CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q23
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Science
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT2_VARC_Q23
Passage · questions 21–24
Different sciences exhibit different science cultures and practices. For example, in astronomy, observation - until what is today called the new astronomy - had always been limited to what could be seen within the limits of optical light. Indeed, until early modernity the limits to optical light were also limits of what humans could themselves see within their limited and relative perceptual spectrum of human vision. With early modernity and the invention of lensed optical instruments - telescopes - astronomers could begin to observe phenomena never seen before. Magnification and resolution began to allow what was previously imperceptible to be perceived - but within the familiar limits of optical vision. Galileo, having learned of the Dutch invention of a telescope by Hans Lippershey, went on to build some hundred of his own, improving from the Dutch 3x to nearly 30x telescopes - which turn out to be the limit of magnificational power without chromatic distortion. And it was with his own telescopes that he made the observations launching early modern astronomy (phases of Venus, satellites of Jupiter, etc.). Isaac Newton's later improvement with reflecting telescopes expanded upon the magnificational-resolution capacity of optical observation; and, from Newton to the twentieth century, improvement continued on to the later very large array of light telescopes today - following the usual technological trajectory of "more-is-better" but still remaining within the limits of the light spectrum. Today's astronomy has now had the benefit of some four centuries of optical telescopy. The "new astronomy," however, opens the full known electromagnetic spectrum to observation, beginning with the accidental discovery of radio astronomy early in the twentieth century, and leading today to the diverse variety of EMS telescopes which can explore the range from gamma to radio waves. Thus, astronomy, now outfitted with new instruments, "smart" adaptive optics, very large arrays, etc., illustrates one style of instrumentally embodied science - a technoscience. Of course astronomy, with the very recent exceptions of probes to solar system bodies (Moon, Mars, Venus, asteroids), remains largely a "receptive" science, dependent upon instrumentation which can detect and receive emissions.
Contemporary biology displays a quite different instrument array and, according to Evelyn Fox-Keller, also a different scientific culture. She cites her own experience, coming from mathematical physics into microbiology, and takes account of the distinctive instrumental culture in her Making Sense of Life (2002). Here, particularly with the development of biotechnology, instrumentation is far more interventional than in the astronomy case. Microscopic instrumentation can be and often is interventional in style: "gene-splicing" and other techniques of biotechnology, while still in their infancy, are clearly part of the interventional trajectory of biological instrumentation. Yet, in both disciplines, the sciences involved are today highly instrumentalized and could not progress successfully without constant improvements upon the respective instrumental trajectories. So, minimalistically, one may conclude that the sciences are technologically, instrumentally embodied. But the styles of embodiment differ, and perhaps the last of the scientific disciplines to move into such technical embodiment is mathematics, which only contemporarily has come to rely more and more upon the computational machinery now in common use.
Question 23
All of the following statements may be rejected as valid inferences from the passage EXCEPT:
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
the author distinguishes between the receptive and interventionist uses of instruments in the sciences by comparing astronomy and biology, respectively.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Logical Evaluation / Affirmative Inference (EXCEPT Question)
-
Passage Reference:
Paragraph 1: "Of course astronomy, with the very recent exceptions of probes to solar system bodies (Moon, Mars, Venus, asteroids), remains largely a 'receptive' science, dependent upon instrumentation which can detect and receive emissions."
Paragraph 2: "Contemporary biology displays a quite different instrument array... Here, particularly with the development of biotechnology, instrumentation is far more interventional than in the astronomy case."
Paragraph 1: "Galileo... with his own telescopes... made the observations launching early modern astronomy (phases of Venus, satellites of Jupiter, etc.). Isaac Newton's later improvement with reflecting telescopes expanded upon the magnificational-resolution capacity..."
Paragraph 1: "The 'new astronomy,' however, opens the full known electromagnetic spectrum to observation, beginning with the accidental discovery of radio astronomy early in the twentieth century..."
Logical Deduction
The question stem asks to identify the single statement that IS a valid inference (since all other statements may be rejected):
-
In Paragraphs 1 and 2, the author establishes the central comparative thesis of the text: astronomy is categorized as a predominantly "receptive" science (dependent on instruments that detect and receive emissions), whereas contemporary biology/biotechnology is characterized as an "interventional" science (utilizing instruments that actively manipulate phenomena). Option 4 directly captures this distinction.
-
The remaining three statements contain demonstrable factual and chronological errors:
-
Statement 1 is false because Newton's reflecting telescopes were confined to visible optical light, whereas the "new astronomy" began in the 20th century with radio astronomy across the non-optical electromagnetic spectrum.
-
Statement 2 is false because interventional instruments are not separate from embodied instruments; rather, interventional tools are a style of instrumental embodiment.
-
Statement 3 is false because Galileo, not Newton, observed the phases of Venus and Jupiter's moons using his early refracting telescopes.
-
Correct Answer: Option 4
- Accurately reflects the author's primary comparative framework, which distinguishes between the receptive observational mode of astronomy and the interventional, manipulative mode of biology.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Chronological & Factual Distortion / Rejectable): Newton's reflecting telescopes improved optical vision within the visible spectrum; the passage explicitly dates the "new astronomy" to the early 20th century with the advent of radio telescopy covering the broader electromagnetic spectrum.
-
Option 2 (Categorical Confusion / False Dichotomy / Rejectable): Erroneously opposes "interventionist" and "embodied" instruments; the passage explicitly states that all these sciences are "instrumentally embodied," with interventional instrumentation representing a specific mode of that embodiment.
-
Option 3 (Historical Misattribution / Factually Inverted / Rejectable): Erroneously credits Newton with observing the phases of Venus and the satellites of Jupiter, discoveries explicitly attributed in Paragraph 1 to Galileo using his early refracting telescopes.
-
Option 4 (Valid Textual Inference / Cannot Be Rejected): Directly reflects the central comparative thesis of the passage, where the author distinguishes receptive scientific practice (astronomy) from interventional practice (biology) via their respective instrumental cultures.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The epistemological and material embodiment of scientific disciplines through instrumentation, defining modern sciences as "technosciences." The author argues that while all scientific disciplines depend fundamentally upon continuous instrumental improvements to progress, their epistemic cultures diverge according to their style of embodiment: astronomy exemplifies a predominantly "receptive" technoscience (passively detecting and resolving electromagnetic emissions across optical and non-optical spectra), contemporary biology represents an "interventional" technoscience (actively manipulating and transforming organic matter via microscopic and biotechnological tools like gene-splicing), and mathematics represents the latest discipline to undergo technical embodiment via modern computational machinery.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Traces the four-century instrumental evolution of astronomy from human naked-eye optical limits to lensed telescopes (Galileo's 30x chromatic limit, Newton's reflecting telescopes, modern light arrays), culminating in the 20th-century "new astronomy" that spans the entire electromagnetic spectrum (radio to gamma waves); defines astronomy as a largely "receptive" technoscience dependent on detecting and receiving external emissions.
-
Paragraph 2: Contrasts astronomy with contemporary biology/microbiology (drawing on Evelyn Fox-Keller), characterizing biological instrumentation as distinctly "interventional" in style (actively manipulating biological substrates through gene-splicing and micro-tools); synthesizes that while all modern sciences are technologically and instrumentally embodied, their styles of embodiment differ, with mathematics being the latest discipline to embrace technical embodiment through computational machinery.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Philosophical-Historical, Analytical, and Epistemological.
-
Author's Perspective: A philosopher or historian of science (grounded in the philosophy of technoscience and postphenomenology) who conceptualizes scientific disciplines not as abstract theorizing, but as material, instrumentally embodied practices whose cultures are shaped by whether their instruments act receptively or interventionally.
Other questions in this set
- Q21. Which one of the following observations is a valid conclusion to draw from the statement that "the sciences involved…
- Q22. To which one of the following instruments would the characterisations of instruments in the passage be least applicable?
- Q24. None of the following statements, if true, contradicts the arguments in the passage EXCEPT:
Science questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q12
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q13
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q14
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q15
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc