CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q11
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT2_DILR_Q11
Data set · questions 10–14
Ananya Raga, Bhaskar Tala, Charu Veena, and Devendra Sur are four musicians. Each of them started and completed their training as students under each of three Gurus - Pandit Meghnath, Ustad Samiran, and Acharya Raghunath between 2013 and 2024, including both the years. Each Guru trains any student for consecutive years only, for a span of 2, 3, or 4 years, with each Guru having a different span. During some of these years, a student may not have trained under these Gurus; however, they never trained under multiple Gurus in the same year.
In none of these years, any of these Gurus trained more than two of these students at the same time. When two students train under the same Guru at the same time, they are referred to as Gurubhai, irrespective of their gender.
The following additional facts are known.
-
Ustad Samiran never trained more than one of these students in the same year.
-
Acharya Raghunath did not train any of these students during 2015-2018, as well as during 2021-24.
-
Ananya and Devendra were never Gurubhai; neither were Bhaskar and Charu. All other pairs of musicians were Gurubhai for exactly 2 years.
-
In 2013, Ananya and Bhaskar started their trainings under Pandit Meghnath and under Ustad Samiran, respectively.
Question 11
In which year did Charu begin her training under Pandit Meghnath?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
2015
Solution
Concept: Multi-Entity Interval Scheduling & Longitudinal Invariants
Master State Table
| Year | Ananya | Bhaskar | Charu | Devendra | Active Count | Gurubhai Pair & Guru |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | Raghunath (R) | Raghunath (R) | 4 | Charu & Devendra under R |
| 2014 | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | Raghunath (R) | Raghunath (R) | 4 | Charu & Devendra under R |
| 2015 | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | — | 3 | Ananya & Charu under M |
| 2016 | Meghnath (M) | — | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | 3 | Ananya & Charu under M |
| 2017 | — | — | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | 2 | None |
| 2018 | — | — | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | 2 | None |
| 2019 | Raghunath (R) | Raghunath (R) | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | 4 | Ananya & Bhaskar under R |
| 2020 | Raghunath (R) | Raghunath (R) | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | 4 | Ananya & Bhaskar under R |
| 2021 | — | Meghnath (M) | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | 3 | Bhaskar & Devendra under M |
| 2022 | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | — | Meghnath (M) | 3 | Bhaskar & Devendra under M |
| 2023 | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | — | — | 2 | None |
| 2024 | Samiran (S) | Meghnath (M) | — | — | 2 | None |
Question Deduction
The question asks for the calendar year in which Charu began her training under Pandit Meghnath.
Tracing Charu's schedule from the Master Logic:
• Charu is committed to Acharya Raghunath during 2013 and 2014 (Block I of Raghunath).
• Charu must be Gurubhai with Ananya for exactly 2 years (Fact 3).
• Because Ustad Samiran never trains two students concurrently (Fact 1) and Raghunath's operational window for Ananya is 2019–2020 (disjoint from Charu's 2013–2014 tenure), the mandatory 2-year Gurubhai overlap between Ananya and Charu must occur under Pandit Meghnath.
• Ananya's 4-year tenure under Pandit Meghnath spans 2013 to 2016 (2013–2016).
• Charu cannot train under Meghnath in 2013 or 2014 because she is under Raghunath. Therefore, the earliest year Charu can join Meghnath is 2015.
• To produce an overlap of exactly 2 years with Ananya, Charu must train under Meghnath during 2015 and 2016.
• Since Pandit Meghnath's training span is 4 consecutive years, Charu's tenure under Meghnath must run for 4 continuous years beginning in 2015:
Therefore, Charu began her training under Pandit Meghnath in 2015.
Evaluating the given options:
• Option 1 (2015): Exactly matches the initial year of Charu's tenure under Pandit Meghnath.
• Option 2 (2021): In 2021, Charu is concluding her 3-year tenure under Ustad Samiran (2019–2021).
• Option 3 (2017): 2017 is Charu's third year under Meghnath, not her start year.
• Option 4 (2016): If Charu began in 2016, her overlap with Ananya (who completes her tenure in 2016) would be restricted to the single year 2016 ( year), directly violating the 2-year Gurubhai requirement.
Hence, the correct option is Option 1.
Topper Take
• The Boundary-Overlap Off-by-One Trap: Test-takers who mistakenly assume Charu starts in 2016 fall into the trap of confusing duration with overlap: an interval starting in 2016 overlapping with an interval ending in 2016 yields an intersection of , which has a cardinality of only , not . To obtain an intersection of cardinality (), the start year must be .
• Chain-Reaction Efficiency: In the actual CAT exam, recognizing that Charu must transition directly from Raghunath (ending in 2014) to Meghnath (starting in 2015) without an intervening gap year is the critical pivot that unlocks the rest of the set. Any gap year placed between 2014 and 2015 for Charu immediately collapses the possibility of a 2-year overlap with Ananya.
Other questions in this set
- Q10. In which of the following years were Ananya and Bhaskar Gurubhai?
- Q12. In which of the following years were Bhaskar and Devendra Gurubhai?
- Q13. Which of the following statements is TRUE?
- Q14. In how many of the years between 2013-24, were only two of these four musicians training under these three Gurus?
Arrangements questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q1
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q2
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q3
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q4
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 DILR Q5
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc