CAT 2018 Slot 1 DILR Q30

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
  • Hard
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT1_DILR_Q30

Data set · questions 29–32

A company administers a written test comprising of three sections of 20 marks each - Data Interpretation (DI), Written English (WE) and General Awareness (GA), for recruitment. A composite score for a candidate (out of 80) is calculated by doubling her marks in DI and adding it to the sum of her marks in the other two sections. Candidates who score less than 70% marks in two or more sections are disqualified. From among the rest, the four with the highest composite scores are recruited. If four or less candidates qualify, all who qualify are recruited.

Ten candidates appeared for the written test. Their marks in the test are given in the table below. Some marks in the table are missing, but the following facts are known:

  1. No two candidates had the same composite score.
  2. Ajay was the unique highest scorer in WE.
  3. Among the four recruited, Geeta had the lowest composite score.
  4. Indu was recruited.
  5. Danish, Harini, and Indu had scored the same marks the in GA.
  6. Indu and Jatin both scored 100% in exactly one section and Jatin’s composite score was 10 more than Indu’s.
Diagram

Question 30

Which of the following statements MUST be FALSE?

  1. A

    Bala scored same as Jatin in DI

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    Harini’s composite score was less than that of Falak

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    Bala’s composite score was less than that of Ester

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    Chetna scored more than Bala in DI

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

Bala scored same as Jatin in DI

Solution

Concept: Proof by Contradiction, Score Collision Constraints & Feasibility Verification

Master State Table

CandidateDI (20)WE (20)GA (20)CompositeStatusRecruited?
Ajay8201652QualifiedNo
BaladBd_B9112dB+202 d_B + 20DisqualifiedNo
Chetna1941254DisqualifiedNo
Danish8152051QualifiedNo
Ester12181658QualifiedYes
Falak1571047DisqualifiedNo
Geeta1419653QualifiedYes
Harini5wHw_H2030+wH30 + w_HConditionalNo
Indu1682060QualifiedYes
Jatin20161470QualifiedYes

Question Deduction

• Baseline Invariants & Composite Formula:

• Jatin's DI score is uniquely fixed as DIJatin=20\text{DI}_{\text{Jatin}} = 20, and Indu's composite score is CIndu=60C_{\text{Indu}} = 60.

• Bala's known scores are WE=9\text{WE} = 9 and GA=11\text{GA} = 11, giving composite score CBala=2dB+9+11=2dB+20C_{\text{Bala}} = 2 d_B + 9 + 11 = 2 d_B + 20.

• Fact 1 strictly mandates: "No two candidates had the same composite score."

• Evaluation of Option 1 (Contradiction Check):

• If Bala scored the same as Jatin in DI, then dB=DIJatin=20d_B = \text{DI}_{\text{Jatin}} = 20.

• Substituting dB=20d_B = 20 into Bala's composite score gives:

• $C_{\text{Bala}} = 2(20) + 20 = 60$.

• This produces an exact collision: CBala=CIndu=60C_{\text{Bala}} = C_{\text{Indu}} = 60.

• Because no two candidates can have equal composite scores, dB=20d_B = 20 is strictly impossible.

• Thus, Option 1 is strictly impossible (MUST BE FALSE).

• Feasibility Analysis of Remaining Options:

• Option 2: Harini's composite score is 30+wH30 + w_H. Setting wH≤16w_H \le 16 (e.g., wH=14  ⟹  CHarini=44<47=CFalakw_H = 14 \implies C_{\text{Harini}} = 44 < 47 = C_{\text{Falak}}) satisfies the inequality without collisions. Can be true.

• Option 3: Ester's composite score is 5858. Setting dB≤18d_B \le 18 (e.g., dB=10  ⟹  CBala=40<58d_B = 10 \implies C_{\text{Bala}} = 40 < 58) satisfies the inequality. Can be true.

• Option 4: Chetna scored 1919 in DI. Any dB≤18d_B \le 18 satisfies DIChetna>DIBala\text{DI}_{\text{Chetna}} > \text{DI}_{\text{Bala}}. Can be true.

• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:

• Option 1 produces an unavoidable composite score collision (6060), proving it must be false.

• Matches Option 1 ("Bala scored same as Jatin in DI").

Topper Take

• Spotting the collision: Jatin's DI=20\text{DI} = 20 immediately yields CBala=2(20)+20=60C_{\text{Bala}} = 2(20) + 20 = 60, directly colliding with Indu's fixed composite score of 6060.

• Testing Option 1 first exposes the impossibility in under 20 seconds, eliminating the need to evaluate options 2, 3, or 4.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q29. Which of the following statements MUST be true? 1. Jatin's composite score was more than that of Danish. 2. Indu…
  2. Q31. If all the candidates except Ajay and Danish had different marks in DI, and Bala's composite score was less than…
  3. Q32. If all the candidates scored different marks in WE then what is the maximum marks that Harini could have scored in WE?

Arrangements questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
    What is the number of the chair initially occupied by Bashir?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
    Who sits on the chair numbered 4 at the end of Turn 3?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
    Which of the chairs are occupied at the end of Turn 6?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
    Which of the following BEST describes the friends sitting on chairs adjacent to the one occupied by Bashir…
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
    In which of the following years were Ananya and Bhaskar Gurubhai?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc