CAT 2019 Slot 2 DILR Q27
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2019_SLOT2_DILR_Q27
Data set · questions 25–28
The first year students in a business school are split into six sections. In the Business Statistics course was taught in these six sections by Annie, Beti, Chetan, Dave, Esha, and Fakir. All six sections had a common midterm (MT) and a common endterm (ET) worth marks each. ET contained more questions than MT. Questions for MT and ET were prepared collectively by the six faculty members. Considering MT and ET together, each faculty member prepared the same number of questions.
Each of MT and ET had at least four questions that were worth marks, at least three questions that were worth marks, and at least two questions that were worth marks. In both MT and ET, all the -mark questions preceded the -mark questions, and all the - mark questions followed the -mark questions.
The following additional facts are known.
i. Annie prepared the fifth question for both MT and ET. For MT, this question carried marks.
ii. Annie prepared one question for MT. Every other faculty member prepared more than one questions for MT.
iii. All questions prepared by a faculty member appeared consecutively in MT as well as ET.
iv. Chetan prepared the third question in both MT and ET; and Esha prepared the eighth question in both.
v. Fakir prepared the first question of MT and the last one in ET. Dave prepared the last question of MT and the first one in ET.
Question 27
Who prepared 15-mark questions for MT and ET?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
Only Dave, Esha and Fakir
Solution
Concept: Positional Interval Mapping, Boundary Tracking & Complement Elimination
Master State Table
| Question No. | Midterm (MT) Marks | Midterm (MT) Faculty | Endterm (ET) Marks | Endterm (ET) Faculty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question 1 | 5 | Fakir | 5 | Dave |
| Question 2 | 5 | Fakir | 5 | Dave |
| Question 3 | 5 | Chetan | 5 | Chetan |
| Question 4 | 5 | Chetan | 5 | Chetan |
| Question 5 | 5 | Annie | 5 | Annie |
| Question 6 | 10 | Beti | 5 | Annie |
| Question 7 | 10 | Beti | 5 | Annie |
| Question 8 | 10 | Esha | 5 | Esha |
| Question 9 | 15 | Esha | 10 | Esha |
| Question 10 | 15 | Dave | 10 | Beti |
| Question 11 | 15 | Dave | 10 | Beti |
| Question 12 | — | — | 15 | Fakir |
| Question 13 | — | — | 15 | Fakir |
Question Deduction
• Positional Intervals of 15-Mark Questions:
• In both exams, -mark questions precede -markers, which precede -markers.
• In MT ( questions), -mark questions occupy Questions 9, 10, and 11.
• In ET ( questions), -mark questions occupy Questions 12 and 13.
• Setters of MT 15-Mark Questions (Q9–Q11):
• Clue (v) fixes Dave at Question 11. In MT, each faculty except Annie prepared contiguous questions, so Dave prepared Questions 10 and 11 ( marks each).
• Clue (iv) fixes Esha at Question 8. Because Beti and Esha prepared contiguous questions each, Beti took Questions 6–7 and Esha took Questions 8–9.
• Question 9 carries marks and was prepared by Esha.
• Thus, MT -mark questions were prepared by Esha (Q9) and Dave (Q10, Q11).
• Setters of ET 15-Mark Questions (Q12–Q13):
• Clue (v) fixes Fakir at the final question (Question 13).
• With a quota of questions and in MT, Fakir prepared questions in ET.
• Contiguity places Fakir at Questions 12 and 13 ( marks each).
• Thus, ET -mark questions were prepared by Fakir (Q12, Q13).
• Union of 15-Mark Question Setters:
• Across both exams, the faculty who prepared -mark questions are:
$$\mathcal{S}_{15} = \{\text{Dave (MT Q10, Q11)}, \text{Esha (MT Q9)}, \text{Fakir (ET Q12, Q13)}\} = \{\text{Dave, Esha, Fakir}\}$$
• Annie and Chetan prepared only -mark questions; Beti prepared only -mark questions.
• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:
• Matches Option 3 ("Only Dave, Esha and Fakir").
• Distractors fail: Option 1 includes Beti; Option 2 omits Dave; Option 4 omits Esha.
Topper Take
• Read tail intervals directly: MT ends with 3 fifteen-markers (Q9–Q11) and ET ends with 2 fifteen-markers (Q12–Q13).
• Dave and Fakir anchor the tails, and Esha spills into MT Q9, making {Dave, Esha, Fakir} immediately clear; Beti made only 10-markers, ruling out Option 1.
Other questions in this set
- Q25. The second question in ET was prepared by:
- Q26. How many 5-mark questions were there in MT and ET combined?
- Q28. Which of the following questions did Beti prepare in ET?
Arrangements questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc