CAT 2021 Slot 3 DILR Q11
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT3_DILR_Q11
Data set · questions 7–12
Three reviewers Amal, Bimal, and Komal are tasked with selecting questions from a pool of 13 questions (Q01 to Q13). Questions can be created by external "subject matter experts" (SMEs) or by one of the three reviewers. Each of the reviewers either approves or disapproves a question that is shown to them. Their decisions lead to eventual acceptance or rejection of the question in the manner described below.
If a question is created by an SME, it is reviewed first by Amal, and then by Bimal. If both of them approve the question, then the question is accepted and is not reviewed by Komal. If both disapprove the question, it is rejected and is not reviewed by Komal. If one of them approves the question and the other disapproves it, then the question is reviewed by Komal. Then the question is accepted only if she approves it.
A question created by one of the reviewers is decided upon by the other two. If a question is created by Amal, then it is first reviewed by Bimal. If Bimal approves the question, then it is accepted. Otherwise, it is reviewed by Komal. The question is then accepted only if Komal approves it. A similar process is followed for questions created by Bimal, whose questions are first reviewed by Komal, and then by Amal only if Komal disapproves it. Questions created by Komal are first reviewed by Amal, and then, if required, by Bimal.
The following facts are also known.
- Q02, Q06, Q09, Q11, and Q12 were rejected and the other questions were accepted.
- Amal reviewed only Q02, Q03, Q04, Q06, Q08, Q10, Q11, and Q13.
- Bimal reviewed only Q02, Q04, Q06 through Q09, Q12, and Q13.
- Komal reviewed only Q01 through Q05, Q07, Q08, Q09, Q11, and Q12.
Question 11
The approval ratio of a reviewer is the ratio of the number of questions (s)he approved to the number of questions (s)he reviewed. Which option best describes Amal's approval ratio?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (A)
lies between 0.25 and 0.75
Solution
Concept: Bounded Ratio Analysis, Combinatorial Extremes & Interval Verification
Master State Table
| Question | Outcome | Reviewers | Creator | Amal | Bimal | Komal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Q01 | Accepted | Komal | Bimal | — | — | Approved (✓) |
| Q02 | Rejected | Amal, Bimal, Komal | SME | Disagreed | Disagreed | Disapproved (✗) |
| Q03 | Accepted | Amal, Komal | Bimal | Approved (✓) | — | Disapproved (✗) |
| Q04 | Accepted | Amal, Bimal, Komal | SME | Disagreed | Disagreed | Approved (✓) |
| Q05 | Accepted | Komal | Bimal | — | — | Approved (✓) |
| Q06 | Rejected | Amal, Bimal | SME or Komal | Disapproved (✗) | Disapproved (✗) | — |
| Q07 | Accepted | Bimal, Komal | Amal | — | Disapproved (✗) | Approved (✓) |
| Q08 | Accepted | Amal, Bimal, Komal | SME | Disagreed | Disagreed | Approved (✓) |
| Q09 | Rejected | Bimal, Komal | Amal | — | Disapproved (✗) | Disapproved (✗) |
| Q10 | Accepted | Amal | Komal | Approved (✓) | — | — |
| Q11 | Rejected | Amal, Komal | Bimal | Disapproved (✗) | — | Disapproved (✗) |
| Q12 | Rejected | Bimal, Komal | Amal | — | Disapproved (✗) | Disapproved (✗) |
| Q13 | Accepted | Amal, Bimal | SME or Komal | ✓ (SME) / ✗ (Komal) | Approved (✓) | — |
Question Deduction
• Review Count for Amal:
• Amal reviewed 8 questions: Q02, Q03, Q04, Q06, Q08, Q10, Q11, and Q13.
• Approval ratio: , where is the count of approved questions.
• Partitioning Amal's Decisions:
• Definitely Approved ():
• Q03 (Bimal's question, Komal rejected, Accepted) $\implies$ Amal approved.
• Q10 (Komal's question, Accepted with Amal only) $\implies$ Amal approved.
• Definitely Disapproved ():
• Q06 (Rejected with $\{A, B\}$) $\implies$ Amal disapproved under both origins.
• Q11 (Bimal's question, Komal rejected, Rejected) $\implies$ Amal disapproved.
• Flexible Decisions (4 questions):
• Q02, Q04, Q08 (SME questions reaching Komal): Amal could approve or disapprove.
• Q13 (Accepted with $\{A, B\}$): Amal approved if SME, or disapproved if Komal.
• Evaluating Bounds on Approval Ratio:
• Minimum approvals: Only Q03 and Q10 .
• Maximum approvals: Q03, Q10, and all 4 flexible questions .
• Achievable ratios span .
• Therefore, Amal's approval ratio lies between and .
• Option Matching:
• Matches Option 1 (lies between 0.25 and 0.75).
Topper Take
• Amal reviewed 8 questions: exactly 2 approvals are fixed (Q03, Q10) and 4 are variable. The ratio spans to lies between 0.25 and 0.75.
Other questions in this set
- Q7. How many questions were DEFINITELY created by Amal?
- Q8. How many questions were DEFINITELY created by Komal?
- Q9. How many questions were DEFINITELY created by the SMEs?
- Q10. How many questions were DEFINITELY disapproved by Bimal?
- Q12. How many questions created by Amal or Bimal were disapproved by at least one of the other reviewers?
Arrangements questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc