CAT 2020 Slot 3 DILR Q13
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Data Interpretation › Venn Diagrams
- Easy
- Type in the answer (TITA)
- CAT_2020_SLOT3_DILR_Q13
Data set · questions 11–14
A survey of schools in India was conducted to gather information about their online teaching learning processes (OTLP).
The following four facilities were studied.
F1: Own software for OTLP
F2: Trained teachers for OTLP
F3: Training materials for OTLP
F4: All students having Laptops
The following observations were summarized from the survey.
-
schools did not have any of the four facilities - F1, F2, F3, F4.
-
schools had all four facilities.
-
The number of schools with only F1, only F2, only F3, and only F4 was 25, 30, and respectively.
-
The number of schools with exactly three of the facilities was the same irrespective of which three were considered.
-
schools had F2.
-
schools had only F2 and F3 (but neither F1 nor F4).
-
Among the schools having F4, had only F3, and had only F2.
-
schools had both F1 and F2.
-
The number of schools having F1 was the same as the number of schools having F4.
Question 13
What was the number of schools having only facilities F1 and F3?
Type-in-the-answer (TITA) question: no options are given; enter the value.
Show answer and solution
Answer:
42
Solution
Concept: Marginal Set Symmetry, Equating Set Cardinalities & Dual-Facility Isolation
Master State Table
| Facility Combination | Schools | Invariant Status & Basis |
|---|---|---|
| None (No Facility) | 80 | Explicit in Observation 1 |
| F1 only | 25 | Explicit in Observation 3 |
| F2 only | 30 | Explicit in Observation 3 |
| F3 only | 26 | Explicit in Observation 3 |
| F4 only | 20 | Explicit in Observation 3 |
| F1 & F2 only | 22 | Solved: |
| F1 & F3 only | 42 | Equated totals: |
| F1 & F4 only | 20 | Population residual: |
| F2 & F3 only | 26 | Explicit in Observation 6 |
| F2 & F4 only | 45 | Explicit in Observation 7 |
| F3 & F4 only | 24 | Explicit in Observation 7 |
| F1, F2 & F3 only | 50 | Equi-triple parameter (Obs 4, 5, 8) |
| F1, F2 & F4 only | 50 | Equi-triple parameter (Obs 4, 5, 8) |
| F1, F3 & F4 only | 50 | Equi-triple parameter (Obs 4, 5, 8) |
| F2, F3 & F4 only | 50 | Equi-triple parameter (Obs 4, 5, 8) |
| All Four (F1–F4) | 40 | Explicit in Observation 2 |
| Facility Totals | F1: 299, F2: 313, F3: 308, F4: 299 | Disjoint region sum per facility |
| Macro Aggregates | Total: 600, Active: 520, None: 80 | Partition () |
Question Deduction
• Target Region Specification:
• The question asks for schools having only facilities F1 and F3: .
• This is the disjoint pairwise intersection between F1 and F3 excluding both F2 and F4.
• Equating Marginal Totals and :
• By Observation 9, . Decomposing both sets into their 8 disjoint regions:
$$n(F1) = \text{Only } F1 + (a_{12} + a_{13} + a_{14}) + 3x + \text{All Four}$$
$$n(F1) = 25 + (22 + a_{13} + a_{14}) + 3(50) + 40 = 237 + a_{13} + a_{14}$$
$$n(F4) = \text{Only } F4 + (a_{14} + a_{24} + a_{34}) + 3x + \text{All Four}$$
$$n(F4) = 20 + (a_{14} + 45 + 24) + 3(50) + 40 = 279 + a_{14}$$
• Isolating via Equivalence:
• Equating and :
$$237 + a_{13} + a_{14} = 279 + a_{14}$$
• The unknown cancels identically from both sides:
$$a_{13} = 279 - 237 = 42$$
• Numerical Answer:
• 42.
Topper Take
• Spot algebraic cancellation: equating and cancels on both sides, yielding without needing first.
• In TITA questions, setting up equations where unneeded variables drop out eliminates arithmetic and prevents cascading errors.
Other questions in this set
- Q11. What was the total number of schools having exactly three of the four facilities?
- Q12. What was the number of schools having facilities F2 and F4?
- Q14. What was the number of schools having only facilities F1 and F4?
Venn Diagrams questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q9
- CAT 2019 Slot 2 DILR Q9
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc