Free CAT library

Stocks, Shares, Dividends & Investment Yields

Master the financial arithmetic of Face Value, Market Value at premium or discount, dividend distributions strictly on Face Value, brokerage costs, and comparative investment yields.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Company vs. The Exchange

Imagine you purchase a rare gold coin with a statutory face value of ₹100100 stamped onto its metal by the government mint. If you visit a bustling collector's bazaar, collectors might bid ₹150150 for that coin because of high demand, or ₹8080 during a market panic.

Now, imagine the government declares an annual loyalty bonus of 10%10\% on all official coins. Which value does the government base its bonus check on?

Strictly the stamped ₹100 face value! The government does not know—and does not care—what price changed hands between collectors in the bazaar!

In the corporate world:

  • The Face Value (FVFV) is the immutable birth certificate of the share.

  • The Market Value (MVMV) is the volatile trading price on the secondary stock exchange.

  • The Dividend is declared and paid strictly as a percentage of the Face Value!


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Vocabulary of Shares

Quantitative Aptitude problems involving shares and dividends adhere to rigid commercial conventions:

A. Nomenclature:

  • Face Value (FVFV / Par Value / Nominal Value): Usually standardized to ₹100100 (or ₹1010, ₹5050). Immutable unless an official stock split occurs.

  • Market Value (MVMV): The secondary market acquisition price per share.

    • At Par: MV=FVMV = FV.

    • At Premium (Above Par): MV=FV+PremiumMV = FV + \text{Premium} (E.g., ₹100 share at 20%20\% premium trades at MV=₹120MV = ₹120).

    • At Discount (Below Par): MV=FV−DiscountMV = FV - \text{Discount} (E.g., ₹100 share at 15%15\% discount trades at MV=₹85MV = ₹85).

B. The Cardinal Rule of Dividends:

THE CARDINAL DIVIDEND RULE:

Dividends are ALWAYS declared and computed strictly on the FACE VALUE (FVFV), NEVER on the Market Value (MVMV)!

Annual Dividend per Share (Ds)=d%100×FV\text{Annual Dividend per Share } (D_s) = \frac{d\%}{100} \times FV

Total Annual Dividend Income =n×Ds=n×FV×d100\text{Total Annual Dividend Income } = n \times D_s = n \times FV \times \frac{d}{100}

(Where nn is the total number of shares held).


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: Capital Deployment & Yield

A. Number of Shares Acquired (nn):

n=Total Capital InvestedEffective Cost per Sharen = \frac{\text{Total Capital Invested}}{\text{Effective Cost per Share}}

B. The Brokerage Rules (bb):

Brokerage is the commission charged by the broker:

  • When Buying: Effective Cost per Share=MV+b\text{Effective Cost per Share} = MV + b

  • When Selling: Net Realization per Share=MV−b\text{Net Realization per Share} = MV - b

(Unless specified otherwise, brokerage is calculated on the Market Value MVMV).

C. Effective Rate of Return (Investment Yield Y%Y\%):

The true return earned on actual cash deployed from your pocket:

Yield (Y%)=Annual Dividend per ShareEffective Cost per Share×100%=d100×FVMV+b×100%\text{Yield } (Y\%) = \frac{\text{Annual Dividend per Share}}{\text{Effective Cost per Share}} \times 100\% = \frac{\frac{d}{100} \times FV}{MV + b} \times 100\%

The Premium vs. Discount Divergence:

  • Stock bought at a premium (MV>FVMV > FV): Yield<d%\text{Yield} < d\%

  • Stock bought at par (MV=FVMV = FV): Yield=d%\text{Yield} = d\%

  • Stock bought at a discount (MV<FVMV < FV): Yield>d%\text{Yield} > d\%

D. Portfolio Switching / Rebalancing:

When an investor sells shares of Stock A to reinvest the entire net proceeds into Stock B:

Net Proceeds from Stock A=nA×(MVA−bA)\text{Net Proceeds from Stock A} = n_A \times (MV_A - b_A)

nB=Net ProceedsMVB+bBn_B = \frac{\text{Net Proceeds}}{MV_B + b_B}

ΔAnnual Income=Total IncomeB−Total IncomeA\Delta \text{Annual Income} = \text{Total Income}_B - \text{Total Income}_A


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Market Value Dividend Error:

The most frequent error in stock problems is computing the dividend as d%×MVd\% \times MV.

Always pause and verify: Is your calculation anchored to Face Value (FVFV)?

Comparing Investment Attractiveness Directly:

To determine which of two stocks yields higher returns without calculating large portfolios, compare unit yield ratios directly:

Compare d1×FV1MV1vs.d2×FV2MV2\text{Compare } \frac{d_1 \times FV_1}{MV_1} \quad \text{vs.} \quad \frac{d_2 \times FV_2}{MV_2}

Formulas

Annual Dividend per Share

Ds=d100×FVD_s = \frac{d}{100} \times FV

Always evaluated on Face Value (FV), never Market Value (MV)
Total Annual Dividend Income

Dtotal=n×FV×d100D_{\text{total}} = n \times FV \times \frac{d}{100}

Where n is the number of shares held
Effective Acquisition Cost per Share

Cshare=MV+bC_{\text{share}} = MV + b

Brokerage b is added on purchase and subtracted on sale
Effective Rate of Return (Yield)

Y%=DsMV+b×100%=d×FVMV+b%Y\% = \frac{D_s}{MV + b} \times 100\% = \frac{d \times FV}{MV + b}\%

Measures actual percentage return on cash invested

Traps and tips

  • Dividends are NEVER on Market Value: Always multiply declared rate by Face Value.
  • Brokerage direction: ADD brokerage when buying shares; SUBTRACT brokerage when selling shares.
  • Higher dividend rate doesn't mean better yield: A 15% stock trading at 200 offers only 7.5% yield, while a 10% stock at par offers 10% yield.
  • Par value defaults: In Indian exam problems, if Face Value is unstated, standard convention assumes FV = ₹100.

Solved examples

Example 8.1: Fundamental Yield on Premium Shares

An investor purchases shares of a consumer FMCG firm with a Face Value of ₹100100 quoting on the stock exchange at a 40%40\% premium. The company declares an annual dividend of 14%14\%. Assuming zero brokerage, determine the investor's effective annual rate of return (yield) on invested capital.

Show solution

Step 1: Determine Face Value and Market Value.

  • Face Value FV=₹100FV = ₹100

  • Quoting at 40%40\% premium   ⟹  MV=100+40=₹140\implies MV = 100 + 40 = ₹140

Step 2: Calculate the annual dividend per share.

Dividends are calculated strictly on Face Value:

Ds=14% of ₹100=₹14D_s = 14\% \text{ of } ₹100 = ₹14

Step 3: Calculate the effective investment yield (Y%Y\%).

Yield Y%=DsMV×100%=₹14₹140×100%=110×100%=10.0%\text{Yield } Y\% = \frac{D_s}{MV} \times 100\% = \frac{₹14}{₹140} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{10} \times 100\% = 10.0\%

The effective annual yield is 10.0%10.0\%.

Takeaway: Because the share was purchased at a premium (₹140), the effective yield (10%) is lower than the declared dividend rate (14%).

Example 8.2: High Yield on Discounted Shares

Shares of an industrial manufacturing firm having a Face Value of ₹100100 are quoting at a 25%25\% discount on the exchange. The company declares an annual dividend of 9%9\%. Determine: (a) the investor's effective annual yield, and (b) why the yield exceeds the dividend rate.

Show solution

Step 1: Determine Face Value and Market Value.

  • Face Value FV=₹100FV = ₹100

  • Quoting at 25%25\% discount   ⟹  MV=100−25=₹75\implies MV = 100 - 25 = ₹75

Step 2: Calculate the annual dividend per share.

Ds=9% of ₹100=₹9D_s = 9\% \text{ of } ₹100 = ₹9

Step 3: Calculate the effective investment yield.

Yield Y%=DsMV×100%=₹9₹75×100%\text{Yield } Y\% = \frac{D_s}{MV} \times 100\% = \frac{₹9}{₹75} \times 100\%

Divide numerator and denominator by 33:

Y%=325×100%=3×4%=12.0%Y\% = \frac{3}{25} \times 100\% = 3 \times 4\% = 12.0\%

The effective annual yield is 12.0%12.0\%. It exceeds the 9%9\% dividend rate because the investor deployed only ₹7575 to capture the dividend on a ₹100100 face asset.

Takeaway: Buying shares at a discount (below par) magnifies the effective yield: ₹9 dividend on a ₹75 outlay produces a 12% yield.

Example 8.3: Investment with Brokerage Costs

An investor deploys ₹88,00088,000 to purchase shares of a renewable energy firm with a Face Value of ₹100100 paying an annual dividend of 12%12\%. The shares are quoting at ₹108108, and the broker levies a transaction fee of ₹22 per share. Determine: (a) the number of shares acquired, (b) the total annual dividend income, and (c) the effective annual rate of return.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate the effective acquisition cost per share.

Cost per share=MV+b=108+2=₹110\text{Cost per share} = MV + b = 108 + 2 = ₹110

Step 2: Calculate the number of shares acquired (nn).

n=Total Capital InvestedCost per share=₹88,000₹110=800 sharesn = \frac{\text{Total Capital Invested}}{\text{Cost per share}} = \frac{₹88,000}{₹110} = 800\text{ shares}

Step 3: Calculate the annual dividend income.

Dividend is calculated strictly on Face Value (FV=₹100FV = ₹100):

Ds=12% of ₹100=₹12D_s = 12\% \text{ of } ₹100 = ₹12

Total Annual Dividend=n×Ds=800×12=₹9,600\text{Total Annual Dividend} = n \times D_s = 800 \times 12 = ₹9,600

Step 4: Compute the effective yield.

Y%=Total IncomeTotal Investment×100%=₹9,600₹88,000×100%=96880×100%=12110×100%=12011%=10.91%Y\% = \frac{\text{Total Income}}{\text{Total Investment}} \times 100\% = \frac{₹9,600}{₹88,000} \times 100\% = \frac{96}{880} \times 100\% = \frac{12}{110} \times 100\% = \frac{120}{11}\% = 10.91\%

Takeaway: Brokerage must be added to the market price when buying: Effective cost is ₹108 + ₹2 = ₹110 per share.

Example 8.4: Comparative Investment Superiority

An investor seeks to deploy capital into dividend-yielding equities and is choosing between two options (both with Face Value ₹100100):

  • Option A: 15%15\% shares quoting at ₹180180.

  • Option B: 10%10\% shares quoting at ₹110110.

Assuming zero brokerage, determine which option offers a fundamentally superior annual return on invested capital.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate the effective yield of Option A.

  • Dividend DA=15%×100=₹15D_A = 15\% \times 100 = ₹15

  • Market Value MVA=₹180MV_A = ₹180

YA=15180×100%=112×100%=8.33%Y_A = \frac{15}{180} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{12} \times 100\% = 8.33\%

Step 2: Calculate the effective yield of Option B.

  • Dividend DB=10%×100=₹10D_B = 10\% \times 100 = ₹10

  • Market Value MVB=₹110MV_B = ₹110

YB=10110×100%=111×100%=9.09%Y_B = \frac{10}{110} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{11} \times 100\% = 9.09\%

Step 3: Compare yields.

YB(9.09%)>YA(8.33%)Y_B (9.09\%) > Y_A (8.33\%)

Option B offers a superior rate of return, despite advertising a lower nominal dividend rate (10%10\% vs 15%15\%), because its acquisition price is relatively more favorable.

Takeaway: Never choose a stock based on the headline dividend rate alone: 10% stock at ₹110 (9.09% yield) beats a 15% stock at ₹180 (8.33% yield).

Example 8.5: Capital Required for Target Cash Flow

A retiree desires to generate a fixed recurring annual dividend income of ₹24,00024,000 by investing in 16%16\% shares of an infrastructure utility with a Face Value of ₹100100, currently quoting at ₹128128. Assuming zero brokerage, determine the total capital the retiree must invest.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate the dividend earned per share.

Ds=16% of ₹100=₹16D_s = 16\% \text{ of } ₹100 = ₹16

Step 2: Determine the number of shares needed (nn).

n=Target Annual IncomeDs=₹24,000₹16=1,500 sharesn = \frac{\text{Target Annual Income}}{D_s} = \frac{₹24,000}{₹16} = 1,500\text{ shares}

Step 3: Calculate the total capital required.

Capital Required=n×MV=1,500×₹128\text{Capital Required} = n \times MV = 1,500 \times ₹128

1,500×128=1,500×(100+28)=1,50,000+42,000=₹1,92,0001,500 \times 128 = 1,500 \times (100 + 28) = 1,50,000 + 42,000 = ₹1,92,000

The retiree must invest ₹1,92,0001,92,000.

Takeaway: First divide target income by dividend per share (₹24,000 / ₹16 = 1,500 shares), then multiply by the market price (1,500 ₹128 = ₹1,92,000).

Example 8.6: Portfolio Switching & Income Optimization

An investor owns 400400 shares of OldCorp (FV=₹100FV = ₹100) paying an annual dividend of 8%8\%, currently quoting at MV=₹90MV = ₹90. Seeking higher income, she sells all 400400 shares (paying ₹11 brokerage per share on sale) and reinvests the complete net proceeds into NewTech shares (FV=₹50FV = ₹50) paying an annual dividend of 12%12\%, quoting at MV=₹70MV = ₹70 (paying ₹11 brokerage per share on purchase). Calculate the net change in her annual dividend income.

Show solution

Step 1: Calculate the liquidation proceeds from OldCorp.

  • Number of shares =400= 400

  • Market Value =₹90= ₹90, Brokerage on sale =₹1= ₹1

Net Realization per share=MV−b=90−1=₹89\text{Net Realization per share} = MV - b = 90 - 1 = ₹89

Total Net Proceeds=400×₹89=₹35,600\text{Total Net Proceeds} = 400 \times ₹89 = ₹35,600

Step 2: Compute initial annual dividend income from OldCorp.

Ds1=8% of ₹100=₹8D_{s1} = 8\% \text{ of } ₹100 = ₹8

Initial Annual Income=400×₹8=₹3,200\text{Initial Annual Income} = 400 \times ₹8 = ₹3,200

Step 3: Determine shares of NewTech acquired.

  • NewTech FV=₹50FV = ₹50, MV=₹70MV = ₹70, Brokerage on buy =₹1= ₹1

Effective Cost per share=MV+b=70+1=₹71\text{Effective Cost per share} = MV + b = 70 + 1 = ₹71

n2=Total ProceedsCost per share=₹35,600₹71=500 sharesn_2 = \frac{\text{Total Proceeds}}{\text{Cost per share}} = \frac{₹35,600}{₹71} = 500\text{ shares}

Step 4: Compute new annual dividend income from NewTech.

Ds2=12% of FV2=12% of ₹50=₹6D_{s2} = 12\% \text{ of } FV_2 = 12\% \text{ of } ₹50 = ₹6

New Annual Income=n2×Ds2=500×₹6=₹3,000\text{New Annual Income} = n_2 \times D_{s2} = 500 \times ₹6 = ₹3,000

Step 5: Calculate net change in annual income.

ΔIncome=New Income−Initial Income=₹3,000−₹3,200=−₹200\Delta \text{Income} = \text{New Income} - \text{Initial Income} = ₹3,000 - ₹3,200 = -₹200

Her annual dividend income decreases by ₹200200 (a 6.25%6.25\% reduction).

Takeaway: In portfolio switching, subtract brokerage on sale (₹90 - ₹1 = ₹89) and add brokerage on purchase (₹70 + ₹1 = ₹71). Check final net cash flow carefully.

Practice questions

Question 1 · Moderate

An investor allocates ₹1,44,0001,44,000 across two dividend-paying equities:

  • Company Alpha: Shares with Face Value ₹100100 paying a 12%12\% annual dividend, quoting at a Market Value of ₹150150.

  • Company Beta: Shares with Face Value ₹5050 paying an 18%18\% annual dividend, quoting at a Market Value of ₹7575.

If the investor achieves an overall annual dividend yield of 11.0%11.0\% on the combined investment, what amount was invested in Company Beta?

  1. A

    ₹72,000

  2. B

    ₹96,000

  3. C

    ₹1,08,000

  4. D

    ₹1,12,000

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) ₹1,08,000

Effective yield of Alpha is Yα=12%×100150×100%=12150×100%=8.0%Y_{\alpha} = \frac{12\% \times 100}{150} \times 100\% = \frac{12}{150} \times 100\% = 8.0\%.

Effective yield of Beta is Yβ=18%×5075×100%=975×100%=12.0%Y_{\beta} = \frac{18\% \times 50}{75} \times 100\% = \frac{9}{75} \times 100\% = 12.0\%.

Applying alligation with target yield 11.0%11.0\%: CapitalαCapitalβ=12.0−11.011.0−8.0=1.03.0=13\frac{\text{Capital}_{\alpha}}{\text{Capital}_{\beta}} = \frac{12.0 - 11.0}{11.0 - 8.0} = \frac{1.0}{3.0} = \frac{1}{3}.

Beta represents 31+3=34\frac{3}{1 + 3} = \frac{3}{4} of the total deployed capital.

Capital allocated to Company Beta is 34×₹1,44,000=₹1,08,000\frac{3}{4} \times ₹1,44,000 = ₹1,08,000.

Question 2 · CAT Level

An investor holds 500500 shares of Stock A (Face Value ₹100100, paying a 9%9\% annual dividend), currently quoting at ₹122122. She sells all 500500 shares paying a flat brokerage fee of ₹22 per share on sale. She immediately invests the entire net realization into shares of Stock B (Face Value ₹5050, paying a 16%16\% annual dividend), quoting at ₹9797, paying a flat brokerage fee of ₹33 per share on purchase. What is the net change in her annual dividend income resulting from this portfolio switch?

  1. A

    Decreased by ₹200

  2. B

    Increased by ₹250

  3. C

    Increased by ₹300

  4. D

    Increased by ₹450

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) Increased by ₹300

Net realization per share of Stock A on sale is MVA−b=₹122−₹2=₹120MV_A - b = ₹122 - ₹2 = ₹120, yielding total proceeds of 500×120=₹60,000500 \times 120 = ₹60,000.

Initial annual dividend income from Stock A is 500×(9%×100)=500×₹9=₹4,500500 \times (9\% \times 100) = 500 \times ₹9 = ₹4,500.

Effective purchase cost per share of Stock B is MVB+b=₹97+₹3=₹100MV_B + b = ₹97 + ₹3 = ₹100, enabling acquisition of 60,000100=600 shares\frac{60,000}{100} = 600\text{ shares}.

New annual dividend income from Stock B is 600×(16%×50)=600×₹8=₹4,800600 \times (16\% \times 50) = 600 \times ₹8 = ₹4,800.

The net change in annual dividend income is ₹4,800−₹4,500=+₹300₹4,800 - ₹4,500 = +₹300 (an increase of ₹300300).

Question 3 · CAT Level

A financial analyst compares two dividend-paying equities for an institutional portfolio:

  • Stock Alpha: Face Value ₹100100, paying an 18%18\% annual dividend, currently trading at ₹150150.

  • Stock Beta: Face Value ₹2020, paying a 24%24\% annual dividend.

At what market price must Stock Beta trade on the exchange so that an investor earns the exact same percentage return (yield) on investment from both stocks?

  1. A

    ₹36

  2. B

    ₹40

  3. C

    ₹44

  4. D

    ₹48

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) ₹40

Dividend earned per share of Stock Alpha is Dα=18% of ₹100=₹18D_{\alpha} = 18\% \text{ of } ₹100 = ₹18.

Effective yield on Stock Alpha is Yα=DαMVα×100%=18150×100%=12.0%Y_{\alpha} = \frac{D_{\alpha}}{MV_{\alpha}} \times 100\% = \frac{18}{150} \times 100\% = 12.0\%.

Dividend earned per share of Stock Beta is Dβ=24% of ₹20=₹4.80D_{\beta} = 24\% \text{ of } ₹20 = ₹4.80.

For equal investment yields, set DβMVβ=0.12  ⟹  4.80MVβ=0.12\frac{D_{\beta}}{MV_{\beta}} = 0.12 \implies \frac{4.80}{MV_{\beta}} = 0.12.

Solving for Market Value of Beta: MVβ=4.800.12=₹40MV_{\beta} = \frac{4.80}{0.12} = ₹40.

Question 4 · CAT Level

An investor purchases 400400 shares of an engineering firm (FV=₹100FV = ₹100) quoting at ₹118118, paying a transaction brokerage of ₹22 per share on purchase. During the holding year, the company declares a 14%14\% annual dividend. At the end of the year, the investor sells all shares at ₹148148, paying a transaction brokerage of ₹22 per share on sale. What is the investor's total percentage return (yield plus capital gain) on the invested capital?

  1. A

    28.50%

  2. B

    30.00%

  3. C

    33.33%

  4. D

    36.67%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 33.33\%

Effective purchase cost per share is MVbuy+b=₹118+₹2=₹120MV_{\text{buy}} + b = ₹118 + ₹2 = ₹120.

Annual dividend received per share is 14% of FV=14%×₹100=₹1414\% \text{ of } FV = 14\% \times ₹100 = ₹14.

Net realization per share on sale is MVsell−b=₹148−₹2=₹146MV_{\text{sell}} - b = ₹148 - ₹2 = ₹146.

Capital gain per share is ₹146−₹120=₹26₹146 - ₹120 = ₹26, giving total profit per share of ₹14+₹26=₹40₹14 + ₹26 = ₹40.

Total percentage return on invested capital is ₹40₹120×100%=13×100%=33.33%\frac{₹40}{₹120} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{3} \times 100\% = 33.33\%.

Question 5 · CAT Level

A shareholder owns 1,2001,200 shares of Firm PP (Face Value ₹100100, paying an 8%8\% annual dividend), currently quoting at ₹9090. The shareholder sells a portion of these shares and deploys the entire proceeds to purchase shares of Firm QQ (Face Value ₹5050, paying a 12%12\% annual dividend), currently quoting at ₹6060. Assuming zero brokerage, how many shares of Firm PP must be sold so that the investor's total annual dividend income increases by ₹960960?

  1. A

    720\text{ shares}

  2. B

    800\text{ shares}

  3. C

    960\text{ shares}

  4. D

    1,050\text{ shares}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 960 shares

For each share of Firm PP sold at MVP=₹90MV_P = ₹90, the dividend income foregone is DP=8%×100=₹8D_P = 8\% \times 100 = ₹8.

Selling one share of Firm PP generates ₹9090, which purchases 9060=1.5\frac{90}{60} = 1.5 shares of Firm QQ at MVQ=₹60MV_Q = ₹60.

Dividend earned per share of Firm QQ is DQ=12%×50=₹6D_Q = 12\% \times 50 = ₹6, so 1.51.5 shares yield 1.5×₹6=₹91.5 \times ₹6 = ₹9.

The net income gain per share switched from PP to QQ is ₹9−₹8=₹1₹9 - ₹8 = ₹1 per share.

To increase total annual dividend income by ₹960960, the investor must switch ₹960₹1=960 shares\frac{₹960}{₹1} = 960\text{ shares}.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library