CAT 2021 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2021_SLOT1_DILR_Q06
Data set · questions 5–8
Ganga, Kaveri, and Narmada are three women who buy four raw materials (Mango, Apple, Banana and Milk) and sell five finished products (Mango smoothie, Apple smoothie, Banana smoothie, Mixed fruit smoothie and Fruit salad). Table-1 gives information about the raw materials required to produce the five finished products. One unit of a finished product requires one unit of each of the raw materials mentioned in the second column of the table.
| Finished product | Raw materials required |
|---|---|
| Mango smoothie | Mango, Milk |
| Apple smoothie | Apple, Milk |
| Banana smoothie | Banana, Milk |
| Mixed fruit smoothie | Mango, Apple, Banana, Milk |
| Fruit salad | Mango, Apple, Banana |
One unit of milk, mango, apple, and banana cost ₹5, ₹3, ₹2, and ₹1 respectively. Each unit of a finished product is sold for a profit equal to two times the number of raw materials used to make that product. For example, apple smoothie is made with two raw materials (apple and milk) and will be sold for a profit of ₹4 per unit. Leftover raw materials are sold during the last business hour of the day for a loss of ₹1 per unit.
The amount, in rupees, received from sales (revenue) for each woman in each of the four business hours of the day is given in Table-2.
| Business Hour | Ganga | Kaveri | Narmada |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hour 1 | 23 | 19 | 31 |
| Hour 2 | 21 | 22 | 21 |
| Hour 3 | 29 | 30 | 23 |
| Hour 4 (last hour) | 30 | 27 | 22 |
The following additional facts are known.
Question 6
Which of the following is NECESSARILY true?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
Ganga did not sell any leftover apples.
Solution
Concept: Revenue Decomposition, Unit Economics & Inventory Optimization
Master State Table
| Woman | Hour 1 Sales (₹) | Hour 2 Sales (₹) | Hour 3 Sales (₹) | Hour 4 Finished Products (₹) | Hour 4 Leftovers Sold (₹) | Hour 4 Total (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ganga | AS (11) + [MS or FS] (12) = 23 | AS (11) + BS (10) = 21 | BS (10) + MF (19) = 29 | MS (12) + FS (12) = 24 | 1 Milk (4) + 1 Mango (2) = 6 | ₹30 (₹24 + ₹6) |
| Kaveri | MF (19) = 19 | BS (10) + FS (12) = 22 | AS (11) + MF (19) = 30 | Case A: AS (11) + BS (10) = 21 Case B: BS (10) + FS (12) = 22 | Case A: 1 Milk (4) + 1 Mango (2) = 6 Case B: 1 Milk (4) + 1 Apple (1) = 5 | ₹27 (₹21 + ₹6 or ₹22 + ₹5) |
| Narmada | MF (19) + FS (12) = 31 | AS (11) + BS (10) = 21 | AS (11) + FS (12) = 23 | MF (19) = 19 | 1 Mango (2) + 1 Apple (1) = 3 | ₹22 (₹19 + ₹3) |
Question Deduction
• Hour 4 Leftover Valuation & Revenue Rules:
• Leftovers are sold in Hour 4 at cost minus ₹1: Milk , Mango , Apple .
• Each woman has exactly one unit each of two different raw materials as leftovers, with no banana leftover.
• Three possible leftover combinations: Milk + Mango (), Milk + Apple (), Mango + Apple ().
• Decomposing Hour 4 Revenues into Finished Products and Leftovers:
• Narmada (Revenue ): Leftovers of ₹6 or ₹5 leave or (unachievable). Leftovers must be ₹3 (Mango + Apple), leaving (MF). Narmada sold 0 leftover milk.
• Ganga (Revenue ): Leftovers of ₹3 or ₹5 leave or (unachievable). Leftovers must be ₹6 (Milk + Mango), leaving , uniquely MS (₹12) + FS (₹12).
• Ganga sold strictly 1 unit of leftover milk and 1 unit of leftover mango, and zero leftover apples.
• Kaveri (Revenue ): Leftovers can be ₹6 (Milk + Mango, finished ) or ₹5 (Milk + Apple, finished ).
• Verifying the Options:
• Option 1 ("Narmada sold one unit of leftover milk"): False (sold Mango + Apple).
• Option 2 ("Ganga did not sell any leftover mangoes"): False (sold 1 leftover mango).
• Option 3 ("Ganga did not sell any leftover apples"): Necessarily True (sold Milk + Mango, hence 0 apples).
• Option 4 ("Kaveri sold one unit of leftover mangoes"): Not necessarily true (false in Case B).
• Option Matching:
• Matches Option 3 (Ganga did not sell any leftover apples.).
Topper Take
• Clean Partition: Ganga's Hour 4 revenue of ₹30 requires , where ₹6 must be Milk (₹4) + Mango (₹2). Ganga's leftover set is uniquely determined as {Milk, Mango}, guaranteeing zero leftover apples.
Other questions in this set
- Q5. What BEST can be concluded about the number of units of fruit salad sold in the first hour?
- Q7. What BEST can be concluded about the total number of units of milk the three women had in the beginning?
- Q8. If it is known that three leftover units of mangoes were sold during the last business hour of the day, how many apple…
Arrangements questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc