP=34CP1⟹CP1=43SP.
For exact breakeven on the combined deal, Total CP=2SP⟹CP2=2SP−43SP=45SP.
Difference between cost prices =CP2−CP1=(45−43)SP=21SP.
Given 21SP=₹1,800⟹SP=1,800×2=₹3,600.
Question 2 · CAT Level
An investor executes four antique coin transactions. He sells Coin 1 and Coin 2 at the same selling price of ₹9,900 each, gaining 10% on Coin 1 and losing 10% on Coin 2. Simultaneously, he purchases Coin 3 and Coin 4 at the same cost price of ₹9,900 each, selling Coin 3 at a profit of 10% and Coin 4 at a loss of 10%. What is the investor\x27s overall net rupee profit or loss across all four transactions combined?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (A) Net loss of ₹ 200
For Coins 1 and 2 (Equal SP of ₹9,900): CP1=1.109,900=₹9,000 and CP2=0.909,900=₹11,000.
Total CP1,2=9,000+11,000=₹20,000, while Total SP1,2=2×9,900=₹19,800, giving a net loss of ₹200.
For Coins 3 and 4 (Equal CP of ₹9,900): Profit on Coin 3 is +₹990 and Loss on Coin 4 is −₹990, yielding exact breakeven (₹0).
Combining both portfolios: Net result =−200+0=−₹200 (Net loss of ₹200).
Equal SP yields an inevitable loss of 100x2%, while Equal CP strictly breaks even.
Question 3 · CAT Level
A machinery merchant sells two industrial generators at the same selling price. On the first generator, he gains x%, and on the second generator, he loses x%. The ratio of the cost price of the first generator to that of the second generator is 3:5. If the total combined selling price of both generators is ₹30,000, what is the total absolute rupee loss incurred on the transaction?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) ₹ 2,000
Let common selling price be SP. Then CP1=1+x/100SP and CP2=1−x/100SP.
Ratio CP2CP1=1+x/1001−x/100=53⟹5−1005x=3+1003x⟹1008x=2⟹x=25%.
By the Equal SP Theorem, overall loss percentage is 100x2%=100625%=6.25%=161 of Total CP.
Thus Total SP=1615CPtotal⟹₹30,000=1615CPtotal⟹CPtotal=₹32,000.
Total rupee loss =32,000−30,000=₹2,000.
Question 4 · CAT Level
Three distinct articles A, B, and C are sold at the same selling price. On article A, the seller earns a profit of 20%; on article B, he earns a profit of 25%; and on article C, he incurs a loss of 10%. If the seller realizes an aggregate net profit of ₹460 across the three articles, what is the cost price of article C?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) ₹ 2,000
Let the common selling price be SP. Individual cost prices are CPA=65SP, CPB=54SP, and CPC=910SP.
Rupee profit/loss on each: ProfitA=61SP, ProfitB=51SP, and LossC=91SP.
Net profit =(61+51−91)SP=9015+18−10SP=9023SP.
Given 9023SP=₹460⟹SP=23460×90=₹1,800.
Cost price of article C=CPC=910×1,800=₹2,000.
Question 5 · CAT Level
A trader sells two articles M and N at the same selling price. On article M, he earns a profit of 3331%, and on article N, he incurs a loss of 25%. He pools the entire sales proceeds from both articles and uses the full amount to purchase article P, which he subsequently sells at a profit of 25%. What is his overall percentage profit on his initial capital invested in articles M and N?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 20\%
Let common selling price of M and N be SP. Initial capital outlay =CPM+CPN=43SP+34SP=1225SP.
Total revenue realized from selling M and N is 2SP=1224SP.
This entire revenue is reinvested to buy article P at cost 2SP.
Article P sells at 25% profit, yielding final cash =2SP×1.25=2.5SP=1230SP.
Overall net profit percentage =1225SP1230SP−1225SP×100%=255×100%=20%.
Try real CAT questions