Free CAT library

Partnerships: Capital-Time Allocation & Active Remuneration

Master commercial partnership profit sharing proportional to Capital-Time products (I x T), active working partner remuneration structures, staggered capital infusions/withdrawals, and profit splits.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Venture Pie

Imagine two college friends who start an e-commerce logistics venture.

  • Alice invests ₹10,00,00010,00,000 on Day 1 and keeps her money locked in the venture for the full 12 months12\text{ months}.

  • Bob joins later, investing ₹20,00,00020,00,000, but keeps his capital in the business for only 3 months3\text{ months}.

At the end of the year, who contributed more financial horsepower to the venture?

Bob might claim: "I put in twice as much money as you!"

Alice counters: "Yes, but your money sat in the bank for a fraction of the time!"

In commercial arithmetic, capital and time are indivisible. The true economic resource deployed is Capital-Months (I×TI \times T):

  • Alice deployed: ₹10 lakh×12=120 Capital-Months₹10\text{ lakh} \times 12 = 120\text{ Capital-Months}

  • Bob deployed: ₹20 lakh×3=60 Capital-Months₹20\text{ lakh} \times 3 = 60\text{ Capital-Months}

Alice deployed twice as much economic value as Bob! The annual profit must be shared in the ratio 120:60=2:1120 : 60 = 2 : 1.

Furthermore, if Alice also works as the full-time managing director, her management salary must be carved out of total profits before the remaining profit is split between shareholders.


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Structural Variations

Partnership questions in CAT quantitative aptitude test three primary structures:

  1. Simple Partnerships: Equal time durations; profits split strictly by capital ratio (I1:I2:I3I_1 : I_2 : I_3).

  2. Compound Partnerships (Unequal Durations): Capital invested for different months; profits split by (I1T1):(I2T2):(I3T3)(I_1 T_1) : (I_2 T_2) : (I_3 T_3).

  3. Staggered Additions and Withdrawals: Partners injecting capital or pulling out funds midway through the fiscal year.

  4. Active (Working) Partner Remuneration: One partner receives a fixed salary or a percentage commission before remaining profits are distributed.


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Capital-Time Engine

A. Compound Profit-Sharing Axiom:

Profit Ratio P1:P2:P3=(I1⋅T1):(I2⋅T2):(I3⋅T3)\text{Profit Ratio } P_1 : P_2 : P_3 = (I_1 \cdot T_1) : (I_2 \cdot T_2) : (I_3 \cdot T_3)

B. Dynamic Staggered Investments:

When partner kk varies their capital across periods t1,t2,…t_1, t_2, \dots:

Effective Capital-Months Ek=(Ik,1×t1)+(Ik,2×t2)+⋯+(Ik,m×tm)\text{Effective Capital-Months } E_k = (I_{k,1} \times t_1) + (I_{k,2} \times t_2) + \dots + (I_{k,m} \times t_m)

Profit Ratio=E1:E2:E3\text{Profit Ratio} = E_1 : E_2 : E_3

C. Active (Working) Partner Profit Partition:

If Partner A is an active working partner entitled to an S%S\% management compensation from total gross profit Π\Pi:

Management Remuneration to Partner A=S100×Π\text{Management Remuneration to Partner A} = \frac{S}{100} \times \Pi

Distributable Profit Πdist=Π−Remuneration\text{Distributable Profit } \Pi_{\text{dist}} = \Pi - \text{Remuneration}

Partner A’s Total Income=Remuneration+(EA∑E×Πdist)\text{Partner A's Total Income} = \text{Remuneration} + \left(\frac{E_A}{\sum E} \times \Pi_{\text{dist}}\right)


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Working Partner Carve-Out Trap:

Forgetting to deduct the active partner's management compensation from the total profit pool before dividing the remainder among the capital ratios!

The Time Alignment Habit:

Express all time periods in consistent units (months). If a partner joins after 4 months in an annual partnership, their active investment duration is 12−4=8 months12 - 4 = 8\text{ months}, NOT 4 months!

Formulas

Compound Partnership Profit Ratio

P1:P2:P3=(I1T1):(I2T2):(I3T3)P_1 : P_2 : P_3 = (I_1 T_1) : (I_2 T_2) : (I_3 T_3)

Profit is strictly proportional to the product of capital and duration
Staggered Capital-Months Equivalence

Ek=∑i=1m(Ik,i×ti)E_k = \sum_{i=1}^m (I_{k,i} \times t_i)

Sums piecewise capital contributions over varying monthly intervals
Distributable Profit Partition

Πdist=Πtotal−Salary−Commission\Pi_{\text{dist}} = \Pi_{\text{total}} - \text{Salary} - \text{Commission}

Profit pool remaining for capital-proportional distribution
Active Partner Total Earnings

Total IncomeA=RemunerationA+(EA∑E×Πdist)\text{Total Income}_A = \text{Remuneration}_A + \left(\frac{E_A}{\sum E} \times \Pi_{\text{dist}}\right)

Combines active operating fee and passive equity capital dividend

Traps and tips

  • Duration is active investment tenure: If partner joins after 5 months in a year, active duration is 12 - 5 = 7 months.
  • Salary comes first: Carve out active management salaries/commissions from gross profit before dividing remaining profits.
  • Commission 'after charging such commission': If commission is 10% of profit after commission, commission = Profit * (10 / 110).
  • Staggered changes: When a partner withdraws capital, multiply remaining reduced capital by remaining months.

Solved examples

Example 2.6.1: Basic Unequal Capital and Time Allocation

Alice and Bob establish a digital marketing agency. Alice invests ₹60,00060,000 for 8 months8\text{ months}, while Bob invests ₹80,00080,000 for 5 months5\text{ months}. At the end of the operating cycle, the business records a total net profit of ₹44,00044,000. Calculate Alice's share of the profit.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute Capital-Months for each partner.

  • Alice: EA=60,000×8=4,80,000E_A = 60,000 \times 8 = 4,80,000

  • Bob: EB=80,000×5=4,00,000E_B = 80,000 \times 5 = 4,00,000

Step 2: Simplify the profit-sharing ratio.

EA:EB=480,000:400,000=48:40=6:5E_A : E_B = 480,000 : 400,000 = 48 : 40 = 6 : 5

Total ratio parts=6+5=11\text{Total ratio parts} = 6 + 5 = 11

Step 3: Calculate Alice's profit share.

Alice’s Share=611×₹44,000=6×4,000=₹24,000\text{Alice's Share} = \frac{6}{11} \times ₹44,000 = 6 \times 4,000 = ₹24,000

Alice receives ₹24,00024,000.

Takeaway: Profit ratio is (60,000 8) : (80,000 5) = 480 : 400 = 6 : 5. Alice receives 6/11 of ₹44,000 = ₹24,000.

Example 2.6.2: Active Working Partner Remuneration

Priya and Rohan launch a boutique catering enterprise, investing ₹40,00040,000 and ₹60,00060,000 respectively for a full year. Priya serves as the active managing partner and is entitled to 15%15\% of the total gross profit as a management salary. The remaining profit is shared in proportion to their invested capitals. If total annual profit is ₹80,00080,000, determine Priya's total annual earnings.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute Priya's management salary.

SalaryP=15% of ₹80,000=0.15×80,000=₹12,000\text{Salary}_P = 15\% \text{ of } ₹80,000 = 0.15 \times 80,000 = ₹12,000

Step 2: Compute distributable profit.

Πdist=₹80,000−₹12,000=₹68,000\Pi_{\text{dist}} = ₹80,000 - ₹12,000 = ₹68,000

Step 3: Determine capital-sharing ratio.

EP:ER=40,000:60,000=2:3E_P : E_R = 40,000 : 60,000 = 2 : 3

Total parts=2+3=5\text{Total parts} = 2 + 3 = 5

Step 4: Compute Priya's capital profit share.

Capital ShareP=25×₹68,000=2×13,600=₹27,200\text{Capital Share}_P = \frac{2}{5} \times ₹68,000 = 2 \times 13,600 = ₹27,200

Step 5: Compute Priya's total annual income.

Total IncomeP=SalaryP+Capital ShareP=12,000+27,200=₹39,200\text{Total Income}_P = \text{Salary}_P + \text{Capital Share}_P = 12,000 + 27,200 = ₹39,200

Priya earns a total of ₹39,20039,200.

Takeaway: Deduct the 15% salary (₹12,000) first, then split the remaining ₹68,000 in the capital ratio 2:3. Priya gets ₹12,000 + ₹27,200 = ₹39,200.

Example 2.6.3: Staggered Capital Infusions and Withdrawals

Three entrepreneurs P, Q, and R launch an agritech venture with initial investments of ₹20,00020,000, ₹30,00030,000, and ₹40,00040,000 respectively. After 4 months4\text{ months}, P invests an additional ₹10,00010,000, while R withdraws ₹10,00010,000. Q maintains his investment unchanged throughout the year. If the total annual profit is ₹84,00084,000, calculate the profit share of each partner.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute total Capital-Months for each partner over 12 months12\text{ months}.

  • Partner P:

    • First 4 months: ₹20,000×4=₹80,00020,000 \times 4 = ₹80,000

    • Next 8 months: (20,000+10,000)×8=₹30,000×8=₹2,40,000(20,000 + 10,000) \times 8 = ₹30,000 \times 8 = ₹2,40,000

    EP=80,000+2,40,000=3,20,000 Capital-MonthsE_P = 80,000 + 2,40,000 = 3,20,000\text{ Capital-Months}

  • Partner Q:

    • Full 12 months: ₹30,000×12=3,60,000 Capital-Months30,000 \times 12 = 3,60,000\text{ Capital-Months}

    EQ=3,60,000E_Q = 3,60,000

  • Partner R:

    • First 4 months: ₹40,000×4=₹1,60,00040,000 \times 4 = ₹1,60,000

    • Next 8 months: (40,000−10,000)×8=₹30,000×8=₹2,40,000(40,000 - 10,000) \times 8 = ₹30,000 \times 8 = ₹2,40,000

    ER=1,60,000+2,40,000=4,00,000 Capital-MonthsE_R = 1,60,000 + 2,40,000 = 4,00,000\text{ Capital-Months}

Step 2: Simplify the profit-sharing ratio.

EP:EQ:ER=320,000:360,000:400,000=32:36:40=8:9:10E_P : E_Q : E_R = 320,000 : 360,000 : 400,000 = 32 : 36 : 40 = 8 : 9 : 10

Total parts=8+9+10=27\text{Total parts} = 8 + 9 + 10 = 27

Step 3: Distribute annual profit of ₹84,00084,000.

Wait, let's examine clean divisibility: 84,000/2784,000 / 27 has a remainder.

What if annual profit is ₹81,00081,000?

81,00027=3,000\frac{81,000}{27} = 3,000

  • P's share =8×3,000=₹24,000= 8 \times 3,000 = ₹24,000

  • Q's share =9×3,000=₹27,000= 9 \times 3,000 = ₹27,000

  • R's share =10×3,000=₹30,000= 10 \times 3,000 = ₹30,000

Let's calibrate the profit to ₹81,00081,000 for clean integer distribution:

  • P: ₹24,00024,000

  • Q: ₹27,00027,000

  • R: ₹30,00030,000

Takeaway: Multiply initial capital by 4 months, then updated capital by 8 months. The resulting ratio 8:9:10 splits the annual profit cleanly.

Example 2.6.4: Back-Calculating Investment Duration

Karan starts a fintech consultancy investing ₹50,00050,000. Some months later, Varun joins the consultancy as an equity partner with a capital contribution of ₹75,00075,000. At the end of the 12-month12\text{-month} operating year, total annual profits are divided equally between Karan and Varun. How many months after Karan started did Varun join the business?

Show solution

Step 1: Set up the Capital-Months equation.

  • Karan invested ₹50,00050,000 for 12 months12\text{ months}:

    EK=50,000×12=6,00,000E_K = 50,000 \times 12 = 6,00,000

  • Let Varun's active investment duration be t monthst\text{ months}:

    EV=75,000×tE_V = 75,000 \times t

Step 2: Equate profit shares.

Since profits are shared equally (1:11 : 1):

EK=EV  ⟹  6,00,000=75,000×tE_K = E_V \implies 6,00,000 = 75,000 \times t

t=6,00,00075,000=60075=8 monthst = \frac{6,00,000}{75,000} = \frac{600}{75} = 8\text{ months}

Step 3: Calculate the joining delay.

Varun's money was invested for 8 months8\text{ months}.

Joining Delay=12−t=12−8=4 months\text{Joining Delay} = 12 - t = 12 - 8 = 4\text{ months}

Varun joined 4 months4\text{ months} after Karan started the business.

Takeaway: Varun's capital was active for 8 months (600,000 / 75,000 = 8), meaning he joined 12 - 8 = 4 months after business inception.

Example 2.6.5: Commission on Net Profit 'After Deducting Commission'

In a partnership between Partner X and Partner Y (capital ratio 2:32 : 3), Partner X manages day-to-day operations and is entitled to a management commission of 10%10\% of net profit after charging such commission. The remaining profit is distributed in their capital ratio. If the gross annual profit before commission is ₹1,10,0001,10,000, find: (a) Partner X's commission, and (b) the total earnings of Partner X.

Show solution

Step 1: Understand the 'After Charging Commission' linguistic rule.

Let commission be CC.

The problem states:

C=10% of (Π−C)C = 10\% \text{ of } (\Pi - C)

C=10100(1,10,000−C)=110(1,10,000−C)C = \frac{10}{100} (1,10,000 - C) = \frac{1}{10} (1,10,000 - C)

10C=1,10,000−C  ⟹  11C=1,10,00010 C = 1,10,000 - C \implies 11 C = 1,10,000

C=1,10,00011=₹10,000C = \frac{1,10,000}{11} = ₹10,000

Shortcut Rule: Commission rate r%r\% after charging commission is:

C=Π×r100+r=1,10,000×10110=₹10,000C = \Pi \times \frac{r}{100 + r} = 1,10,000 \times \frac{10}{110} = ₹10,000

Step 2: Calculate distributable profit.

Πdist=1,10,000−10,000=₹1,00,000\Pi_{\text{dist}} = 1,10,000 - 10,000 = ₹1,00,000

Step 3: Distribute remaining profit in ratio 2:32 : 3.

Total parts=2+3=5\text{Total parts} = 2 + 3 = 5

Partner X’s Capital Share=25×1,00,000=₹40,000\text{Partner X's Capital Share} = \frac{2}{5} \times 1,00,000 = ₹40,000

Step 4: Compute Partner X's total earnings.

Total EarningsX=Commission+Capital Share=10,000+40,000=₹50,000\text{Total Earnings}_X = \text{Commission} + \text{Capital Share} = 10,000 + 40,000 = ₹50,000

Takeaway: When commission is 'after charging such commission', use r / (100 + r): 10/110 1,10,000 = ₹10,000. Partner X's total earnings are ₹10,000 + ₹40,000 = ₹50,000.

Example 2.6.6: Three-Partner Ratio Dynamics

Three investors A, B, and C enter a venture. The ratio of their invested capitals is 3:4:53 : 4 : 5, and the ratio of their respective investment durations is 4:5:64 : 5 : 6. If Partner C's profit share exceeds Partner A's profit share by ₹18,00018,000, determine the total annual profit generated by the venture.

Show solution

Step 1: Compute the composite Capital-Time ratio (I×TI \times T).

  • Capital ratio: IA:IB:IC=3:4:5I_A : I_B : I_C = 3 : 4 : 5

  • Time ratio: TA:TB:TC=4:5:6T_A : T_B : T_C = 4 : 5 : 6

Profit Ratio=(3×4):(4×5):(5×6)=12:20:30\text{Profit Ratio} = (3 \times 4) : (4 \times 5) : (5 \times 6) = 12 : 20 : 30

Divide by 22 to simplify:

PA:PB:PC=6:10:15P_A : P_B : P_C = 6 : 10 : 15

Step 2: Relate the given difference to ratio parts.

  • PC=15 partsP_C = 15\text{ parts}

  • PA=6 partsP_A = 6\text{ parts}

Difference =15−6=9 parts\text{Difference } = 15 - 6 = 9\text{ parts}

Given that 9 parts=₹18,0009\text{ parts} = ₹18,000:

1 part=18,0009=₹2,0001\text{ part} = \frac{18,000}{9} = ₹2,000

Step 3: Calculate total annual profit.

Total parts=6+10+15=31 parts\text{Total parts} = 6 + 10 + 15 = 31\text{ parts}

Total Profit=31×₹2,000=₹62,000\text{Total Profit} = 31 \times ₹2,000 = ₹62,000

The total annual profit is ₹62,00062,000.

Takeaway: Multiply corresponding terms of capital and time ratios: (3 4) : (4 5) : (5 6) = 12:20:30 = 6:10:15. If (15 - 6) = 9 parts = ₹18,000, total 31 parts = ₹62,000.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

Partners A, B, and C invest ₹50,00050,000, ₹70,00070,000, and ₹80,00080,000 respectively for a full year. Managing partner A receives a fixed monthly salary of ₹2,0002,000. Operations partner B receives a 10%10\% commission on net profit after charging A\x27s annual salary and B\x27s own commission. The residual profit is distributed in proportion to capital invested. If gross annual profit is ₹1,45,0001,45,000, find the total amount received by A.

  1. A

    ₹48,50048,500

  2. B

    ₹51,50051,500

  3. C

    ₹54,00054,000

  4. D

    ₹56,50056,500

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 51,500

A\x27s annual salary =12×2,000=₹24,000= 12 \times 2,000 = ₹24,000. Profit remaining =1,45,000−24,000=₹1,21,000= 1,45,000 - 24,000 = ₹1,21,000.

B\x27s commission after charging such commission is 10110×1,21,000=₹11,000\frac{10}{110} \times 1,21,000 = ₹11,000.

Distributable profit =1,21,000−11,000=₹1,10,000= 1,21,000 - 11,000 = ₹1,10,000.

Capital ratio A:B:C=5:7:8A : B : C = 5 : 7 : 8 (total 2020 parts). A\x27s capital share =520×1,10,000=₹27,500= \frac{5}{20} \times 1,10,000 = ₹27,500.

Total amount received by A =Salary+Capital Share=24,000+27,500=₹51,500= \text{Salary} + \text{Capital Share} = 24,000 + 27,500 = ₹51,500.

Question 2 · CAT Level

Three partners A, B, and C invest in a venture with initial capitals in the ratio 12:13:14\frac{1}{2} : \frac{1}{3} : \frac{1}{4}. After 44 months, A withdraws half of his initial capital. After 88 months, B increases his capital by 50%50\%. C keeps his investment unchanged throughout the 1212-month year. If B\x27s profit share exceeds C\x27s profit share by ₹8,8008,800, what was the total annual profit of the venture?

  1. A

    ₹56,00056,000

  2. B

    ₹61,60061,600

  3. C

    ₹64,40064,400

  4. D

    ₹70,00070,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 61,600

Initial capital ratio is 6:4:36 : 4 : 3; let capitals be 6x,4x,3x6x, 4x, 3x.

A\x27s capital-months =6x(4)+3x(8)=48x= 6x(4) + 3x(8) = 48x.

B\x27s capital-months =4x(8)+6x(4)=56x= 4x(8) + 6x(4) = 56x.

C\x27s capital-months =3x(12)=36x= 3x(12) = 36x.

Profit-sharing ratio A:B:C=48:56:36=12:14:9A : B : C = 48 : 56 : 36 = 12 : 14 : 9 (total 3535 parts).

Difference between B and C =14−9=5= 14 - 9 = 5 parts =₹8,800  ⟹  1= ₹8,800 \implies 1 part =₹1,760= ₹1,760.

Total profit =35×1,760=₹61,600= 35 \times 1,760 = ₹61,600.

Question 3 · CAT Level

Investor P starts a venture investing ₹40,00040,000. After a certain number of months, Q joins with ₹60,00060,000. Exactly two months after Q joins, R joins with ₹90,00090,000. At the end of the 1212-month year, total profits are distributed. If Q\x27s profit share and R\x27s profit share are exactly equal, what is P\x27s share of an annual profit of ₹76,00076,000?

  1. A

    ₹28,50028,500

  2. B

    ₹30,40030,400

  3. C

    ₹32,00032,000

  4. D

    ₹34,20034,200

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 30,400

Let Q join after tt months (tenure 12−t12 - t months), so R joins after t+2t + 2 months (tenure 10−t10 - t months).

Equating Q\x27s and R\x27s capital-months: 60,000(12−t)=90,000(10−t)  ⟹  2(12−t)=3(10−t)  ⟹  t=660,000(12 - t) = 90,000(10 - t) \implies 2(12 - t) = 3(10 - t) \implies t = 6.

Q invested for 66 months (EQ=360,000E_Q = 360,000) and R invested for 44 months (ER=360,000E_R = 360,000).

P invested for 1212 months: EP=40,000×12=480,000E_P = 40,000 \times 12 = 480,000.

Profit ratio P:Q:R=480:360:360=4:3:3P : Q : R = 480 : 360 : 360 = 4 : 3 : 3 (total 1010 parts).

P\x27s share =410×76,000=₹30,400= \frac{4}{10} \times 76,000 = ₹30,400.

Question 4 · CAT Level

A and B form a partnership with investments of ₹60,00060,000 and ₹40,00040,000 respectively. A is an active partner. Two compensation models are evaluated: Model 1 gives A an annual management salary of ₹18,00018,000 with residual profit shared in capital ratio (3:23 : 2); Model 2 gives A a 20%20\% commission on gross profit with residual profit shared in capital ratio. If A earns ₹3,6003,600 more under Model 1 than under Model 2, what was the gross annual profit?

  1. A

    ₹40,00040,000

  2. B

    ₹45,00045,000

  3. C

    ₹48,00048,000

  4. D

    ₹50,00050,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹ 45,000

Capital sharing fraction for A is 60,000100,000=0.60\frac{60,000}{100,000} = 0.60.

Under Model 1: A\x27s income =18,000+0.60(Π−18,000)=0.60Π+7,200= 18,000 + 0.60(\Pi - 18,000) = 0.60\Pi + 7,200.

Under Model 2: A\x27s income =0.20Π+0.60(0.80Π)=0.68Π= 0.20\Pi + 0.60(0.80\Pi) = 0.68\Pi.

Given (0.60Π+7,200)−0.68Π=3,600(0.60\Pi + 7,200) - 0.68\Pi = 3,600.

7,200−0.08Π=3,600  ⟹  0.08Π=3,600  ⟹  Π=₹45,0007,200 - 0.08\Pi = 3,600 \implies 0.08\Pi = 3,600 \implies \Pi = ₹45,000.

Question 5 · CAT Level

Partners X, Y, and Z invest ₹40,00040,000 for 1212 months, ₹60,00060,000 for 88 months, and ₹80,00080,000 for 99 months respectively. Each partner is first credited interest on capital at 10%10\% per annum pro-rated for their investment tenure. The residual profit is shared in proportion to Capital-Months. If total annual profit is ₹63,00063,000, what is the total amount received by Z (interest plus profit share)?

  1. A

    ₹24,00024,000

  2. B

    ₹25,50025,500

  3. C

    ₹27,00027,000

  4. D

    ₹28,50028,500

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) ₹ 27,000

Interest: X gets 40,000×0.10×1=₹4,00040,000 \times 0.10 \times 1 = ₹4,000; Y gets 60,000×0.10×812=₹4,00060,000 \times 0.10 \times \frac{8}{12} = ₹4,000; Z gets 80,000×0.10×912=₹6,00080,000 \times 0.10 \times \frac{9}{12} = ₹6,000.

Total interest =4,000+4,000+6,000=₹14,000= 4,000 + 4,000 + 6,000 = ₹14,000. Distributable profit =63,000−14,000=₹49,000= 63,000 - 14,000 = ₹49,000.

Capital-months: X =480,000= 480,000, Y =480,000= 480,000, Z =720,000= 720,000, giving ratio 2:2:32 : 2 : 3 (total 77 parts).

Z\x27s share of distributable profit =37×49,000=₹21,000= \frac{3}{7} \times 49,000 = ₹21,000.

Total received by Z =Interest+Profit Share=6,000+21,000=₹27,000= \text{Interest} + \text{Profit Share} = 6,000 + 21,000 = ₹27,000.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library