CAT 2018 Slot 1 DILR Q28

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Data Interpretation › Venn Diagrams
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT1_DILR_Q28

Data set · questions 25–28

1600 satellites were sent up by a country for several purposes. The purposes are classified as broadcasting (B), communication (C), surveillance (S), and others (O). A satellite can serve multiple purposes; however a satellite serving either B, or C, or S does not serve O. The following facts are known about the satellites:

  1. The numbers of satellites serving B, C, and S (though may be not exclusively) are in the ratio 2:1:1.
  2. The number of satellites serving all three of B, C, and S is 100.
  3. The number of satellites exclusively serving C is the same as the number of satellites exclusively serving S. This number is 30% of the number of satellites exclusively serving B.
  4. The number of satellites serving O is the same as the number of satellites serving both C and S but not B.

Question 28

If the number of satellites serving at least two among B, C, and S is 1200, which of the following MUST be FALSE?

  1. A

    The number of satellites serving B exclusively is exactly 250

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    The number of satellites serving B is more than 1000

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    All 1600 satellites serve B or C or S

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (C)

The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined

Solution

Concept: Degenerate State Collapse, Exact System Determination & Statement Falsification

Master State Table

ComponentExpression (z∈[0,110]z \in [0, 110])Feasible Range
Only Broadcasting (bb)5z+2505z + 250[250,800][250, 800]
Only Communication (cc)1.5z+751.5z + 75[75,240][75, 240]
Only Surveillance (ss)1.5z+751.5z + 75[75,240][75, 240]
Both B & C Only (xx)550−5z550 - 5z[0,550][0, 550]
Both B & S Only (yy)550−5z550 - 5z[0,550][0, 550]
Both C & S Only (zz)zz[0,110][0, 110]
All Three (B∩C∩SB \cap C \cap S)100100100100
Others (OO)zz[0,110][0, 110]
Total Broadcasting (TBT_B)1450−5z1450 - 5z[900,1450][900, 1450]
Total Communication (TCT_C)725−2.5z725 - 2.5z[450,725][450, 725]
Total Surveillance (TST_S)725−2.5z725 - 2.5z[450,725][450, 725]

Question Deduction

• Formulation of Multi-Purpose Overlap Condition:

• The premise stipulates that satellites serving at least two among B,C,SB, C, S equals 1200.

• In the 3-set Venn diagram, this equals the three pairwise overlaps plus the center:

$$\text{At least two} = [(B \cap C) \setminus S] + [(B \cap S) \setminus C] + [(C \cap S) \setminus B] + [B \cap C \cap S] = x + y + z + 100$$

• Parameter Collapse via Boundary Equation:

• Substituting the baseline invariants x=y=550−5zx = y = 550 - 5z:

$$\text{At least two} = 2(550 - 5z) + z + 100 = 1200 - 9z$$

• Equating this expression to the premise value of 1200:

$$1200 - 9z = 1200 \implies 9z = 0 \implies z = 0$$

• The parameter degree of freedom collapses to zero, uniquely fixing every region:

• $z = 0 \implies \vert O \vert = 0$, $x = y = 550$, $b = 250$, $c = s = 75$, center $= 100$.

• Totals: $T_B = 1450$, $T_C = 725$, $T_S = 725$, and $B \cup C \cup S = 1600$.

• Systematic Falsification of Options:

• Option 1: "The number of satellites serving B exclusively is exactly 250." True, as b=250b = 250.

• Option 2: "The number of satellites serving B is more than 1000." True, as TB=1450>1000T_B = 1450 > 1000.

• Option 4: "All 1600 satellites serve B or C or S." True, as ∣O∣=0  ⟹  B∪C∪S=1600\vert O \vert = 0 \implies B \cup C \cup S = 1600.

• Option 3: "The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined." False, as TCT_C is uniquely fixed at 725.

• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:

• Option 3 is the statement that MUST BE FALSE.

• Matches Option 3 ("The number of satellites serving C cannot be uniquely determined").

Topper Take

• Recognizing that At least two=1200−9z\text{At least two} = 1200 - 9z has a theoretical ceiling of 1200 at z=0z = 0 immediately forces z=0z = 0.

• Once z=0z = 0, the entire system collapses to fixed constants, meaning EVERY quantity is uniquely determined; Option 3 is instantly false on inspection.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q25. What best can be said about the number of satellites serving C?
  2. Q26. What is the minimum possible number of satellites serving B exclusively?
  3. Q27. If at least 100 of the 1600 satellites were serving O, what can be said about the number of satellites serving S?

Venn Diagrams questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q6
    How many countries in Asia were visited by at least one of Dheeraj, Samantha and Nitesh?
  2. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q7
    How many countries in Europe were visited only by Nitesh?
  3. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q8
    How many countries in the ROW were visited by both Nitesh and Samantha?
  4. CAT 2024 Slot 1 DILR Q9
    How many countries in Europe were visited by exactly one of Dheeraj, Samantha and Nitesh?
  5. CAT 2020 Slot 1 DILR Q1
    How many patients were treated with medicine type B?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc