CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q21
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Math Puzzles
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2025_SLOT1_DILR_Q21
Data set · questions 19–22
Alia, Badal, Clive, Dilshan, and Ehsaan played a game in which each asks a unique question to all the others and they respond by tapping their feet, either once or twice or thrice. One tap means “Yes”, two taps mean “No”, and three taps mean “Maybe”.
A total of 40 taps were heard across the five questions. Each question received at least one “Yes”, one “No”, and one “Maybe.”
The following information is known.
-
Alia tapped a total of 6 times and received 9 taps to her question. She responded “Yes” to the questions asked by both Clive and Dilshan.
-
Dilshan and Ehsaan tapped a total of 11 and 9 times respectively. Dilshan responded “No” to Badal.
-
Badal, Dilshan, and Ehsaan received equal number of taps to their respective questions.
-
No one responded “Yes” more than twice.
-
No one’s answer to Alia’s question matched the answer that Alia gave to that person’s question. This was also true for Ehsaan.
-
Clive tapped more times in total than Badal.
Question 21
What was Clive’s response to Ehsaan’s question?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
No
Solution
Concept: Matrix Deductions & Truth-Value Cost Minimization
Master State Table
| Responder | QA (Alia) | QB (Badal) | QC (Clive) | QD (Dilshan) | QE (Esha) | Total Taps | Cost () |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alia | — | (No) | (Yes) | (Yes) | (No) | ||
| Badal | (Yes) | — | (No) | (No) | (Yes) | ||
| Clive | (Yes) | (No) | — | (No) | (Maybe) | ||
| Dilshan | (Yes) | (Yes) | (Yes) | — | (No) | ||
| Esha | (Maybe) | (Yes) | (No) | (Maybe) | — | ||
| Column Taps | — | ||||||
| Cost Paid () | — |
Question Deduction
• To determine (Clive's response to Ehsaan's question):
• In column , Ehsaan gave ("Yes").
• By Clue 5 for Ehsaan, Clive cannot give the same response to Ehsaan:
• From the column sum constraint, , meaning .
• Since , the only mathematically permissible value is:
• In the game rules, taps signify "No".
• Evaluating the given options:
• Option 1: Yes Disqualified ( violates Clue 5).
• Option 2: Maybe Disqualified ( violates column sum of ).
• Option 3: No Perfectly matches .
• Option 4: Cannot be determined Disqualified (uniquely locked).
• Therefore, Option 3 is the correct choice.
Topper Take
• The "Cannot Be Determined" Trap: CAT DILR sets involving reciprocal condition rules frequently feature "Cannot be determined" as an attractive distractor. Students who hesitate to test sub-cases or who miss how column forces often default to guessing "Cannot be determined".
• Constraint Convergence: Notice how two distinct constraints converged to isolate cell :
Other questions in this set
- Q19. How many taps did Clive receive for his question?
- Q20. Which two people tapped an equal number of times in total?
- Q22. How many “Yes” responses were received across all the questions?
Math Puzzles questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q6
- CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q7
- CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q8
- CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q9
- CAT 2023 Slot 3 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc