CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q1
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Verbal Ability › Odd One Out
- Hard
- Type in the answer (TITA)
- CAT_2025_SLOT1_VARC_Q01
Question 1
Five jumbled sentences (labelled 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5), related to a topic, are given below. Four of them can be put together to form a coherent paragraph. Identify the odd sentence out and key in the number of that sentence as your answer.
-
Developments both technological and sociocultural have afforded us far greater freedom over death than we had in the past, and while we are still adapting ourselves to that freedom, we now appreciate the moral importance of this freedom.
-
But I believe that a type of freedom we can call freedom over death – that is, a freedom in which we shape the timing and circumstances of how we die – should be central to this conversation.
-
Legalising assisted dying is but a further step in realising this freedom over death.
-
Many people endorse, through their opinions or their choices, our freedom over death encompassing a right to medical assistance in hastening our deaths.
-
Freedom is a notoriously complex and contested philosophical notion, and I won’t pretend to settle any of the big controversies it raises.
Type-in-the-answer (TITA) question: no options are given; enter the value.
Show answer and solution
Answer:
4
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Odd Sentence Out (TITA)
-
Given Sentences:
- "Developments both technological and sociocultural have afforded us far greater freedom over death than we had in the past, and while we are still adapting ourselves to that freedom, we now appreciate the moral importance of this freedom."
- "But I believe that a type of freedom we can call freedom over death – that is, a freedom in which we shape the timing and circumstances of how we die – should be central to this conversation."
- "Legalising assisted dying is but a further step in realising this freedom over death."
- "Many people endorse, through their opinions or their choices, our freedom over death encompassing a right to medical assistance in hastening our deaths."
- "Freedom is a notoriously complex and contested philosophical notion, and I won’t pretend to settle any of the big controversies it raises."
Logical Deduction & Narrative Assembly
-
Identify the Opening Framework: Sentence 5 provides the indispensable broad opening premise by introducing the overarching concept of "freedom" as a complex philosophical notion.
-
Establish the Conceptual Pivot: Sentence 2 connects directly to 5 via the contrastive discourse marker "But I believe that a type of freedom...", transitioning from general freedom controversies to the specific construct of "freedom over death."
-
Elaborate on Historical Progression: Sentence 1 builds upon Sentence 2 by tracing how modern technological and sociocultural developments have granted humans greater "freedom over death," emphasizing our evolving moral appreciation of this prerogative.
-
Determine the Logical Climax: Sentence 3 delivers the natural normative conclusion to the sequence (5–2–1), positing that "Legalising assisted dying is but a further step in realising this freedom over death."
-
Evaluate Sentence 4 (Odd Sentence Out): Sentence 4 shifts from the first-person philosophical argument (Sentences 5, 2, 1, 3) to an empirical sociological observation ("Many people endorse, through their opinions or their choices..."). It disrupts the tight logical progression from abstract philosophy (5) to conceptual definition (2), historical expansion (1), and legislative consequence (3), acting as an extraneous restatement rather than a progression link.
Correct Answer: 4
- Sentence 4 is the odd sentence out as it breaks the cohesive philosophical discourse structure of sequence 5–2–1–3.
Elimination Analysis
-
Sentence 5 (Coherent Anchor): Serves as the mandatory introductory sentence framing the philosophical scope of freedom.
-
Sentence 2 (Coherent Pivot): Forms an indispensable conceptual bridge, introducing and defining "freedom over death."
-
Sentence 1 (Coherent Elaboration): Directly substantiates Sentence 2 by explaining the technological and moral expansion of this freedom.
-
Sentence 3 (Coherent Climax): Concludes the philosophical progression by linking the concept to the legalisation of assisted dying.
Detailed explanation
📖 Context & Discourse Structure
Central Theme
The philosophical conceptualization of "freedom over death"—tracing how the broader, contested concept of human freedom can be framed to encompass control over the timing, circumstances, and moral legitimacy of one's own mortality, culminating in the legal sanction of assisted dying.
Key Structural Components & Logical Flow
-
Philosophical Premise (Sentence 5): Establishes the macro context by acknowledging freedom as an inherently complex, contested philosophical notion without purporting to resolve its broader dialectical debates.
-
Conceptual Narrowing (Sentence 2): Uses the contrastive conjunction "But" to narrow the inquiry to a specific, neglected category: "freedom over death"—defining it as the human agency to shape the timing and circumstances of dying, and asserting it should be central to the conversation.
-
Historical & Sociocultural Context (Sentence 1): Explains that recent technological and sociocultural developments have materially expanded this freedom over death, leading to a growing societal recognition of its profound moral importance.
-
Normative Culmination (Sentence 3): Advances the argument to its logical legislative conclusion: legalising assisted dying represents a necessary and natural progressive step in institutionalizing and realizing this freedom over death.
Tone and Authorial Perspective
-
Tone: Academic, Philosophical, Analytical, and Normative.
-
Author's Perspective: The author advocates for the moral recognition of individual autonomy over mortality, presenting assisted dying not as a radical departure, but as the progressive realization of human freedom over death.
Odd One Out questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q20
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q22
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 2 VARC Q22
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q14
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc