Free CAT library

The Repeated Dilution & Replacement Formula

Deconstruct the exponential decay of repeated dilutions (Final/Initial = (1 - x/V)^n), back-calculate vessel volumes from final component ratios, and evaluate multi-stage siphoning cycles.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Leaky Cask

Imagine an oak cask containing 100 liters100\text{ liters} of pure aged single malt whisky. A dishonest cellar hand sneaks into the vault, siphons out 10 liters10\text{ liters} of pure whisky, and refills the cask with 10 liters10\text{ liters} of tap water.

On Night 1, the cellar hand stole 10 liters10\text{ liters} of pure whisky. The cask now holds 90 liters90\text{ liters} of whisky and 10 liters10\text{ liters} of water (90%90\% purity).

On Night 2, the cellar hand returns and repeats the exact crime: he siphons out 10 liters10\text{ liters} of the liquid and refills with water.

Did he steal another 10 liters10\text{ liters} of pure whisky on Night 2?

No! He siphoned 10 liters10\text{ liters} of a blend that was already 10%10\% water! He stole only 9 liters9\text{ liters} of pure whisky (90%90\% of 10L10\text{L}). The pure whisky remaining is:

90−9=81 liters=100×(0.90)290 - 9 = 81\text{ liters} = 100 \times (0.90)^2

With every successive cycle, the thief steals less pure whisky because the cask is progressively diluted. This compounding decay follows the Exponential Dilution Law.


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Dilution Sequence

CAT and IPMAT test this concept in three distinct mathematical disguises:

  1. The Forward Computation: Initial capacity VV, replacement volume xx, and nn operations are given; find remaining pure liquid.

  2. The Final Component Ratio: Expressing the remaining pure liquid relative to the accumulated water.

  3. The Reverse Capacity Extraction: The replacement volume xx, operation count nn, and the final ratio of Pure Liquid:Water\text{Pure Liquid} : \text{Water} are given; back-calculate the original cask capacity VV.


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Exponential Dilution Law

If a container of capacity VV initially holds pure liquid (or a solution of concentration C0C_0), and xx liters are withdrawn and replaced with pure water nn times successively:

Quantity of Pure Liquid RemainingInitial Quantity of Pure Liquid=(1−xV)n\frac{\text{Quantity of Pure Liquid Remaining}}{\text{Initial Quantity of Pure Liquid}} = \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n

Absolute Remaining Pure Liquid (QpureQ_{\text{pure}}):

Qpure=V(1−xV)nQ_{\text{pure}} = V \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n

Ratio of Pure Liquid to Added Water:

Pure Liquid RemainingAdded Water=(1−xV)n1−(1−xV)n\frac{\text{Pure Liquid Remaining}}{\text{Added Water}} = \frac{\left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n}{1 - \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n}

Reverse Extraction of Vessel Capacity (VV):

If the final ratio of Pure Liquid to Water is given as P:WP : W:

Fraction of Pure Liquid=PP+W=(1−xV)n\text{Fraction of Pure Liquid} = \frac{P}{P + W} = \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n

  ⟹  1−xV=PP+Wn  ⟹  V=x1−PP+Wn\implies 1 - \frac{x}{V} = \sqrt[n]{\frac{P}{P + W}} \implies V = \frac{x}{1 - \sqrt[n]{\frac{P}{P + W}}}

Varying Siphon Volumes (x1,x2,x3x_1, x_2, x_3):

If the withdrawal amounts vary per cycle:

Qpure=V(1−x1V)(1−x2V)(1−x3V)Q_{\text{pure}} = V \left(1 - \frac{x_1}{V}\right)\left(1 - \frac{x_2}{V}\right)\left(1 - \frac{x_3}{V}\right)


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Denominator Ratio Trap:

If the final ratio of wine to water is 16:6516 : 65:

  • Do NOT equate (1−xV)4\left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^4 to 1665\frac{16}{65}!
  • The denominator must be the TOTAL volume (Wine + Water):

Total Parts=16+65=81\text{Total Parts} = 16 + 65 = 81

(1−xV)4=1681  ⟹  1−xV=16814=23  ⟹  xV=13\left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^4 = \frac{16}{81} \implies 1 - \frac{x}{V} = \sqrt[4]{\frac{16}{81}} = \frac{2}{3} \implies \frac{x}{V} = \frac{1}{3}

Solved in two lines!

Formulas

Exponential Dilution Formula

QfinalQinitial=(1−xV)n\frac{Q_{\text{final}}}{Q_{\text{initial}}} = \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n

Fraction of original liquid remaining after n replacements of volume x
Remaining Volume of Pure Liquid

Qpure=V(1−xV)nQ_{\text{pure}} = V \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n

Absolute volume of pure liquid left in vessel of capacity V
Capacity Extraction from Ratio

1−xV=Pure PartsPure Parts+Water Partsn1 - \frac{x}{V} = \sqrt[n]{\frac{\text{Pure Parts}}{\text{Pure Parts} + \text{Water Parts}}}

Extracts vessel capacity V by taking the n-th root of pure fraction
Varying Multi-Stage Dilution

Qpure=V∏i=1n(1−xiV)Q_{\text{pure}} = V \prod_{i=1}^n \left(1 - \frac{x_i}{V}\right)

Used when siphon volumes x_i differ across consecutive rounds

Traps and tips

  • Total parts in denominator: In ratio P : W, the fraction of pure liquid is P / (P + W), NEVER P / W.
  • Recognize n-th powers: For n = 4, look for powers like 16/81 = (2/3)^4. For n = 3, look for 27/64 = (3/4)^3 or 8/27 = (2/3)^3.
  • Varying replacements: When siphoning 10L, 20L, 25L from 100L, multiply (0.90) * (0.80) * (0.75) = 0.54 (54L remaining).
  • Diluting existing solutions: If starting with a solution of concentration C0, final concentration is C0 * (1 - x/V)^n.

Solved examples

Example 4.5.1: Two-Stage Successive Dilution

A dairy storage container initially holds 80.0 liters80.0\text{ liters} of pure whole milk. A worker siphons out 8.0 liters8.0\text{ liters} of milk and replenishes the container with 8.0 liters8.0\text{ liters} of water. The mixture is thoroughly blended, and the worker repeats the operation a second time (withdrawing 8.0 liters8.0\text{ liters} of the mixture and adding 8.0 liters8.0\text{ liters} of water). Determine the quantity of pure milk remaining in the container.

Show solution

Step 1: Identify dilution parameters.

  • Vessel capacity V=80.0 litersV = 80.0\text{ liters}

  • Replacement volume x=8.0 litersx = 8.0\text{ liters}

  • Number of operations n=2n = 2

Step 2: Compute single-cycle retention fraction (1−xV1 - \frac{x}{V}).

1−xV=1−8.080.0=1−110=910=0.901 - \frac{x}{V} = 1 - \frac{8.0}{80.0} = 1 - \frac{1}{10} = \frac{9}{10} = 0.90

Step 3: Apply the exponential dilution formula.

Qmilk=V(1−xV)n=80.0×(910)2Q_{\text{milk}} = V \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n = 80.0 \times \left(\frac{9}{10}\right)^2

Qmilk=80.0×81100=80.0×0.81=64.8 litersQ_{\text{milk}} = 80.0 \times \frac{81}{100} = 80.0 \times 0.81 = 64.8\text{ liters}

The container holds 64.8 liters64.8\text{ liters} of pure milk.

Takeaway: Each cycle retains 9/10 of the pure liquid. After 2 cycles, remaining milk is 80 (9/10)^2 = 80 0.81 = 64.8 liters.

Example 4.5.2: Three-Stage Dilution with Clean Fractions

A chemical processing vat holds 60.0 liters60.0\text{ liters} of pure laboratory solvent. An automated valve withdraws 12.0 liters12.0\text{ liters} of the solvent and replaces it with pure water. This replacement procedure is executed a total of 3 times3\text{ times}. Calculate: (a) the volume of pure solvent remaining, and (b) the volume of water in the vat.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute retention fraction.

1−xV=1−12.060.0=1−15=45=0.801 - \frac{x}{V} = 1 - \frac{12.0}{60.0} = 1 - \frac{1}{5} = \frac{4}{5} = 0.80

Step 2: Apply formula for n=3n = 3 cycles.

Qsolvent=V(1−xV)3=60.0×(45)3Q_{\text{solvent}} = V \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^3 = 60.0 \times \left(\frac{4}{5}\right)^3

Qsolvent=60.0×64125=12×6425=76825=30.72 litersQ_{\text{solvent}} = 60.0 \times \frac{64}{125} = \frac{12 \times 64}{25} = \frac{768}{25} = 30.72\text{ liters}

Step 3: Compute water volume.

Qwater=V−Qsolvent=60.0−30.72=29.28 litersQ_{\text{water}} = V - Q_{\text{solvent}} = 60.0 - 30.72 = 29.28\text{ liters}

Takeaway: Retention fraction is 4/5. After 3 cycles, solvent remaining is 60 (4/5)^3 = 60 64/125 = 30.72 liters.

Example 4.5.3: Back-Calculating Cask Capacity from Final Ratio

From a cask completely filled with pure French wine, a dishonest server draws off 8.0 liters8.0\text{ liters} and replaces it with water. He repeats this exact process 3 more times3\text{ more times} (a total of 4 operations4\text{ operations}). The ratio of pure wine to water in the cask is now 16:6516 : 65. Determine the original total capacity of the cask in liters.

Show solution

Step 1: Determine the fraction of pure wine in the total mixture.

  • Ratio of Wine to Water =16:65= 16 : 65

  • Total volume parts =16+65=81 parts= 16 + 65 = 81\text{ parts}

Fraction of pure wine remaining=1681\text{Fraction of pure wine remaining} = \frac{16}{81}

Step 2: Relate to the dilution formula for n=4n = 4.

(1−xV)4=1681\left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^4 = \frac{16}{81}

Step 3: Take the 4th4^{\text{th}} root on both sides.

Notice that 16=2416 = 2^4 and 81=3481 = 3^4:

1−xV=16814=231 - \frac{x}{V} = \sqrt[4]{\frac{16}{81}} = \frac{2}{3}

Step 4: Solve for capacity VV.

xV=1−23=13  ⟹  V=3x\frac{x}{V} = 1 - \frac{2}{3} = \frac{1}{3} \implies V = 3x

Given x=8.0 litersx = 8.0\text{ liters}:

V=3×8.0=24.0 litersV = 3 \times 8.0 = 24.0\text{ liters}

The original capacity of the cask was 24.0 liters24.0\text{ liters}.

Takeaway: Total parts = 16 + 65 = 81. Taking the 4th root of 16/81 gives 2/3. Thus x/V = 1/3, meaning V = 3 8 = 24 liters.

Example 4.5.4: Varying Multi-Stage Withdrawal Volumes

A 100.0-liter100.0\text{-liter} reservoir contains pure industrial acid. An operator executes three successive dilution stages with varying withdrawal volumes:

  • Stage 1: 10.0 liters10.0\text{ liters} withdrawn and replaced with water.

  • Stage 2: 20.0 liters20.0\text{ liters} of the mixture withdrawn and replaced with water.

  • Stage 3: 25.0 liters25.0\text{ liters} of the mixture withdrawn and replaced with water.

Calculate the final volume of pure acid remaining in the reservoir.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute retention fractions for each stage.

  • Stage 1: M1=1−10100=0.90=910M_1 = 1 - \frac{10}{100} = 0.90 = \frac{9}{10}

  • Stage 2: M2=1−20100=0.80=45M_2 = 1 - \frac{20}{100} = 0.80 = \frac{4}{5}

  • Stage 3: M3=1−25100=0.75=34M_3 = 1 - \frac{25}{100} = 0.75 = \frac{3}{4}

Step 2: Chain the multipliers together.

Mnet=M1×M2×M3=910×45×34M_{\text{net}} = M_1 \times M_2 \times M_3 = \frac{9}{10} \times \frac{4}{5} \times \frac{3}{4}

Step 3: Cancel and evaluate.

Mnet=910×45×34=2750=0.54M_{\text{net}} = \frac{9}{10} \times \frac{\cancel{4}}{5} \times \frac{3}{\cancel{4}} = \frac{27}{50} = 0.54

Step 4: Compute final acid volume.

Qacid=V×Mnet=100.0×0.54=54.0 litersQ_{\text{acid}} = V \times M_{\text{net}} = 100.0 \times 0.54 = 54.0\text{ liters}

The reservoir holds 54.0 liters54.0\text{ liters} of pure acid.

Takeaway: With varying replacements, multiply individual retention factors: 0.90 0.80 0.75 = 0.54, leaving 54 liters of pure acid.

Example 4.5.5: Percentage-Based Siphoning Cycle

A container is completely filled with pure ethyl alcohol. Exactly 20.0%20.0\% of the liquid is drained and replaced with water. After thorough mixing, 20.0%20.0\% of the mixture is again drained and replaced with water. What percentage of the final mixture is water?

Show solution

Step 1: Formulate single-cycle alcohol retention fraction.

Draining 20.0%20.0\% means retaining 80.0%80.0\% of the alcohol:

1−xV=1−0.20=0.801 - \frac{x}{V} = 1 - 0.20 = 0.80

Step 2: Compute alcohol percentage after n=2n = 2 cycles.

% Alcohol Remaining=(0.80)2×100%=0.64×100%=64.0%\% \text{ Alcohol Remaining} = (0.80)^2 \times 100\% = 0.64 \times 100\% = 64.0\%

Step 3: Compute final water percentage.

% Water=100.0%−64.0%=36.0%\% \text{ Water} = 100.0\% - 64.0\% = 36.0\%

Water constitutes 36.0%36.0\% of the final mixture.

Takeaway: Draining 20% twice retains (0.80)^2 = 64% pure alcohol, leaving 100% - 64% = 36% water in the container.

Example 4.5.6: Direct Solute Concentration Tracking

A 50.0-liter50.0\text{-liter} carboy contains an aqueous solution with a 40.0%40.0\% spirit concentration. A technician draws off 10.0 liters10.0\text{ liters} of the solution and replaces it with pure water, executing this cycle a total of 2 times2\text{ times}. Determine the final percentage concentration of spirit in the carboy.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute retention fraction per cycle.

1−xV=1−10.050.0=1−15=45=0.801 - \frac{x}{V} = 1 - \frac{10.0}{50.0} = 1 - \frac{1}{5} = \frac{4}{5} = 0.80

Step 2: Apply the concentration decay formula.

Cfinal=Cinitial×(1−xV)nC_{\text{final}} = C_{\text{initial}} \times \left(1 - \frac{x}{V}\right)^n

Given Cinitial=40.0%C_{\text{initial}} = 40.0\% and n=2n = 2:

Cfinal=40.0%×(0.80)2=40.0%×0.64=25.6%C_{\text{final}} = 40.0\% \times (0.80)^2 = 40.0\% \times 0.64 = 25.6\%

The final spirit concentration is 25.6%25.6\%.

Takeaway: For an initial solution, multiply starting concentration by the retention factor squared: 40% (0.80)^2 = 40% 0.64 = 25.6%.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

A storage vat initially holds 80 liters80\text{ liters} of an alcohol solution containing alcohol and water in the ratio 4:14 : 1. A technician draws off 20 liters20\text{ liters} of the solution and replaces it with pure water. This entire operation (drawing off 20 liters20\text{ liters} and replacing with water) is repeated two more times (for a total of 33 operations). What is the ratio of alcohol to water in the final mixture in the vat?

  1. A

    27:5327 : 53

  2. B

    27:6427 : 64

  3. C

    37:4337 : 43

  4. D

    81:17581 : 175

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) 27 : 53

Step 1: The initial alcohol volume is A0=80×44+1=64 litersA_0 = 80 \times \frac{4}{4 + 1} = 64\text{ liters}.

Step 2: In each withdrawal of 20 L20\text{ L} from the 80 L80\text{ L} vat, the retention factor is 1−2080=341 - \frac{20}{80} = \frac{3}{4}.

Step 3: After n=3n = 3 successive cycles, the remaining alcohol volume is Afinal=64×(34)3=64×2764=27 litersA_{\text{final}} = 64 \times \left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^3 = 64 \times \frac{27}{64} = 27\text{ liters}.

Step 4: The total volume remains 80 liters80\text{ liters}, so the remaining water volume is 80−27=53 liters80 - 27 = 53\text{ liters}.

Step 5: The final ratio of alcohol to water in the vat is 27:5327 : 53.

Question 2 · CAT Level

A 50-liter50\text{-liter} container is completely filled with pure ethanol. First, x litersx\text{ liters} of ethanol is siphoned off and replaced with pure water. Next, (x+10) liters(x + 10)\text{ liters} of the resulting mixture is siphoned off and replaced with pure water. If the final ratio of pure ethanol to water in the container is 12:1312 : 13, what is the value of xx?

  1. A

    8 liters8\text{ liters}

  2. B

    10 liters10\text{ liters}

  3. C

    12 liters12\text{ liters}

  4. D

    15 liters15\text{ liters}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 10 liters

Step 1: Initial ethanol is 50 liters50\text{ liters}. The successive retention factors are (1−x50)\left(1 - \frac{x}{50}\right) and (1−x+1050)\left(1 - \frac{x + 10}{50}\right).

Step 2: The final ratio of ethanol to water is 12:1312 : 13, so the final ethanol volume is 1212+13×50=24 liters\frac{12}{12 + 13} \times 50 = 24\text{ liters}.

Step 3: Setting up the product: 50(50−x50)(40−x50)=24  ⟹  (50−x)(40−x)=120050\left(\frac{50 - x}{50}\right)\left(\frac{40 - x}{50}\right) = 24 \implies (50 - x)(40 - x) = 1200.

Step 4: Expanding gives x2−90x+2000=1200  ⟹  x2−90x+800=0  ⟹  (x−10)(x−80)=0x^2 - 90x + 2000 = 1200 \implies x^2 - 90x + 800 = 0 \implies (x - 10)(x - 80) = 0.

Step 5: Since x<50x < 50, the extraneous root 8080 is rejected, leaving x=10 litersx = 10\text{ liters}.

Question 3 · CAT Level

A laboratory carboy initially holds 100 liters100\text{ liters} of pure concentrated nitric acid. In each dilution cycle, 20 liters20\text{ liters} of liquid is withdrawn from the carboy and replaced with pure distilled water. What is the minimum number of such cycles required for the concentration of acid in the carboy to fall strictly below 30%30\%?

  1. A

    4

  2. B

    5

  3. C

    6

  4. D

    7

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 6

Step 1: The retention factor per cycle is 1−20100=0.801 - \frac{20}{100} = 0.80.

Step 2: After nn cycles, the remaining acid concentration is Cn=100%×(0.8)nC_n = 100\% \times (0.8)^n. We require (0.8)n<0.30(0.8)^n < 0.30.

Step 3: Calculating successive powers: (0.8)1=0.8(0.8)^1 = 0.8, (0.8)2=0.64(0.8)^2 = 0.64, (0.8)3=0.512(0.8)^3 = 0.512, (0.8)4=0.4096(0.8)^4 = 0.4096.

Step 4: Continuing: (0.8)5=0.32768(0.8)^5 = 0.32768 (32.8%>30%32.8\% > 30\%), and (0.8)6=0.262144(0.8)^6 = 0.262144 (26.2%<30%26.2\% < 30\%).

Step 5: Hence, the minimum number of cycles required to drop strictly below 30%30\% is 66.

Question 4 · CAT Level

A container initially holds 60 liters60\text{ liters} of pure milk. In Stage 1, 12 liters12\text{ liters} of milk is drawn off and replaced with pure water. In Stage 2, 15 liters15\text{ liters} of the mixture is drawn off and replaced with pure water. In Stage 3, 20 liters20\text{ liters} of the mixture is drawn off and replaced with pure fruit syrup. What is the volume of pure water remaining in the container at the end of Stage 3?

  1. A

    12 liters12\text{ liters}

  2. B

    16 liters16\text{ liters}

  3. C

    18 liters18\text{ liters}

  4. D

    20 liters20\text{ liters}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 16 liters

Step 1: After Stage 1, the container has 48 L48\text{ L} milk and 12 L12\text{ L} water.

Step 2: In Stage 2, withdrawing 15 L15\text{ L} leaves a retention factor of 1−1560=341 - \frac{15}{60} = \frac{3}{4}, so remaining water from Stage 1 is 12×34=9 L12 \times \frac{3}{4} = 9\text{ L}.

Step 3: Replenishing with 15 L15\text{ L} water gives a total of 9+15=24 L9 + 15 = 24\text{ L} water before Stage 3.

Step 4: In Stage 3, withdrawing 20 L20\text{ L} leaves a retention factor of 1−2060=231 - \frac{20}{60} = \frac{2}{3}, with no water added (pure syrup is added instead).

Step 5: The final water remaining is 24×23=16 liters24 \times \frac{2}{3} = 16\text{ liters}.

Question 5 · CAT Level

From a cask completely filled with pure wine, 9 liters9\text{ liters} of liquid is drawn and replaced with water. This replacement procedure is executed a total of 44 times. At the end of the fourth operation, the ratio of the volume of wine remaining in the cask to the volume of water in the cask is 16:6516 : 65. What was the original capacity of the cask?

  1. A

    21 liters21\text{ liters}

  2. B

    24 liters24\text{ liters}

  3. C

    27 liters27\text{ liters}

  4. D

    36 liters36\text{ liters}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 27 liters

Step 1: After 44 dilution cycles of withdrawing 9 L9\text{ L} from capacity VV, the fraction of wine remaining is (1−9V)4\left(1 - \frac{9}{V}\right)^4.

Step 2: The final wine-to-water ratio is 16:6516 : 65, so wine represents 1616+65=1681\frac{16}{16 + 65} = \frac{16}{81} of the total capacity.

Step 3: Equating fractions gives (1−9V)4=1681=(23)4\left(1 - \frac{9}{V}\right)^4 = \frac{16}{81} = \left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^4.

Step 4: Taking the fourth root of both sides yields 1−9V=23  ⟹  9V=1−23=131 - \frac{9}{V} = \frac{2}{3} \implies \frac{9}{V} = 1 - \frac{2}{3} = \frac{1}{3}.

Step 5: Solving for VV gives V=9×3=27 litersV = 9 \times 3 = 27\text{ liters}.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library