CAT 2020 Slot 1 DILR Q3
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Data Interpretation › Venn Diagrams
- Medium
- Type in the answer (TITA)
- CAT_2020_SLOT1_DILR_Q03
Data set · questions 1–4
1000 patients currently suffering from a disease were selected to study the effectiveness of treatment of four types of medicines A, B, C and D. These patients were first randomly assigned into two groups of equal size, called treatment group and control group. The patients in the control group were not treated with any of these medicines; instead they were given a dummy medicine, called placebo, containing only sugar and starch. The following information is known about the patients in the treatment group.
- A total of 250 patients were treated with type A medicine and a total of 210 patients were treated with type C medicine.
- 25 patients were treated with type A medicine only. 20 patients were treated with type C medicine only. 10 patients were treated with type D medicine only.
- 35 patients were treated with type A and type D medicines only. 20 patients were treated with type A and type B medicines only. 30 patients were treated with type A and type C medicines only. 20 patients were treated with type C and type D medicines only.
- 100 patients were treated with exactly three types of medicines.
- 40 patients were treated with medicines of types A, B and C, but not with medicines of type D. 20 patients were treated with medicines of types A, C and D, but not with medicines of type В.
- 50 patients were given all the four types of medicines. 75 patients were treated with exactly one type of medicine.
Question 3
How many patients were treated with medicine types B and D only?
Type-in-the-answer (TITA) question: no options are given; enter the value.
Show answer and solution
Answer:
150
Solution
Concept: Global Cohort Balance, Dual Overlap Residual & Partition Accounting
Master State Table
| Medicine Regimen | Patients | Invariant Status & Basis |
|---|---|---|
| A only | 25 | Explicit in Clue (b) |
| B only | 20 | Residual: |
| C only | 20 | Explicit in Clue (b) |
| D only | 10 | Explicit in Clue (b) |
| AB only | 20 | Explicit in Clue (c) |
| AC only | 30 | Explicit in Clue (c) |
| AD only | 35 | Explicit in Clue (c) |
| BC only | 20 | Total C residual: |
| BD only | 150 | Treatment pool residual: |
| CD only | 20 | Explicit in Clue (c) |
| ABC only | 40 | Explicit in Clue (e) |
| ABD only | 30 | Total A residual: |
| ACD only | 20 | Explicit in Clue (e) |
| BCD only | 10 | Triple overlap residual: |
| ABCD (All 4) | 50 | Explicit in Clue (f) |
| Cohort Split | Treatment: 500, Control: 500 | Random half-split () |
| Medicine Totals | A: 250, B: 340, C: 210, D: 325 | Set sums across all 8 constituent subsets |
Question Deduction
• Target Region Specification:
• The question asks for patients treated with medicine types B and D only.
• In set notation, this corresponds strictly to the disjoint pairwise intersection (denoted only).
• Global Treatment Group Accounting:
• The 1,000 disease patients were split equally into Control (500) and Treatment (500) groups.
• Because control patients received placebo only, the union of all 15 active medicine subsets equals 500:
$$n(A \cup B \cup C \cup D) = 500$$
• Summing All Non- Disjoint Subsets:
• Single medicine: Clue (f) fixes single-medicine patients at 75.
• Triple medicine: Clue (d) fixes three-medicine patients at 100.
• All four medicines: Clue (f) gives .
• Pairwise overlaps excluding :
• Clue (c) gives $AB = 20$, $AC = 30$, $AD = 35$, $CD = 20$.
• From Total C (210), $BC = 210 - 190 = 20$.
• Sum of these five pairwise subsets: $20 + 30 + 35 + 20 + 20 = 125$.
• Solving for via Treatment Pool Conservation:
• Sum of all 14 other disjoint subsets in the treatment group:
$$\text{Known Subtotal} = 75 + 125 + 100 + 50 = 350$$
• Since the treatment group comprises exactly 500 patients:
$$n(BD) = 500 - 350 = 150$$
• Thus, exactly 150 patients were treated with medicine types B and D only.
• Numerical Answer:
• 150.
Topper Take
• Macro Residual Shortcut: The treatment cohort has 500 patients. Adding single (75), triple (100), quad (50), and the other 5 pairs (125) gives 350. The sole remaining unknown region takes .
Other questions in this set
- Q1. How many patients were treated with medicine type B?
- Q2. The number of patients who were treated with medicine types B, C and D, but not type A was:
- Q4. The number of patients who were treated with medicine type D was:?
Venn Diagrams questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q9
- CAT 2019 Slot 2 DILR Q9
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc