CAT 2020 Slot 1 DILR Q23
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Data Interpretation › Venn Diagrams
- Easy
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2020_SLOT1_DILR_Q23
Data set · questions 21–24
Ten musicians (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I and J) are experts in at least one of the following three percussion instruments: tabla, mridangam, and ghatam. Among them, three are experts in tabla but not in mridangam or ghatam, another three are experts in mridangam but not in tabla or ghatam, and one is an expert in ghatam but not in tabla or mridangam. Further, two are experts in tabla and mridangam but not in ghatam, and one is an expert in tabla and ghatam but not in mridangam.
The following facts are known about these ten musicians.
-
Both A and B are experts in mridangam, but only one of them is also an expert in tabla.
-
D is an expert in both tabla and ghatam.
-
Both F and G are experts in tabla, but only one of them is also an expert in mridangam.
-
Neither I nor J is an expert in tabla.
-
Neither H nor I is an expert in mridangam, but only one of them is an expert in ghatam
Question 23
Which of the following pairs CANNOT have any musician who is an expert in both tabla and mridangam but not in ghatam?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
C and E
Solution
Concept: Cardinality Quota Exhaustion, Entangled Pairs & Intersection Invariance
Master State Table
| Musician | Tabla | Mridangam | Ghatam | Invariant Category | Core Deduction Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Feasible | Yes | No | Only M OR T & M only | Plays Mridangam (Clue 1); pair with B |
| B | Feasible | Yes | No | Only M OR T & M only | Plays Mridangam (Clue 1); pair with A |
| C | Feasible | Feasible | No | Only T OR Only M | Excluded from T & M; pair with E |
| D | Yes | No | Yes | T & G only (Unique) | Clue 2: uniquely fills T & G quota |
| E | Feasible | Feasible | No | Only T OR Only M | Excluded from T & M; pair with C |
| F | Yes | Feasible | No | Only T OR T & M only | Plays Tabla (Clue 3); pair with G |
| G | Yes | Feasible | No | Only T OR T & M only | Plays Tabla (Clue 3); pair with F |
| H | Yes | No | No | Only T (Deterministic) | Clue 5: no Mridangam, no Ghatam |
| I | No | No | Yes | Only G (Deterministic) | Clues 4 & 5: no Tabla, no Mridangam |
| J | No | Yes | No | Only M (Deterministic) | Clue 4: no Tabla; Ghatam quota full |
Question Deduction
• Dual-Intersection Capacity Constraint:
• The passage fixes experts in both Tabla and Mridangam but not Ghatam: .
• Exhaustive Quota Saturation:
• Clue 1: Exactly one member of {A, B} belongs to , while the other belongs to Only Mridangam.
• Clue 3: Exactly one member of {F, G} belongs to , while the other belongs to Only Tabla.
• Summing contributions: musicians.
• Since total capacity , these two slots are completely saturated by one from {A, B} and one from {F, G}.
• Exclusion of Residual Musicians (C and E):
• Musicians D, H, I, and J are uniquely fixed in other categories.
• Remaining musicians C and E cannot belong to (capacity full).
• Thus, {C, E} partition residual single-instrument slots: one in Only Tabla and one in Only Mridangam.
• Neither C nor E can play both Tabla and Mridangam under any valid assignment.
• Option Matching:
• Options 1 (A, B) & 2 (F, G): Each contains exactly 1 musician in T & M only.
• Option 4 (C and F): Can contain 1 musician in T & M only (via F).
• Option 3 (C and E): Contains 0 musicians in T & M only; cannot have any such musician.
• Matches Option 3 (C and E).
Topper Take
• Pigeonhole Principle: The two Tabla + Mridangam slots are pre-emptively booked by Clue 1 (one of A/B) and Clue 3 (one of F/G).
• Any pair of outsiders ({C, E}) automatically has zero representation in the dual set, solving the question without case exploration.
Other questions in this set
- Q21. Who among the following is DEFINITELY an expert in tabla but not in either mridangam or ghatam?
- Q22. Who among the following is DEFINITELY an expert in mridangam but not in either tabla or ghatam?
- Q24. If C is an expert in mridangam and F is not, then which are the three musicians who are experts in tabla but not in…
Venn Diagrams questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q9
- CAT 2019 Slot 2 DILR Q9
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc