Free CAT library

The Rule of Alligation (Cross Diagram Mechanics)

Master the visual Alligation Cross diagram, identify the reference denominator base across diverse arithmetic domains (price, speed, profit, interest), and solve complex 3-variable mixture ratios.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Inverted Lever

Two thousand years ago in Syracuse, Archimedes proved the Law of the Lever: to balance two unequal weights on a lever, the distance from the fulcrum must be inversely proportional to the weight. A 10 kg10\text{ kg} weight placed 2 meters2\text{ meters} from the pivot balances a 20 kg20\text{ kg} weight placed 1 meter1\text{ meter} from the pivot:

w1⋅d1=w2⋅d2  ⟺  w1w2=d2d1w_1 \cdot d_1 = w_2 \cdot d_2 \iff \frac{w_1}{w_2} = \frac{d_2}{d_1}

In quantitative aptitude, The Rule of Alligation is nothing more than Archimedes' lever transformed into a rapid visual cross diagram. Whenever two entities with different rates are combined to produce a mean target rate, Alligation instantly reveals the ratio in which they must be blended—bypassing linear equations completely.


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Chameleon Shortcut

Alligation is the single most versatile tactical weapon in the entire CAT syllabus because it applies across completely different chapters:

  1. Commercial Blending: Mixing cheap grain with expensive grain to achieve a target price.

  2. Profit and Loss: Selling part of goods at +20%+20\% profit and part at −10%-10\% loss to average +5%+5\% profit (Weights are Cost Prices!).

  3. Kinematics (TSD): Traveling part-way at 60 km/h60\text{ km/h} and part-way at 90 km/h90\text{ km/h} to average 70 km/h70\text{ km/h} (Weights are Travel Times!).

  4. Simple Interest: Splitting a capital sum between 8%8\% and 12%12\% lending rates to earn an average return of 9.5%9.5\% (Weights are Principals!).


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Alligation Cross Diagram


Cheaper Rate (c)             Dearer Rate (d)

                \           /

                 Mean Rate (m)

                /           \

Quantity (d - m)      :      Quantity (m - c)

QcheaperQdearer=d−mm−c\frac{Q_{\text{cheaper}}}{Q_{\text{dearer}}} = \frac{d - m}{m - c}

THE CARDINAL RULE: What Do the Bottom Quantities Represent?

The bottom quantities ALWAYS represent the denominator unit of the rates being alligated:

Rates Being AlligatedRate UnitResulting Alligation Weights (Q1:Q2Q_1 : Q_2)
Price per kg₹ / kgMass in Kilograms
Speedkm / hourTravel Time in Hours
Profit / Loss %Profit / Cost PriceCost Price in ₹
Interest Rate %Interest / PrincipalPrincipal Amount in ₹
Concentration %Solute / SolutionSolution Volume in Liters
Average MarksMarks / StudentNumber of Students

4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Speed Alligation Trap:

When alligating speeds (60 km/h60\text{ km/h} and 90 km/h90\text{ km/h}), the resulting ratio is the ratio of TIMES, NEVER distances! To find distances, multiply the resulting time parts by their respective speeds.

The Selling Price Blending Trap:

You CANNOT alligate Selling Prices directly if the mixture selling price includes an embedded profit percentage!

  • Must convert first: Find the Cost Price of the mixture: CPmean=SPmean1+P%/100CP_{\text{mean}} = \frac{SP_{\text{mean}}}{1 + P\%/100}.
  • Then alligate Cost Prices.

Formulas

The Rule of Alligation

QcQd=d−mm−c\frac{Q_c}{Q_d} = \frac{d - m}{m - c}

Where c is cheaper rate, d is dearer rate, and m is composite mean
Mean Cost Price Extraction

CPmean=SPmean1+P%100CP_{\text{mean}} = \frac{SP_{\text{mean}}}{1 + \frac{P\%}{100}}

Mandatory prerequisite before alligating commercial blends with profit
Distance Conversion from Speed Alligation

D1:D2=(S1⋅t1):(S2⋅t2)D_1 : D_2 = (S_1 \cdot t_1) : (S_2 \cdot t_2)

Converts time ratio obtained from alligation into distance ratio
Principal Split via Rate Alligation

P1P2=r2−rmeanrmean−r1\frac{P_1}{P_2} = \frac{r_2 - r_{\text{mean}}}{r_{\text{mean}} - r_1}

Splits capital across two simple interest lending rates

Traps and tips

  • Never alligate mixture SP: Always extract mixture CP first before drawing the cross diagram.
  • Speed alligation yields Time: Distance = Speed * Time; speed alligation strictly produces time weights.
  • Profit alligation yields Cost Price: Because profit% = P / CP, alligating profit rates gives the ratio of Cost Prices.
  • Subtractions are always positive: It is always (Dearer - Mean) and (Mean - Cheaper).

Solved examples

Example 4.3.1: Fundamental Commodity Price Blending

A tea merchant blends high-altitude Assam tea priced at ₹240240 per kg with premium Darjeeling tea priced at ₹360360 per kg. In what ratio must he mix the two varieties so that the resulting blended tea is worth ₹310310 per kg?

Show solution

Step 1: Set up the Alligation Cross diagram.

  • Cheaper tea rate c=₹240/kgc = ₹240/\text{kg}

  • Dearer tea rate d=₹360/kgd = ₹360/\text{kg}

  • Target mean rate m=₹310/kgm = ₹310/\text{kg}

Step 2: Calculate cross differences.

  • Right branch: d−m=360−310=50d - m = 360 - 310 = 50

  • Left branch: m−c=310−240=70m - c = 310 - 240 = 70

Step 3: Express the ratio.

QAssamQDarjeeling=d−mm−c=5070=57\frac{Q_{\text{Assam}}}{Q_{\text{Darjeeling}}} = \frac{d - m}{m - c} = \frac{50}{70} = \frac{5}{7}

The merchant must mix Assam and Darjeeling tea in the ratio 5:75 : 7.

Takeaway: The cross differences are (360 - 310) = 50 and (310 - 240) = 70. The ratio is 50:70 = 5:7.

Example 4.3.2: Blending with Embedded Retail Profit

A grain merchant mixes red lentils costing ₹4545 per kg with yellow lentils costing ₹6060 per kg. He sells the blended mixture at ₹6666 per kg, thereby making a net profit of 20%20\%. In what ratio did he mix the red and yellow lentils?

Show solution

Step 1: Extract the true Cost Price of the mixture (CPmeanCP_{\text{mean}}).

The selling price of ₹6666 includes a 20%20\% profit:

CPmean=SPmean1+0.20=₹661.20=66012=₹55 per kgCP_{\text{mean}} = \frac{SP_{\text{mean}}}{1 + 0.20} = \frac{₹66}{1.20} = \frac{660}{12} = ₹55\text{ per kg}

Step 2: Apply Alligation on Cost Prices.

  • Cheaper lentils c=₹45/kgc = ₹45/\text{kg}

  • Dearer lentils d=₹60/kgd = ₹60/\text{kg}

  • Mean mixture cost m=₹55/kgm = ₹55/\text{kg}

Step 3: Calculate cross differences.

  • d−m=60−55=5d - m = 60 - 55 = 5

  • m−c=55−45=10m - c = 55 - 45 = 10

QredQyellow=510=12\frac{Q_{\text{red}}}{Q_{\text{yellow}}} = \frac{5}{10} = \frac{1}{2}

The merchant mixed the lentils in the ratio 1:21 : 2.

Takeaway: Never alligate with SP (₹66). Extract mixture CP = 66 / 1.2 = ₹55 first. Then alligate: (60 - 55) : (55 - 45) = 5:10 = 1:2.

Example 4.3.3: Alligation on Speeds — The Time Base Rule

An autonomous delivery van travels a total distance of 300 km300\text{ km} in 6 hours6\text{ hours} (average speed 50 km/h50\text{ km/h}). The van traveled part of the journey on an express highway at 70 km/h70\text{ km/h} and the remaining part through urban congestion at 25 km/h25\text{ km/h}. Calculate: (a) the time spent on the highway, and (b) the distance covered on the highway.

Show solution

Step 1: Set up Alligation on speeds.

  • Urban speed c=25 km/hc = 25\text{ km/h}

  • Highway speed d=70 km/hd = 70\text{ km/h}

  • Average speed m=50 km/hm = 50\text{ km/h}

Step 2: Calculate cross differences.

  • d−m=70−50=20d - m = 70 - 50 = 20

  • m−c=50−25=25m - c = 50 - 25 = 25

TurbanThighway=2025=45\frac{T_{\text{urban}}}{T_{\text{highway}}} = \frac{20}{25} = \frac{4}{5}

(CRITICAL: This is the ratio of travel TIMES, not distances!)

Step 3: Distribute total journey time of 6 hours6\text{ hours}.

Total parts =4+5=9 parts=6 hours= 4 + 5 = 9\text{ parts} = 6\text{ hours}.

Thighway=59×6 hours=309=103 hours=3 hours 20 minutesT_{\text{highway}} = \frac{5}{9} \times 6\text{ hours} = \frac{30}{9} = \frac{10}{3}\text{ hours} = 3\text{ hours } 20\text{ minutes}

Step 4: Compute distance covered on the highway.

Dhighway=Shighway×Thighway=70×103=7003≈233.33 kmD_{\text{highway}} = S_{\text{highway}} \times T_{\text{highway}} = 70 \times \frac{10}{3} = \frac{700}{3} \approx 233.33\text{ km}

Takeaway: Alligating speeds produces the ratio of travel times (4:5). Highway time is (5/9) 6 = 10/3 hours, giving distance = 70 10/3 = 233.33 km.

Example 4.3.4: Alligation on Profits and Losses

A vintage dealer purchases two antique wristwatches for a combined sum of ₹3,0003,000. He sells the first watch at a profit of 15%15\% and the second watch at a loss of 10%10\%. On the whole transaction, he breaks even (neither profit nor loss, 0%0\% net change). Find the cost price of each individual watch.

Show solution

Step 1: Set up Alligation on profit/loss percentages.

  • Watch 2 (loss) c=−10%c = -10\%

  • Watch 1 (profit) d=+15%d = +15\%

  • Mean transaction return m=0%m = 0\%

Step 2: Calculate cross differences.

  • d−m=15−0=15d - m = 15 - 0 = 15

  • m−c=0−(−10)=10m - c = 0 - (-10) = 10

CPWatch 2CPWatch 1=1510=32  ⟺  CPWatch 1CPWatch 2=23\frac{CP_{\text{Watch 2}}}{CP_{\text{Watch 1}}} = \frac{15}{10} = \frac{3}{2} \iff \frac{CP_{\text{Watch 1}}}{CP_{\text{Watch 2}}} = \frac{2}{3}

(CRITICAL: Alligating profit rates gives the ratio of Cost Prices!)

Step 3: Distribute total Cost Price of ₹3,0003,000.

Total parts =2+3=5 parts=₹3,000= 2 + 3 = 5\text{ parts} = ₹3,000.

  • 1 part =3,0005=₹600= \frac{3,000}{5} = ₹600

  • CPWatch 1=2×600=₹1,200CP_{\text{Watch 1}} = 2 \times 600 = ₹1,200

  • CPWatch 2=3×600=₹1,800CP_{\text{Watch 2}} = 3 \times 600 = ₹1,800

Takeaway: Alligating profit percentages (+15% and -10% with mean 0%) gives the Cost Price ratio 2:3. Watch 1 cost ₹1,200 and Watch 2 cost ₹1,800.

Example 4.3.5: Alligation on Interest Rates

An angel investor deploys a capital pool of ₹50,00050,000 into two debt facilities: Facility A at 8.0%8.0\% simple interest and Facility B at 12.0%12.0\% simple interest. At the end of one year, the investor receives total interest of ₹4,6004,600. Find the capital deployed in each facility.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute effective combined annual interest rate.

rmean=Total InterestTotal Capital×100%=₹4,600₹50,000×100%=9.2%r_{\text{mean}} = \frac{\text{Total Interest}}{\text{Total Capital}} \times 100\% = \frac{₹4,600}{₹50,000} \times 100\% = 9.2\%

Step 2: Apply Alligation on interest rates.

  • Facility A: c=8.0%c = 8.0\%

  • Facility B: d=12.0%d = 12.0\%

  • Combined: m=9.2%m = 9.2\%

Step 3: Calculate cross differences.

  • d−m=12.0−9.2=2.8d - m = 12.0 - 9.2 = 2.8

  • m−c=9.2−8.0=1.2m - c = 9.2 - 8.0 = 1.2

PAPB=2.81.2=2812=73\frac{P_A}{P_B} = \frac{2.8}{1.2} = \frac{28}{12} = \frac{7}{3}

Step 4: Distribute ₹50,00050,000 in the ratio 7:37 : 3.

Total parts =7+3=10 parts=₹50,000= 7 + 3 = 10\text{ parts} = ₹50,000.

  • PA=710×50,000=₹35,000P_A = \frac{7}{10} \times 50,000 = ₹35,000

  • PB=310×50,000=₹15,000P_B = \frac{3}{10} \times 50,000 = ₹15,000

Takeaway: Combined rate is 9.2%. Alligation gives principal ratio (12 - 9.2) : (9.2 - 8) = 2.8 : 1.2 = 7 : 3. Facility A gets ₹35,000; Facility B gets ₹15,000.

Example 4.3.6: Three-Component Commodity Alligation

A gourmet roaster blends three varieties of coffee beans priced at ₹100100, ₹120120, and ₹150150 per kg to produce a signature house blend valued at ₹130130 per kg. Determine a valid blending ratio of the three varieties.

Show solution

Step 1: Deconstruct into two independent two-component pairs.

To obtain a mean of 130130, we must pair rates below 130130 with rates above 130130:

  • Pair 1: Variety 1 (₹100₹100) and Variety 3 (₹150₹150)

  • Pair 2: Variety 2 (₹120₹120) and Variety 3 (₹150₹150)

Step 2: Alligate Pair 1 (100100 and 150150 to get 130130).

  • 150−130=20150 - 130 = 20 (parts of Variety 1)

  • 130−100=30130 - 100 = 30 (parts of Variety 3)

Ratio1=20:30=2:3\text{Ratio}_1 = 20 : 30 = 2 : 3

Step 3: Alligate Pair 2 (120120 and 150150 to get 130130).

  • 150−130=20150 - 130 = 20 (parts of Variety 2)

  • 130−120=10130 - 120 = 10 (parts of Variety 3)

Ratio2=20:10=2:1\text{Ratio}_2 = 20 : 10 = 2 : 1

Step 4: Combine the allocations.

  • Variety 1 (₹100₹100): 2 parts2\text{ parts}

  • Variety 2 (₹120₹120): 2 parts2\text{ parts}

  • Variety 3 (₹150₹150): 3+1=4 parts3 + 1 = 4\text{ parts}

Combined Ratio=2:2:4=1:1:2\text{Combined Ratio} = 2 : 2 : 4 = 1 : 1 : 2

Verification: 1(100)+1(120)+2(150)1+1+2=100+120+3004=5204=₹130/kg\frac{1(100) + 1(120) + 2(150)}{1 + 1 + 2} = \frac{100 + 120 + 300}{4} = \frac{520}{4} = ₹130/\text{kg}.

Takeaway: For three-component alligation, pair components below the mean with those above the mean. Combining pairs yields the valid ratio 1 : 1 : 2.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

A milk vendor claims to sell diluted milk at the cost price of pure milk. However, to increase his profit margins, he uses a faulty measuring container that dispenses only 800 ml800\text{ ml} whenever a customer purchases 1000 ml1000\text{ ml}. If his overall profit percentage across all sales is 50%50\%, and water is available at zero cost, what is the ratio of water to pure milk in the mixture he dispenses?

  1. A

    1:41 : 4

  2. B

    1:51 : 5

  3. C

    1:61 : 6

  4. D

    2:72 : 7

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 1 : 5

Step 1: Let the cost price of pure milk be CC per ml. The vendor charges 1000C1000C for a nominal liter.

Step 2: For each nominal liter, the vendor provides 800 ml800\text{ ml} of mixture containing milk and water in volume ratio M:WM : W.

Step 3: The volume of pure milk in 800 ml800\text{ ml} is 800(MM+W)800\left(\frac{M}{M + W}\right), incurring a cost of 800C(MM+W)800C\left(\frac{M}{M + W}\right).

Step 4: A 50%50\% profit means RevenueCost=1.5=32  ⟹  1000C800C(M/(M+W))=5(M+W)4M=32\frac{\text{Revenue}}{\text{Cost}} = 1.5 = \frac{3}{2} \implies \frac{1000C}{800C(M / (M + W))} = \frac{5(M + W)}{4M} = \frac{3}{2}.

Step 5: Cross-multiplying gives 10(M+W)=12M  ⟹  10W=2M  ⟹  WM=1510(M + W) = 12M \implies 10W = 2M \implies \frac{W}{M} = \frac{1}{5}, so W:M=1:5W : M = 1 : 5.

Question 2 · CAT Level

A tea merchant blends three varieties of tea—T1,T2T_1, T_2, and T3T_3—costing ₹180 per kg180\text{ per kg}, ₹240 per kg240\text{ per kg}, and ₹320 per kg320\text{ per kg}, respectively, to produce a 100 kg100\text{ kg} commercial blend with a mean cost of ₹260 per kg260\text{ per kg}. If the quantities of T1T_1 and T2T_2 mixed are in the ratio 1:21 : 2, what is the quantity of the most expensive variety (T3T_3) used in the blend?

  1. A

    30 kg30\text{ kg}

  2. B

    35 kg35\text{ kg}

  3. C

    40 kg40\text{ kg}

  4. D

    45 kg45\text{ kg}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 40 kg

Step 1: Combine T1T_1 and T2T_2 in ratio 1:21 : 2 to find their composite unit cost: C12=1(180)+2(240)1+2=6603=₹220 per kgC_{12} = \frac{1(180) + 2(240)}{1 + 2} = \frac{660}{3} = ₹220\text{ per kg}.

Step 2: Alligate the composite mixture (T1+T2)(T_1 + T_2) at ₹220220 with T3T_3 at ₹320320 against the mean price ₹260260.

Step 3: Cross differences give ∣320−260∣=60|320 - 260| = 60 and ∣220−260∣=40|220 - 260| = 40, yielding weight ratio (T1+T2):T3=60:40=3:2(T_1 + T_2) : T_3 = 60 : 40 = 3 : 2.

Step 4: The total weight of the final blend is 100 kg100\text{ kg}, divided into 3+2=53 + 2 = 5 equal ratio parts.

Step 5: Thus, the weight of T3T_3 used in the blend is 25×100=40 kg\frac{2}{5} \times 100 = 40\text{ kg}.

Question 3 · CAT Level

A retailer purchases two items, A and B, for a combined total cost of ₹8,4008,400. He marks up item A by 40%40\% and sells it at a 15%15\% discount on its marked price. He marks up item B by 50%50\% and sells it at a 30%30\% discount on its marked price. If his overall profit across both items is 11%11\%, what is the cost price of item A?

  1. A

    ₹$3,200

  2. B

    ₹$3,600

  3. C

    ₹$4,000

  4. D

    ₹$4,800

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹$3,600

Step 1: For item A, selling multiplier is 1.40×(1−0.15)=1.191.40 \times (1 - 0.15) = 1.19, yielding a profit of 19%19\%.

Step 2: For item B, selling multiplier is 1.50×(1−0.30)=1.051.50 \times (1 - 0.30) = 1.05, yielding a profit of 5%5\%.

Step 3: Alligating profit percentages (base is Cost Price) against mean profit 11%11\%:

∣5−11∣=6|5 - 11| = 6 and ∣19−11∣=8|19 - 11| = 8, giving cost price ratio CPA:CPB=6:8=3:4CP_A : CP_B = 6 : 8 = 3 : 4.

Step 4: Total cost is ₹8,4008,400 divided into 3+4=73 + 4 = 7 ratio parts.

Step 5: The cost price of item A is 37×8400=₹3,600\frac{3}{7} \times 8400 = ₹3,600.

Question 4 · CAT Level

An investment firm allocates a capital pool of ₹12,00,00012,00,000 between two bond portfolios, P and Q. Portfolio P earns an annual simple interest rate of 15%15\%, but its earnings are subject to a 20%20\% withholding tax. Portfolio Q earns an annual simple interest rate of 10%10\% and is entirely tax-exempt. If the firm realizes a net effective post-tax return of 11.2%11.2\% on the total corpus across one year, what is the difference between the capital invested in Portfolio P and Portfolio Q?

  1. A

    ₹$1,80,000

  2. B

    ₹$2,00,000

  3. C

    ₹$2,40,000

  4. D

    ₹$3,00,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) ₹$2,40,000

Step 1: The net post-tax return of Portfolio P is 15%×(1−0.20)=12.0%15\% \times (1 - 0.20) = 12.0\%. Portfolio Q yields 10.0%10.0\%.

Step 2: Alligating interest rates on the principal investment base against mean return 11.2%11.2\%:

∣10.0−11.2∣=1.2|10.0 - 11.2| = 1.2 and ∣12.0−11.2∣=0.8|12.0 - 11.2| = 0.8, giving principal ratio PP:PQ=1.2:0.8=3:2P_P : P_Q = 1.2 : 0.8 = 3 : 2.

Step 3: The total capital ₹12,00,00012,00,000 splits into 3+2=53 + 2 = 5 parts, each equal to ₹2,40,0002,40,000.

Step 4: PP=3×2,40,000=₹7,20,000P_P = 3 \times 2,40,000 = ₹7,20,000 and PQ=2×2,40,000=₹4,80,000P_Q = 2 \times 2,40,000 = ₹4,80,000.

Step 5: The difference between the two allocations is 7,20,000−4,80,000=₹2,40,0007,20,000 - 4,80,000 = ₹2,40,000.

Question 5 · CAT Level

A commuter travels a total distance of 300 km300\text{ km} in 5 hours5\text{ hours} (average speed 60 km/h60\text{ km/h}). Part of the trip is driven on a highway at a constant speed of 80 km/h80\text{ km/h}, and the remainder is driven through city roads at a constant speed of 30 km/h30\text{ km/h}. What fraction of the total distance was traveled on the highway?

  1. A

    35\frac{3}{5}

  2. B

    23\frac{2}{3}

  3. C

    34\frac{3}{4}

  4. D

    45\frac{4}{5}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (D) 4/5

Step 1: Alligate speeds with respect to the denominator base, which is travel time: Highway =80 km/h= 80\text{ km/h}, City =30 km/h= 30\text{ km/h}, Mean =60 km/h= 60\text{ km/h}.

Step 2: Cross differences give ∣30−60∣=30|30 - 60| = 30 and ∣80−60∣=20|80 - 60| = 20, yielding time ratio Thwy:Tcity=30:20=3:2T_{\text{hwy}} : T_{\text{city}} = 30 : 20 = 3 : 2.

Step 3: Out of the total 5 hours5\text{ hours}, highway time is Thwy=3 hoursT_{\text{hwy}} = 3\text{ hours} and city time is Tcity=2 hoursT_{\text{city}} = 2\text{ hours}.

Step 4: Highway distance =3 h×80 km/h=240 km= 3\text{ h} \times 80\text{ km/h} = 240\text{ km}, and city distance =2 h×30 km/h=60 km= 2\text{ h} \times 30\text{ km/h} = 60\text{ km}.

Step 5: The fraction of total distance covered on the highway is 240300=45\frac{240}{300} = \frac{4}{5}.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library