CAT 2022 Slot 3 VARC Q7

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Technology
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2022_SLOT3_VARC_Q07

Passage · questions 5–8

As software improves, the people using it become less likely to sharpen their own know-how. Applications that offer lots of prompts and tips are often to blame; simpler, less solicitous programs push people harder to think, act and learn.

Ten years ago, information scientists at Utrecht University in the Netherlands had a group of people carry out complicated analytical and planning tasks using either rudimentary software that provided no assistance or sophisticated software that offered a great deal of aid. The researchers found that the people using the simple software developed better strategies, made fewer mistakes and developed a deeper aptitude for the work. The people using the more advanced software, meanwhile, would often "aimlessly click around" when confronted with a tricky problem. The supposedly helpful software actually short-circuited their thinking and learning.

According to philosopher Hubert Dreyfus, our skills get sharper only through practice, when we use them regularly to overcome different sorts of difficult challenges. The goal of modern software, by contrast, is to ease our way through such challenges. Arduous, painstaking work is exactly what programmers are most eager to automate. After all, that is where the immediate efficiency gains tend to lie. In other words, a fundamental tension ripples between the interests of the people doing the automation and the interests of the people doing the work.

Nevertheless, automation's scope continues to widen. With the rise of electronic health records, physicians increasingly rely on software templates to guide them through patient exams. The programs incorporate valuable checklists and alerts, but they also make medicine more routinized and formulaic and distance doctors from their patients. Harvard Medical School professor Beth Lown, in a 2012 journal article, warned that when doctors become "screen-driven,” following a computer's prompts rather than "the patient's narrative thread," their thinking can become constricted. In the worst cases, they may miss important diagnostic signals.

In a recent paper published in the journal Diagnosis, three medical researchers examined the misdiagnosis of Thomas Eric Duncan, the first person to die of Ebola in the U.S., at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Dallas. They argue that the digital templates used by the hospital's clinicians to record patient information probably helped to induce a kind of tunnel vision. "These highly constrained tools,” the researchers write, "are optimized for data capture but at the expense of sacrificing their utility for appropriate triage and diagnosis, leading users to miss the forest for the trees.” Medical software, they write, is no "replacement for basic history-taking, examination skills, and critical thinking."

There is an alternative. In "human-centered automation," the talents of people take precedence. In this model, software plays an essential but secondary role. It takes over routine functions that a human operator has already mastered, issues alerts when unexpected situations arise, provides fresh information that expands the operator's perspective and counters the biases that often distort human thinking. The technology becomes the expert's partner, not the expert's replacement.

Question 7

From the passage, we can infer that the author is apprehensive about the use of sophisticated automation for all of the following reasons EXCEPT that:

  1. A

    it could mislead people.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    it stunts the development of its users.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    it stops users from exercising their minds.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    computers could replace humans.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (D)

computers could replace humans.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Negative Inference / Except Question

  • Passage Reference:

"Harvard Medical School professor Beth Lown... warned that when doctors become 'screen-driven,' following a computer's prompts rather than 'the patient's narrative thread,' their thinking can become constricted. In the worst cases, they may miss important diagnostic signals."

"They argue that the digital templates used by the hospital's clinicians... probably helped to induce a kind of tunnel vision... leading users to miss the forest for the trees."

"The supposedly helpful software actually short-circuited their thinking and learning."

"As software improves, the people using it become less likely to sharpen their own know-how."

"In 'human-centered automation,' the talents of people take precedence... The technology becomes the expert's partner, not the expert's replacement."

Logical Deduction

In an "EXCEPT" question, the correct choice is an assertion that does NOT represent a reason for the author's apprehension regarding sophisticated automation.

  1. Evaluating Option 1: The author expresses grave concern that automation can mislead practitioners, citing instances where clinicians developed tunnel vision, missed the forest for the trees, and overlooked critical diagnostic signals. This is an explicit authorial apprehension.

  2. Evaluating Option 2: The author repeatedly notes that software stunts user development, stating that users "become less likely to sharpen their own know-how" and that software "short-circuited their thinking and learning." This is an explicit authorial apprehension.

  3. Evaluating Option 3: The author emphasizes that solicitous automation prevents users from exercising their minds, depriving them of the arduous problem-solving challenges necessary to sharpen cognitive skills. This is an explicit authorial apprehension.

  4. Evaluating Option 4: Does the author fear that computers will literally replace humans? No. The researchers cited explicitly affirm that software is no replacement for essential clinical and critical thinking skills (Paragraph 5), and the author advocates for human-centered automation where software serves as an assistant/partner ("not the expert's replacement" in Paragraph 6). The author's apprehension is centered on human cognitive atrophy, deskilling, and erroneous reliance—not an existential fear of computers replacing human beings.

Correct Answer: Option 4

  • The author is apprehensive about human cognitive atrophy and misplaced over-reliance, not that computers will replace humans; indeed, the passage explicitly asserts that software cannot substitute for human critical thinking.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Passage-Supported Apprehension / Valid Concern): Validated in Paragraphs 4 and 5, where screen-driven templates mislead clinicians into tunnel vision and missed diagnostic signals.

  • Option 2 (Passage-Supported Apprehension / Valid Concern): Validated in Paragraphs 1, 2, and 3, which explain that solicitous software stunts the cultivation of deep aptitude and professional know-how.

  • Option 3 (Passage-Supported Apprehension / Valid Concern): Validated in Paragraphs 1 and 2, which demonstrate that helpful software short-circuits independent cognitive exertion and critical thinking.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The cognitive erosion and professional deskilling induced by over-engineered, prescriptive automation and solicitous software. The passage investigates how modern applications laden with automated tips, checklists, and prompts short-circuit independent human critical thinking, problem-solving aptitude, and holistic judgment. Drawing on philosophical foundations (Hubert Dreyfus), experimental evidence (Utrecht University), and clinical medical failures (the fatal Ebola misdiagnosis of Thomas Eric Duncan), the author critiques "screen-driven" cognitive constriction and champions "human-centered automation," wherein technology acts as an expert's subordinate partner rather than an autonomous replacement.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Sets forth the overarching thesis: sophisticated, solicitous software featuring excessive prompts and tips discourages users from cultivating and sharpening their personal expertise, whereas simpler, unassisted tools compel users to think, act, and learn independently.

  • Paragraph 2: Details empirical findings from an information science study at Utrecht University. Subjects using rudimentary software developed superior analytical strategies, made fewer mistakes, and acquired deeper competence; conversely, subjects using advanced, aid-heavy software engaged in "aimless clicking" when encountering tricky problems, demonstrating that software assistance short-circuited active cognition and learning.

  • Paragraph 3: Examines philosopher Hubert Dreyfus's thesis that true expertise develops only through continuous practice in overcoming difficult challenges. Identifies the structural tension between programmers (who automate arduous tasks for rapid efficiency gains) and practitioners (who require engagement with those very challenges to build proficiency).

  • Paragraph 4: Details the real-world expansion of automation into clinical medicine through Electronic Health Records (EHRs) and diagnostic templates. Cites Beth Lown's warning that "screen-driven" clinicians prioritizing computerized prompts lose the patient's narrative thread, resulting in formulaic care, constricted reasoning, and missed diagnostic cues.

  • Paragraph 5: Analyzes the fatal misdiagnosis of Ebola patient Thomas Eric Duncan in Dallas. Researchers in Diagnosis found that clinicians' digital templates induced severe cognitive "tunnel vision," optimizing for mechanical data capture at the expense of triage and holistic synthesis ("missing the forest for the trees"). Emphasizes that software cannot substitute for clinical examination and critical thinking.

  • Paragraph 6: Proposes the normative framework of "human-centered automation." In this model, human talent takes precedence: software handles mastered routine functions, flags unexpected anomalies, broadens perspective, and debiases human cognition, acting as an expert partner rather than an expert replacement.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Critical, Analytical, Thoughtful, and Cautionary.

  • Author's Perspective: The author adopts a discerning, cautionary stance toward technological over-reliance. Resisting simplistic technophobia, the author does not advocate abandoning software, but instead critiques prescriptive automation that displaces human cognitive effort, making a compelling case for a collaborative paradigm ("human-centered automation") where technology augments human agency without eroding critical thinking.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q5. In the Ebola misdiagnosis case, we can infer that doctors probably missed the forest for the trees because:
  2. Q6. It can be inferred that in the Utrecht University experiment, one group of people was "aimlessly clicking around"…
  3. Q8. In the context of the passage, all of the following can be considered examples of human-centered automation EXCEPT:

Technology questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q17
    The author of the passage is least likely to agree with which one of the following claims?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q18
    The author compares AI-generated texts with "a beige office building" for all of the following reasons EXCEPT:
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q19
    On the basis of the purpose of the examples in the passage, pick the odd one out from the following…
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 2 VARC Q20
    All of the following statements from the passage affirm the disjunct between the claims about AI made by…
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q1
    "Netflix had begun editing old episodes of Stranger Things to retroactively improve their visual effects."…

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc