Free CAT library

Ratio Fundamentals, Chained Ratios & The Addition Inequality

Master ratios as abstract scaling operators, bridging multi-variable chains via LCM unification, duplicate and sub-duplicate transformations, and the foundational Addition and Subtraction Inequalities governing ratio drift toward unity.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Directional Vector & The Unity Magnet

Imagine an architect drafting the blueprint for a futuristic eco-skyscraper. On her blueprint, the ratio of structural steel to reinforced concrete to glass composite is specified strictly as 3:7:23 : 7 : 2.

Notice what this ratio does—and what it does not do:

  • It does not specify whether the construction crew will pour 1212 metric tonnes or 12,00012,000 metric tonnes of materials.

  • It establishes an invariant directional ray in three-dimensional resource space. The ratio a:ba : b is completely dimensionless; it strips away absolute magnitude to reveal pure relative scale.

To transition from the dimensionless world of blueprints to the physical world of tonnage, we must attach an unknown dimensional scalar, known as the scaling constant (kk).

Steel=3k,Concrete=7k,Glass=2k(k>0)\text{Steel} = 3k, \quad \text{Concrete} = 7k, \quad \text{Glass} = 2k \quad (k > 0)

The Unity Magnet (The Addition Inequality Metaphor)

Now imagine two startup founders: Founder A owns 900,000$ in equity, while Junior Employee B owns 100,000.Theratiooftheirwealthisastaggering. The ratio of their wealth is a staggering 9 : 1(aratioofgreaterinequality,(a ratio of greater inequality,> 1$).

Suppose the company wins an unrestricted government grant of 900,000$ and divides it **equally** between them (450,000$ each).

  • Founder A now has $$1,350,000$.

  • Employee B now has $$550,000$.

  • The new wealth ratio collapses to 1,350,000550,000=2711≈2.45:1\frac{1,350,000}{550,000} = \frac{27}{11} \approx 2.45 : 1.

Adding an identical positive quantity to both sides acted as a Unity Magnet—it pulled the disparate ratio violently toward equality (1:11 : 1). Conversely, had both surrendered equal capital, their relative inequality would have exploded away from 11. This geometric gravitation toward unity under positive addition is one of the most tested algebraic principles in competitive quantitative exams.


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: How Exam Setters Disguise Ratio Mechanics

Exam setters rarely ask you to simplify sterile ratios. Instead, they disguise core ratio mechanics inside four distinct question archetypes:

  1. The Multi-Stage Dilution & Chained Bridge:

    You are given pair-wise relationships across distinct funding rounds, supply chains, or demographic cohorts (A:BA : B, B:CB : C, C:DC : D). The examiner deliberately staggers the middle terms. Your objective is to find the unifying Least Common Multiple (LCM) across the intermediary bridge nodes to create the single unbroken chain A:B:C:DA : B : C : D.

  2. The Diophantine Headcount Trap (Integer Constraints):

    Humans, shares of stock, votes, and coins cannot exist in fractional amounts. If the ratio of engineers to designers is 7:47 : 4, the total headcount must be an integer multiple of (7+4)=11(7 + 4) = 11. Examiners pair ratio relationships with divisibility constraints to force a unique integer solution without providing explicit equations.

  3. The Addition & Subtraction Drift Inequality:

    Questions involving mixtures, admission selection rates, or financial leverage ask: "If equal numbers of voters/students/substances are added to both groups, does the ratio increase, decrease, or remain invariant?" Test-takers who lack the analytical inequality waste precious minutes testing random numbers.

  4. Geometric & Kinetic Power Scaling (Duplicate & Triplicate Ratios):

    Problems connecting kinetic energy (E∝v2E \propto v^2), aerodynamic surface areas (A∝L2A \propto L^2), or acoustic volumes (V∝r3V \propto r^3) test duplicate (a2:b2a^2 : b^2), triplicate (a3:b3a^3 : b^3), and sub-duplicate (a:b\sqrt{a} : \sqrt{b}) transformations disguised as physical word problems.


3. Core Concepts, Formulae & Derivations

A. Formal Ratio Mechanics & The Compounding Operator

A ratio a:ba : b represents the quotient ab\frac{a}{b}, where b≠0b \neq 0.

  • Compounded Ratio: Given two ratios a:ba : b and c:dc : d, their compounded ratio is obtained by multiplying antecedent with antecedent and consequent with consequent:

    Compounded Ratio=a⋅cb⋅d=ac:bd\text{Compounded Ratio} = \frac{a \cdot c}{b \cdot d} = ac : bd

  • Duplicate Ratio: The ratio compounded with itself: a2:b2a^2 : b^2.

  • Triplicate Ratio: a3:b3a^3 : b^3.

  • Sub-Duplicate Ratio: a:b\sqrt{a} : \sqrt{b}.

  • Sub-Triplicate Ratio: a3:b3\sqrt[3]{a} : \sqrt[3]{b}.

  • Reciprocal (Inverse) Ratio: 1a:1b=b:a\frac{1}{a} : \frac{1}{b} = b : a.

B. The Chained Ratio Unification Algorithm

To combine A:B=a:bA : B = a : b and B:C=c:dB : C = c : d into A:B:CA : B : C:

  1. Identify the common pivot variable (BB).

  2. The pivot has coefficient bb in the first ratio and cc in the second ratio.

  3. Multiply the first ratio by cc and the second ratio by bb:

    A:B=ac:bc,B:C=bc:bd  ⟹  A:B:C=ac:bc:bdA : B = ac : bc, \quad B : C = bc : bd \implies A : B : C = ac : bc : bd

For a four-variable chain A:B=a:bA : B = a : b, B:C=c:dB : C = c : d, and C:D=e:fC : D = e : f:

A:B:C:D=(a⋅c⋅e):(b⋅c⋅e):(b⋅d⋅e):(b⋅d⋅f)A : B : C : D = (a \cdot c \cdot e) : (b \cdot c \cdot e) : (b \cdot d \cdot e) : (b \cdot d \cdot f)

C. Rigorous Derivation of the Addition & Subtraction Inequalities

Let a,b,x>0a, b, x > 0 be positive real numbers. Consider the difference between the modified ratio a+xb+x\frac{a+x}{b+x} and the original ratio ab\frac{a}{b}:

Δadd=a+xb+x−ab=b(a+x)−a(b+x)b(b+x)=ab+bx−ab−axb(b+x)=x(b−a)b(b+x)\Delta_{\text{add}} = \frac{a+x}{b+x} - \frac{a}{b} = \frac{b(a+x) - a(b+x)}{b(b+x)} = \frac{ab + bx - ab - ax}{b(b+x)} = \frac{x(b - a)}{b(b+x)}

Since x>0x > 0 and b(b+x)>0b(b+x) > 0, the algebraic sign of Δadd\Delta_{\text{add}} is determined entirely by the sign of (b−a)(b - a):

  1. Ratio of Less Inequality (a<b  ⟺  ab<1a < b \iff \frac{a}{b} < 1):

    b−a>0  ⟹  Δadd>0  ⟹  a+xb+x>abb - a > 0 \implies \Delta_{\text{add}} > 0 \implies \frac{a+x}{b+x} > \frac{a}{b}

    Adding an identical positive quantity to numerator and denominator increases a proper fraction.

  2. Ratio of Greater Inequality (a>b  ⟺  ab>1a > b \iff \frac{a}{b} > 1):

    b−a<0  ⟹  Δadd<0  ⟹  a+xb+x<abb - a < 0 \implies \Delta_{\text{add}} < 0 \implies \frac{a+x}{b+x} < \frac{a}{b}

    Adding an identical positive quantity to numerator and denominator decreases an improper fraction.

  3. Asymptotic Convergence toward Unity:

    lim⁡x→∞a+xb+x=lim⁡x→∞1+a/x1+b/x=1\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{a+x}{b+x} = \lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{1 + a/x}{1 + b/x} = 1

    Addition of positive quantities acts as a universal magnet pulling any ratio toward 11.

Now consider subtracting a positive quantity xx (where 0<x<min⁡(a,b)0 < x < \min(a, b)):

Δsub=a−xb−x−ab=b(a−x)−a(b−x)b(b−x)=−bx+axb(b−x)=x(a−b)b(b−x)\Delta_{\text{sub}} = \frac{a-x}{b-x} - \frac{a}{b} = \frac{b(a-x) - a(b-x)}{b(b-x)} = \frac{-bx + ax}{b(b-x)} = \frac{x(a - b)}{b(b-x)}

  • If ab>1\frac{a}{b} > 1 (a>ba > b), then Δsub>0  ⟹  a−xb−x>ab\Delta_{\text{sub}} > 0 \implies \frac{a-x}{b-x} > \frac{a}{b} (subtraction increases an improper fraction further away from 1).

  • If ab<1\frac{a}{b} < 1 (a<ba < b), then Δsub<0  ⟹  a−xb−x<ab\Delta_{\text{sub}} < 0 \implies \frac{a-x}{b-x} < \frac{a}{b} (subtraction depresses a proper fraction further away from 1).


4. Common Pitfalls & Speed Shortcuts

The Phantom Addition Trap:

Never add ratios term-by-term!

If Class X has a boy-to-girl ratio of 2:32 : 3 and Class Y has a boy-to-girl ratio of 4:54 : 5, the combined ratio of boys to girls is NOT (2+4):(3+5)=6:8=3:4(2+4) : (3+5) = 6 : 8 = 3 : 4.

You can only sum ratios if the absolute scale (the common multiplier kk) of both cohorts is identical.

The Homogeneous Polynomial Cancellation Shortcut:

If an expression is homogeneous (every term in the numerator and denominator has the exact same total degree in the variables), you do not need to carry the scaling constant kk.

For example, if x:y=3:4x : y = 3 : 4, to find 2x2+5xy3x2−y2\frac{2x^2 + 5xy}{3x^2 - y^2}, simply plug in x=3x = 3 and y=4y = 4 directly:

2(3)2+5(3)(4)3(3)2−(4)2=18+6027−16=7811\frac{2(3)^2 + 5(3)(4)}{3(3)^2 - (4)^2} = \frac{18 + 60}{27 - 16} = \frac{78}{11}

The k2k^2 factors in the numerator and denominator cancel identically.

Formulas

Chained Ratio 3-Variable Unification

A:B=a:b,  B:C=c:d  ⟹  A:B:C=ac:bc:bdA:B = a:b, \; B:C = c:d \implies A:B:C = ac : bc : bd

Scale by LCM of the intermediary pivot term B
Chained Ratio 4-Variable Unification

A:B:C:D=ace:bce:bde:bdfA:B:C:D = ace : bce : bde : bdf

Continuous compounding across pivots B and C
The Addition Inequality (Unity Magnet)

a+xb+x>ab  ⟺  ab<1anda+xb+x<ab  ⟺  ab>1(x>0)\frac{a+x}{b+x} > \frac{a}{b} \iff \frac{a}{b} < 1 \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{a+x}{b+x} < \frac{a}{b} \iff \frac{a}{b} > 1 \quad (x > 0)

Adding positive x pulls any positive ratio strictly closer to 1
The Subtraction Inequality (Divergence from Unity)

a−xb−x<ab  ⟺  ab<1anda−xb−x>ab  ⟺  ab>1(0<x<min⁡(a,b))\frac{a-x}{b-x} < \frac{a}{b} \iff \frac{a}{b} < 1 \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{a-x}{b-x} > \frac{a}{b} \iff \frac{a}{b} > 1 \quad (0 < x < \min(a,b))

Subtracting positive x pushes the ratio further away from 1
Power Transformations (Duplicate & Sub-Duplicate)

Duplicate=a2:b2,Sub-duplicate=a:b,Triplicate=a3:b3\text{Duplicate} = a^2 : b^2, \quad \text{Sub-duplicate} = \sqrt{a} : \sqrt{b}, \quad \text{Triplicate} = a^3 : b^3

Applied in area scaling (L^2), volume scaling (L^3), and kinetic energy

Traps and tips

  • Never add ratios across different groups unless the absolute base denominators are mathematically proven to be identical.
  • The Unity Magnet Rule: When adding equal positive increments to both terms, the ratio always moves closer to 1. If initially < 1, it increases; if initially > 1, it decreases.
  • Homogeneous degree shortcut: If an algebraic fraction has identical total polynomial degree in every term of numerator and denominator, substitute ratio units directly without carrying the scaling constant k.
  • Headcount / share divisibility: Always check that the sum of ratio parts divides the total count. Fractional people or shares are impossible in CAT word problems.

Solved examples

Example 1.1: Multi-Stage Venture Capital Cap Table Unification

In a deep-tech robotics startup, equity ownership across funding rounds is distributed among the Founders (FF), Angel Investors (AA), Early VC (V1V_1), and Growth Syndicate (V2V_2). The cap table specifies the following pairwise equity ratios: F:A=5:3F : A = 5 : 3, A:V1=4:5A : V_1 = 4 : 5, and V1:V2=6:7V_1 : V_2 = 6 : 7. The company's total issued equity consists of 1,290,0001,290,000 common shares. If each shareholder holds an integer number of shares, determine the exact number of shares owned by the Founders.

Show solution

To find the Founders' absolute shareholding, we must unify the three pairwise ratios into a single continuous chain F:A:V1:V2F : A : V_1 : V_2.

Step 1: Unify F:AF : A and A:V1A : V_1 using the pivot AA

We are given:

F:A=5:3F : A = 5 : 3

A:V1=4:5A : V_1 = 4 : 5

The pivot entity is AA, with coefficients 33 and 44. The LCM(3,4)=12\text{LCM}(3, 4) = 12.

  • Multiply F:AF : A by 44: F:A=20:12F : A = 20 : 12

  • Multiply A:V1A : V_1 by 33: A:V1=12:15A : V_1 = 12 : 15

  ⟹  F:A:V1=20:12:15\implies F : A : V_1 = 20 : 12 : 15

Step 2: Unify (F:A:V1)(F : A : V_1) with V1:V2V_1 : V_2 using the pivot V1V_1

We have:

F:A:V1=20:12:15F : A : V_1 = 20 : 12 : 15

V1:V2=6:7V_1 : V_2 = 6 : 7

The pivot entity is V1V_1, with coefficients 1515 and 66. The LCM(15,6)=30\text{LCM}(15, 6) = 30.

  • Multiply the first chain by 22: F:A:V1=40:24:30F : A : V_1 = 40 : 24 : 30

  • Multiply the second ratio by 55: V1:V2=30:35V_1 : V_2 = 30 : 35

  ⟹  F:A:V1:V2=40:24:30:35\implies F : A : V_1 : V_2 = 40 : 24 : 30 : 35

Step 3: Verify irreducibility and sum of ratio units

The greatest common divisor of 40,24,30,3540, 24, 30, 35 is gcd⁡(40,24,30,35)=1\gcd(40, 24, 30, 35) = 1.

Sum of ratio parts:

Total parts=40+24+30+35=129 units\text{Total parts} = 40 + 24 + 30 + 35 = 129 \text{ units}

Step 4: Compute the scaling factor kk and Founder equity

Total shares=129k=1,290,000  ⟹  k=1,290,000129=10,000\text{Total shares} = 129 k = 1,290,000 \implies k = \frac{1,290,000}{129} = 10,000

Therefore, the Founders' shareholding is:

F=40×k=40×10,000=400,000 sharesF = 40 \times k = 40 \times 10,000 = 400,000 \text{ shares}

Takeaway: Chain multi-stage ratios sequentially by scaling adjacent pairs to the LCM of their shared pivot variable.

Example 1.2: Integer Headcount Constraints & Inter-Departmental Transfers

A global management consulting firm employs consultants across three divisions: Technology (TT), Strategy (SS), and Design (DD). Initially, the ratio of Tech to Strategy consultants is T:S=7:4T : S = 7 : 4, while the ratio of the combined Tech and Strategy consultants to Design consultants is (T+S):D=11:5(T + S) : D = 11 : 5. Following an internal reorganization, 1515 consultants are transferred from Design to Strategy, making the new headcount of Strategy and Design exactly equal (Snew:Dnew=1:1S_{\text{new}} : D_{\text{new}} = 1 : 1). Assuming no employee leaves or joins the firm, find the total number of consultants employed across all three divisions.

Show solution

Let us represent the initial distribution in terms of consistent algebraic units.

Step 1: Harmonize the initial ratios

Given:

T:S=7:4  ⟹  T=7x,S=4xfor some scaling factor xT : S = 7 : 4 \implies T = 7x, \quad S = 4x \quad \text{for some scaling factor } x

Notice that the sum of Tech and Strategy is:

T+S=7x+4x=11xT + S = 7x + 4x = 11x

We are given the compound ratio:

T+SD=115  ⟹  11xD=115  ⟹  D=5x\frac{T + S}{D} = \frac{11}{5} \implies \frac{11x}{D} = \frac{11}{5} \implies D = 5x

Thus, the initial headcounts of the three divisions share the identical scaling factor xx:

T:S:D=7x:4x:5xT : S : D = 7x : 4x : 5x

Step 2: Model the internal transfer

Fifteen consultants transfer from Design to Strategy:

Snew=4x+15S_{\text{new}} = 4x + 15

Dnew=5x−15D_{\text{new}} = 5x - 15

Tech headcount remains unchanged: Tnew=7xT_{\text{new}} = 7x.

Step 3: Solve for the scaling factor xx

We are given that the post-transfer ratio is Snew:Dnew=1:1S_{\text{new}} : D_{\text{new}} = 1 : 1:

4x+15=5x−154x + 15 = 5x - 15

5x−4x=15+15  ⟹  x=305x - 4x = 15 + 15 \implies x = 30

Step 4: Calculate initial and total firm headcount

The total number of consultants across all three divisions is:

Total=T+S+D=7x+4x+5x=16x\text{Total} = T + S + D = 7x + 4x + 5x = 16x

Total=16×30=480 consultants\text{Total} = 16 \times 30 = 480 \text{ consultants}

Verification:

  • Initial: T=210,S=120,D=150T = 210, S = 120, D = 150.

  • After 15 move from DD to SS: Snew=120+15=135S_{\text{new}} = 120 + 15 = 135, Dnew=150−15=135D_{\text{new}} = 150 - 15 = 135. Ratio is indeed 135:135=1:1135 : 135 = 1 : 1.

Takeaway: When a sub-sum matches the antecedent of a secondary ratio, all variables immediately collapse onto a single common multiplier.

Example 1.3: Duplicate, Triplicate & Sub-Triplicate Scaling in Drone Aerodynamics

In autonomous drone engineering, kinetic energy EE scales as the duplicate ratio of cruising velocity vv (E∝v2E \propto v^2), while aerodynamic power consumption PP scales as the triplicate ratio of cruising velocity (P∝v3P \propto v^3). Two autonomous drone prototypes, Aero-X and Aero-Y, operate at cruising velocities that are in the sub-triplicate ratio of their onboard battery capacities CX:CY=27:64C_X : C_Y = 27 : 64.

(a) Determine the ratio of their kinetic energies EX:EYE_X : E_Y.

(b) If Aero-Y's power consumption exceeds Aero-X's power consumption by 148 Watts148\text{ Watts}, calculate the exact power consumption of Aero-X.

Show solution

Let us systematically unpack the power-ratio terminology.

Step 1: Velocity ratio from sub-triplicate ratio of capacities

The sub-triplicate ratio of a:ba : b is defined as a3:b3\sqrt[3]{a} : \sqrt[3]{b}:

vXvY=CXCY3=27643=34\frac{v_X}{v_Y} = \sqrt[3]{\frac{C_X}{C_Y}} = \sqrt[3]{\frac{27}{64}} = \frac{3}{4}

Thus, vX:vY=3:4v_X : v_Y = 3 : 4.

Step 2: Kinetic energy ratio via duplicate ratio of velocities

The duplicate ratio of a:ba : b is defined as a2:b2a^2 : b^2:

EXEY=(vXvY)2=(34)2=916\frac{E_X}{E_Y} = \left(\frac{v_X}{v_Y}\right)^2 = \left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^2 = \frac{9}{16}

Thus, EX:EY=9:16E_X : E_Y = 9 : 16.

Step 3: Power consumption ratio via triplicate ratio of velocities

The triplicate ratio of a:ba : b is defined as a3:b3a^3 : b^3:

PXPY=(vXvY)3=(34)3=2764\frac{P_X}{P_Y} = \left(\frac{v_X}{v_Y}\right)^3 = \left(\frac{3}{4}\right)^3 = \frac{27}{64}

Thus, PX:PY=27:64P_X : P_Y = 27 : 64.

Step 4: Solve for absolute power consumption

Let PX=27kP_X = 27k Watts and PY=64kP_Y = 64k Watts for some constant kk.

We are given the difference in power consumption:

PY−PX=64k−27k=37k=148 WP_Y - P_X = 64k - 27k = 37k = 148\text{ W}

k=14837=4k = \frac{148}{37} = 4

Therefore, the power consumption of Aero-X is:

PX=27×4=108 WattsP_X = 27 \times 4 = 108\text{ Watts}

(And PY=64×4=256 WattsP_Y = 64 \times 4 = 256\text{ Watts}, with difference 256−108=148 W256 - 108 = 148\text{ W}).

Takeaway: Translate 'duplicate' as squared, 'triplicate' as cubed, and 'sub-' prefixes as their respective roots before forming algebraic equations.

Example 1.4: The Addition Inequality & Bounding Quantitative Win Ratios

Two algorithmic trading strategies, Alpha and Beta, track their winning trades relative to total trades. Alpha currently has 1414 winning trades out of 1919 total trades (14/1914/19), while Beta has 1919 winning trades out of 1414 benchmarked reference units (19/1419/14). Both strategies subsequently execute an identical sequence of kk consecutive winning trades (k∈Z+k \in \mathbb{Z}^+).

(a) Prove using the Addition Inequality which strategy's win ratio increases and which decreases.

(b) Find the minimum number of consecutive winning trades kk that strategy Alpha must achieve so that its overall win ratio exceeds 90%90\%.

Show solution

Let us analyze both strategies using the fundamental Addition Inequality.

Part (a): Direction of Ratio Drift

Let x=k>0x = k > 0. The updated ratios become:

Alphanew=14+k19+k,Betanew=19+k14+k\text{Alpha}_{\text{new}} = \frac{14 + k}{19 + k}, \quad \text{Beta}_{\text{new}} = \frac{19 + k}{14 + k}

  1. Strategy Alpha:

    Initial ratio is 1419\frac{14}{19}. Since 14<1914 < 19, this is a ratio of less inequality (proper fraction, <1< 1).

    By the Addition Inequality Theorem:

    a+xb+x−ab=x(b−a)b(b+x)\frac{a+x}{b+x} - \frac{a}{b} = \frac{x(b-a)}{b(b+x)}

    Here b−a=19−14=+5>0b - a = 19 - 14 = +5 > 0. Hence, 14+k19+k>1419\frac{14+k}{19+k} > \frac{14}{19}.

    Alpha's win ratio strictly increases (it is pulled upward toward 11).

  2. Strategy Beta:

    Initial ratio is 1914\frac{19}{14}. Since 19>1419 > 14, this is a ratio of greater inequality (improper fraction, >1> 1).

    Here b−a=14−19=−5<0b - a = 14 - 19 = -5 < 0. Hence, 19+k14+k<1914\frac{19+k}{14+k} < \frac{19}{14}.

    Beta's ratio strictly decreases (it is pulled downward toward 11).

Part (b): Minimum winning streak for Alpha to exceed 90%90\%

We require:

14+k19+k>0.90=910\frac{14 + k}{19 + k} > 0.90 = \frac{9}{10}

Since k>0k > 0, (19+k)>0(19 + k) > 0. Cross-multiply safely:

10(14+k)>9(19+k)10(14 + k) > 9(19 + k)

140+10k>171+9k140 + 10k > 171 + 9k

10k−9k>171−140  ⟹  k>3110k - 9k > 171 - 140 \implies k > 31

Since kk must be an integer, the minimum value is:

kmin⁡=32k_{\min} = 32

Verification:

For k=31k = 31: 14+3119+31=4550=0.9000\frac{14+31}{19+31} = \frac{45}{50} = 0.9000 (exactly 90%90\%, not strictly exceeding).

For k=32k = 32: 14+3219+32=4651≈0.90196>90%\frac{14+32}{19+32} = \frac{46}{51} \approx 0.90196 > 90\%.

Takeaway: Adding equal positive quantities always pulls any positive ratio closer to 1; fractions less than 1 increase, while fractions greater than 1 decrease.

Example 1.5: The Subtraction Inequality in Corporate Debt Restructuring

A manufacturing conglomerate carries Debt of 75\text{ Million}$ and Equity of 45\text{ Million},givingitaDebt−to−Equityleverageratioof, giving it a Debt-to-Equity leverage ratio of 75 : 45 = 5 : 3 > 1. The Chief Financial Officer plans a balance-sheet restructuring that will reduce both Debt and Equity simultaneously by an identical amount of $$x\text{ Million} (x>0x > 0).

(a) Explain why subtracting equal amounts increases the leverage ratio rather than reducing it.

(b) If loan covenant agreements strictly prohibit the company's Debt-to-Equity ratio from exceeding 2.5:12.5 : 1, calculate the maximum allowable simultaneous reduction xx.

Show solution

Let us rigorously evaluate the effect of simultaneous subtraction on an improper ratio.

Part (a): The Subtraction Inequality Mechanism

The initial Debt-to-Equity ratio is:

Rinitial=7545=53≈1.667>1R_{\text{initial}} = \frac{75}{45} = \frac{5}{3} \approx 1.667 > 1

When both Debt and Equity are reduced by xx, the new ratio is:

R(x)=75−x45−xR(x) = \frac{75 - x}{45 - x}

Consider the difference R(x)−R(0)R(x) - R(0):

75−x45−x−53=3(75−x)−5(45−x)3(45−x)=225−3x−225+5x3(45−x)=2x3(45−x)\frac{75 - x}{45 - x} - \frac{5}{3} = \frac{3(75 - x) - 5(45 - x)}{3(45 - x)} = \frac{225 - 3x - 225 + 5x}{3(45 - x)} = \frac{2x}{3(45 - x)}

For any positive reduction 0<x<450 < x < 45, the numerator 2x>02x > 0 and the denominator 3(45−x)>03(45 - x) > 0.

Therefore, R(x)>53R(x) > \frac{5}{3}.

Subtracting equal positive amounts pushes a ratio greater than 1 further away from 1, thereby increasing financial leverage and risk!

Part (b): Maximum Allowable Reduction xx

We require that the modified ratio does not exceed 2.5:1=522.5 : 1 = \frac{5}{2}:

75−x45−x≤52\frac{75 - x}{45 - x} \le \frac{5}{2}

Since x<45x < 45, (45−x)>0(45 - x) > 0. Cross-multiply:

2(75−x)≤5(45−x)2(75 - x) \le 5(45 - x)

150−2x≤225−5x150 - 2x \le 225 - 5x

5x−2x≤225−150  ⟹  3x≤75  ⟹  x≤255x - 2x \le 225 - 150 \implies 3x \le 75 \implies x \le 25

Thus, the maximum allowable simultaneous reduction is:

xmax⁡=$25 Millionx_{\max} = \text{\textdollar}25\text{ Million}

Verification:

At x=25x = 25: Debt=75−25=50\text{Debt} = 75 - 25 = 50, Equity=45−25=20\text{Equity} = 45 - 25 = 20. Ratio =5020=2.5:1= \frac{50}{20} = 2.5 : 1.

Takeaway: Subtracting equal amounts from numerator and denominator pushes any ratio further from unity; for ratios 1, subtraction increases the value.

Example 1.6: Homogeneous Polynomial Invariance & Scale Cancellation

Two real variables aa and bb satisfy the linear relation (5a+2b):(3a+4b)=9:8(5a + 2b) : (3a + 4b) = 9 : 8. Without solving for the individual magnitudes of aa and bb, determine the exact numerical value of the homogeneous expression:

E=3a2−2ab+b22a2+ab−b2E = \frac{3a^2 - 2ab + b^2}{2a^2 + ab - b^2}

Show solution

We can exploit the property that homogeneous algebraic fractions depend solely on the ratio of the variables, not their absolute magnitudes.

Step 1: Extract the ratio a:ba : b

Given:

5a+2b3a+4b=98\frac{5a + 2b}{3a + 4b} = \frac{9}{8}

Cross-multiply:

8(5a+2b)=9(3a+4b)8(5a + 2b) = 9(3a + 4b)

40a+16b=27a+36b40a + 16b = 27a + 36b

Collect like terms:

40a−27a=36b−16b40a - 27a = 36b - 16b

13a=20b  ⟹  ab=201313a = 20b \implies \frac{a}{b} = \frac{20}{13}

Step 2: Homogeneous Degree Division

Notice that every term in both the numerator and denominator of EE has degree 22 (a2,ab,b2a^2, ab, b^2). Divide both numerator and denominator by b2b^2:

E=3a2b2−2abb2+b2b22a2b2+abb2−b2b2=3(ab)2−2(ab)+12(ab)2+(ab)−1E = \frac{\frac{3a^2}{b^2} - \frac{2ab}{b^2} + \frac{b^2}{b^2}}{\frac{2a^2}{b^2} + \frac{ab}{b^2} - \frac{b^2}{b^2}} = \frac{3\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)^2 - 2\left(\frac{a}{b}\right) + 1}{2\left(\frac{a}{b}\right)^2 + \left(\frac{a}{b}\right) - 1}

Step 3: Substitute ab=2013\frac{a}{b} = \frac{20}{13}

Let u=ab=2013u = \frac{a}{b} = \frac{20}{13}. Then u2=400169u^2 = \frac{400}{169}.

  • Numerator:

    N=3(400169)−2(2013)+1=1200−40×13+169169=1200−520+169169=849169N = 3\left(\frac{400}{169}\right) - 2\left(\frac{20}{13}\right) + 1 = \frac{1200 - 40 \times 13 + 169}{169} = \frac{1200 - 520 + 169}{169} = \frac{849}{169}

  • Denominator:

    D=2(400169)+2013−1=800+20×13−169169=800+260−169169=891169D = 2\left(\frac{400}{169}\right) + \frac{20}{13} - 1 = \frac{800 + 20 \times 13 - 169}{169} = \frac{800 + 260 - 169}{169} = \frac{891}{169}

Step 4: Compute the final quotient

E=849/169891/169=849891E = \frac{849 / 169}{891 / 169} = \frac{849}{891}

Both numbers are divisible by 33 (sum of digits 8+4+9=218+4+9=21, 8+9+1=188+9+1=18):

E=849÷3891÷3=283297E = \frac{849 \div 3}{891 \div 3} = \frac{283}{297}

Takeaway: In any homogeneous algebraic fraction, divide by the highest power of the denominator variable to evaluate using the single ratio value directly.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

Let aa and bb be positive integers such that a:b=3:7a : b = 3 : 7. A positive integer kk is added to both terms of the ratio, increasing its value by 114\frac{1}{14}. If another kk is subsequently added to both terms of the resulting ratio (so that the terms become a+2ka + 2k and b+2kb + 2k), by how much does the ratio increase in this second step?

  1. A

    118\frac{1}{18}

  2. B

    563\frac{5}{63}

  3. C

    121\frac{1}{21}

  4. D

    227\frac{2}{27}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) 1/18

Let a=3ma = 3m and b=7mb = 7m for some positive integer mm.

By the addition drift formula, Δ1=a+kb+k−ab=k(b−a)b(b+k)=4km7m(7m+k)=4k7(7m+k)\Delta_1 = \frac{a+k}{b+k} - \frac{a}{b} = \frac{k(b-a)}{b(b+k)} = \frac{4km}{7m(7m+k)} = \frac{4k}{7(7m+k)}.

Given Δ1=114\Delta_1 = \frac{1}{14}, we have 4k7(7m+k)=114  ⟹  8k=7m+k  ⟹  k=m\frac{4k}{7(7m+k)} = \frac{1}{14} \implies 8k = 7m+k \implies k = m.

With k=mk = m, the intermediate ratio is a+kb+k=4m8m=12\frac{a+k}{b+k} = \frac{4m}{8m} = \frac{1}{2}, and the subsequent ratio is a+2kb+2k=5m9m=59\frac{a+2k}{b+2k} = \frac{5m}{9m} = \frac{5}{9}.

The second incremental increase is a+2kb+2k−a+kb+k=59−12=118\frac{a+2k}{b+2k} - \frac{a+k}{b+k} = \frac{5}{9} - \frac{1}{2} = \frac{1}{18}.

Question 2 · CAT Level

In a multinational software enterprise, the headcount across four engineering units AA, BB, CC, and DD initially satisfies the pairwise ratios A:B=3:4A : B = 3 : 4, B:C=6:7B : C = 6 : 7, and C:D=14:15C : D = 14 : 15. During an organizational restructuring, xx engineers transfer from unit BB to unit AA, and 2x2x engineers transfer from unit DD to unit CC. As a result, the ratio of employees in AA to BB becomes 4:54 : 5. If the total headcount of the enterprise is known to lie strictly between 650650 and 850850, what is the final headcount of unit CC?

  1. A

    210

  2. B

    215

  3. C

    220

  4. D

    225

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 220

Unifying the 4-tier chain using pivot LCMs: A:B=9:12A : B = 9 : 12, B:C=12:14B : C = 12 : 14, and C:D=14:15C : D = 14 : 15, yielding A:B:C:D=9:12:14:15A : B : C : D = 9 : 12 : 14 : 15.

Let initial headcounts be 9k,12k,14k,15k9k, 12k, 14k, 15k, giving total headcount N=50kN = 50k.

After transfers, the ratio of AA to BB is 9k+x12k−x=45  ⟹  45k+5x=48k−4x  ⟹  k=3x\frac{9k + x}{12k - x} = \frac{4}{5} \implies 45k + 5x = 48k - 4x \implies k = 3x.

Total headcount is N=50(3x)=150xN = 50(3x) = 150x. Given 650<150x<850650 < 150x < 850, integer x=5x = 5, which implies k=15k = 15.

Unit CC initially had 14k=14(15)=21014k = 14(15) = 210 engineers, and receives 2x=102x = 10 incoming transfers.

Therefore, the final headcount of unit CC is 210+10=220210 + 10 = 220.

Question 3 · CAT Level

Let xx and yy be positive real numbers with x>yx > y. The compounded ratio of (x+y):(x−y)(x + y) : (x - y) and (x2+y2):(x2−y2)(x^2 + y^2) : (x^2 - y^2) is equal to 5:25 : 2. What is the value of x3−y3x3+y3\frac{x^3 - y^3}{x^3 + y^3}?

  1. A

    1314\frac{13}{14}

  2. B

    79\frac{7}{9}

  3. C

    2527\frac{25}{27}

  4. D

    45\frac{4}{5}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) 13/14

The compounded ratio is x+yx−y×x2+y2x2−y2=x+yx−y×x2+y2(x−y)(x+y)=x2+y2(x−y)2=52\frac{x+y}{x-y} \times \frac{x^2+y^2}{x^2-y^2} = \frac{x+y}{x-y} \times \frac{x^2+y^2}{(x-y)(x+y)} = \frac{x^2+y^2}{(x-y)^2} = \frac{5}{2}.

Setting r=xy>1r = \frac{x}{y} > 1 and dividing numerator and denominator by y2y^2 gives r2+1(r−1)2=52\frac{r^2+1}{(r-1)^2} = \frac{5}{2}.

Cross-multiplying yields 2(r2+1)=5(r2−2r+1)  ⟹  3r2−10r+3=0  ⟹  (3r−1)(r−3)=02(r^2+1) = 5(r^2-2r+1) \implies 3r^2 - 10r + 3 = 0 \implies (3r-1)(r-3) = 0.

Since x>y>0x > y > 0, we have r>1r > 1, which uniquely fixes r=3r = 3.

Evaluating the homogeneous target expression: x3−y3x3+y3=r3−1r3+1=27−127+1=2628=1314\frac{x^3-y^3}{x^3+y^3} = \frac{r^3-1}{r^3+1} = \frac{27-1}{27+1} = \frac{26}{28} = \frac{13}{14}.

Question 4 · CAT Level

Two positive numbers aa and bb initially satisfy a:b=5:8a : b = 5 : 8. When a positive value xx is subtracted from both numbers, their ratio becomes equal to the sub-duplicate ratio of 1:41 : 4. If c⋅xc \cdot x is instead added to both original numbers such that their ratio becomes 5:65 : 6, what is the value of the integer multiplier cc?

  1. A

    3

  2. B

    4

  3. C

    5

  4. D

    6

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 5

Let a=5ma = 5m and b=8mb = 8m for m>0m > 0. The sub-duplicate ratio of 1:41 : 4 is 1:4=1:2\sqrt{1} : \sqrt{4} = 1 : 2.

From the subtraction condition: 5m−x8m−x=12  ⟹  2(5m−x)=8m−x  ⟹  10m−2x=8m−x  ⟹  x=2m\frac{5m - x}{8m - x} = \frac{1}{2} \implies 2(5m - x) = 8m - x \implies 10m - 2x = 8m - x \implies x = 2m.

Adding c⋅x=2cmc \cdot x = 2cm to both original numbers yields the ratio: 5m+2cm8m+2cm=5+2c8+2c=56\frac{5m + 2cm}{8m + 2cm} = \frac{5 + 2c}{8 + 2c} = \frac{5}{6}.

Cross-multiplying gives 6(5+2c)=5(8+2c)  ⟹  30+12c=40+10c6(5 + 2c) = 5(8 + 2c) \implies 30 + 12c = 40 + 10c.

Simplifying yields 2c=10  ⟹  c=52c = 10 \implies c = 5.

Question 5 · CAT Level

Let a,b,a, b, and cc be positive real numbers with a<ba < b. Three ratios are defined by successive additions of cc:

R1=a+cb+c,R2=a+2cb+2c,andR3=a+3cb+3cR_1 = \frac{a+c}{b+c}, \quad R_2 = \frac{a+2c}{b+2c}, \quad \text{and} \quad R_3 = \frac{a+3c}{b+3c}

If R1=57R_1 = \frac{5}{7} and R3=79R_3 = \frac{7}{9}, what is the exact value of R2R_2?

  1. A

    34\frac{3}{4}

  2. B

    1723\frac{17}{23}

  3. C

    2331\frac{23}{31}

  4. D

    1115\frac{11}{15}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (A) 3/4

From R1=a+cb+c=57R_1 = \frac{a+c}{b+c} = \frac{5}{7}, cross-multiplying yields 7(a+c)=5(b+c)  ⟹  5b−7a=2c7(a+c) = 5(b+c) \implies 5b - 7a = 2c.

From R3=a+3cb+3c=79R_3 = \frac{a+3c}{b+3c} = \frac{7}{9}, cross-multiplying yields 9(a+3c)=7(b+3c)  ⟹  7b−9a=6c9(a+3c) = 7(b+3c) \implies 7b - 9a = 6c.

Multiplying the first equation by 33 gives 15b−21a=6c15b - 21a = 6c. Equating this to 7b−9a7b - 9a gives 8b=12a  ⟹  b=32a8b = 12a \implies b = \frac{3}{2}a.

Substituting b=32ab = \frac{3}{2}a into 2c=5b−7a2c = 5b - 7a yields 2c=152a−7a=12a  ⟹  a=4c2c = \frac{15}{2}a - 7a = \frac{1}{2}a \implies a = 4c and b=6cb = 6c.

Substituting a=4ca = 4c and b=6cb = 6c into R2R_2: R2=a+2cb+2c=4c+2c6c+2c=6c8c=34R_2 = \frac{a+2c}{b+2c} = \frac{4c+2c}{6c+2c} = \frac{6c}{8c} = \frac{3}{4}.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library