CAT 2018 Slot 1 DILR Q24

  • Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
  • Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
  • Medium
  • Multiple choice
  • CAT_2018_SLOT1_DILR_Q24

Data set · questions 21–24

Twenty four people are part of three committees which are to look at research, teaching, and administration respectively. No two committees have any member in common. No two committees are of the same size. Each committee has three types of people: bureaucrats, educationalists, and politicians, with at least one from each of the three types in each committee. The following facts are also known about the committees:

  1. The numbers of bureaucrats in the research and teaching committees are equal, while the number of bureaucrats in the research committee is 75% of the number of bureaucrats in the administration committee.
  2. The number of educationalists in the teaching committee is less than the number of educationalists in the research committee. The number of educationalists in the research committee is the average of the numbers of educationalists in the other two committees.
  3. 60% of the politicians are in the administration committee, and 20% are in the teaching committee.

Question 24

Which of the following CANNOT be determined uniquely based on the given information?

  1. A

    The size of the teaching committee

    Answer A in PrepSoc practice
  2. B

    The size of the research committee

    Answer B in PrepSoc practice
  3. C

    The total number of bureaucrats in the three committees

    Answer C in PrepSoc practice
  4. D

    The total number of educationalists in the three committees

    Answer D in PrepSoc practice

Answer this questionOr tap an option. Opens in practice mode, free, no sign-in.

Show answer and solution

Answer: (A)

The size of the teaching committee

Solution

Concept: System Invariance vs. Degree of Freedom Analysis in Constrained Partitions

Master State Table

CommitteeBureaucrats (BB)Educationalists (EE)Politicians (PP)Total Size
Research (RR)3317
Teaching (TT)31 or 2 (3−d3 - d)15 or 6
Administration (AA)45 or 4 (3+d3 + d)312 or 11
Total109524

Question Deduction

• Parametric System Invariants from Passage Rules:

• Partitioning 24 individuals across three disjoint committees yields:

$10x + 3y + 5z = 24$, where $x, y, z \in \mathbb{Z}^+$.

• Bound analysis:

• $x \ge 2 \implies 10x \ge 20$, leaving $3y + 5z \le 4$, contradicting $3y + 5z \ge 8$. Thus, $x = 1$.

• $x = 1 \implies 3y + 5z = 14$, whose unique positive integer solution is $z = 1, y = 3$.

• Invariant totals are uniquely established:

• Bureaucrats: $B_R = 3, B_T = 3, B_A = 4 \implies B_{\text{total}} = 10$.

• Politicians: $P_R = 1, P_T = 1, P_A = 3 \implies P_{\text{total}} = 5$.

• Educationalists: $E_R = 3 \implies E_{\text{total}} = 3y = 9$.

• Research committee size: $\vert R \vert = 3 + 3 + 1 = 7$.

• Unresolved Degree of Freedom in Committee Sizes:

• While total educationalists is fixed at 9, their distribution between Teaching and Administration depends on d=ER−ET>0d = E_R - E_T > 0.

• Requiring ET≥1  ⟹  3−d≥1  ⟹  d∈{1,2}E_T \ge 1 \implies 3 - d \ge 1 \implies d \in \{1, 2\}:

• Case 1 ($d = 1$): $E_T = 2, E_A = 4 \implies \vert T \vert = 6, \vert A \vert = 11$, and $\vert R \vert = 7$. All sizes distinct ($6 \neq 7 \neq 11$). Valid.

• Case 2 ($d = 2$): $E_T = 1, E_A = 5 \implies \vert T \vert = 5, \vert A \vert = 12$, and $\vert R \vert = 7$. All sizes distinct ($5 \neq 7 \neq 12$). Valid.

• Both cases strictly satisfy all passage constraints, so the teaching committee size can be either 6 or 5.

• Evaluation of Options:

• Option 1: The size of the teaching committee can be 6 or 5, so it cannot be determined uniquely.

• Option 2: The size of the research committee is uniquely fixed at 7.

• Option 3: Total bureaucrats is uniquely 10.

• Option 4: Total educationalists is uniquely 9.

• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:

• The size of the teaching committee varies across valid branches (55 or 66), so it cannot be determined uniquely.

• Matches Option 1.

Topper Take

• The common difference dd in educationalists can be either 11 or 22 without violating any constraint (ET≥1E_T \ge 1 and all committee sizes remain strictly distinct).

• Because dd dictates the educationalist split (3−d3 - d in Teaching vs. 3+d3 + d in Administration), the teaching committee size is non-unique (55 or 66), pinpointing Option 1 immediately.

Other questions in this set

  1. Q21. Based on the given information, which of the following statements MUST be FALSE?
  2. Q22. What is the number of bureaucrats in the administration committee?
  3. Q23. What is the number of educationalists in the research committee?

Arrangements questions from other CAT papers

  1. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
    What is the number of the chair initially occupied by Bashir?
  2. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
    Who sits on the chair numbered 4 at the end of Turn 3?
  3. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
    Which of the chairs are occupied at the end of Turn 6?
  4. CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
    Which of the following BEST describes the friends sitting on chairs adjacent to the one occupied by Bashir…
  5. CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
    In which of the following years were Ananya and Bhaskar Gurubhai?

Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.

Practise in PrepSoc