CAT 2018 Slot 1 DILR Q3
- Data Interpretation and Logical Reasoning
- Logical Reasoning › Arrangements
- Hard
- Multiple choice
- CAT_2018_SLOT1_DILR_Q03
Data set · questions 1–4
Adriana, Bandita, Chitra, and Daisy are four female students, and Amit, Barun, Chetan, and Deb are four male students. Each of them studies in one of three institutes and . Each student majors in one subject among Marketing, Operations, and Finance, and minors in a different one among these three subjects. The following facts are known about the eight students:
-
Three students are from , three are from , and the remaining two students, both female, are from .
-
Both the male students from minor in Finance, while the female student from majors in Operations.
-
Only one male student majors in Operations, while three female students minor in Marketing.
-
One female and two male students major in Finance.
-
Adriana and Deb are from the same institute. Daisy and Amit are from the same institute.
-
Barun is from and majors in Operations. Chetan is from and majors in Finance.
-
Daisy minors in Operations.
Question 3
Which subject does Amit major in?
Show answer and solution
Answer: (D)
Finance
Solution
Concept: Quota Invariants, Pigeonhole Elimination & Multi-Constraint Major Allocation
Master State Table
| Student | Gender | Institute | Major | Minor | Baseline Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adriana | Female | Y | Operations | Marketing | Fixed via Clues 2 & 3 |
| Bandita | Female | Z | Finance / Operations | Marketing | Institute fixed; Minor fixed via Clue 3 |
| Chitra | Female | Z | Operations / Finance | Marketing | Institute fixed; Minor fixed via Clue 3 |
| Daisy | Female | X | Marketing / Finance | Operations | Institute fixed; Minor fixed via Clue 7 |
| Amit | Male | X | Finance | Operations / Marketing | Major fixed via male Finance quota |
| Barun | Male | Y | Operations | Finance | Fixed via Clues 2 & 6 |
| Chetan | Male | X | Finance | Marketing / Operations | Fixed via Clue 6; Minor in {M, O} |
| Deb | Male | Y | Marketing | Finance | Fixed via Clues 2 & 3 |
Question Deduction
• Institute Mapping for Amit:
• Clue 1 fixes capacities () with having only females, so all 4 males attend or .
• Clue 2 fixes as 2 males and 1 female, leaving with 2 males and 1 female.
• Barun is in and Chetan is in (Clue 6).
• From Clue 5, mixed pairs are {Adriana, Deb} and {Daisy, Amit}. Daisy cannot attend because her Operations minor (Clue 7) clashes with Clue 2 (female in majors in Operations).
• Thus Daisy and Amit attend , making Amit and Chetan the two males in .
• Male Quota Constraints & Exhaustive Major Elimination:
• The four male students are Barun, Deb, Chetan, and Amit.
• Clue 4 mandates: "One female and two male students major in Finance."
• Evaluating major subjects for the other three males:
• **Barun**: Majors in Operations (explicitly stated in Clue 6).
• **Deb**: Minors in Finance (Clue 2) and cannot major in Operations (Clue 3 limits male Operations majors to one), forcing Deb to major in Marketing.
• **Chetan**: Majors in Finance (explicitly stated in Clue 6).
• With Chetan occupying the first male Finance slot and Barun and Deb ruled out, Amit takes the second: .
• Option Matching / Numerical Answer:
• Amit majors in Finance.
• Matches Option 4 ("Finance").
• Distractor Analysis: Option 1 belongs to Deb, Option 2 belongs to Barun, and Option 3 is refuted as the quota uniquely forces Finance for Amit.
Topper Take
• Quota tracking solves this instantly: 4 males, 1 Operations major (Barun), 1 Marketing major (Deb), leaving exactly 2 Finance majors (Chetan and Amit).
• Knowing Chetan majors in Finance, Amit is locked into Finance in under 15 seconds by pure elimination.
Other questions in this set
- Q1. Who are the students from the institute Z ?
- Q2. Which subject does Deb minor in?
- Q4. If Chitra majors in Finance, which subject does Bandita major in?
Arrangements questions from other CAT papers
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q5
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q6
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q7
- CAT 2025 Slot 1 DILR Q8
- CAT 2025 Slot 2 DILR Q10
Practise this question with timing, notes and your mistake notebook.
Practise in PrepSoc