CAT 2022 Slot 3 VARC Q23
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Verbal Ability › Parajumbles
- Medium
- Type in the answer (TITA)
- CAT_2022_SLOT3_VARC_Q23
Question 23
The sentences given below, when properly sequenced, would yield a coherent paragraph. Decide on the proper sequencing of the order of the sentences and key in the sequence of the numbers as your answer.
- The more we are able to accept that our achievements are largely out of our control, the easier it becomes to understand that our failures, and those of others, are too.
- But the raft of recent books about the limits of merit is an important correction to the arrogance of contemporary entitlement and an opportunity to reassert the importance of luck, or grace, in our thinking.
- Meritocracy as an organising principle is an inevitable function of a free society, as we are designed to see our achievements as worthy of reward.
- And that in turn should increase our humility and the respect with which we treat our fellow citizens, helping ultimately to build a more compassionate society.
Type-in-the-answer (TITA) question: no options are given; enter the value.
Show answer and solution
Answer:
3214
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Parajumble / Sentence Rearrangement (TITA)
-
Logical Progression & Mandatory Pairs:
-
Sentence 3 as the Foundational Thesis: Sentence 3 introduces the baseline societal doctrine: "Meritocracy as an organising principle is an inevitable function of a free society, as we are designed to see our achievements as worthy of reward."
-
Pair 3–2 (Thesis and Counter-Critique): Sentence 2 introduces a vital corrective using the contrastive conjunction "But": "But the raft of recent books about the limits of merit is an important correction to the arrogance of contemporary entitlement and an opportunity to reassert the importance of luck, or grace, in our thinking."
-
Pair 2–1 (From Luck/Grace to Loss of Absolute Agency): Sentence 1 unpacks the philosophical corollary of recognizing luck/grace: "The more we are able to accept that our achievements are largely out of our control, the easier it becomes to understand that our failures, and those of others, are too."
-
Pair 1–4 (Realization to Social Humility and Compassion): Sentence 4 provides the climactic moral conclusion: "And that in turn should increase our humility and the respect with which we treat our fellow citizens, helping ultimately to build a more compassionate society." The pronoun phrase "And that in turn" refers specifically to the realization in 1 that achievements and failures are outside personal control.
-
Logical Deduction
The passage develops a classic Hegelian philosophical movement:
-
Thesis: Meritocracy as an inevitable organizing principle rewarding achievement (3).
-
Antithesis: The contemporary critique of merit reasserting luck and grace against entitlement (2).
-
Internalization: The realization that both success and failure are largely beyond personal control (1).
-
Synthesis / Social Impact: Greater civic humility, mutual respect, and social compassion (4).
Correct Answer: 3214
- Structures the philosophical critique into an airtight sequence: Meritocracy's inevitability (3) → Critique asserting luck/grace (2) → Re-evaluating control over success and failure (1) → Emergence of societal humility and compassion (4).
Option Elimination / Invalid Sequences
-
Opening with 1, 2, or 4: Sentence 1 begins with a comparative progression ("The more we are able to accept...") that presupposes the critique of merit; Sentence 2 begins with the adversative "But"; Sentence 4 opens with the conjunctive link "And that in turn."
-
Placing 4 before 1: Breaks the referential chain, as "And that in turn" in Sentence 4 requires the specific psychological shift explained in Sentence 1.
Detailed explanation
📖 Structural Flow & Logical Progression
Central Theme
A philosophical critique of meritocracy, demonstrating how recognizing the role of contingency, luck, and grace in human achievement dismantles arrogance and fosters a more compassionate, egalitarian society.
Narrative Arc & Logical Progression
-
Opening Premise (Sentence 3): Establishes the foundational status quo: meritocracy functions as an inevitable organizing principle of free societies because humans naturally perceive achievements as worthy of reward.
-
The Critical Pivot (Sentence 2): Uses the contrastive connector "But" to introduce contemporary critiques of meritocracy, showing that recognizing the limits of merit punctures arrogant entitlement and reasserts the vital role of luck or grace.
-
Philosophical Extrapolation (Sentence 1): Develops the philosophical consequence of embracing luck: acknowledging that our achievements are largely outside personal control helps us realize that our failures—and the failures of others—are equally contingent.
-
Ethical & Societal Culmination (Sentence 4): Delivers the ultimate ethical resolution, demonstrating that this awareness fosters humility, mutual civic respect, and a genuinely compassionate society.
Cohesive Devices & Transition Markers
-
Sentence 3 establishes meritocracy as a societal organizing principle; Sentence 2 counters this conventional wisdom with "But the raft of recent books..."
-
Sentence 2's introduction of "luck, or grace" directly leads to Sentence 1's reflection on achievements and failures being "largely out of our control."
-
Sentence 4's additive connector "And that in turn..." links directly to the realization in Sentence 1, completing the chain of moral reasoning.
Parajumbles questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q24
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q2
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q12
- CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc