Free CAT library

Faulty Weights & The Dishonest Dealer

Deconstruct deceptive weight mechanics, master the False Weight Multiplier (Claimed/Actual), chain weight tampering with markups and discounts, and solve double-cheating transactions.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Rigged Scale

In a traditional spice market, an old merchant proudly hangs a banner: "Honest Grocer: I sell all organic almonds at Cost Price. Zero markup!"

Customers flock to his shop, believing they are getting the bargain of the decade. But under his brass counter, the merchant has placed a concealed magnet under the weighing pan. When a customer orders 1,000 grams1,000\text{ grams}, the scale tips when only 800 grams800\text{ grams} of almonds are in the pan.

The customer hands over money for 1,000g1,000\text{g}. The merchant parts with only 800g800\text{g} of inventory.

What was his profit?

Profit=1000−800800=200800=25%!\text{Profit} = \frac{1000 - 800}{800} = \frac{200}{800} = \mathbf{25\%!}

Without marking up his nominal price by a single rupee, the merchant generated a massive 25%25\% profit purely by tampering with the physical denominator.


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Layers of Deception

In CAT Quantitative Aptitude, dishonest dealer problems are rarely simple single-weight tricks. They combine multiple deceptive layers:

  1. The Pure False Weight: Selling at cost price, but dispensing less weight.

  2. Cheating in Both Buying and Selling: Using a heavy weight (1,100g1,100\text{g}) when buying from wholesalers, and a light weight (900g900\text{g}) when selling to retail consumers.

  3. Compound Fraud: Marking up the nominal price, giving an apparent promotional discount, AND using a false weight.

  4. Adulteration / Impurity Infusion: Adding water to milk or stones to grain and selling at cost price.


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Master Composite Multiplier

The cleanest, most foolproof method to solve any dishonest dealer problem is the Multiplier Method. Break the fraud into independent dimensionless multipliers and multiply:

Mnet=Mweight×Mmarkup×MdiscountM_{\text{net}} = M_{\text{weight}} \times M_{\text{markup}} \times M_{\text{discount}}

A. The False Weight Multiplier (MweightM_{\text{weight}}):

Mweight=Weight Claimed / Charged to CustomerActual Weight Dispensed from InventoryM_{\text{weight}} = \frac{\text{Weight Claimed / Charged to Customer}}{\text{Actual Weight Dispensed from Inventory}}

  • Gives 900g900\text{g} for 1,000g  ⟹  Mw=1000900=1091,000\text{g} \implies M_w = \frac{1000}{900} = \frac{10}{9}

  • Gives 800g800\text{g} for 1,000g  ⟹  Mw=1000800=54=1.251,000\text{g} \implies M_w = \frac{1000}{800} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25

  • Gives 750g750\text{g} for 1,000g  ⟹  Mw=1000750=431,000\text{g} \implies M_w = \frac{1000}{750} = \frac{4}{3}

B. Cheating in Both Buying and Selling:

When purchasing from a farmer/wholesaler, the dealer extracts extra goods for the same cost:

Mbuy=Actual Weight ReceivedNominal Weight Paid ForM_{\text{buy}} = \frac{\text{Actual Weight Received}}{\text{Nominal Weight Paid For}}

When selling to a consumer:

Msell=Nominal Weight ChargedActual Weight DispensedM_{\text{sell}} = \frac{\text{Nominal Weight Charged}}{\text{Actual Weight Dispensed}}

  ⟹  Mnet=Mbuy×Msell=Actual Weight ReceivedActual Weight Dispensed\implies M_{\text{net}} = M_{\text{buy}} \times M_{\text{sell}} = \frac{\text{Actual Weight Received}}{\text{Actual Weight Dispensed}}

C. Extracting Net Profit Percentage:

% Profit=(Mnet−1)×100%\% \text{ Profit} = (M_{\text{net}} - 1) \times 100\%


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The 200g Fallacy:

If a dealer gives 800g800\text{g} instead of 1,000g1,000\text{g}:

  • The Trap: Students think 2001000=20%\frac{200}{1000} = 20\% profit (WRONG!)
  • The Reality: The dealer parted with only 800g800\text{g} of cost. The base is 800g800\text{g}:

Profit %=1000−800800×100%=200800=25%\text{Profit \%} = \frac{1000 - 800}{800} \times 100\% = \frac{200}{800} = \mathbf{25\%}

The Multiplier Speed Chain:

If a dealer marks up by 20%20\%, gives a 10%10\% discount, and uses 900g900\text{g} for 1kg1\text{kg}:

Mnet=1000900×1.20×0.90=109×65×910=65=1.20  ⟹  +20% profitM_{\text{net}} = \frac{1000}{900} \times 1.20 \times 0.90 = \frac{10}{9} \times \frac{6}{5} \times \frac{9}{10} = \frac{6}{5} = 1.20 \implies \mathbf{+20\% \text{ profit}}

Solved in one cancellation line!

Formulas

False Weight Multiplier

Mweight=Claimed WeightActual Weight DispensedM_{\text{weight}} = \frac{\text{Claimed Weight}}{\text{Actual Weight Dispensed}}

Measures ratio of revenue billed to physical cost dispensed
Master Composite Dealer Multiplier

Mnet=Mweight×Mmarkup×MdiscountM_{\text{net}} = M_{\text{weight}} \times M_{\text{markup}} \times M_{\text{discount}}

Chains all deceptive and commercial price adjustments
Dual Cheating Formula (Buying & Selling)

Mnet=Weight Taken from SupplierWeight Given to CustomerM_{\text{net}} = \frac{\text{Weight Taken from Supplier}}{\text{Weight Given to Customer}}

Bypasses nominal intermediate weights
Adulteration Profit Multiplier

Madulteration=Volume of MixtureVolume of Pure Liquid CostedM_{\text{adulteration}} = \frac{\text{Volume of Mixture}}{\text{Volume of Pure Liquid Costed}}

Used when zero-cost diluents like water are blended

Traps and tips

  • The denominator is ALWAYS the actual weight dispensed: If a dealer dispenses x grams instead of y grams, base is x, not y.
  • Dual cheating is multiplicative, not additive: Stealing 10% in buying and 10% in selling is (1.10) * (1000/900), not +20%.
  • Cloth meter stick: A shortened meter measuring 90cm has Mw = 100/90 = 10/9 (+11.11% profit).
  • Chain fractions directly: Always express false weights as fractions (e.g., 1000/800 = 5/4) to enable immediate cancellations.

Solved examples

Example 2.4.1: Fundamental False Weight Profit

A dry fruits trader advertises that he sells Californian almonds strictly at Cost Price with zero markup. However, using a tampered digital balance, he dispenses only 900 grams900\text{ grams} whenever a customer purchases a 1-kilogram1\text{-kilogram} pack. Determine the trader's actual percentage profit.

Show solution

Step 1: Identify claimed weight and actual weight dispensed.

  • Claimed weight =1,000 grams= 1,000\text{ grams}

  • Actual weight dispensed =900 grams= 900\text{ grams}

Step 2: Formulate the False Weight Multiplier (MweightM_{\text{weight}}).

Mweight=Claimed WeightActual Weight=1,000900=109M_{\text{weight}} = \frac{\text{Claimed Weight}}{\text{Actual Weight}} = \frac{1,000}{900} = \frac{10}{9}

Step 3: Compute percentage profit.

% Profit=(Mweight−1)×100%=(109−1)×100%=19×100%=11.11%\% \text{ Profit} = (M_{\text{weight}} - 1) \times 100\% = \left(\frac{10}{9} - 1\right) \times 100\% = \frac{1}{9} \times 100\% = 11.11\%

The trader makes an actual profit of 11.11%11.11\%.

Takeaway: The profit is 100g on an 800g/900g base. 100/900 = 1/9 = 11.11%, NOT 10%!

Example 2.4.2: Combined Markup, Discount & False Weight

A grocery store merchant marks up the price of basmati rice by 20%20\% above Cost Price, offers a promotional clearance discount of 10%10\%, and additionally uses a faulty weighing stone of 800 grams800\text{ grams} instead of a standard 1-kilogram1\text{-kilogram} weight. Calculate the merchant's net overall profit percentage.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute individual component multipliers.

  • Markup multiplier: Mmarkup=1+0.20=65M_{\text{markup}} = 1 + 0.20 = \frac{6}{5}

  • Discount multiplier: Mdiscount=1−0.10=910M_{\text{discount}} = 1 - 0.10 = \frac{9}{10}

  • False weight multiplier: Mweight=1,000g800g=54M_{\text{weight}} = \frac{1,000\text{g}}{800\text{g}} = \frac{5}{4}

Step 2: Chain the multipliers into the Master Multiplier (MnetM_{\text{net}}).

Mnet=Mweight×Mmarkup×MdiscountM_{\text{net}} = M_{\text{weight}} \times M_{\text{markup}} \times M_{\text{discount}}

Mnet=54×65×910M_{\text{net}} = \frac{5}{4} \times \frac{6}{5} \times \frac{9}{10}

Step 3: Cancel and evaluate.

Mnet=54×65×910=5440=2720=1.35M_{\text{net}} = \frac{\cancel{5}}{4} \times \frac{6}{\cancel{5}} \times \frac{9}{10} = \frac{54}{40} = \frac{27}{20} = 1.35

Step 4: Extract net profit percentage.

% Profit=(1.35−1)×100%=+35%\% \text{ Profit} = (1.35 - 1) \times 100\% = +35\%

The merchant earns a net profit of 35%35\%.

Takeaway: Multiplying (5/4) (6/5) (9/10) simplifies cleanly to 27/20 = 1.35, revealing an exact 35% net profit.

Example 2.4.3: Cheating in Both Buying and Selling

A dishonest spice wholesaler uses tampered weights at both ends of his supply chain: when buying whole black pepper from farmers, he uses a false weight of 1,100 grams1,100\text{ grams} for a kilogram; when selling to retailers, he uses a false weight of 880 grams880\text{ grams} for a kilogram. If he sells the pepper at nominal cost price, find his net profit percentage.

Show solution

Step 1: Analyze the procurement stage (Buying).

For every nominal 1kg1\text{kg} payment, he takes 1,100g1,100\text{g}:

Mbuy=1,1001,000=1.10M_{\text{buy}} = \frac{1,100}{1,000} = 1.10

Step 2: Analyze the dispensing stage (Selling).

For every nominal 1kg1\text{kg} billed, he dispenses 880g880\text{g}:

Msell=1,000880=10088=2522M_{\text{sell}} = \frac{1,000}{880} = \frac{100}{88} = \frac{25}{22}

Step 3: Combine multipliers using the Dual Cheating formula.

Mnet=Weight TakenWeight Given=1,100880M_{\text{net}} = \frac{\text{Weight Taken}}{\text{Weight Given}} = \frac{1,100}{880}

Divide numerator and denominator by 220220:

Mnet=54=1.25M_{\text{net}} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25

Step 4: Extract net profit percentage.

% Profit=(1.25−1)×100%=25%\% \text{ Profit} = (1.25 - 1) \times 100\% = 25\%

The wholesaler makes a net profit of 25%25\%.

Takeaway: In dual cheating, directly divide Weight Received (1,100g) by Weight Given (880g): 1,100 / 880 = 5/4 = 1.25 (+25% profit).

Example 2.4.4: Defective Meter Scale in Textile Retail

A textile retailer advertises pure silk fabric at Cost Price. However, his measuring meter stick has shrunk due to humidity and actually measures only 92 cm92\text{ cm} instead of 100 cm100\text{ cm}. In addition, he levies a 3.5%3.5\% handling fee on each invoice. Calculate his net overall profit percentage.

Show solution

Step 1: Formulate the meter stick multiplier (MscaleM_{\text{scale}}).

Mscale=Claimed LengthActual Length=100 cm92 cm=2523M_{\text{scale}} = \frac{\text{Claimed Length}}{\text{Actual Length}} = \frac{100\text{ cm}}{92\text{ cm}} = \frac{25}{23}

Step 2: Formulate the handling fee multiplier.

Handling fee =+3.5%  ⟹  Mfee=1+0.035=103.5100=207200= +3.5\% \implies M_{\text{fee}} = 1 + 0.035 = \frac{103.5}{100} = \frac{207}{200}

Step 3: Compute the composite multiplier (MnetM_{\text{net}}).

Mnet=2523×207200M_{\text{net}} = \frac{25}{23} \times \frac{207}{200}

Notice that 207=23×9207 = 23 \times 9:

Mnet=2523×9×23200=25×9200=98=1.125M_{\text{net}} = \frac{25}{\cancel{23}} \times \frac{9 \times \cancel{23}}{200} = \frac{25 \times 9}{200} = \frac{9}{8} = 1.125

Step 4: Compute net profit percentage.

% Profit=(1.125−1)×100%=12.5%\% \text{ Profit} = (1.125 - 1) \times 100\% = 12.5\%

The retailer earns a net profit of 12.5%12.5\%.

Takeaway: The meter stick multiplier is 100/92 = 25/23. Multiplying by 207/200 yields 9/8 = 1.125, which is exactly a 12.5% profit.

Example 2.4.5: Calibrating a False Weight for Target Profit

A merchant sells grain nominally at Cost Price. Seeking to covertly earn an exact profit of 33.33%33.33\% through scale manipulation alone, what physical weight (in grams) must his calibrated balance dispense whenever a customer pays for 1 kilogram1\text{ kilogram}?

Show solution

Step 1: Identify target profit and required multiplier.

Target Profit=+33.33%=+13\text{Target Profit} = +33.33\% = +\frac{1}{3}

Mrequired=1+13=43M_{\text{required}} = 1 + \frac{1}{3} = \frac{4}{3}

Step 2: Relate to the false weight equation.

M=Claimed WeightActual Weight  ⟹  43=1,000gWactualM = \frac{\text{Claimed Weight}}{\text{Actual Weight}} \implies \frac{4}{3} = \frac{1,000\text{g}}{W_{\text{actual}}}

Step 3: Solve for WactualW_{\text{actual}}.

Wactual=1,000×34=750 gramsW_{\text{actual}} = \frac{1,000 \times 3}{4} = 750\text{ grams}

The balance must dispense 750 grams750\text{ grams}.

Takeaway: To earn a 33.33% profit (multiplier 4/3), the actual weight dispensed must be 3/4 of the claimed weight: (3/4) 1,000g = 750g.

Example 2.4.6: Adulteration with Free Diluent & Price Markup

A dairy vendor purchases pure unadulterated milk at ₹4040 per liter. He mixes free tap water such that water constitutes 20%20\% of the total final mixture. He then sells the diluted milk at ₹4545 per liter. Determine his net percentage profit.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute dilution volume expansion.

Let the volume of pure milk purchased be 4 liters4\text{ liters} at a cost of 4×40=₹1604 \times 40 = ₹160.

If water is 20%20\% (15\frac{1}{5}) of the final mixture, then pure milk represents 80%80\% (45\frac{4}{5}) of the mixture.

Thus, total volume of mixture =40.80=5 liters= \frac{4}{0.80} = 5\text{ liters} (containing 1 liter1\text{ liter} water).

Step 2: Compute total revenue generated (SPSP).

SP=5 liters×₹45/liter=₹225SP = 5\text{ liters} \times ₹45/\text{liter} = ₹225

Step 3: Calculate net profit percentage.

Net Profit=SP−CP=₹225−₹160=₹65\text{Net Profit} = SP - CP = ₹225 - ₹160 = ₹65

% Profit=65160×100%=65016=40.625%\% \text{ Profit} = \frac{65}{160} \times 100\% = \frac{650}{16} = 40.625\%

Multiplier Verification:

  • Dilution multiplier: Mvol=54=1.25M_{\text{vol}} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25

  • Price multiplier: Mprice=4540=1.125M_{\text{price}} = \frac{45}{40} = 1.125

Mnet=1.25×1.125=1.40625  ⟹  +40.625%M_{\text{net}} = 1.25 \times 1.125 = 1.40625 \implies +40.625\%

Takeaway: The volume expansion factor (5/4) combines multiplicatively with the price markup factor (45/40) to yield a 40.625% net profit.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

A dishonest spice dealer cheats his supplier by procuring 20%20\% more weight than he pays for. While selling to customers, he marks up the price by 10%10\%, offers a discount of 10%10\%, and uses a tampered balance dispensing 10%10\% less weight than claimed. Additionally, 5%5\% of his procured stock spoils during storage and is discarded. What is his net overall profit percentage on the transaction?

  1. A

    22.5%22.5\%

  2. B

    24.0%24.0\%

  3. C

    25.4%25.4\%

  4. D

    26.8%26.8\%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 25.4\%

Buying multiplier: Mbuy=1.20=65M_{\text{buy}} = 1.20 = \frac{6}{5}; spoilage multiplier: Mspoil=1−0.05=1920M_{\text{spoil}} = 1 - 0.05 = \frac{19}{20}.

Markup multiplier: Mmark=1.10M_{\text{mark}} = 1.10; discount multiplier: Mdisc=0.90M_{\text{disc}} = 0.90.

False weight multiplier on selling: Mwt=1,000900=109M_{\text{wt}} = \frac{1,000}{900} = \frac{10}{9}.

Master composite multiplier Mnet=65×1920×1110×910×109=6×19×111,000=1,2541,000=1.254M_{\text{net}} = \frac{6}{5} \times \frac{19}{20} \times \frac{11}{10} \times \frac{9}{10} \times \frac{10}{9} = \frac{6 \times 19 \times 11}{1,000} = \frac{1,254}{1,000} = 1.254.

Net profit percentage =(1.254−1)×100%=25.4%= (1.254 - 1) \times 100\% = 25.4\%.

Question 2 · CAT Level

A dry-fruit merchant marks up almonds by 25%25\% above Cost Price and advertises a 10%10\% discount on the marked price. However, he also uses a false weighing stone for 1 kg1\text{ kg}. On an order billed as 40 kg40\text{ kg} for a total invoice of ₹18,00018,000, the merchant realizes an actual rupee profit of ₹6,0006,000. What was the true weight (in grams) dispensed by his 1-kg1\text{-kg} weighing stone?

  1. A

    720 g720\text{ g}

  2. B

    750 g750\text{ g}

  3. C

    800 g800\text{ g}

  4. D

    825 g825\text{ g}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 750 g

Billed rate per kg =18,00040=₹450= \frac{18,000}{40} = ₹450. With price multiplier 1.25×0.90=981.25 \times 0.90 = \frac{9}{8}, true CP=450×89=₹400/kgCP = 450 \times \frac{8}{9} = ₹400/\text{kg}.

Merchant\x27s total cost =Revenue−Profit=18,000−6,000=₹12,000= \text{Revenue} - \text{Profit} = 18,000 - 6,000 = ₹12,000.

Actual weight of almonds dispensed =12,000400=30 kg= \frac{12,000}{400} = 30\text{ kg}.

The merchant dispensed 30 kg30\text{ kg} while billing for 40 kg40\text{ kg}.

Weight per nominal kilogram =3040×1,000 g=750 grams= \frac{30}{40} \times 1,000\text{ g} = 750\text{ grams}.

Question 3 · CAT Level

A dishonest milkman adulterates pure milk by adding 1 liter1\text{ liter} of water (available free of cost) for every 4 liters4\text{ liters} of pure milk purchased. He advertises that he sells the mixture at a discount of 4%4\% below the cost price of pure milk. However, he uses a measuring vessel that dispenses only 800 mL800\text{ mL} for every nominal 1 liter1\text{ liter} billed. What is his net profit percentage?

  1. A

    40%40\%

  2. B

    45%45\%

  3. C

    50%50\%

  4. D

    56%56\%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 50\%

Dilution multiplier: 4 L4\text{ L} pure becomes 5 L5\text{ L} mixture   ⟹  Mvol=54\implies M_{\text{vol}} = \frac{5}{4}.

Discount multiplier: 4%4\% below cost   ⟹  Mprice=1−0.04=0.96=2425\implies M_{\text{price}} = 1 - 0.04 = 0.96 = \frac{24}{25}.

False measurement multiplier: 800 mL800\text{ mL} dispensed per 1,000 mL1,000\text{ mL} billed   ⟹  Mwt=1,000800=54\implies M_{\text{wt}} = \frac{1,000}{800} = \frac{5}{4}.

Master multiplier Mnet=Mvol×Mprice×Mwt=54×2425×54=2416=1.50M_{\text{net}} = M_{\text{vol}} \times M_{\text{price}} \times M_{\text{wt}} = \frac{5}{4} \times \frac{24}{25} \times \frac{5}{4} = \frac{24}{16} = 1.50.

Net profit percentage =(1.50−1)×100%=50%= (1.50 - 1) \times 100\% = 50\%.

Question 4 · CAT Level

A saffron trader uses a fraudulent weighing balance. When purchasing saffron from a wholesaler, his scale reads 900 grams900\text{ grams} when 1 kilogram1\text{ kilogram} is placed on the pan. When selling to retail customers, his scale reads 1 kilogram1\text{ kilogram} when only 800 grams800\text{ grams} is placed on the pan. If he advertises his saffron at an apparent promotional loss of 10%10\% on nominal cost price, what is his actual net profit percentage?

  1. A

    20%20\%

  2. B

    22.5%22.5\%

  3. C

    25%25\%

  4. D

    28%28\%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 25\%

When buying, the scale reads 900 g900\text{ g} for 1,000 g1,000\text{ g} actual, so he takes 1,000900=109\frac{1,000}{900} = \frac{10}{9} times true weight: Mbuy=109M_{\text{buy}} = \frac{10}{9}.

When selling, the scale reads 1,000 g1,000\text{ g} for 800 g800\text{ g} actual, so Msell=1,000800=54M_{\text{sell}} = \frac{1,000}{800} = \frac{5}{4}.

He sells at 10%10\% below nominal cost: Mprice=0.90=910M_{\text{price}} = 0.90 = \frac{9}{10}.

Composite multiplier Mnet=109×54×910=54=1.25M_{\text{net}} = \frac{10}{9} \times \frac{5}{4} \times \frac{9}{10} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25.

Actual net profit percentage =(1.25−1)×100%=25%= (1.25 - 1) \times 100\% = 25\%.

Question 5 · CAT Level

A merchant maintains two balances: Balance A is perfectly accurate, while Balance B dispenses only 800 g800\text{ g} for every 1 kg1\text{ kg} billed. He marks his entire inventory 25%25\% above Cost Price. He dispenses 60%60\% of his physical inventory using Balance B, offering a 4%4\% discount on Marked Price. He dispenses the remaining 40%40\% of his physical inventory using Balance A at the full Marked Price. What is his overall net profit percentage across the entire inventory?

  1. A

    35%35\%

  2. B

    38%38\%

  3. C

    40%40\%

  4. D

    42.5%42.5\%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 40\%

Let total physical stock be 1,000 g1,000\text{ g} at CP=₹1/gCP = ₹1/\text{g} (Total CP=₹1,000CP = ₹1,000). Marked Price MP=₹1.25/gMP = ₹1.25/\text{g}.

Batch 1 (600 g600\text{ g} physical on Balance B): billed as 600×1,000800=750 g600 \times \frac{1,000}{800} = 750\text{ g}.

Selling price with 4%4\% discount =1.25×0.96=₹1.20/g= 1.25 \times 0.96 = ₹1.20/\text{g}, yielding revenue =750×1.20=₹900= 750 \times 1.20 = ₹900.

Batch 2 (400 g400\text{ g} physical on Balance A): billed as 400 g400\text{ g} at MP=₹1.25/gMP = ₹1.25/\text{g}, yielding revenue =400×1.25=₹500= 400 \times 1.25 = ₹500.

Total revenue =900+500=₹1,400= 900 + 500 = ₹1,400, giving net profit percentage =1,400−1,0001,000×100%=40%= \frac{1,400 - 1,000}{1,000} \times 100\% = 40\%.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library