CAT 2023 Slot 3 VARC Q5

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Politics
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2023_SLOT3_VARC_Q05

Passage · questions 5–8

In 2006, the Met (art museum in the US) agreed to return the Euphronios krater, a masterpiece Greek urn that had been a museum draw since 1972. In 2007, the Getty (art museum in the US) agreed to return 40 objects to Italy, including a marble Aphrodite, in the midst of looting scandals. And in December, Sotheby's and a private owner agreed to return an ancient Khmer statue of a warrior, pulled from auction two years before, to Cambodia.

Cultural property, or patrimony, laws limit the transfer of cultural property outside the source country's territory, including outright export prohibitions and national ownership laws. Most art historians, archaeologists, museum officials and policymakers portray cultural property laws in general as invaluable tools for counteracting the ugly legacy of Western cultural imperialism.

During the late 19th and early 20th century - an era former Met director Thomas Having called "the age of piracy" - American and European art museums acquired antiquities by hook or by crook, from grave robbers or souvenir collectors, bounty from digs and ancient sites in impoverished but art-rich source countries. Patrimony laws were intended to protect future archaeological discoveries against Western imperialist designs.

I surveyed 90 countries with one or more archaeological sites on UNESCO's World Heritage Site list, and my study shows that in most cases the number of discovered sites diminishes sharply after a country passes a cultural property law. There are 222 archaeological sites listed for those 90 countries. When you look into the history of the sites, you see that all but 21 were discovered before the passage of cultural property laws.

Strict cultural patrimony laws are popular in most countries. But the downside may be that they reduce incentives for foreign governments, non governmental organizations and educational institutions to invest in overseas exploration because their efforts will not necessarily be rewarded by opportunities to hold, display and study what is uncovered. To the extent that source countries can fund their own archaeological projects, artifacts and sites may still be discovered. The survey has far-reaching implications. It suggests that source countries, particularly in the developing world, should narrow their cultural property laws so that they can reap the benefits of new archaeological discoveries, which typically increase tourism and enhance cultural pride. This does not mean these nations should abolish restrictions on foreign excavation and foreign claims to artifacts.

China provides an interesting alternative approach for source nations eager for foreign archaeological investment. From 1935 to 2003, China had a restrictive cultural property law that prohibited foreign ownership of Chinese cultural artifacts. In those years, China's most significant archaeological discovery occurred by chance, in 1974, when peasant farmers accidentally uncovered ranks of buried terra cotta warriors, which are part of Emperor Qin's spectacular tomb system.

In 2003, the Chinese government switched course, dropping its cultural property law and embracing collaborative international archaeological research. Since then, China has nominated 11 archaeological sites for inclusion in the World Heritage Site list, including eight in 2013, the most ever for China.

Question 5

Which one of the following statements, if true, would undermine the central idea of the passage?

  1. A

    Museums established in economically deprived archaeologically-rich source countries can display the antiques discovered there.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Affluent archaeologically-rich source countries can afford to carry out their own excavations.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    UNESCO finances archaeological research in poor, but archaeologically-rich source countries.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Western countries will have to apologise to countries for looting their cultural property in the past century.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

UNESCO finances archaeological research in poor, but archaeologically-rich source countries.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning / Weaken the Argument

  • Passage Reference:

"Strict cultural patrimony laws are popular in most countries. But the downside may be that they reduce incentives for foreign governments, non governmental organizations and educational institutions to invest in overseas exploration because their efforts will not necessarily be rewarded by opportunities to hold, display and study what is uncovered. To the extent that source countries can fund their own archaeological projects, artifacts and sites may still be discovered. The survey has far-reaching implications. It suggests that source countries, particularly in the developing world, should narrow their cultural property laws so that they can reap the benefits of new archaeological discoveries, which typically increase tourism and enhance cultural pride."

Logical Deduction

The author's thesis rests on a crucial causal chain:

  1. Impoverished, archaeologically-rich source countries lack the domestic financial capital to undertake complex archaeological excavations independently.

  2. Because strict cultural patrimony laws prevent foreign institutions (museums, universities, foundations) from retaining, studying, or exhibiting excavated artifacts, foreign entities have no incentive to finance or conduct excavations in those countries.

  3. As a direct result, overseas investment collapses, leading to a precipitous decline in archaeological discoveries after patrimony laws are enacted.

  4. Hence, the author argues that developing countries must relax or narrow their patrimony restrictions to attract foreign private and institutional investment.

If Option 3 is true—that UNESCO (an international, multilateral body that does not seek ownership, physical acquisition, or foreign exhibition rights) directly finances archaeological exploration in poor, archaeologically-rich nations—the author's entire foundational premise is shattered. Developing nations would not depend on self-interested foreign museums or universities for excavation capital, nor would they suffer an archaeological deficit under strict patrimony laws. Discoveries would continue unabated under international funding without any necessity to dilute or narrow protective patrimony legislation. Thus, Option 3 fundamentally undermines the central idea of the passage.

Correct Answer: Option 3

  • Option 3 is correct because if an international multilateral agency like UNESCO finances archaeological research in impoverished nations without demanding artifact ownership or exhibition rights, it invalidates the author's core claim that strict patrimony laws inevitably dry up excavation funding and stifle discoveries unless relaxed.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Out of Scope): The capacity of local museums in poor nations to display domestically unearthed artifacts does not address the critical financial barrier highlighted by the author—namely, how resource-depleted nations will secure the massive capital required to locate and excavate those sites in the first place.

  • Option 2 (Incomplete Fact): The passage already acknowledges this possibility in Paragraph 5 ("To the extent that source countries can fund their own archaeological projects, artifacts and sites may still be discovered"). The author's thesis specifically targets economically impoverished developing nations that cannot fund excavations; therefore, stating that wealthy nations can self-fund confirms rather than undermines the author's argument.

  • Option 4 (Out of Scope): Demanding moral or diplomatic apologies from Western nations for colonial-era looting addresses historical restorative justice; it has no bearing on the contemporary financial and legal dynamics governing modern archaeological excavations and site discoveries.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The passage examines the unintended negative consequences of strict cultural patrimony and property laws, presenting empirical survey evidence that national ownership mandates and export bans severely diminish foreign archaeological investment and subsequent discoveries in developing nations, and advocates for a balanced, collaborative regulatory model exemplified by China's post-2003 reforms.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Cites prominent recent repatriations of looted cultural artifacts by Western institutions—the Metropolitan Museum returning the Euphronios krater, the Getty Museum returning 40 antiquities to Italy, and Sotheby's returning an ancient Khmer warrior statue to Cambodia—illustrating the modern enforcement of cultural property norms.

  • Paragraph 2: Defines cultural patrimony laws (territorial transfer restrictions, export bans, and state ownership declarations) and summarizes the prevailing institutional consensus among art historians, archaeologists, and policymakers who celebrate these laws as essential remedies against Western cultural imperialism.

  • Paragraph 3: Contextualizes the historical impetus behind patrimony laws, detailing the late 19th and early 20th-century "age of piracy" in which Western museums acquired antiquities through illicit digging, grave robbery, and exploitation of impoverished source nations, establishing that the laws were intended to shield future discoveries from imperialist appropriation.

  • Paragraph 4: Presents the author's central empirical study of 90 nations home to UNESCO World Heritage archaeological sites, revealing that the discovery of new sites drops precipitously after the enactment of cultural property laws (all but 21 of 222 listed sites were uncovered prior to the passage of such legislation).

  • Paragraph 5: Explains the underlying economic mechanism causing this decline: strict patrimony laws disincentivize foreign universities, NGOs, and governments from financing overseas exploration because they are denied opportunities to hold, display, or study discoveries; consequently, developing nations that lack independent excavation funding suffer a loss of potential tourism revenue and cultural pride. The author recommends narrowing rather than abolishing these laws.

  • Paragraph 6: Introduces China as a compelling comparative case study, noting that during its rigid patrimony regime (1935–2003), major archaeological breakthroughs were virtually nonexistent except for accidental findings by rural laborers (the 1974 Terracotta Army).

  • Paragraph 7: Highlights China's pragmatic policy reversal in 2003, when it repealed restrictive ownership laws to embrace international archaeological collaboration, resulting in a dramatic resurgence of discoveries, culminating in 11 new UNESCO World Heritage nominations (including eight in 2013 alone).

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Empirical, Critical, Pragmatic, and Policy-Oriented.

  • Author's Perspective: While acknowledging the moral legitimacy and historical justification of cultural property laws as defenses against colonial plunder, the author adopts an evidence-based, utilitarian perspective, arguing that overly rigid patrimony restrictions unintentionally paralyze archaeological exploration in resource-constrained developing nations and proposing collaborative regulatory frameworks that align foreign investment incentives with national heritage preservation.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q6. Which one of the following statements best expresses the paradox of patrimony laws?
  2. Q7. It can be inferred from the passage that archaeological sites are considered important by some source countries…
  3. Q8. From the passage we can infer that the author is likely to advise poor, but archaeologically-rich source countries to…

Politics questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q5
    The word “instantiation” is used in the first paragraph. Which one of the following pairs of terms would be…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q6
    Which one of the following sets of terms is closest to mapping the key arguments of the passage?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q7
    What does the author wish to communicate by referring to the Hoover and Aswan dams in the first paragraph?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q8
    All of the following statements may be considered valid inferences from the passage EXCEPT that:
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q16
    The author mentions all of the following reasons to dismiss concerns about contaminating Mars EXCEPT:

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc