CAT 2018 Slot 2 VARC Q16
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Business
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2018_SLOT2_VARC_Q16
Passage · questions 16–20
More and more companies, government agencies, educational institutions and philanthropic organisations are today in the grip of a new phenomenon: 'metric fixation'. The key components of metric fixation are the belief that it is possible and desirable to replace professional judgment (acquired through personal experience and talent) with numerical indicators of comparative performance based upon standardised data (metrics); and that the best way to motivate people within these organisations is by attaching rewards and penalties to their measured performance.
The rewards can be monetary, in the form of pay for performance, say, or reputational, in the form of college rankings, hospital ratings, surgical report cards and so on. But the most dramatic negative effect of metric fixation is its propensity to incentivise gaming: that is, encouraging professionals to maximise the metrics in ways that are at odds with the larger purpose of the organisation. If the rate of major crimes in a district becomes the metric according to which police officers are promoted, then some officers will respond by simply not recording crimes or downgrading them from major offences to misdemeanours. Or take the case of surgeons. When the metrics of success and failure are made public affecting their reputation and income some surgeons will improve their metric scores by refusing to operate on patients with more complex problems, whose surgical outcomes are more likely to be negative. Who suffers? The patients who don't get operated upon.
When reward is tied to measured performance, metric fixation invites just this sort of gaming. But metric fixation also leads to a variety of more subtle unintended negative consequences. These include goal displacement, which comes in many varieties: when performance is judged by a few measures, and the stakes are high (keeping one's job, getting a pay rise or raising the stock price at the time that stock are vested), people focus on satisfying those measures often at the expense of other, more important organisational goals that are not measured. The best-known example is 'teaching to the test', a widespread phenomenon that has distorted primary and secondary education in the United States since the adoption of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001. Short-termism is another negative. Measured performance encourages what the US sociologist Robert K Merton in called 'the imperious immediacy of interests where the actor's paramount concern with the foreseen immediate consequences excludes consideration of further or other consequences'. In short, advancing short-term goals at the expense of long-range considerations. This problem is endemic to publicly traded corporations that sacrifice long-term research and development, and the development of their staff, to the perceived imperatives of the quarterly report. To the debit side of the ledger must also be added the transactional costs of metrics: the expenditure of employee time by those tasked with compiling and processing the metrics in the first place - not to mention the time required to actually read them.
Question 16
Of the following, which would have added the least depth to the author's argument?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (B)
More real-life illustrations of the consequences of employees and professionals gaming metrics-based performance measurement systems.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Evaluation of Argument / Reasoning Weakness
-
Passage Reference:
"If the rate of major crimes in a district becomes the metric according to which police officers are promoted, then some officers will respond by simply not recording crimes or downgrading them from major offences to misdemeanours. Or take the case of surgeons. When the metrics of success and failure are made public affecting their reputation and income some surgeons will improve their metric scores by refusing to operate on patients with more complex problems... When reward is tied to measured performance, metric fixation invites just this sort of gaming."
Logical Deduction
The question asks which potential addition would add the least depth to the author's argument. In academic and rhetorical evaluation, adding "depth" requires introducing new conceptual dimensions, theoretical frameworks, comparative paradigms, or causal explanations. The author has already provided detailed, concrete case studies demonstrating how professionals 'game' performance metrics (police officers misclassifying offenses and surgeons cherry-picking low-risk patients). Providing additional anecdotal illustrations of the exact same phenomenon would merely offer redundant empirical confirmation of an already well-substantiated premise, adding minimal intellectual depth to the core thesis.
Conversely, exploring why metrics fixation remains popular despite its flaws (Option 3), evaluating a comparative case study between metrics and non-metrics evaluation (Option 1), or assessing the trade-offs of professional judgment (Option 4) would broaden the analytical scope and substantially deepen the argument.
Correct Answer: Option 2
- Option 2 would add the least depth because the author has already established and illustrated the gaming phenomenon with concrete examples; additional illustrations would be repetitive rather than conceptually expansive.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Factual Distortion / Desirable Addition): A comparative case study evaluating metrics-based versus non-metrics-based systems would provide substantial empirical depth by testing the author's hypotheses against an alternative model.
-
Option 3 (Factual Distortion / Desirable Addition): Analyzing why metric fixation has proliferated across institutions would address a crucial causal gap in the text, significantly deepening the argument.
-
Option 4 (Factual Distortion / Desirable Addition): Assessing the merits and limitations of professional judgment would provide a nuanced, balanced evaluation of the alternative paradigm advocated by the author.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The passage critiques the pervasive institutional phenomenon of 'metric fixation'—the replacement of professional judgment with standardized numerical indicators tied to reward-and-punishment systems—demonstrating how it perversely incentivizes gaming, goal displacement, short-termism, and onerous administrative overhead at the expense of fundamental organizational purposes.
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Defines 'metric fixation' as the institutional belief that qualitative professional judgment should be replaced by comparative quantitative metrics, with employee motivation steered via reward and penalty mechanisms.
-
Paragraph 2: Illustrates the primary negative pathology of metric fixation—the incentivization of 'gaming'—through concrete case studies of police officers downgrading crimes and surgeons turning away high-risk patients to preserve their statistical ratings.
-
Paragraph 3: Details the subtle systemic dysfunctions generated by metrics: goal displacement (e.g., 'teaching to the test' under No Child Left Behind), institutional short-termism sacrificing research and staff development for quarterly reports, and substantial administrative transaction costs.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Analytical, Critical, and Discursive.
-
Author's Perspective: Skeptical of uncritical quantification; argues that mechanistic reliance on performance metrics systematically distorts organizational priorities and undermines professional integrity.
Other questions in this set
- Q17. Which of the following is NOT a consequence of the 'metric fixation' phenomenon mentioned in the passage?
- Q18. All of the following can be a possible feature of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, EXCEPT:
- Q19. What is the main idea that the author is trying to highlight in the passage?
- Q20. What main point does the author want to convey through the examples of the police officer and the surgeon?
Business questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q7
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q9
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 VARC Q10
- CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q8
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc