CAT 2018 Slot 1 DILR Q28
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Data Interpretation › Venn Diagrams
- Medium
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2018_SLOT1_DILR_Q28
Data set · questions 25–28
1600 satellites were sent up by a country for several purposes. The purposes are classified as broadcasting (B), communication (C), surveillance (S), and others (O). A satellite can serve multiple purposes; however a satellite serving either B, or C, or S does not serve O. The following facts are known about the satellites:
- The numbers of satellites serving B, C, and S (though may be not exclusively) are in the ratio 2:1:1.
- The number of satellites serving all three of B, C, and S is 100.
- The number of satellites exclusively serving C is the same as the number of satellites exclusively serving S. This number is 30% of the number of satellites exclusively serving B.
- The number of satellites serving O is the same as the number of satellites serving both C and S but not B.
Question 28
If the number of satellites serving at least two among B, C, and S is 1200, which of the following MUST be FALSE?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (C)
The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined
Solution
Concept: Degenerate State Collapse, Exact System Determination & Statement Falsification
Master State Table
| Component | Expression () | Feasible Range |
|---|---|---|
| Only Broadcasting () | ||
| Only Communication () | ||
| Only Surveillance () | ||
| Both B & C Only () | ||
| Both B & S Only () | ||
| Both C & S Only () | ||
| All Three () | ||
| Others () | ||
| Total Broadcasting () | ||
| Total Communication () | ||
| Total Surveillance () |
Question Deduction
• Formulation of Multi-Purpose Overlap Condition:
• The premise stipulates that satellites serving at least two among equals 1200.
• In the 3-set Venn diagram, this equals the three pairwise overlaps plus the center:
$$\text{At least two} = [(B \cap C) \setminus S] + [(B \cap S) \setminus C] + [(C \cap S) \setminus B] + [B \cap C \cap S] = x + y + z + 100$$
• Parameter Collapse via Boundary Equation:
• Substituting the baseline invariants :
$$\text{At least two} = 2(550 - 5z) + z + 100 = 1200 - 9z$$
• Equating this expression to the premise value of 1200:
$$1200 - 9z = 1200 \implies 9z = 0 \implies z = 0$$
• The parameter degree of freedom collapses to zero, uniquely fixing every region:
• $z = 0 \implies \vert O \vert = 0$, $x = y = 550$, $b = 250$, $c = s = 75$, center $= 100$.
• Totals: $T_B = 1450$, $T_C = 725$, $T_S = 725$, and $B \cup C \cup S = 1600$.
• Systematic Falsification of Options:
• Option 1: "The number of satellites serving B exclusively is exactly 250." True, as .
• Option 2: "The number of satellites serving B is more than 1000." True, as .
• Option 4: "All 1600 satellites serve B or C or S." True, as .
• Option 3: "The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined." False, as is uniquely fixed at 725.
• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:
• Option 3 is the statement that MUST BE FALSE.
• Matches Option 3 ("The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined").
Topper Take
• Recognizing that has a theoretical ceiling of 1200 at immediately forces .
• Once , the entire system collapses to fixed constants, meaning EVERY quantity is uniquely determined; Option 3 is instantly false on inspection.
Other questions in this set
- Q25. What best can be said about the number of satellites serving C?
- Q26. What is the minimum possible number of satellites serving B exclusively?
- Q27. If at least 100 of the 1600 satellites were serving O, what can be said about the number of satellites serving S?
Venn Diagrams questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q9
- CAT 2020 Slot 1 DILR Q1
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc