CAT 2021 Slot 1 DILR Q11

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2021_SLOT1_DILR_Q11

Data set · questions 9–14

A journal plans to publish 18 research papers, written by eight authors (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, and H) in four issues of the journal scheduled in January, April, July and October. Each of the research papers was written by exactly one of the eight authors. Five papers were scheduled in each of the first two issues, while four were scheduled in each of the last two issues. Every author wrote at least one paper and at most three papers. The total number of papers written by A, D, G and H was double the total number of papers written by the other four authors.

Four of the authors were from India and two each were from Japan and China. Each author belonged to exactly one of the three areas Manufacturing, Automation and Logistics. Four of the authors were from the Logistics area and two from the Automation area. As per the journal policy, none of the authors could have more than one paper in any issue of the journal.

The following facts are also known.

  • F, an Indian author from the Logistics area, wrote only one paper. It was scheduled in the October issue.
  • A was from the Automation area and did not have a paper scheduled in the October issue.
  • None of the Indian authors were from the Manufacturing area and none of the Japanese or Chinese authors were from the Automation area.
  • A and H were from different countries, but had their papers scheduled in exactly the same issues.
  • C and E, both Chinese authors from different areas, had the same number of papers scheduled. Further, E had papers scheduled in consecutive issues of the journal but C did not.
  • B, from the Logistics area, had a paper scheduled in the April issue of the journal.
  • B and G belonged to the same country. None of their papers were scheduled in the same issue of the journal.
  • D, a Japanese author from the Manufacturing area, did not have a paper scheduled in the July issue.
  • C and H belonged to different areas.
  • Question 11

    Which of the following statement(s) MUST be true?

    Statement A: Every issue had at least one paper by author(s) from each country.
    Statement B: Every issue had at most two papers by author(s) from each area.

    1. A

      Both the statements

      Answer A in PrepSoc practice
    2. B

      Neither of the statements

      Answer B in PrepSoc practice
    3. C

      Only Statement A

      Answer C in PrepSoc practice
    4. D

      Only Statement B

      Answer D in PrepSoc practice

    Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

    Show answer and solution

    Answer: (C)

    Only Statement A

    Solution

    Concept: Exhaustive Issue-Wise Cross-Tabulation & Counterexample Disproof

    Master State Table

    AuthorCountryAreaTotal PapersJanuaryAprilJulyOctober
    AIndiaAutomation3YesYesYes—
    BIndiaLogistics1—Yes——
    CChinaManufacturing2Yes——Yes
    DJapanManufacturing3YesYes—Yes
    EChinaLogistics2—YesYes—
    FIndiaLogistics1———Yes
    GIndiaAutomation3Yes—YesYes
    HJapanLogistics3YesYesYes—
    Total——185544

    Question Deduction

    • Evaluating Statement A (Every issue had at least one paper from each country):

    • The three countries represented are India, Japan, and China.

    • We audit the author roster across all four publication issues:

    • January (5 papers): A (India), C (China), D (Japan), G (India), H (Japan) $\implies$ all 3 countries present.
    
    • April (5 papers): A (India), B (India), D (Japan), E (China), H (Japan) $\implies$ all 3 countries present.
    
    • July (4 papers): A (India), E (China), G (India), H (Japan) $\implies$ all 3 countries present.
    
    • October (4 papers): C (China), D (Japan), F (India), G (India) $\implies$ all 3 countries present.
    

    • Across every scheduled issue, each country has at least 1 paper published.

    • Hence, Statement A is universally TRUE.

    • Evaluating Statement B (Every issue had at most two papers from each area):

    • The three research areas are Automation, Manufacturing, and Logistics.

    • We audit the distribution of areas in the April issue:

    • Author A is from Automation (1 paper).
    
    • Author D is from Manufacturing (1 paper).
    
    • Authors B, E, and H all represent Logistics:
    
      • Author B is from Logistics (Fact 6).
    
      • Author E is from Logistics (Fact 5 & Fact 9).
    
      • Author H is from Logistics (Fact 3 & Fact 8).
    

    • Thus, the April issue contains exactly 3 papers from Logistics (1+1+1=31 + 1 + 1 = 3).

    • Because 3 exceeds the upper bound of 2 papers per area, the April issue provides a definitive counterexample.

    • Hence, Statement B is demonstrably FALSE.

    • Option Matching:

    • Statement A is true while Statement B is false.

    • Matches Option 3 (Only Statement A).

    Topper Take

    • In April, authors B, E, and H all belong to Logistics, giving 3 papers and instantly disproving Statement B.

    • Statement A holds because Chinese authors alternate (CC in Jan/Oct, EE in Apr/Jul), while India and Japan publish in every issue.

    Other questions in this set

    1. Q9. What is the correct sequence of number of papers written by B, C, E and G, respectively?
    2. Q10. How many papers were written by Indian authors?
    3. Q12. Which of the following statements is FALSE?
    4. Q13. Which of the following statements is FALSE?
    5. Q14. Which of the following is the correct sequence of number of papers by authors from Automation, Manufacturing and…

    Arrangements questions from other CAT papers

    1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
      What is the number of the chair initially occupied by Bashir?
    2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
      Who sits on the chair numbered 4 at the end of Turn 3?
    3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
      Which of the chairs are occupied at the end of Turn 6?
    4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
      Which of the following BEST describes the friends sitting on chairs adjacent to the one occupied by Bashir…
    5. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
      In which of the following years were Ananya and Bhaskar Gurubhai?

    Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

    Practise in PrepSoc