CAT 2021 Slot 3 VARC Q15

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Psychology
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2021_SLOT3_VARC_Q15

Passage · questions 13–16

Starting in 1957, Noam Chomsky proclaimed a new doctrine: Language, that most human of all attributes, was innate. The grammatical faculty was built into the infant brain, and your average 3-year-old was not a mere apprentice in the great enterprise of absorbing English from his or her parents, but a "linguistic genius." Since this message was couched in terms of Chomskyan theoretical linguistics, in discourse so opaque that it was nearly incomprehensible even to some scholars, many people did not hear it. Now, in a brilliant, witty and altogether satisfying book, Mr. Chomsky's colleague Steven Pinker has brought Mr. Chomsky's findings to everyman. In "The Language Instinct" he has gathered persuasive data from such diverse fields as cognitive neuroscience, developmental psychology and speech therapy to make his points, and when he disagrees with Mr. Chomsky he tells you so.

For Mr. Chomsky and Mr. Pinker, somewhere in the human brain there is a complex set of neural circuits that have been programmed with "super-rules" (making up what Mr. Chomsky calls "universal grammar"), and that these rules are unconscious and instinctive. A half-century ago, this would have been pooh-poohed as a "black box" theory, since one could not actually pinpoint this grammatical faculty in a specific part of the brain, or describe its functioning. But now things are different. Neurosurgeons have now found that this "black box" is situated in and around Broca's area, on the left side of the forebrain.

Unlike Mr. Chomsky, Mr. Pinker firmly places the wiring of the brain for language within the framework of Darwinian natural selection and evolution. He effectively disposes of all claims that intelligent nonhuman primates like chimps have any abilities to learn and use language. It is not that chimps lack the vocal apparatus to speak; it is just that their brains are unable to produce or use grammar. On the other hand, the "language instinct," when it first appeared among our most distant hominid ancestors, must have given them a selective reproductive advantage over their competitors (including the ancestral chimps).

So according to Mr. Pinker, the roots of language must be in the genes, but there cannot be a "grammar gene" any more than there can be a gene for the heart or any other complex body structure. This proposition will undoubtedly raise the hackles of some behavioral psychologists and anthropologists, for it apparently contradicts the liberal idea that human behavior may be changed for the better by improvements in culture and environment, and it might seem to invite the twin bugaboos of biological determinism and racism. Yet Mr. Pinker stresses one point that should allay such fears. Even though there are 4,000 to 6,000languages today, they are all sufficiently alike to be considered one language by an extraterrestrial observer. In other words, most of the diversity of the world's cultures, so beloved to anthropologists, is superficial and minor compared to the similarities. Racial differences are literally only "skin deep." The fundamental unity of humanity is the theme of Mr. Chomsky's universal grammar, and of this exciting book.

Question 15

From the passage, it can be inferred that all of the following are true about Pinker 'book, "The Language Instinct", EXCEPT that Pinker:

  1. A

    writes in a different style from Chomsky

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    draws from behavioural psychology theories

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    disagrees with Chomsky on certain grounds

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    draws extensively from Chomsky's propositions

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (B)

draws from behavioural psychology theories

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Negative Inference / Except Question

  • Passage Reference:

"In 'The Language Instinct' he has gathered persuasive data from such diverse fields as cognitive neuroscience, developmental psychology and speech therapy to make his points, and when he disagrees with Mr. Chomsky he tells you so."

"This proposition will undoubtedly raise the hackles of some behavioral psychologists and anthropologists, for it apparently contradicts the liberal idea that human behavior may be changed for the better by improvements in culture and environment..."

"Since this message was couched in terms of Chomskyan theoretical linguistics, in discourse so opaque that it was nearly incomprehensible even to some scholars... Now, in a brilliant, witty and altogether satisfying book... Pinker has brought Mr. Chomsky's findings to everyman."

Logical Deduction

To identify the ungrounded or contradictory claim regarding Pinker's book:

  1. Paragraph 1 enumerates the disciplines Pinker synthesizes: "cognitive neuroscience, developmental psychology and speech therapy." Behavioral psychology is conspicuously absent.

  2. Furthermore, Paragraph 4 explicitly highlights that Pinker's innate genetic framework directly antagonizes behavioral psychology: "This proposition will undoubtedly raise the hackles of some behavioral psychologists... for it apparently contradicts the liberal idea that human behavior may be changed for the better by improvements in culture and environment."

  3. Because Pinker's nativist paradigm fundamentally challenges the environmental determinism of behavioral psychology, Pinker does not draw from behavioral psychology theories.

Therefore, Option 2 is false according to the passage and is the credited answer.

Correct Answer: Option 2

  • Directly contradicted by the text: Pinker's innate genetic model antagonizes behavioral psychologists by refuting their belief in environmental/cultural plasticity, and behavioral psychology is not among the disciplines he draws from.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Supported Fact / Opposite in EXCEPT): True; Paragraph 1 contrasts Chomsky's "opaque" discourse with Pinker's "brilliant, witty" writing accessible to "everyman."

  • Option 3 (Supported Fact / Opposite in EXCEPT): True; Paragraph 1 and Paragraph 3 explicitly note that Pinker states when he disagrees with Chomsky, notably regarding Darwinian natural selection.

  • Option 4 (Supported Fact / Opposite in EXCEPT): True; Paragraph 1 states Pinker brings Chomsky's findings to everyman, and Paragraph 4 highlights that Chomsky's universal grammar is the unifying theme of the book.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The biological and evolutionary foundations of human language, examining Noam Chomsky's foundational thesis of an innate "universal grammar" and Steven Pinker's evolutionary synthesis in The Language Instinct. The passage explores the neurological localization of language, Pinker's Darwinian framework of natural selection, the refutation of primate language claims, and how the deep structural unity of human languages disarms allegations of biological determinism and racism.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: Introduces Noam Chomsky's 1957 revolutionary thesis that language is an innate human faculty built into the infant brain. Explains that Chomsky's dense, opaque theoretical linguistics prevented widespread public understanding until Steven Pinker popularized and expanded these findings for a general audience in The Language Instinct, drawing upon cognitive neuroscience, developmental psychology, and speech therapy while articulating key disagreements with Chomsky.

  • Paragraph 2: Explores the shared neurobiological premise of Chomsky and Pinker: human brains contain neural circuits programmed with instinctive, unconscious "super-rules" (universal grammar). Notes that while previously dismissed as an untestable "black box" hypothesis, modern neuroscience has localized this grammatical circuitry in and around Broca's area in the left forebrain.

  • Paragraph 3: Identifies the critical divergence between Chomsky and Pinker: Pinker situates language wiring firmly within Darwinian natural selection and evolutionary advantage. Explains Pinker's refutation of nonhuman primate language claims (noting chimps lack the grammatical brain wiring, not vocal anatomy) and posits that the language instinct conferred selective reproductive advantages to hominid ancestors.

  • Paragraph 4: Discusses the genetic basis of language, clarifying that no single "grammar gene" exists. Addresses potential socio-political objections from behavioral psychologists and anthropologists regarding biological determinism and racism, countering them with Pinker's core thesis: all 4,000 to 6,000 human languages share profound structural commonalities, proving that cultural variations and racial differences are merely superficial, and establishing the fundamental biological unity of humanity.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Academic, Expository, Appreciative, and Evaluative.

  • Author's Perspective: The author strongly endorses Pinker's accessible synthesis of linguistics and evolutionary biology, viewing The Language Instinct as an exciting, satisfying vindication of Chomsky's universal grammar that reinforces the fundamental biological unity of humanity.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q13. On the basis of the information in the passage, Pinker and Chomsky may disagree with each other on which one of the…
  2. Q14. According to the passage, all of the following are true about the language instinct EXCEPT that:
  3. Q16. Which one of the following statements best summarises the author's position about Pinker's book?

Psychology questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q9
    The last paragraph of the passage refers to “middle-class, white, professional men”. Which one of the…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q10
    “Conversely, when a defendant struck officials as unlike themselves, whether by dint of disease, gender,…
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q11
    According to the passage, who or what was an “alienist”?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q12
    Study the following sets of concepts and identify the set that is conceptually closest to the concerns and…
  5. CAT 2020 Slot 2 VARC Q15
    All of the following statements can be seen as logically implied by the arguments of the passage EXCEPT:

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc