The Rule of Alligation (Cross Diagram Mechanics)
Master the visual Alligation Cross diagram, identify the reference denominator base across diverse arithmetic domains (price, speed, profit, interest), and solve complex 3-variable mixture ratios.
1. The Story & Mental Model: The Inverted Lever
Two thousand years ago in Syracuse, Archimedes proved the Law of the Lever: to balance two unequal weights on a lever, the distance from the fulcrum must be inversely proportional to the weight. A weight placed from the pivot balances a weight placed from the pivot:
In quantitative aptitude, The Rule of Alligation is nothing more than Archimedes' lever transformed into a rapid visual cross diagram. Whenever two entities with different rates are combined to produce a mean target rate, Alligation instantly reveals the ratio in which they must be blended—bypassing linear equations completely.
2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Chameleon Shortcut
Alligation is the single most versatile tactical weapon in the entire CAT syllabus because it applies across completely different chapters:
-
Commercial Blending: Mixing cheap grain with expensive grain to achieve a target price.
-
Profit and Loss: Selling part of goods at profit and part at loss to average profit (Weights are Cost Prices!).
-
Kinematics (TSD): Traveling part-way at and part-way at to average (Weights are Travel Times!).
-
Simple Interest: Splitting a capital sum between and lending rates to earn an average return of (Weights are Principals!).
3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Alligation Cross Diagram
Cheaper Rate (c) Dearer Rate (d)
\ /
Mean Rate (m)
/ \
Quantity (d - m) : Quantity (m - c)
THE CARDINAL RULE: What Do the Bottom Quantities Represent?
The bottom quantities ALWAYS represent the denominator unit of the rates being alligated:
| Rates Being Alligated | Rate Unit | Resulting Alligation Weights () |
|---|---|---|
| Price per kg | ₹ / kg | Mass in Kilograms |
| Speed | km / hour | Travel Time in Hours |
| Profit / Loss % | Profit / Cost Price | Cost Price in ₹ |
| Interest Rate % | Interest / Principal | Principal Amount in ₹ |
| Concentration % | Solute / Solution | Solution Volume in Liters |
| Average Marks | Marks / Student | Number of Students |
4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut
The Speed Alligation Trap:
When alligating speeds ( and ), the resulting ratio is the ratio of TIMES, NEVER distances! To find distances, multiply the resulting time parts by their respective speeds.
The Selling Price Blending Trap:
You CANNOT alligate Selling Prices directly if the mixture selling price includes an embedded profit percentage!
- Must convert first: Find the Cost Price of the mixture: .
- Then alligate Cost Prices.
Formulas
| The Rule of Alligation | |
|---|---|
| Mean Cost Price Extraction | |
| Distance Conversion from Speed Alligation | |
| Principal Split via Rate Alligation |
Traps and tips
- Never alligate mixture SP: Always extract mixture CP first before drawing the cross diagram.
- Speed alligation yields Time: Distance = Speed * Time; speed alligation strictly produces time weights.
- Profit alligation yields Cost Price: Because profit% = P / CP, alligating profit rates gives the ratio of Cost Prices.
- Subtractions are always positive: It is always (Dearer - Mean) and (Mean - Cheaper).
Solved examples
Example 4.3.1: Fundamental Commodity Price Blending
A tea merchant blends high-altitude Assam tea priced at ₹ per kg with premium Darjeeling tea priced at ₹ per kg. In what ratio must he mix the two varieties so that the resulting blended tea is worth ₹ per kg?
Show solution
Step 1: Set up the Alligation Cross diagram.
-
Cheaper tea rate
-
Dearer tea rate
-
Target mean rate
Step 2: Calculate cross differences.
-
Right branch:
-
Left branch:
Step 3: Express the ratio.
The merchant must mix Assam and Darjeeling tea in the ratio .
Takeaway: The cross differences are (360 - 310) = 50 and (310 - 240) = 70. The ratio is 50:70 = 5:7.
Example 4.3.2: Blending with Embedded Retail Profit
A grain merchant mixes red lentils costing ₹ per kg with yellow lentils costing ₹ per kg. He sells the blended mixture at ₹ per kg, thereby making a net profit of . In what ratio did he mix the red and yellow lentils?
Show solution
Step 1: Extract the true Cost Price of the mixture ().
The selling price of ₹ includes a profit:
Step 2: Apply Alligation on Cost Prices.
-
Cheaper lentils
-
Dearer lentils
-
Mean mixture cost
Step 3: Calculate cross differences.
The merchant mixed the lentils in the ratio .
Takeaway: Never alligate with SP (₹66). Extract mixture CP = 66 / 1.2 = ₹55 first. Then alligate: (60 - 55) : (55 - 45) = 5:10 = 1:2.
Example 4.3.3: Alligation on Speeds — The Time Base Rule
An autonomous delivery van travels a total distance of in (average speed ). The van traveled part of the journey on an express highway at and the remaining part through urban congestion at . Calculate: (a) the time spent on the highway, and (b) the distance covered on the highway.
Show solution
Step 1: Set up Alligation on speeds.
-
Urban speed
-
Highway speed
-
Average speed
Step 2: Calculate cross differences.
(CRITICAL: This is the ratio of travel TIMES, not distances!)
Step 3: Distribute total journey time of .
Total parts .
Step 4: Compute distance covered on the highway.
Takeaway: Alligating speeds produces the ratio of travel times (4:5). Highway time is (5/9) 6 = 10/3 hours, giving distance = 70 10/3 = 233.33 km.
Example 4.3.4: Alligation on Profits and Losses
A vintage dealer purchases two antique wristwatches for a combined sum of ₹. He sells the first watch at a profit of and the second watch at a loss of . On the whole transaction, he breaks even (neither profit nor loss, net change). Find the cost price of each individual watch.
Show solution
Step 1: Set up Alligation on profit/loss percentages.
-
Watch 2 (loss)
-
Watch 1 (profit)
-
Mean transaction return
Step 2: Calculate cross differences.
(CRITICAL: Alligating profit rates gives the ratio of Cost Prices!)
Step 3: Distribute total Cost Price of ₹.
Total parts .
-
1 part
-
-
Takeaway: Alligating profit percentages (+15% and -10% with mean 0%) gives the Cost Price ratio 2:3. Watch 1 cost ₹1,200 and Watch 2 cost ₹1,800.
Example 4.3.5: Alligation on Interest Rates
An angel investor deploys a capital pool of ₹ into two debt facilities: Facility A at simple interest and Facility B at simple interest. At the end of one year, the investor receives total interest of ₹. Find the capital deployed in each facility.
Show solution
Step 1: Compute effective combined annual interest rate.
Step 2: Apply Alligation on interest rates.
-
Facility A:
-
Facility B:
-
Combined:
Step 3: Calculate cross differences.
Step 4: Distribute ₹ in the ratio .
Total parts .
Takeaway: Combined rate is 9.2%. Alligation gives principal ratio (12 - 9.2) : (9.2 - 8) = 2.8 : 1.2 = 7 : 3. Facility A gets ₹35,000; Facility B gets ₹15,000.
Example 4.3.6: Three-Component Commodity Alligation
A gourmet roaster blends three varieties of coffee beans priced at ₹, ₹, and ₹ per kg to produce a signature house blend valued at ₹ per kg. Determine a valid blending ratio of the three varieties.
Show solution
Step 1: Deconstruct into two independent two-component pairs.
To obtain a mean of , we must pair rates below with rates above :
-
Pair 1: Variety 1 () and Variety 3 ()
-
Pair 2: Variety 2 () and Variety 3 ()
Step 2: Alligate Pair 1 ( and to get ).
-
(parts of Variety 1)
-
(parts of Variety 3)
Step 3: Alligate Pair 2 ( and to get ).
-
(parts of Variety 2)
-
(parts of Variety 3)
Step 4: Combine the allocations.
-
Variety 1 ():
-
Variety 2 ():
-
Variety 3 ():
Verification: .
Takeaway: For three-component alligation, pair components below the mean with those above the mean. Combining pairs yields the valid ratio 1 : 1 : 2.
Practice questions
Question 1 · CAT Level
A milk vendor claims to sell diluted milk at the cost price of pure milk. However, to increase his profit margins, he uses a faulty measuring container that dispenses only whenever a customer purchases . If his overall profit percentage across all sales is , and water is available at zero cost, what is the ratio of water to pure milk in the mixture he dispenses?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 1 : 5
Step 1: Let the cost price of pure milk be per ml. The vendor charges for a nominal liter.
Step 2: For each nominal liter, the vendor provides of mixture containing milk and water in volume ratio .
Step 3: The volume of pure milk in is , incurring a cost of .
Step 4: A profit means .
Step 5: Cross-multiplying gives , so .
Question 2 · CAT Level
A tea merchant blends three varieties of tea—, and —costing ₹, ₹, and ₹, respectively, to produce a commercial blend with a mean cost of ₹. If the quantities of and mixed are in the ratio , what is the quantity of the most expensive variety () used in the blend?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 40 kg
Step 1: Combine and in ratio to find their composite unit cost: .
Step 2: Alligate the composite mixture at ₹ with at ₹ against the mean price ₹.
Step 3: Cross differences give and , yielding weight ratio .
Step 4: The total weight of the final blend is , divided into equal ratio parts.
Step 5: Thus, the weight of used in the blend is .
Question 3 · CAT Level
A retailer purchases two items, A and B, for a combined total cost of ₹. He marks up item A by and sells it at a discount on its marked price. He marks up item B by and sells it at a discount on its marked price. If his overall profit across both items is , what is the cost price of item A?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) ₹$3,600
Step 1: For item A, selling multiplier is , yielding a profit of .
Step 2: For item B, selling multiplier is , yielding a profit of .
Step 3: Alligating profit percentages (base is Cost Price) against mean profit :
and , giving cost price ratio .
Step 4: Total cost is ₹ divided into ratio parts.
Step 5: The cost price of item A is .
Question 4 · CAT Level
An investment firm allocates a capital pool of ₹ between two bond portfolios, P and Q. Portfolio P earns an annual simple interest rate of , but its earnings are subject to a withholding tax. Portfolio Q earns an annual simple interest rate of and is entirely tax-exempt. If the firm realizes a net effective post-tax return of on the total corpus across one year, what is the difference between the capital invested in Portfolio P and Portfolio Q?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) ₹$2,40,000
Step 1: The net post-tax return of Portfolio P is . Portfolio Q yields .
Step 2: Alligating interest rates on the principal investment base against mean return :
and , giving principal ratio .
Step 3: The total capital ₹ splits into parts, each equal to ₹.
Step 4: and .
Step 5: The difference between the two allocations is .
Question 5 · CAT Level
A commuter travels a total distance of in (average speed ). Part of the trip is driven on a highway at a constant speed of , and the remainder is driven through city roads at a constant speed of . What fraction of the total distance was traveled on the highway?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (D) 4/5
Step 1: Alligate speeds with respect to the denominator base, which is travel time: Highway , City , Mean .
Step 2: Cross differences give and , yielding time ratio .
Step 3: Out of the total , highway time is and city time is .
Step 4: Highway distance , and city distance .
Step 5: The fraction of total distance covered on the highway is .
Try real CAT questions
Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.
Open the concept library