CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q4
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Verbal Ability › Odd One Out
- Medium
- Type in the answer (TITA)
- CAT_2025_SLOT3_VARC_Q04
Question 4
Five jumbled sentences (labelled 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5), related to a topic, are given below. Four of them can be put together to form a coherent paragraph. Identify the odd sentence out and key in the number of that sentence as your answer.
-
About half of all the oxygen we breathe is made near the surface of the ocean by phytoplankton that photosynthesize just like land-dwelling plants.
-
A team of scientists that includes Boston University experts has discovered they also produce oxygen on the seafloor.
-
The research team used deep-sea chambers that land on the seafloor and enclose the seawater, sediment, polymetallic nodules, and living organisms.
-
The discovery is a surprise considering oxygen is typically created by plants and organisms with help from the sun—not by rocks on the ocean floor.
-
The deep-sea rocks, called polymetallic nodules, don’t only host a surprising number of sea critters.
Type-in-the-answer (TITA) question: no options are given; enter the value.
Show answer and solution
Answer:
3
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Odd Sentence Out / Outlier Identification (TITA)
-
Passage Reference:
- "About half of all the oxygen we breathe is made near the surface of the ocean by phytoplankton that photosynthesize just like land-dwelling plants."
- "The deep-sea rocks, called polymetallic nodules, don’t only host a surprising number of sea critters."
- "A team of scientists that includes Boston University experts has discovered they also produce oxygen on the seafloor."
- "The discovery is a surprise considering oxygen is typically created by plants and organisms with help from the sun—not by rocks on the ocean floor."
- "The research team used deep-sea chambers that land on the seafloor and enclose the seawater, sediment, polymetallic nodules, and living organisms."
Logical Deduction
To identify the odd sentence out, we isolate the coherent narrative formed by four of the sentences and identify the conceptual outlier:
-
Establishing the Scientific Paradigm (Sentence 1): Sentence 1 introduces the established scientific consensus: half of Earth's oxygen is produced near the ocean surface by photosynthesizing phytoplankton.
-
Introducing the Deep-Sea Subject (Sentence 5): Sentence 5 pivots to the seafloor, introducing polymetallic nodules: "The deep-sea rocks, called polymetallic nodules, don’t only host a surprising number of sea critters." The phrasing "don't only host..." sets up a dramatic revelation.
-
The Discovery (Sentence 2): Sentence 2 delivers that revelation via the pronoun "they": "A team of scientists... has discovered they also produce oxygen on the seafloor." ("they" refers directly to the polymetallic nodules in Sentence 5).
-
The Conceptual Paradox (Sentence 4): Sentence 4 reflects on the surprise of the discovery, directly contrasting it with Sentence 1: oxygen is typically created by organisms with sunlight, not by deep-sea rocks.
-
The Coherent Group (1-5-2-4): Together, Sentences 1, 5, 2, and 4 form a seamless narrative tracing the discovery of seafloor oxygen production that upends photosynthetic dogma.
-
The Outlier (Sentence 3): Sentence 3 describes the mechanical procedure and experimental equipment (deep-sea chambers enclosing sediment and nodules). This is a technical procedural detail regarding experimental apparatus, deviating from the conceptual narrative of the discovery.
Correct Answer: 3
- Sentence 3 is an operational methodology note detailing deep-sea experimental equipment, making it an extraneous procedural detail that does not belong in the conceptual discovery narrative formed by sentences 1, 5, 2, and 4.
Option Elimination
-
Coherent Group (1-5-2-4): Sentence 1 sets up surface photosynthetic oxygen; Sentence 5 introduces polymetallic nodules; Sentence 2 reveals that these nodules produce oxygen on the seafloor; Sentence 4 synthesizes the surprising paradigm shift contrasting sunlight photosynthesis with rock-produced oxygen.
-
Sentence 3 (Procedural Outlier): Focuses narrowly on the mechanical apparatus (deep-sea chambers) used during the experiment, breaking the conceptual flow of the discovery narrative.
Detailed explanation
📖 Context & Paragraph Structure
Central Theme
The scientific discovery of "dark oxygen" production on the ocean floor, challenging the foundational biological paradigm that oxygen is generated exclusively by photosynthetic organisms utilizing sunlight.
Structural Progression & Coherent Narrative (1-5-2-4)
-
Baseline Paradigm (Sentence 1): Establishes that about half of planetary oxygen is produced near the ocean surface by photosynthesizing phytoplankton.
-
Deep-Sea Subject Introduction (Sentence 5): Introduces seafloor rocks ("polymetallic nodules"), noting with "don't only host..." that they possess properties beyond supporting marine life.
-
The Revolutionary Discovery (Sentence 2): Connects via the pronoun "they," revealing that scientists discovered these nodules also produce oxygen on the dark seafloor.
-
Paradigm Shift & Surprise (Sentence 4): Synthesizes why this discovery is extraordinary: oxygen was thought to require sunlight and plants, not deep-sea rocks.
-
Methodological Outlier (Sentence 3): Describes the procedural hardware (deep-sea chambers enclosing seawater and sediment), which constitutes experimental methodology rather than part of the conceptual discovery narrative.
Tone and Perspective
- Tone: Informative, Scientific, and Paradigm-Challenging.
Odd One Out questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q20
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q22
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q22
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q14
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc