Free CAT library

Square Roots of Quadratic & Multi-Term Surds

Master the art of de-nesting radicals and extracting square roots of binomial and trinomial surds: the master identity √(a ± 2√b) = √x ± √y, the three methods for forcing the mandatory coefficient 2, handling fractional radicands, and de-nesting 3-term radical expressions √(a + √b + √c + √d) = √x + √y + √z.

1. The Story & Mental Model: Unpacking the Perfect Square Container

Imagine an engineer inspecting a sealed black box labelled with an internal weight of 14+65 kg14 + 6\sqrt{5}\text{ kg}. To transport it efficiently, the engineer needs to determine whether this strange, nested object is actually a composite parcel created by packing a simple binomial item into a square container:

(Parcel)2=14+65(\text{Parcel})^2 = 14 + 6\sqrt{5}

If we can "un-square" or de-nest the box, we replace a terrifying radical-of-a-radical with a clean, linear combination of elementary square roots: x+y\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y}.

Consider what happens when we square an elementary binomial surd:

(x+y)2=(x)2+(y)2+2xy=(x+y)+2xy(\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y})^2 = (\sqrt{x})^2 + (\sqrt{y})^2 + 2\sqrt{x}\sqrt{y} = (x + y) + 2\sqrt{xy}

Look closely at the resulting expression:

  1. The rational component is the direct sum of the two underlying numbers: x+yx + y.

  2. The irrational component contains the cross-term: 2xy2\sqrt{xy}.

  3. Most importantly, the irrational part carries an immutable algebraic signature: the coefficient 22!

The mental model for de-nesting radicals is algebraic reverse-engineering:

You treat the radical expression a+2ba + 2\sqrt{b} as a chemistry compound. You look at the "cross-product bond" 2b2\sqrt{b} to find two positive numbers xx and yy that simultaneously satisfy:

  • Their product equals the interior radicand: x⋅y=bx \cdot y = b

  • Their sum equals the outer rational number: x+y=ax + y = a

Once you identify the factor pair (x,y)(x, y), the radical sign effortlessly dissolves:

a+2b=x+y\sqrt{a + 2\sqrt{b}} = \sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y}


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Concealed Perfect Square

In CAT and competitive examinations, examiners intentionally obscure the perfect square structure. They never serve a+2ba + 2\sqrt{b} with a neat coefficient of 22 on a silver platter. Instead, they disguise the expression using four classic blueprints:

  1. The Absorbed Multiplier (Excess Outside Factor):

    The examiner writes 28−10328 - 10\sqrt{3}. The coefficient outside the radical is 1010, not 22. You must factor 10=2×510 = 2 \times 5 and push the excess factor 55 back inside the square root (52×3=755^2 \times 3 = 75), revealing the true form: 28−27528 - 2\sqrt{75}.

  2. The Swallowed Multiplier (Factor of 4 Trapped Inside):

    The examiner writes 11+11211 + \sqrt{112}. No coefficient 22 is visible outside. You must factor out 44 from inside the radicand: 112=4×28=228\sqrt{112} = \sqrt{4 \times 28} = 2\sqrt{28}.

  3. The Odd Integer Disguise (No Factor of 2 Anywhere):

    The examiner presents an expression like 3−53 - \sqrt{5}. The radicand 55 has no factor of 44, and the outside coefficient is an odd 11. Students get completely stuck. The master technique: artificially inject 2 by multiplying and dividing the entire interior by 22:

    3−5=6−252=6−252=5−12\sqrt{3 - \sqrt{5}} = \sqrt{\frac{6 - 2\sqrt{5}}{2}} = \frac{\sqrt{6 - 2\sqrt{5}}}{\sqrt{2}} = \frac{\sqrt{5} - 1}{\sqrt{2}}

  4. The Multi-Term Trinomial Radical:

    Expressions featuring three distinct square root cross-terms:

    15+215+221+235\sqrt{15 + 2\sqrt{15} + 2\sqrt{21} + 2\sqrt{35}}

    This is the square of a trinomial: (x+y+z)2(\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} + \sqrt{z})^2.


3. Core Concepts, Formulae & Derivations

A. Master Identity for Binomial Quadratic Surds

For positive rational numbers a,ba, b where b\sqrt{b} is irrational:

a±2b=x±y(with x>y>0)\sqrt{a \pm 2\sqrt{b}} = \sqrt{x} \pm \sqrt{y} \quad (\text{with } x > y > 0)

if and only if there exist rational numbers x,yx, y such that:

x+y=aandxy=bx + y = a \quad \text{and} \quad xy = b

Rigorous Derivation:

Let a±2b=x±y\sqrt{a \pm 2\sqrt{b}} = \sqrt{x} \pm \sqrt{y}.

Squaring both sides:

a±2b=(x±y)2=(x+y)±2xya \pm 2\sqrt{b} = (\sqrt{x} \pm \sqrt{y})^2 = (x + y) \pm 2\sqrt{xy}

Equating the rational parts and irrational parts:

x+y=ax + y = a

2xy=2b  ⟹  xy=b2\sqrt{xy} = 2\sqrt{b} \implies xy = b

From elementary quadratic theory, xx and yy are the roots of the quadratic equation:

t2−(x+y)t+xy=0  ⟹  t2−at+b=0t^2 - (x+y)t + xy = 0 \implies t^2 - at + b = 0

Using the quadratic formula:

t=a±a2−4b2t = \frac{a \pm \sqrt{a^2 - 4b}}{2}

Thus:

x=a+a2−4b2,y=a−a2−4b2x = \frac{a + \sqrt{a^2 - 4b}}{2}, \quad y = \frac{a - \sqrt{a^2 - 4b}}{2}

For x\sqrt{x} and y\sqrt{y} to be clean surds (or rationals), the discriminant a2−4ba^2 - 4b must be a perfect square in Q\mathbb{Q}.

B. The Three Canonical Cases for Forcing the Coefficient 2

Case 1: Excess Even Multiplier Outside (2km2k\sqrt{m})

When the coefficient is an even number greater than 22:

a±2km=a±2k2⋅ma \pm 2k\sqrt{m} = a \pm 2\sqrt{k^2 \cdot m}

Push kk inside by squaring it. Now match factors of b=k2mb = k^2 m that sum to aa.

Case 2: Pure Radical with Internal Factor of 4 ( 4k  \,\sqrt{4k}\,\,)

When the radical has no external coefficient but the radicand is divisible by 44:

a±N=a±4×k=a±2ka \pm \sqrt{N} = a \pm \sqrt{4 \times k} = a \pm 2\sqrt{k}

Extract 2=42 = \sqrt{4} outside. Now match factors of kk that sum to aa.

Case 3: Odd Radicand with No Factor of 2

When the radical has no coefficient of 22 and its radicand is not divisible by 44:

a±b=2(a±b)2=2a±2b2\sqrt{a \pm \sqrt{b}} = \sqrt{\frac{2(a \pm \sqrt{b})}{2}} = \frac{\sqrt{2a \pm 2\sqrt{b}}}{\sqrt{2}}

Now match factors of bb that sum to 2a2a. De-nest the numerator and keep 2\sqrt{2} in the denominator.

C. Multi-Term Radicals (Trinomial Square Roots)

To de-nest expressions with three cross-terms:

S=a+2p+2q+2rS = \sqrt{a + 2\sqrt{p} + 2\sqrt{q} + 2\sqrt{r}}

Recall the algebraic identity:

(x+y+z)2=(x+y+z)+2xy+2yz+2zx(\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} + \sqrt{z})^2 = (x + y + z) + 2\sqrt{xy} + 2\sqrt{yz} + 2\sqrt{zx}

Comparing terms:

x+y+z=ax + y + z = a

xy=p,yz=q,zx=rxy = p, \quad yz = q, \quad zx = r

The Cyclic Product Extraction Algorithm:

Multiply all three cross-product equations together:

(xy)(yz)(zx)=p⋅q⋅r  ⟹  (xyz)2=pqr  ⟹  xyz=pqr(xy)(yz)(zx) = p \cdot q \cdot r \implies (xyz)^2 = pqr \implies xyz = \sqrt{pqr}

Now divide by each individual product to isolate the variables:

x=xyzyz=pqrqx = \frac{xyz}{yz} = \frac{\sqrt{pqr}}{q}

y=xyzzx=pqrry = \frac{xyz}{zx} = \frac{\sqrt{pqr}}{r}

z=xyzxy=pqrpz = \frac{xyz}{xy} = \frac{\sqrt{pqr}}{p}

Finally, verify that x+y+z=ax + y + z = a. If it matches, the square root is x+y+z\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} + \sqrt{z}.

Handling Negative Cross-Terms:

If the radicand contains two negative cross-terms, such as:

a+2p−2q−2ra + 2\sqrt{p} - 2\sqrt{q} - 2\sqrt{r}

Notice that p=xyp = xy is positive, while q=yzq = yz and r=xzr = xz are negative.

This implies zz carries the negative sign:

(x+y−z)2=x+y+z+2xy−2xz−2yz(\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} - \sqrt{z})^2 = x + y + z + 2\sqrt{xy} - 2\sqrt{xz} - 2\sqrt{yz}

The variable common to both negative cross-terms is the one with the minus sign!


4. Common Pitfalls & Speed Shortcuts

Pitfall 1: The Negative Principal Square Root Blunder

When de-nesting 7−210\sqrt{7 - 2\sqrt{10}}, the factor pair of 1010 summing to 77 is 55 and 22.

Students sometimes write 2−5\sqrt{2} - \sqrt{5}.

Fatal Error: 2−5≈1.414−2.236=−0.822<0\sqrt{2} - \sqrt{5} \approx 1.414 - 2.236 = -0.822 < 0.

The radical sign ⋅\sqrt{\cdot} denotes the principal (non-negative) square root. Writing a negative result creates catastrophic errors in downstream equations. Always enforce x>yx > y:

7−210=5−2\sqrt{7 - 2\sqrt{10}} = \sqrt{5} - \sqrt{2}

Pitfall 2: Forgetting the Denominator 2\sqrt{2} in Case 3

When solving 3−5\sqrt{3 - \sqrt{5}}, students correctly find that 6−25=(5−1)26 - 2\sqrt{5} = (\sqrt{5}-1)^2, but then report the final answer as 5−1\sqrt{5} - 1, forgetting that they multiplied the radicand by 22.

Correction: The true value is 5−12=10−22\frac{\sqrt{5} - 1}{\sqrt{2}} = \frac{\sqrt{10} - \sqrt{2}}{2}.

Speed Shortcut: The Factor-Pair Mental Inspection

To de-nest a±2ba \pm 2\sqrt{b} in under 55 seconds:

  1. Don't solve the quadratic equation t2−at+b=0t^2 - at + b = 0.

  2. List the factor pairs of bb starting from b\sqrt{b} downwards.

  3. Mentally check their sum against aa.

Example: For 28−27528 - 2\sqrt{75}, factors of 7575 are (75,1),(25,3),(15,5)(75,1), (25,3), (15,5). Instantly spot 25+3=2825 + 3 = 28. Answer: 25−3=5−3\sqrt{25} - \sqrt{3} = 5 - \sqrt{3}. Done!

Formulas

Principal Binomial Square Root Identity

a±2b=x±y(x>y>0)\sqrt{a \pm 2\sqrt{b}} = \sqrt{x} \pm \sqrt{y} \quad (x > y > 0)

Holds if and only if x + y = a and xy = b. The larger term x must be placed first.
External Factor Absorption

a±2km=a±2k2ma \pm 2k\sqrt{m} = a \pm 2\sqrt{k^2 m}

Absorb excess factor k inside the square root to expose the mandatory coefficient 2.
Internal Factor Extraction

a±4k=a±2ka \pm \sqrt{4k} = a \pm 2\sqrt{k}

Extract 2 = sqrt(4) outside the radical before factoring.
Artificial Coefficient 2 Insertion

a±b=2a±2b2\sqrt{a \pm \sqrt{b}} = \frac{\sqrt{2a \pm 2\sqrt{b}}}{\sqrt{2}}

Used when the radicand b is odd and contains no factors of 4.
Trinomial Cyclic Product Formula

xyz=pqr  ⟹  x=pqrq,  y=pqrr,  z=pqrpxyz = \sqrt{pqr} \implies x = \frac{\sqrt{pqr}}{q}, \; y = \frac{\sqrt{pqr}}{r}, \; z = \frac{\sqrt{pqr}}{p}

Extracts individual components x, y, z for sqrt(a + 2*sqrt(p) + 2*sqrt(q) + 2*sqrt(r)).

Traps and tips

  • The Negative Root Disaster: The square root of any real number is non-negative by definition. In de-nesting sqrt(7 - 2*sqrt(10)), the answer is strictly sqrt(5) - sqrt(2), NEVER sqrt(2) - sqrt(5).
  • The Disguised Outside Factor: For 14 + 6sqrt(5), rewrite 6sqrt(5) as 2*(3sqrt(5)) = 2sqrt(45). The numbers to sum to 14 are 9 and 5, giving sqrt(9) + sqrt(5) = 3 + sqrt(5).
  • Missing Root 2 Denominator: When evaluating sqrt(4 - sqrt(15)), multiplying by 2 inside gives sqrt((8 - 2*sqrt(15))/2) = (sqrt(5) - sqrt(3))/sqrt(2). Forgetting the sqrt(2) denominator skews the answer by ~41%.
  • Negative Signs in Trinomial Radicals: In a + 2sqrt(p) - 2sqrt(q) - 2*sqrt(r), identify the variable present in BOTH negative cross-terms (q = yz, r = xz). That variable (z) is the unique term with the minus sign: sqrt(x) + sqrt(y) - sqrt(z).

Solved examples

Example 2.1: Factoring Excess Multipliers Inside Radical

Find the simplified principal square root of the expression:

E=38−1210E = 38 - 12\sqrt{10}

Show solution

Step 1: Convert the radical to standard a−2Ba - 2\sqrt{B} format.

The coefficient of the irrational term is 1212. Factor out 22:

1210=2(610)12\sqrt{10} = 2(6\sqrt{10})

Push the factor 66 inside the square root by squaring it (62=366^2 = 36):

2(610)=236×10=23602(6\sqrt{10}) = 2\sqrt{36 \times 10} = 2\sqrt{360}

Thus, the expression is:

E=38−2360E = 38 - 2\sqrt{360}

Step 2: Find two numbers xx and yy such that x+y=38x + y = 38 and xy=360xy = 360.

Inspect factor pairs of 360360:

  • 360=36×10  ⟹  36+10=46360 = 36 \times 10 \implies 36 + 10 = 46

  • 360=20×18  ⟹  20+18=38360 = 20 \times 18 \implies 20 + 18 = 38 (Exact match!)

Step 3: Extract the square root with x>yx > y.

Here x=20x = 20 and y=18y = 18:

38−1210=20−18\sqrt{38 - 12\sqrt{10}} = \sqrt{20} - \sqrt{18}

Step 4: Simplify individual radicals.

20=4×5=25\sqrt{20} = \sqrt{4 \times 5} = 2\sqrt{5}

18=9×2=32\sqrt{18} = \sqrt{9 \times 2} = 3\sqrt{2}

  ⟹  E=25−32\implies \sqrt{E} = 2\sqrt{5} - 3\sqrt{2}

Sanity check: 25=20≈4.4722\sqrt{5} = \sqrt{20} \approx 4.472, and 32=18≈4.2423\sqrt{2} = \sqrt{18} \approx 4.242. Since 4.472>4.2424.472 > 4.242, the result is strictly positive.

Takeaway: Always isolate a leading coefficient of 2 by absorbing any excess multiplier (k) as k^2 inside the square root before hunting for factor pairs.

Example 2.2: Extracting 2 from an Internal Multiple of 4

Evaluate the simplified numerical value of:

S=19+288−11−72S = \sqrt{19 + \sqrt{288}} - \sqrt{11 - \sqrt{72}}

Show solution

Step 1: Simplify the first term T1=19+288T_1 = \sqrt{19 + \sqrt{288}}.

Extract factor of 44 from 288288:

288=4×72  ⟹  288=272288 = 4 \times 72 \implies \sqrt{288} = 2\sqrt{72}

T1=19+272T_1 = \sqrt{19 + 2\sqrt{72}}

Find x,yx, y such that x+y=19x + y = 19 and xy=72xy = 72:

16×3=72,16+3=1916 \times 3 = 72, \quad 16 + 3 = 19

  ⟹  T1=16+3=4+3\implies T_1 = \sqrt{16} + \sqrt{3} = 4 + \sqrt{3}

Step 2: Simplify the second term T2=11−72T_2 = \sqrt{11 - \sqrt{72}}.

Extract factor of 44 from 7272:

72=4×18  ⟹  72=21872 = 4 \times 18 \implies \sqrt{72} = 2\sqrt{18}

T2=11−218T_2 = \sqrt{11 - 2\sqrt{18}}

Find u,vu, v such that u+v=11u + v = 11 and uv=18uv = 18:

9×2=18,9+2=119 \times 2 = 18, \quad 9 + 2 = 11

  ⟹  T2=9−2=3−2\implies T_2 = \sqrt{9} - \sqrt{2} = 3 - \sqrt{2}

Step 3: Compute the difference S=T1−T2S = T_1 - T_2.

S=(4+3)−(3−2)=4+3−3+2=1+2+3S = (4 + \sqrt{3}) - (3 - \sqrt{2}) = 4 + \sqrt{3} - 3 + \sqrt{2} = 1 + \sqrt{2} + \sqrt{3}

Takeaway: When no external coefficient is present, divide the radicand by 4; taking sqrt(4) = 2 outside immediately establishes the standard de-nesting format.

Example 2.3: Artificial Coefficient 2 for Odd Radical Expressions

Find the exact simplified value of:

E=4−15+4+15E = \sqrt{4 - \sqrt{15}} + \sqrt{4 + \sqrt{15}}

Show solution

Step 1: Analyze the radicands.

The number 1515 has no factor of 44, and there is no coefficient of 22. Multiply and divide inside each square root by 22:

4−15=2(4−15)2=8−2152\sqrt{4 - \sqrt{15}} = \sqrt{\frac{2(4 - \sqrt{15})}{2}} = \frac{\sqrt{8 - 2\sqrt{15}}}{\sqrt{2}}

4+15=2(4+15)2=8+2152\sqrt{4 + \sqrt{15}} = \sqrt{\frac{2(4 + \sqrt{15})}{2}} = \frac{\sqrt{8 + 2\sqrt{15}}}{\sqrt{2}}

Step 2: De-nest the numerators.

For 8±2158 \pm 2\sqrt{15}, find factors of 1515 that sum to 88:

5×3=15,5+3=85 \times 3 = 15, \quad 5 + 3 = 8

  ⟹  8−215=5−3\implies \sqrt{8 - 2\sqrt{15}} = \sqrt{5} - \sqrt{3}

  ⟹  8+215=5+3\implies \sqrt{8 + 2\sqrt{15}} = \sqrt{5} + \sqrt{3}

Step 3: Combine over the common denominator 2\sqrt{2}.

E=5−32+5+32=(5−3)+(5+3)2=252E = \frac{\sqrt{5} - \sqrt{3}}{\sqrt{2}} + \frac{\sqrt{5} + \sqrt{3}}{\sqrt{2}} = \frac{(\sqrt{5} - \sqrt{3}) + (\sqrt{5} + \sqrt{3})}{\sqrt{2}} = \frac{2\sqrt{5}}{\sqrt{2}}

Rationalizing 22=2\frac{2}{\sqrt{2}} = \sqrt{2}:

E=2×5=10E = \sqrt{2} \times \sqrt{5} = \sqrt{10}

Verification via Squaring: Let E=4−15+4+15E = \sqrt{4-\sqrt{15}} + \sqrt{4+\sqrt{15}}.

E2=(4−15)+(4+15)+2(4−15)(4+15)=8+216−15=8+2(1)=10E^2 = (4-\sqrt{15}) + (4+\sqrt{15}) + 2\sqrt{(4-\sqrt{15})(4+\sqrt{15})} = 8 + 2\sqrt{16-15} = 8 + 2(1) = 10

  ⟹  E=10\implies E = \sqrt{10}

Takeaway: When a radicand has no factor of 2, multiply and divide by 2 inside the radical; de-nest the numerator and carry the sqrt(2) divisor to the final step.

Example 2.4: Nested Radical Denominators in Fractional Differences

Evaluate the exact numerical value of the expression:

F=616−255−814−233F = \frac{6}{\sqrt{16 - 2\sqrt{55}}} - \frac{8}{\sqrt{14 - 2\sqrt{33}}}

Show solution

Step 1: De-nest the first denominator D1=16−255D_1 = \sqrt{16 - 2\sqrt{55}}.

Find two numbers with product 5555 and sum 1616:

11×5=55,11+5=1611 \times 5 = 55, \quad 11 + 5 = 16

  ⟹  D1=11−5\implies D_1 = \sqrt{11} - \sqrt{5}

Step 2: Rationalize the first fraction.

611−5=6(11+5)(11−5)(11+5)=6(11+5)11−5=6(11+5)6=11+5\frac{6}{\sqrt{11} - \sqrt{5}} = \frac{6(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{5})}{(\sqrt{11} - \sqrt{5})(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{5})} = \frac{6(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{5})}{11 - 5} = \frac{6(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{5})}{6} = \sqrt{11} + \sqrt{5}

Step 3: De-nest the second denominator D2=14−233D_2 = \sqrt{14 - 2\sqrt{33}}.

Find two numbers with product 3333 and sum 1414:

11×3=33,11+3=1411 \times 3 = 33, \quad 11 + 3 = 14

  ⟹  D2=11−3\implies D_2 = \sqrt{11} - \sqrt{3}

Step 4: Rationalize the second fraction.

811−3=8(11+3)(11−3)(11+3)=8(11+3)11−3=8(11+3)8=11+3\frac{8}{\sqrt{11} - \sqrt{3}} = \frac{8(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{3})}{(\sqrt{11} - \sqrt{3})(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{3})} = \frac{8(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{3})}{11 - 3} = \frac{8(\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{3})}{8} = \sqrt{11} + \sqrt{3}

Step 5: Compute the difference.

F=(11+5)−(11+3)=5−3F = (\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{5}) - (\sqrt{11} + \sqrt{3}) = \sqrt{5} - \sqrt{3}

Takeaway: De-nest denominators first before rationalizing; often the resulting difference of squares perfectly cancels the numerator coefficients.

Example 2.5: De-nesting a Three-Radical Trinomial Square Root

Find the simplified square root of the multi-term expression:

M=15+215+221+235M = 15 + 2\sqrt{15} + 2\sqrt{21} + 2\sqrt{35}

Show solution

Step 1: Match with the trinomial square expansion identity.

Recall: (x+y+z)2=(x+y+z)+2xy+2yz+2zx(\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} + \sqrt{z})^2 = (x + y + z) + 2\sqrt{xy} + 2\sqrt{yz} + 2\sqrt{zx}.

Here, the three cross-terms are:

xy=15,yz=21,zx=35xy = 15, \quad yz = 21, \quad zx = 35

Step 2: Apply the cyclic product extraction algorithm.

Multiply all three equations:

(xy)(yz)(zx)=(xyz)2=15×21×35(xy)(yz)(zx) = (xyz)^2 = 15 \times 21 \times 35

Factorize each number into prime factors:

15=3×5,21=3×7,35=5×715 = 3 \times 5, \quad 21 = 3 \times 7, \quad 35 = 5 \times 7

(xyz)2=(3×5)×(3×7)×(5×7)=32×52×72=(3×5×7)2=(105)2(xyz)^2 = (3 \times 5) \times (3 \times 7) \times (5 \times 7) = 3^2 \times 5^2 \times 7^2 = (3 \times 5 \times 7)^2 = (105)^2

  ⟹  xyz=105\implies xyz = 105

Step 3: Solve for individual variables.

x=xyzyz=10521=5x = \frac{xyz}{yz} = \frac{105}{21} = 5

y=xyzzx=10535=3y = \frac{xyz}{zx} = \frac{105}{35} = 3

z=xyzxy=10515=7z = \frac{xyz}{xy} = \frac{105}{15} = 7

Step 4: Verify the sum condition.

x+y+z=5+3+7=15x + y + z = 5 + 3 + 7 = 15

This matches the given rational constant 1515 perfectly!

Step 5: Write the final square root.

M=3+5+7\sqrt{M} = \sqrt{3} + \sqrt{5} + \sqrt{7}

Takeaway: For multi-term square roots, cyclic multiplication gives (xyz)^2 = pqr; dividing by each pair reveals the underlying single variables x, y, and z instantly.

Example 2.6: Trinomial Radical De-nesting with Mixed Signs

De-nest and express in simplest form the principal square root:

R=14+43−47−221R = \sqrt{14 + 4\sqrt{3} - 4\sqrt{7} - 2\sqrt{21}}

Show solution

Step 1: Standardize the cross-term coefficients to 22.

  • 43=2(23)=2124\sqrt{3} = 2(2\sqrt{3}) = 2\sqrt{12}

  • −47=−2(27)=−228-4\sqrt{7} = -2(2\sqrt{7}) = -2\sqrt{28}

  • −221=−221-2\sqrt{21} = -2\sqrt{21}

So the expression is:

R=14+212−228−221R = \sqrt{14 + 2\sqrt{12} - 2\sqrt{28} - 2\sqrt{21}}

Step 2: Identify the sign structure.

The positive cross-term is 2xy=212  ⟹  xy=122\sqrt{xy} = 2\sqrt{12} \implies xy = 12.

The negative cross-terms are −2xz=−228-2\sqrt{xz} = -2\sqrt{28} and −2yz=−221-2\sqrt{yz} = -2\sqrt{21}.

Notice that the variable zz is common to BOTH negative cross-terms! Therefore, z\sqrt{z} must carry the minus sign: (x+y−z)2(\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} - \sqrt{z})^2.

Step 3: Solve for x,y,zx, y, z.

(xyz)2=12×28×21=(3×4)×(4×7)×(3×7)=32×42×72=(84)2(xyz)^2 = 12 \times 28 \times 21 = (3 \times 4) \times (4 \times 7) \times (3 \times 7) = 3^2 \times 4^2 \times 7^2 = (84)^2

  ⟹  xyz=84\implies xyz = 84

z=xyzxy=8412=7z = \frac{xyz}{xy} = \frac{84}{12} = 7

y=xyzxz=8428=3y = \frac{xyz}{xz} = \frac{84}{28} = 3

x=xyzyz=8421=4x = \frac{xyz}{yz} = \frac{84}{21} = 4

Step 4: Verify the sum condition.

x+y+z=4+3+7=14(Matches the given constant 14!)x + y + z = 4 + 3 + 7 = 14 \quad (\text{Matches the given constant 14!})

Step 5: Formulate the square root.

x+y−z=4+3−7=2+3−7\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} - \sqrt{z} = \sqrt{4} + \sqrt{3} - \sqrt{7} = 2 + \sqrt{3} - \sqrt{7}

Positivity check: 2+3≈2+1.732=3.7322 + \sqrt{3} \approx 2 + 1.732 = 3.732, and 7≈2.646\sqrt{7} \approx 2.646. Since 3.732>2.6463.732 > 2.646, the result is strictly positive.

Takeaway: When a multi-term radical contains negative cross-terms, the variable present in both negative products is the one that carries the minus sign in the de-nested root.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

Determine the exact numerical value of the nested radical expression:

E=2⋅28−63−12+63+3E = \sqrt{2} \cdot \sqrt{28 - 6\sqrt{3} - \sqrt{12 + 6\sqrt{3}}} + \sqrt{3}

  1. A

    55

  2. B

    66

  3. C

    77

  4. D

    88

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 7

De-nest the innermost radical first: 12+63=12+227=9+3=3+3\sqrt{12 + 6\sqrt{3}} = \sqrt{12 + 2\sqrt{27}} = \sqrt{9} + \sqrt{3} = 3 + \sqrt{3}.

Substitute this into the outer radicand: 28−63−(3+3)=25−7328 - 6\sqrt{3} - (3 + \sqrt{3}) = 25 - 7\sqrt{3}.

Absorb the factor 2\sqrt{2} into the radical: 225−73=50−143=50−2147\sqrt{2} \sqrt{25 - 7\sqrt{3}} = \sqrt{50 - 14\sqrt{3}} = \sqrt{50 - 2\sqrt{147}}.

Find two numbers summing to 5050 with product 147147: 49+3=5049 + 3 = 50 and 49×3=14749 \times 3 = 147.

Therefore, 50−2147=49−3=7−3\sqrt{50 - 2\sqrt{147}} = \sqrt{49} - \sqrt{3} = 7 - \sqrt{3}.

Adding 3\sqrt{3} gives E=(7−3)+3=7E = (7 - \sqrt{3}) + \sqrt{3} = 7.

Question 2 · CAT Level

If xx satisfies the inequality 2<x<62 < x < 6, simplify the algebraic surd expression:

E=x−1+2x−2+x+2−4x−2E = \sqrt{x - 1 + 2\sqrt{x - 2}} + \sqrt{x + 2 - 4\sqrt{x - 2}}

  1. A

    33

  2. B

    2x−2−12\sqrt{x - 2} - 1

  3. C

    2x−2+32\sqrt{x - 2} + 3

  4. D

    11

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) 3

Let u=x−2>0u = \sqrt{x - 2} > 0, which implies x=u2+2x = u^2 + 2.

The first radicand simplifies to (u2+2)−1+2u=u2+2u+1=(u+1)2(u^2 + 2) - 1 + 2u = u^2 + 2u + 1 = (u + 1)^2.

The second radicand simplifies to (u2+2)+2−4u=u2−4u+4=(u−2)2(u^2 + 2) + 2 - 4u = u^2 - 4u + 4 = (u - 2)^2.

Taking square roots yields E=∣u+1∣+∣u−2∣E = |u + 1| + |u - 2|.

Since 2<x<62 < x < 6, we have 0<x−2<40 < x - 2 < 4, so 0<u<20 < u < 2.

Because u<2u < 2, the term ∣u−2∣=−(u−2)=2−u|u - 2| = -(u - 2) = 2 - u, while ∣u+1∣=u+1|u + 1| = u + 1.

Adding the two simplified terms gives E=(u+1)+(2−u)=3E = (u + 1) + (2 - u) = 3.

Question 3 · CAT Level

Evaluate the exact simplified value of:

P=(31+415−610−106+15)2P = \left(\sqrt{31 + 4\sqrt{15} - 6\sqrt{10} - 10\sqrt{6}} + \sqrt{15}\right)^2

  1. A

    16+41516 + 4\sqrt{15}

  2. B

    16−41516 - 4\sqrt{15}

  3. C

    31+21531 + 2\sqrt{15}

  4. D

    15+4615 + 4\sqrt{6}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) 16 + 4 15

Standardize cross-term coefficients to 22: 415=2604\sqrt{15} = 2\sqrt{60}, −610=−290-6\sqrt{10} = -2\sqrt{90}, and −106=−2150-10\sqrt{6} = -2\sqrt{150}.

Let the de-nested form be x+y−z\sqrt{x} + \sqrt{y} - \sqrt{z} where zz appears in both negative terms: xy=60,xz=90,yz=150xy = 60, xz = 90, yz = 150.

Multiply the three products: (xyz)2=60×90×150=810000  ⟹  xyz=900(xyz)^2 = 60 \times 90 \times 150 = 810000 \implies xyz = 900.

Solve for components: z=900/60=15z = 900/60 = 15, y=900/90=10y = 900/90 = 10, x=900/150=6x = 900/150 = 6, with sum 6+10+15=316 + 10 + 15 = 31.

Thus the radical equals 6+10−15\sqrt{6} + \sqrt{10} - \sqrt{15}, so adding 15\sqrt{15} leaves 6+10\sqrt{6} + \sqrt{10}.

Squaring yields (6+10)2=6+10+260=16+415(\sqrt{6} + \sqrt{10})^2 = 6 + 10 + 2\sqrt{60} = 16 + 4\sqrt{15}.

Question 4 · CAT Level

If A=97+5634A = \sqrt[4]{97 + 56\sqrt{3}} and B=97−5634B = \sqrt[4]{97 - 56\sqrt{3}}, evaluate the exact value of:

K=(A−B)2+(A+B)2K = (A - B)^2 + (A + B)^2

  1. A

    2424

  2. B

    2828

  3. C

    3232

  4. D

    3636

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 28

Write the fourth roots as two sequential square roots: A=97+563A = \sqrt{\sqrt{97 + 56\sqrt{3}}} and B=97−563B = \sqrt{\sqrt{97 - 56\sqrt{3}}}.

For the inner surd, 97±563=97±2235297 \pm 56\sqrt{3} = 97 \pm 2\sqrt{2352}. Since 49+48=9749 + 48 = 97 and 49×48=235249 \times 48 = 2352, 97±563=7±43\sqrt{97 \pm 56\sqrt{3}} = 7 \pm 4\sqrt{3}.

De-nesting the second time: 7±43=7±212=4±3=2±3\sqrt{7 \pm 4\sqrt{3}} = \sqrt{7 \pm 2\sqrt{12}} = \sqrt{4} \pm \sqrt{3} = 2 \pm \sqrt{3}.

Therefore, A=2+3A = 2 + \sqrt{3} and B=2−3B = 2 - \sqrt{3}, giving A+B=4A + B = 4 and A−B=23A - B = 2\sqrt{3}.

Expanding the requested expression: (A−B)2+(A+B)2=(23)2+42=12+16=28(A - B)^2 + (A + B)^2 = (2\sqrt{3})^2 + 4^2 = 12 + 16 = 28.

Question 5 · CAT Level

Find the sum of all integer values of xx that satisfy the radical equation:

x+3−4x−1+x+8−6x−1=1\sqrt{x + 3 - 4\sqrt{x - 1}} + \sqrt{x + 8 - 6\sqrt{x - 1}} = 1

  1. A

    3535

  2. B

    4040

  3. C

    4545

  4. D

    5050

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 45

Substitute u=x−1≥0u = \sqrt{x - 1} \ge 0, which yields x=u2+1x = u^2 + 1.

The first radicand becomes (u2+1)+3−4u=u2−4u+4=(u−2)2(u^2 + 1) + 3 - 4u = u^2 - 4u + 4 = (u - 2)^2, so its square root is ∣u−2∣|u - 2|.

The second radicand becomes (u2+1)+8−6u=u2−6u+9=(u−3)2(u^2 + 1) + 8 - 6u = u^2 - 6u + 9 = (u - 3)^2, so its square root is ∣u−3∣|u - 3|.

The equation reduces to ∣u−2∣+∣u−3∣=1|u - 2| + |u - 3| = 1, which holds if and only if 2≤u≤32 \le u \le 3.

Substituting back u=x−1u = \sqrt{x - 1} gives 2≤x−1≤3  ⟹  4≤x−1≤9  ⟹  5≤x≤102 \le \sqrt{x - 1} \le 3 \implies 4 \le x - 1 \le 9 \implies 5 \le x \le 10.

The integer solutions are 5,6,7,8,9,105, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, whose sum is 5+6+7+8+9+10=455 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9 + 10 = 45.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library