CAT 2018 Slot 2 VARC Q7

  • Verbal Ability and Reading Comprehension
  • Reading Comprehension › Politics
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT2_VARC_Q07

Passage · questions 6–10

Will a day come when India's poor can access government services as easily as drawing cash from an ATM? No country in the world has made accessing education or health or policing or dispute resolution as easy as an ATM, because the nature of these activities requires individuals to use their discretion in a positive way. Technology can certainly facilitate this in a variety of ways if it is seen as one part of an overall approach, but the evidence so far in education, for instance, is that just adding computers alone doesn't make education any better.

The dangerous illusion of technology is that it can create stronger, top down accountability of service providers in implementation intensive services within existing public sector organisations. One notion is that electronic management information systems (EMIS) keep better track of inputs and those aspects of personnel that are 'EMIS visible' can lead to better services. A recent study examined attempts to increase attendance of Auxiliary Nurse Midwife (ANMs) at clinics in Rajasthan, which involved high-tech time clocks to monitor attendance. The study's title says it all: Band-Aids on a Corpse. E-governance can be just as bad as any other governance when the real issue is people and their motivation.

For services to improve, the people providing the services have to want to do a better job with the skills they have. A study of medical care in Delhi found that even though providers, in the public sector had much better skills than private sector providers their provision of care in actual practice was much worse.

In implementation intensive services the key to success is face-to-face interactions between a teacher, a nurse, a policeman, an extension agent and a citizen. This relationship is about power. Amartya Sen's report on education in West Bengal had a supremely telling anecdote in which the villagers forced the teacher to attend school, but then, when the parents went off to work, the teacher did not teach, but forced the children to massage his feet. As long as the system empowers providers over citizens, technology is irrelevant.

The answer to successfully providing basic services is to create systems that provide both autonomy and accountability. In basic education for instance, the answer to poor teaching is not controlling teachers more. The key is to hire teachers who want to teach and let them teach, expressing their professionalism and vocation as a teacher through autonomy in the classroom. This autonomy has to be matched with accountability for results-not just narrowly measured through test scores, but broadly for the quality of the education they provide.

A recent study in Uttar Pradesh showed that if, somehow, all civil service teachers could be replaced with contract teachers, the state could save a billion dollars a year in revenue and double student learning. Just the additional autonomy and accountability of contracts through local groups-even without complementary system changes in information and empowerment-led to that much improvement. The first step to being part of the solution is to create performance information accessible to those outside of the government.

Question 7

Which of the following, IF TRUE, would undermine the passage's main argument?

  1. A

    If it were proven that service providers in the private sector have better skills than those in the public sector.

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    If absolute instead of moderate technological surveillance is exercised over the performance of service providers.

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Empowerment of service providers leads to increased complacency and rigged performance results.

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    If it were proven that increase in autonomy of service providers leads to an exponential increase in their work ethic and sense of responsibility.

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

Empowerment of service providers leads to increased complacency and rigged performance results.

Solution

🎯 Question Analysis & Solution

  • Question Type: Critical Reasoning (Weaken / Undermine)

  • Passage Reference:

"The answer to successfully providing basic services is to create systems that provide both autonomy and accountability. In basic education for instance, the answer to poor teaching is not controlling teachers more. The key is to hire teachers who want to teach and let them teach, expressing their professionalism and vocation as a teacher through autonomy in the classroom."

Logical Deduction

The author's central argument is that improving frontline implementation-intensive services requires abandoning rigid top-down control in favor of empowering providers with professional autonomy ("let them teach, expressing their professionalism and vocation... through autonomy in the classroom") matched with outcome-based accountability. To undermine this thesis, a premise must prove that granting autonomy and empowering service providers leads to failure rather than performance gains. If empowering service providers breeds complacency and incentivizes the manipulation of performance outcomes, the author's proposed mechanism of autonomy-driven reform is fundamentally discredited.

Correct Answer: Option 3

  • If provider empowerment generates complacency and fraudulent performance reporting, the author's foundational claim that granting autonomy enhances professional dedication and service quality is invalidated.

Option Elimination

  • Option 1 (Out of Scope): The passage cites the Delhi medical study in Paragraph 3 solely to show that public providers possessed superior skills yet delivered inferior care; proving private providers had superior skills does not refute the central thesis regarding motivation, autonomy, and accountability.

  • Option 2 (Out of Scope / Factual Distortion): The author has already argued in Paragraphs 2 and 4 that surveillance cannot address discretionary effort; intensifying technological monitoring does not weaken the claim that autonomy and motivation are what truly matter.

  • Option 4 (Opposite Meaning / Scope Reversal): If granting autonomy exponentially increases work ethic and responsibility, it validates and reinforces the author's argument rather than undermining it.

Detailed explanation

📖 Passage Breakdown & Structure

Central Theme

The delivery of implementation-intensive public services cannot be resolved through top-down technological surveillance; genuine improvement requires reforming institutional power dynamics, recruiting intrinsically motivated personnel, and instituting an operational balance of professional autonomy and decentralized, outcome-based accountability.

Paragraph-by-Paragraph Summary

  • Paragraph 1: The author contrasts transactional services (like ATMs) with implementation-intensive public services (education, healthcare, policing), arguing that the latter inherently demand positive individual discretion, which technology alone cannot supply.

  • Paragraph 2: Critiques the technocratic illusion of top-down accountability via electronic management information systems (EMIS), citing the Rajasthan ANM study ("Band-Aids on a Corpse") to illustrate that digital tools fail when the fundamental issue is worker motivation.

  • Paragraph 3: Demonstrates via a Delhi healthcare study that technical competence does not guarantee service quality; public sector providers possessed superior medical skills compared to private peers but delivered markedly inferior care due to a lack of motivation.

  • Paragraph 4: Identifies discretionary face-to-face human interactions and asymmetric power dynamics as central to service delivery; cites Amartya Sen’s West Bengal anecdote to prove that surveillance is futile as long as providers remain unaccountably empowered over citizens.

  • Paragraph 5: Outlines the core institutional remedy: granting practitioners operational autonomy in their work while establishing robust accountability for broad educational and qualitative outcomes rather than rigid procedural compliance.

  • Paragraph 6: Presents empirical evidence from Uttar Pradesh where contract teachers managed by local communities doubled learning outcomes at lower cost, concluding that making performance metrics accessible to external stakeholders is an essential catalyst for reform.

Tone and Author's Perspective

  • Tone: Analytical, Critical, and Prescriptive (evaluating institutional and technocratic failures while arguing systematically for policy and structural alternatives).

  • Author's Perspective: Skeptical of technocentric, top-down bureaucratic control; advocates for human-centric public administration grounded in practitioner autonomy, intrinsic motivation, and decentralized accountability to citizens.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q6. The main purpose of the passage is to:
  2. Q8. According to the author, service delivery in Indian education can be improved in all of the following ways EXCEPT…
  3. Q9. The author questions the use of monitoring systems in services that involve face-to face interaction between service…
  4. Q10. In the context of the passage, we can infer that the title "Band Aids on a Corpse" (in paragraph 2) suggests that:

Politics questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q5
    The word “instantiation” is used in the first paragraph. Which one of the following pairs of terms would be…
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q6
    Which one of the following sets of terms is closest to mapping the key arguments of the passage?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q7
    What does the author wish to communicate by referring to the Hoover and Aswan dams in the first paragraph?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 3 VARC Q8
    All of the following statements may be considered valid inferences from the passage EXCEPT that:
  5. CAT 2024 Slot 3 VARC Q16
    The author mentions all of the following reasons to dismiss concerns about contaminating Mars EXCEPT:

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc