CAT 2018 Slot 2 VARC Q12
- Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
- Reading Comprehension › Psychology
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2018_SLOT2_VARC_Q12
Passage · questions 11–15
The complexity of modern problems often precludes any one person from fully understanding them. Factors contributing to rising obesity levels, for example, include transportation systems and infrastructure, media, convenience foods, changing social norms, human biology and psychological factors. The multidimensional or layered character of complex problems also undermines the principle of meritocracy: the idea that the 'best person' should be hired. There is no best person. When putting together an oncological research team, a biotech company such as Gilead or Genentech would not construct a multiple choice test and hire the top scorers, or hire people whose resumes score highest according to some performance criteria. Instead, they would seek diversity.
They would build a team of people who bring diverse knowledge bases, tools and analytic skills. Believers in a meritocracy might grant that teams ought to be diverse but then argue that meritocratic principles should apply within each category. Thus the team should consist of the 'best' mathematicians, the 'best' oncologists, and the 'best' biostatisticians from within the pool. That position suffers from a similar flaw. Even with a knowledge domain, no test or criteria applied to individuals will produce the best team. Each of these domains possesses such depth and breadth, that no test can exist. Consider the field of neuroscience. Upwards of 50,000 papers were published last year covering various techniques, domains of enquiry and levels of analysis, ranging from molecules and synapses up through networks of neurons. Given that complexity, any attempt to rank a collection of neuroscientists from best to worst, as if they were competitors in the -metre butterfly, must fail. What could be true is that given a specific task and the composition of a particular team, one scientist would be more likely to contribute than another. Optimal hiring depends on context. Optimal teams will be diverse.
Evidence for this claim can be seen in the way that papers and patents that combine diverse ideas tend to rank as high-impact. It can also be found in the structure of the socalled random decision forest, a state-of-the-art machine-learning algorithm. Random forests consist of ensembles of decision trees. If classifying pictures, each tree makes a vote: is that a picture of a fox or a dog? A weighted majority rules. Random forests can serve many ends. They can identify bank fraud and diseases, recommend ceiling fans and predict online dating behaviour. When building a forest, you do not select the best trees as they tend to make similar classifications. You want diversity. Programmers achieve that diversity by training each tree on different data, a technique known as bagging. They also boost the forest 'cognitively' by training trees on the hardest cases those that the current forest gets wrong. This ensures even more diversity and accurate forests.
Yet the fallacy of meritocracy persists. Corporations, non-profits, governments, universities and even preschools test, score and hire the 'best'. This all but guarantees not creating the best team. Ranking people by common criteria produces homogeneity. That's not likely to lead to breakthroughs.
Question 12
Which of the following conditions, if true, would invalidate the passage's main argument?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
If top-scorers possessed multidisciplinary knowledge that enabled them to look at a problem from several perspectives.
Solution
🎯 Question Analysis & Solution
-
Question Type: Critical Reasoning (Weaken / Invalidate)
-
Passage Reference:
"The multidimensional or layered character of complex problems also undermines the principle of meritocracy: the idea that the 'best person' should be hired. There is no best person... When building a forest, you do not select the best trees as they tend to make similar classifications. You want diversity... Yet the fallacy of meritocracy persists. Corporations, non-profits, governments, universities and even preschools test, score and hire the 'best'. This all but guarantees not creating the best team. Ranking people by common criteria produces homogeneity. That's not likely to lead to breakthroughs."
Logical Deduction
The foundational premise of the author's critique is that meritocratic hiring based on standardized testing produces intellectual homogeneity, which fails because complex problems demand multidisciplinary perspectives. The author argues that selecting "top scorers" necessarily precludes cognitive diversity. However, if top-scorers on tests inherently possessed multidisciplinary knowledge allowing them to examine problems from diverse perspectives, selecting top scorers would simultaneously deliver cognitive and analytical diversity. This would dismantle the author's dichotomy between hiring top scorers and assembling a diverse, effective team, thereby invalidating the passage's core argument.
Correct Answer: Option 4
- If high-scoring individuals naturally possess multidisciplinary perspectives, hiring top scorers would yield cognitive diversity rather than homogeneity, directly collapsing the author's central critique of meritocratic selection.
Option Elimination
-
Option 1 (Out of Scope / Incomplete Fact): Internal team friction or prolonged deliberation does not negate the author's argument that diverse teams are uniquely capable of solving complex problems and achieving breakthroughs.
-
Option 2 (Factual Distortion): The author asserts in Paragraph 2 that "no test can exist" because knowledge domains are fundamentally multidimensional; increasing test rigor or length does not resolve this structural limitation.
-
Option 3 (Out of Scope): The random decision forest is merely an explanatory computational analogy supporting the thesis; the emergence of an alternative algorithm would not invalidate the author's core claims about human collaborative teams.
Detailed explanation
📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure
Central Theme
The multifaceted nature of complex modern challenges renders traditional individual meritocracy obsolete; solving complex systemic problems requires building diverse, context-dependent teams rather than ranking and selecting homogeneous "top scorers."
Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary
-
Paragraph 1: Explains that complex modern problems (e.g., obesity) are layered across disciplines, invalidating the meritocratic assumption of a single "best person" and prompting forward-looking organizations to seek cross-disciplinary diversity over top test scores.
-
Paragraph 2: Refutes the meritocratic counter-argument that one should pick the "best" within each category; demonstrates via neuroscience that knowledge domains possess such immense depth and breadth that standardized individual rankings are meaningless, making context and diversity paramount.
-
Paragraph 3: Introduces empirical and computational evidence, noting that multidisciplinary research has higher impact, and machine learning random forests succeed by aggregating diverse, bagged trees and boosting on difficult edge cases rather than selecting identical "best" trees.
-
Paragraph 4: Critiques the enduring institutional dogma of meritocracy, arguing that sorting individuals by uniform test criteria produces intellectual homogeneity that actively impedes genuine breakthroughs.
Tone and Author's Perspective
-
Tone: Critical, Analytical, and Argumentative (dismantling the standard paradigm of meritocracy using domain-specific examples and computational metaphors).
-
Author's Perspective: Strongly opposes standardized, linear individual rankings in high-complexity problem solving; advocates for holistic cognitive, analytical, and cross-disciplinary diversity tailored to specific collaborative contexts.
Other questions in this set
- Q11. Which of the following best describes the purpose of the example of neuroscienc
- Q13. Which of the following conditions would weaken the efficacy of a random decision forest?
- Q14. The author critiques meritocracy for all the following reasons EXCEPT that:
- Q15. On the basis of the passage, which of the following teams is likely to be most effective in solving the problem of…
Psychology questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q9
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q10
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q11
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 VARC Q12
- CAT 2021 Slot 1 VARC Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc