Free CAT library

Product Constancy & The Expenditure-Consumption Rule

Master the Product Constancy theorem when P = A x B is fixed, the expenditure-consumption see-saw, speed-time relations, and solving physical quantity-price problems in one line.

1. The Story & Mental Model: The Fixed Budget Squeeze

Imagine managing monthly household finances. You have a strictly fixed monthly petrol budget of ₹6,0006,000. One morning, international crude prices spike, and petrol prices shoot up by 25%25\%.

Because your bank account does not expand with the petrol pump, your expenditure is locked:

Expenditure (E)=Price per Liter (P)×Consumption in Liters (C)\text{Expenditure } (E) = \text{Price per Liter } (P) \times \text{Consumption in Liters } (C)

If PP expands, CC must shrink to keep the product EE constant. This is Product Constancy—the fundamental governing principle of all two-variable multiplicative systems in arithmetic.


2. The CAT Question Blueprint: The Multiplicative Product Family

In CAT and IPMAT, Product Constancy is not confined to shopping carts. It governs a vast spectrum of word problems across arithmetic and geometry:

  1. Household Finance: Expenditure=Price×Consumption\text{Expenditure} = \text{Price} \times \text{Consumption}

  2. Kinematics (TSD): Distance=Speed×Time\text{Distance} = \text{Speed} \times \text{Time}

  3. Time and Work: Total Work=Workers×Days\text{Total Work} = \text{Workers} \times \text{Days}

  4. Corporate Revenue: Total Revenue=Ticket Price×Footfall\text{Total Revenue} = \text{Ticket Price} \times \text{Footfall}

  5. Geometry: Area of Rectangle=Length×Breadth\text{Area of Rectangle} = \text{Length} \times \text{Breadth}

The question will fix the product (or modify it by a secondary percentage) and ask for the percentage change in one factor, or give a physical difference (e.g. "enables buying 5 kg5\text{ kg} less").


3. The Single Tactical Weapon: The Product Constancy Shift

When P=A×B=ConstantP = A \times B = \text{Constant}:

If factor A increases by +ab  ⟹  factor B must decrease by −aa+b\text{If factor } A \text{ increases by } +\frac{a}{b} \implies \text{factor } B \text{ must decrease by } -\frac{a}{a+b}

If factor A decreases by −ab  ⟹  factor B must increase by +ab−a\text{If factor } A \text{ decreases by } -\frac{a}{b} \implies \text{factor } B \text{ must increase by } +\frac{a}{b-a}

When the Product Itself Changes by k%k\%:

If the product is not constant, but changes by multiplier MPM_P:

MP=MA×MB  ⟹  MB=MPMAM_P = M_A \times M_B \implies M_B = \frac{M_P}{M_A}

The Physical Quantity & Rupee Shortcut:

A classic CAT question type states: "A reduction of x%x\% in the price enables a buyer to purchase K kgK\text{ kg} more for ₹TT".

Instead of setting up quadratic equations:

Current (Reduced) Price per kg=Total Budget T×x100K\text{Current (Reduced) Price per kg} = \frac{\text{Total Budget } T \times \frac{x}{100}}{K}

Original Price per kg=Current Price1−x100\text{Original Price per kg} = \frac{\text{Current Price}}{1 - \frac{x}{100}}


4. The Classic Exam Trap & Speed Shortcut

The Linear Substitution Trap:

Setting up two simultaneous equations P1C1=600P_1 C_1 = 600 and P2C2=600P_2 C_2 = 600 and solving quadratic equations. In an exam with 120 seconds per question, this consumes 4 minutes!

  • The Product Constancy fraction rule yields the answer in 10 seconds.
  • E.g., Price +25%=+14  ⟹  +25\% = +\frac{1}{4} \implies Consumption drops by −15=−20%-\frac{1}{5} = -20\%. Done!

Formulas

Product Constancy Shift

A↑+ab  ⟺  B↓−aa+b(A×B=Constant)A \uparrow +\frac{a}{b} \iff B \downarrow -\frac{a}{a+b} \quad (A \times B = \text{Constant})

Maintains fixed expenditure, distance, area, or work
Variable Product Multiplier

MB=MPMA=1±%ΔP1001±%ΔA100M_B = \frac{M_P}{M_A} = \frac{1 \pm \frac{\%\Delta P}{100}}{1 \pm \frac{\%\Delta A}{100}}

Used when expenditure or area also changes
Reduced / Current Price per Unit

Pcurrent=Budget T×x100ΔKP_{\text{current}} = \frac{\text{Budget } T \times \frac{x}{100}}{\Delta K}

Calculates new discounted price directly from rupee savings and extra quantity
Original Price per Unit

Poriginal=Pcurrent1±x100P_{\text{original}} = \frac{P_{\text{current}}}{1 \pm \frac{x}{100}}

Extracts original price before the discount or hike

Traps and tips

  • Spot the product: Ask yourself, 'Is Variable 1 * Variable 2 = Constant?' If yes, apply the reciprocal shift immediately.
  • The 'Savings Buys Extra' intuition: If price drops by 20%, you save 20% of your budget. That saved cash is what buys the extra kg!
  • Kinematics: If speed increases by 25% (+1/4), time drops by 20% (-1/5) for constant distance.
  • Rectangle dimensions: If length increases by 50% (+1/2), breadth must decrease by 33.33% (-1/3) to keep area constant.

Solved examples

Example 6.1: Classic Fuel Price Hike and Consumption Cut

Due to geopolitical supply constraints, the retail price of petrol increases by 25%25\%. By what percentage must a motorist reduce monthly fuel consumption so that the total monthly fuel expenditure remains strictly unchanged?

Show solution

Step 1: Identify the multiplicative relationship.

Expenditure (E)=Price (P)×Consumption (C)\text{Expenditure } (E) = \text{Price } (P) \times \text{Consumption } (C)

Here, EE is held strictly constant.

Step 2: Express price increase as a fraction.

Price increase=+25%=+14\text{Price increase} = +25\% = +\frac{1}{4}

Step 3: Apply the product constancy rule (+1n→−1n+1+\frac{1}{n} \to -\frac{1}{n+1}).

With n=4n = 4:

Consumption drop=−14+1=−15\text{Consumption drop} = -\frac{1}{4+1} = -\frac{1}{5}

Step 4: Convert to percentage.

−15×100%=−20%-\frac{1}{5} \times 100\% = -20\%

The motorist must reduce fuel consumption by 20%20\%.

Takeaway: When expenditure is fixed, a +25% (+1/4) price hike forces an exact -20% (-1/5) drop in consumption.

Example 6.2: Awkward Fraction Electricity Tariff Surge

A commercial manufacturing facility faces an increase of 37.5%37.5\% in industrial electricity tariffs per kilowatt-hour (kWhkWh). To ensure that the total monthly electricity bill does not exceed the sanctioned budget, by what percentage must the plant curtail its electricity consumption in kWhkWh?

Show solution

Step 1: Convert the tariff increase to a fraction.

+37.5%=+38+37.5\% = +\frac{3}{8}

Here, a=3a = 3 and b=8b = 8.

Step 2: Apply the product constancy shift (+ab→−aa+b+\frac{a}{b} \to -\frac{a}{a+b}).

Consumption reduction=−33+8=−311\text{Consumption reduction} = -\frac{3}{3 + 8} = -\frac{3}{11}

Step 3: Evaluate in percentage terms.

Since 111=9.0909%\frac{1}{11} = 9.0909\%:

−311=−(3×9.0909%)=−27.27%-\frac{3}{11} = -(3 \times 9.0909\%) = -27.27\%

The facility must curtail power consumption by 27.27%27.27\%.

Takeaway: A +3/8 tariff increase requires a 3/(3+8) = 3/11 = 27.27% reduction in kilowatt-hour consumption.

Example 6.3: Speed-Time Commute Application

An express commuter train increases its operating speed by 20%20\% over its normal schedule to recover lost maintenance time on a fixed 240 km240\text{ km} intercity route. As a result, the journey duration decreases by 15 minutes15\text{ minutes}. Determine the normal scheduled duration of the journey.

Show solution

Step 1: Apply product constancy on Distance=Speed×Time\text{Distance} = \text{Speed} \times \text{Time}.

Distance is constant.

Speed increase=+20%=+15\text{Speed increase} = +20\% = +\frac{1}{5}

  ⟹  Time decrease=−15+1=−16\implies \text{Time decrease} = -\frac{1}{5+1} = -\frac{1}{6}

Step 2: Equate the fractional time drop to physical minutes saved.

16 of Normal Time (Tnormal)=15 minutes\frac{1}{6} \text{ of Normal Time } (T_{\text{normal}}) = 15\text{ minutes}

Tnormal=15×6=90 minutes=1.5 hoursT_{\text{normal}} = 15 \times 6 = 90\text{ minutes} = 1.5\text{ hours}

The normal scheduled journey time is 90 minutes90\text{ minutes}.

Takeaway: A 20% (+1/5) speed hike reduces travel time by 1/6. If 1/6 corresponds to 15 minutes, the original time is 15 6 = 90 minutes.

Example 6.4: When Expenditure Also Increases

The price of edible cooking oil surges by 30%30\%. In response, a family adjusts its household budget, allowing its total spending on cooking oil to increase by 4%4\%. By what percentage did the family's cooking oil consumption change?

Show solution

Step 1: Set up the multiplier product equation.

Expenditure (E)=Price (P)×Consumption (C)\text{Expenditure } (E) = \text{Price } (P) \times \text{Consumption } (C)

ME=MP×MCM_E = M_P \times M_C

Given:

  • ME=1+0.04=1.04M_E = 1 + 0.04 = 1.04

  • MP=1+0.30=1.30M_P = 1 + 0.30 = 1.30

Step 2: Solve for the consumption multiplier (MCM_C).

MC=MEMP=1.041.30=104130M_C = \frac{M_E}{M_P} = \frac{1.04}{1.30} = \frac{104}{130}

Divide numerator and denominator by 2626:

MC=45=0.80M_C = \frac{4}{5} = 0.80

Step 3: Extract the percentage change in consumption.

%ΔC=(0.80−1)×100%=−20%\%\Delta C = (0.80 - 1) \times 100\% = -20\%

The family's cooking oil consumption decreased by 20%20\%.

Takeaway: When expenditure changes too, divide multipliers: MC = ME / MP = 1.04 / 1.30 = 4/5 = 0.80, which is an exact 20% drop.

Example 6.5: Physical Quantity & Rupee Problem

A reduction of 20%20\% in the market price of sugar enables a consumer to purchase 5 kg5\text{ kg} more sugar for a fixed budget of ₹600600. Determine: (a) the reduced price of sugar per kg, and (b) the original price of sugar per kg.

Show solution

Step 1: Understand the economic savings intuition.

The consumer spends ₹600600.

A 20%20\% price cut frees up cash savings:

Cash Saved=20% of ₹600=0.20×600=₹120\text{Cash Saved} = 20\% \text{ of } ₹600 = 0.20 \times 600 = ₹120

This saved cash of ₹120120 is what buys the extra 5 kg5\text{ kg} at the new price!

Step 2: Compute the reduced (current) price per kg.

Preduced=Cash SavedExtra Quantity=₹1205 kg=₹24 per kgP_{\text{reduced}} = \frac{\text{Cash Saved}}{\text{Extra Quantity}} = \frac{₹120}{5\text{ kg}} = ₹24\text{ per kg}

Step 3: Compute the original price per kg.

The reduced price is 80%80\% (1−0.201 - 0.20) of the original price:

Poriginal=Preduced0.80=240.80=₹30 per kgP_{\text{original}} = \frac{P_{\text{reduced}}}{0.80} = \frac{24}{0.80} = ₹30\text{ per kg}

Fractional Verification:

Price −20%=−15  ⟹  -20\% = -\frac{1}{5} \implies Consumption +14+ \frac{1}{4}.

If 14\frac{1}{4} extra =5 kg= 5\text{ kg}, original consumption =20 kg= 20\text{ kg}.

Original price =60020=₹30/kg= \frac{600}{20} = ₹30/\text{kg}. Reduced price =60025=₹24/kg= \frac{600}{25} = ₹24/\text{kg}.

Takeaway: The 20% savings (₹120) directly purchases the extra 5 kg, giving the reduced price as 120 / 5 = ₹24/kg, and original price as 24 / 0.8 = ₹30/kg.

Example 6.6: 2D Geometry Area Product

The length of a rectangular municipal sports ground is increased by 40%40\%, while its width is reduced by 15%15\%. Calculate the net percentage change in the ground's total surface area.

Show solution

Step 1: Express area as a two-factor product.

Area (A)=Length (L)×Width (W)\text{Area } (A) = \text{Length } (L) \times \text{Width } (W)

MA=ML×MWM_A = M_L \times M_W

Step 2: Identify multipliers.

  • ML=1+0.40=1.40M_L = 1 + 0.40 = 1.40

  • MW=1−0.15=0.85M_W = 1 - 0.15 = 0.85

Step 3: Compute the area multiplier.

MA=1.40×0.85M_A = 1.40 \times 0.85

1.40×0.85=1.40×(1−0.15)=1.40−0.21=1.191.40 \times 0.85 = 1.40 \times (1 - 0.15) = 1.40 - 0.21 = 1.19

Step 4: Extract the net percentage change.

%ΔA=(1.19−1)×100%=+19%\%\Delta A = (1.19 - 1) \times 100\% = +19\%

(Formula Check: a+b+ab100=40−15−600100=25−6=+19%a + b + \frac{ab}{100} = 40 - 15 - \frac{600}{100} = 25 - 6 = +19\%).

The ground's total surface area increased by 19%19\%.

Takeaway: Area = Length Width follows the successive multiplier rule: 1.40 0.85 = 1.19, which is a net 19% expansion in area.

Practice questions

Question 1 · CAT Level

A reduction of 25%25\% in the price of imported coffee beans enables a café owner to purchase 6 kg6\text{ kg} more coffee while spending 5%5\% less than the original monthly budget. If the café owner originally spent ₹7,2007,200, what was the original price of the coffee beans per kg?

  1. A

    ₹280\text{ per kg}

  2. B

    ₹300\text{ per kg}

  3. C

    ₹320\text{ per kg}

  4. D

    ₹360\text{ per kg}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) ₹320 per kg

Multipliers for price and expenditure are MP=1−0.25=34M_P = 1 - 0.25 = \frac{3}{4} and ME=1−0.05=0.95=1920M_E = 1 - 0.05 = 0.95 = \frac{19}{20}.

The consumption multiplier is MC=MEMP=19/203/4=1915M_C = \frac{M_E}{M_P} = \frac{19/20}{3/4} = \frac{19}{15}, so the fractional increase in consumption is 1915−1=415\frac{19}{15} - 1 = \frac{4}{15}.

Equating the extra quantity: 415C0=6 kg  ⟹  C0=6×154=22.5 kg\frac{4}{15} C_0 = 6\text{ kg} \implies C_0 = \frac{6 \times 15}{4} = 22.5\text{ kg}.

Original price per kg is P0=Original BudgetC0=₹7,20022.5 kg=₹320 per kgP_0 = \frac{\text{Original Budget}}{C_0} = \frac{₹7,200}{22.5\text{ kg}} = ₹320\text{ per kg}.

Question 2 · CAT Level

The radius of a cylindrical chemical storage tank is increased by 20%20\%, while its height is adjusted such that the total storage volume increases by 8%8\%. By what percentage was the height of the tank increased or decreased?

  1. A

    Decreased by 20%

  2. B

    Decreased by 25%

  3. C

    Decreased by 28%

  4. D

    Increased by 25%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) Decreased by 25\%

Cylinder volume follows the relationship V=πr2h  ⟹  MV=Mr2×MhV = \pi r^2 h \implies M_V = M_r^2 \times M_h.

The radius multiplier is Mr=1+0.20=65M_r = 1 + 0.20 = \frac{6}{5}, so Mr2=3625M_r^2 = \frac{36}{25}.

Given volume multiplier is MV=1+0.08=108100=2725M_V = 1 + 0.08 = \frac{108}{100} = \frac{27}{25}.

Solve for the height multiplier: Mh=MVMr2=27/2536/25=2736=34=0.75M_h = \frac{M_V}{M_r^2} = \frac{27/25}{36/25} = \frac{27}{36} = \frac{3}{4} = 0.75.

Thus, the height was decreased by (1−0.75)×100%=25%(1 - 0.75) \times 100\% = 25\%.

Question 3 · CAT Level

An executive commutes from home to office every day. One morning, due to heavy rainfall, her average driving speed decreases by 28.57%28.57\%. As a result, she arrives at the office 24 minutes24\text{ minutes} later than her usual arrival time. On another morning, she wishes to arrive 10 minutes10\text{ minutes} earlier than her usual arrival time. By what percentage must she increase her average driving speed above her usual speed?

  1. A

    16.67%

  2. B

    20.00%

  3. C

    22.50%

  4. D

    25.00%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 20.00\%

A speed drop of 28.57%=−2728.57\% = -\frac{2}{7} implies a time multiplier of MT=75=1+25M_T = \frac{7}{5} = 1 + \frac{2}{5} via product constancy.

The extra time is 25T0=24 minutes  ⟹  T0=24×52=60 minutes\frac{2}{5} T_0 = 24\text{ minutes} \implies T_0 = \frac{24 \times 5}{2} = 60\text{ minutes} (usual commute duration).

To arrive 10 minutes10\text{ minutes} early, the new travel time is T′=60−10=50 minutesT' = 60 - 10 = 50\text{ minutes}.

The required time multiplier is MT′=5060=56M_T' = \frac{50}{60} = \frac{5}{6}, which requires speed multiplier MS′=65=1+15M_S' = \frac{6}{5} = 1 + \frac{1}{5}.

Therefore, she must increase her speed by 15×100%=20.00%\frac{1}{5} \times 100\% = 20.00\%.

Question 4 · Moderate

Due to a reduction in import duties, the retail price of a specialty alloy falls by 16.67%16.67\%. A manufacturing company increases its procurement such that its total spending on the alloy increases by 25%25\%. Consequently, it procures 150 tonnes150\text{ tonnes} more alloy than its baseline procurement. What was the baseline procurement of the alloy?

  1. A

    250\text{ tonnes}

  2. B

    280\text{ tonnes}

  3. C

    300\text{ tonnes}

  4. D

    350\text{ tonnes}

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (C) 300 tonnes

Multiplier for price is MP=1−16=56M_P = 1 - \frac{1}{6} = \frac{5}{6}, and multiplier for expenditure is ME=1+14=54M_E = 1 + \frac{1}{4} = \frac{5}{4}.

Consumption multiplier satisfies MC=MEMP=5/45/6=64=1.50=32M_C = \frac{M_E}{M_P} = \frac{5/4}{5/6} = \frac{6}{4} = 1.50 = \frac{3}{2}.

The fractional increase in procurement is MC−1=32−1=12M_C - 1 = \frac{3}{2} - 1 = \frac{1}{2}.

Given that the extra procurement is 150 tonnes150\text{ tonnes}, we have 12C0=150 tonnes\frac{1}{2} C_0 = 150\text{ tonnes}.

Baseline procurement is C0=150×2=300 tonnesC_0 = 150 \times 2 = 300\text{ tonnes}.

Question 5 · CAT Level

A commercial bakery spends a total of ₹50,00050,000 every month on sugar and flour, allocating 20%20\% of the budget to sugar and 80%80\% to flour. In a subsequent month, the price of sugar rises by 20%20\% and the bakery cuts its sugar consumption by 33.33%33.33\%. If the price of flour also rises by 20%20\%, by what percentage must the bakery curtail its flour consumption so that its total combined monthly expenditure on sugar and flour remains strictly capped at ₹50,00050,000?

  1. A

    10.0%

  2. B

    12.5%

  3. C

    15.0%

  4. D

    16.67%

Show answer and explanation

Answer: (B) 12.5\%

Initial allocations are Sugar =₹10,000= ₹10,000 (20%20\%) and Flour =₹40,000= ₹40,000 (80%80\%) of the ₹50,00050,000 total budget.

New sugar expenditure is ES′=₹10,000×1.20×(1−13)=₹10,000×0.80=₹8,000E'_S = ₹10,000 \times 1.20 \times \left(1 - \frac{1}{3}\right) = ₹10,000 \times 0.80 = ₹8,000.

Remaining budget available for flour is EF′=₹50,000−₹8,000=₹42,000E'_F = ₹50,000 - ₹8,000 = ₹42,000.

Flour expenditure equation: ₹40,000×1.20×MC,F=₹42,000  ⟹  48,000MC,F=42,000₹40,000 \times 1.20 \times M_{C,F} = ₹42,000 \implies 48,000 M_{C,F} = 42,000.

Solving gives MC,F=4248=78M_{C,F} = \frac{42}{48} = \frac{7}{8}, so flour consumption must be reduced by 1−78=18=12.5%1 - \frac{7}{8} = \frac{1}{8} = 12.5\%.

Try real CAT questions

Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.

Open the concept library