CAT 2025 Slot 3 DILR Q4

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Math Puzzles
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2025_SLOT3_DILR_Q04

Data set · questions 1–5

Three countries -- Pumpland (P), Xiland (X) and Cheeseland (C) -- trade among themselves and with the (other countries in) Rest of World (ROW). All trade volumes are given in IC (international currency). The following terminology is used:

  • Trade balance = Exports - Imports

  • Total trade = Exports + Imports

  • Normalized trade balance = Trade balance / Total trade, expressed in percentage terms

The following information is known.

  1. The normalized trade balances of P, X and C are 0%, 10%, and -20%, respectively.

  2. 40% of exports of X are to P. 22% of imports of P are from X.

  3. 90% of exports of C are to P; 4% are to ROW.

  4. 12% of exports of ROW are to X, 40% are to P.

  5. The export volumes of P, in IC, to X and C are 600 and 1200, respectively. P is the only country that exports to C.

Question 4

What is the trade balance of ROW?

  1. A

    100

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    -200

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    0

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    200

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (D)

200

Solution

Concept: Bilateral International Trade & Input-Output Accounting

Master State Table

Exporting Entity (From \ To)Pumpland (PP)Xiland (XX)Cheeseland (CC)Rest of World (ROW\text{ROW})Total Exports (EE)
Pumpland (PP)—6006001200120020020020002000
Xiland (XX)440440—0066066011001100
Cheeseland (CC)7207204848—3232800800
Rest of World (ROW\text{ROW})840840252252001008100821002100
Total Imports (MM)20002000900900120012001900190060006000

Question Deduction

The question asks for the trade balance of Rest of World (ROW\text{ROW}), defined as:

TBROW=EROW−MROWTB_{\text{ROW}} = E_{\text{ROW}} - M_{\text{ROW}}

We can solve this using two rigorous approaches:

• Method 1: Direct Tabular Calculation (Bottom-Up Inflow Summation):

• Total exports of ROW\text{ROW} from the Master Deduction:

EROW=2100 ICE_{\text{ROW}} = 2100\text{ IC}

• Total imports of ROW\text{ROW} represent the sum of all inflows into the ROW\text{ROW} column:

MROW=T(P,ROW)+T(X,ROW)+T(C,ROW)+T(ROW,ROW)M_{\text{ROW}} = T(P, \text{ROW}) + T(X, \text{ROW}) + T(C, \text{ROW}) + T(\text{ROW}, \text{ROW})

• Outflow from PP to ROW\text{ROW}: T(P,ROW)=200 ICT(P, \text{ROW}) = 200\text{ IC}

• Outflow from XX to ROW\text{ROW}: T(X,ROW)=EX−T(X,P)=1100−440=660 ICT(X, \text{ROW}) = E_X - T(X, P) = 1100 - 440 = 660\text{ IC}

• Outflow from CC to ROW\text{ROW}: T(C,ROW)=0.04×800=32 ICT(C, \text{ROW}) = 0.04 \times 800 = 32\text{ IC}

• Outflow from ROW\text{ROW} to ROW\text{ROW}: T(ROW,ROW)=1008 ICT(\text{ROW}, \text{ROW}) = 1008\text{ IC}

• Summing the imports of ROW\text{ROW}:

MROW=200+660+32+1008=1900 ICM_{\text{ROW}} = 200 + 660 + 32 + 1008 = 1900\text{ IC}

• Calculating the trade balance:

TBROW=EROW−MROW=2100−1900=+200 ICTB_{\text{ROW}} = E_{\text{ROW}} - M_{\text{ROW}} = 2100 - 1900 = +200\text{ IC}

• Method 2: Global Macroeconomic Conservation Principle (Zero-Sum Invariant):

• In any closed bilateral trade ecosystem, every export transaction is identically an import transaction for the receiving entity.

• Hence, the sum of total exports across all trading entities identically equals the sum of total imports:

∑iEi=∑iMi  ⟺  ∑i(Ei−Mi)=∑iTBi=0\sum_{i} E_i = \sum_{i} M_i \iff \sum_{i} (E_i - M_i) = \sum_{i} TB_i = 0

• Expanding across the four entities:

TBP+TBX+TBC+TBROW=0TB_P + TB_X + TB_C + TB_{\text{ROW}} = 0

• Evaluating individual trade balances for the three sovereign countries:

• Pumpland: TBP=EP−MP=2000−2000=0 ICTB_P = E_P - M_P = 2000 - 2000 = 0\text{ IC}

• Xiland: TBX=EX−MX=1100−900=+200 ICTB_X = E_X - M_X = 1100 - 900 = +200\text{ IC}

• Cheeseland: TBC=EC−MC=800−1200=−400 ICTB_C = E_C - M_C = 800 - 1200 = -400\text{ IC}

• Substituting these values into the global conservation equation:

0+200−400+TBROW=00 + 200 - 400 + TB_{\text{ROW}} = 0

−200+TBROW=0  ⟹  TBROW=+200 IC-200 + TB_{\text{ROW}} = 0 \implies TB_{\text{ROW}} = +200\text{ IC}

• Options Comparison Matrix:

OptionStated ValueAnalytical EvaluationCorrectness Status
Option 1100100Inconsistent with both tabular summation and zero-sum invariantIncorrect
Option 2−200-200Sign inversion error resulting from computing Imports minus ExportsIncorrect
Option 300Incorrectly assumes balanced trade for the aggregate external sectorIncorrect
Option 4200200Matches EROW−MROW=2100−1900=+200E_{\text{ROW}} - M_{\text{ROW}} = 2100 - 1900 = +200 and global zero-sum identityCorrect

Therefore, the trade balance of Rest of World is 200, corresponding to Option 4.

Topper Take

• The Sign Inversion Trap: A classic pitfall in trade balance questions is computing M−EM - E instead of E−ME - M, yielding −200-200 (Option 2). The passage explicitly defines: Trade balance=Exports−Imports\text{Trade balance} = \text{Exports} - \text{Imports}. Because ROW's exports (21002100) exceed its imports (19001900), ROW runs a trade surplus (+200+200). Test-setters intentionally place −200-200 as Option 2 to trap rushed candidates.

• The Zero-Sum 5-Second Super-Shortcut: Notice that Method 2 solves this question in literally 55 seconds without knowing anything about internal ROW trade (T(ROW,ROW)T(\text{ROW}, \text{ROW})) or computing ROW imports (MROWM_{\text{ROW}})! Because global trade is zero-sum, TBROW=−(TBP+TBX+TBC)=−(0+200−400)=+200TB_{\text{ROW}} = -(TB_P + TB_X + TB_C) = -(0 + 200 - 400) = +200. A 99.99th-percentile candidate uses this macroeconomic conservation law to skip cumbersome column additions entirely.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q1. How much is exported from C to X, in IC?
  2. Q2. How much is exported from P to ROW, in IC?
  3. Q3. How much is exported from ROW to ROW, in IC?
  4. Q5. Which among the countries P, X, and C has/have the least total trade?

Math Puzzles questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q6
    What was Rini's score in the project?
  2. CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q7
    What was the weight of the test component?
  3. CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q8
    What was the maximum aggregate score obtained by the students?
  4. CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q9
    What was Mathew's score in the test?
  5. CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q10
    Which of the following pairs of students were part of the same project team? i) Amala and Biman ii) Koli and…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc