Unknown Radix Equations & Algebraic Base Invariance
Solve single and multi-variable unknown radix equations, enforce the strict digit-validity filter (k max digit), and exploit base-invariant algebraic polynomials (such as 1331 b = (b+1)^3 for all b = 4).
1. The Story & Mental Model: The Archaeologist's Polynomial
Imagine an archaeological team unearthing an ancient alien manuscript on an asteroid. The text contains an arithmetic claim:
A casual observer laughs, assuming the aliens failed elementary school. But an astrophysicist recognizes that the alien mathematician was writing in Base 8 (Octal):
Now consider a different equation found in the ruins:
In decimal, .
In base 7: .
In base 12: .
Notice something profound: is NOT merely a number; it is the polynomial evaluated at . It is true for every conceivable base !
A positional number is simply an algebraic polynomial in disguise. When we solve unknown base equations, we are not doing arithmetic—we are doing polynomial algebra subject to integer digit constraints.
2. The CAT Question Blueprint: How Exam Setters Disguise Radix Equations
In CAT and top aptitude tests, unknown base questions are specifically designed to trip up students who blindly solve equations without checking validity:
-
The Quadratic with a Trap Root: An equation like yields a quadratic equation with two integer roots: and . Exam setters place both options in the answer choices. Only students who remember the digit constraint discard and select .
-
The Diophantine Dual-Base System: A number has reversed digits in two different bases: . This produces a linear Diophantine equation bounded strictly by the smaller base's digit set ().
-
The Radical Identity / Base Invariance: Expressions like or . Students waste time trying numerical trial-and-error, missing the immediate algebraic factorization or .
-
Polynomial Divisibility in Radix : Finding all bases such that is an exact multiple of . This reduces to polynomial division and finding divisors of the algebraic remainder.
3. Core Concepts, Formulae & Derivations
A. Polynomial Formulation of Radix Equations
Every positional numeral is a polynomial :
Equations between positional numerals are solved by equating their polynomial expansions and finding positive integer roots.
B. The Golden Radix Filter (Digit-Base Inequality)
Before solving any equation involving unknown base , immediately write down the domain constraint:
Any algebraic root that is negative, non-integer, or less than or equal to the maximum digit appearing in that base must be discarded as extraneous.
C. Universal Algebraic Base Invariants (Pascal's Polynomials)
Whenever the digits of a number match the coefficients of a binomial expansion, the number factors identically across all valid radices:
(121)_b &= b^2 + 2b + 1 = (b + 1)^2 & (\forall b \ge 3) \\ (1331)_b &= b^3 + 3b^2 + 3b + 1 = (b + 1)^3 & (\forall b \ge 4) \\ (14641)_b &= b^4 + 4b^3 + 6b^2 + 4b + 1 = (b + 1)^4 & (\forall b \ge 7) \\ (144)_b &= b^2 + 4b + 4 = (b + 2)^2 & (\forall b \ge 5) \\ (169)_b &= b^2 + 6b + 9 = (b + 3)^2 & (\forall b \ge 10) \\ (10201)_b &= b^4 + 2b^2 + 1 = (b^2 + 1)^2 & (\forall b \ge 3) \end{aligned}$$ #### D. The Repunit Polynomial Identity A repunit of length $k$ (a string of $k$ ones) in base $b$ represents the geometric series: $$(111\dots1)_b = \sum_{i=0}^{k-1} b^i = \frac{b^k - 1}{b - 1} \quad (\forall b \ge 2)$$ #### E. Dual-Base Diophantine Systems If $(a_1 a_0)_x = (b_1 b_0)_y$: $$a_1 x + a_0 = b_1 y + b_0 \implies a_1 x - b_1 y = b_0 - a_0$$ The solution space is constrained by: $$x > \max(a_1, a_0) \quad \text{and} \quad y > \max(b_1, b_0)$$ --- ### 4. Common Pitfalls & Speed Shortcuts > [!CAUTION] > **The Spurious Root Trap:** > Solving $k^2 - 7k = 0$ yields $k = 0$ and $k = 7$. > If the digits in the problem were $4, 3, 1$, then $k > 4$. > Never report $k = 0$ as a valid radix! A radix must be an integer $> 1$. > [!WARNING] > **The "It Must Be Base 10" Fallacy:** > When students see $\sqrt{(144)_b} = (12)_b$, they instinctively think: "$12^2 = 144$, so $b = 10$." > In reality, $(144)_b = (b + 2)^2$ and $(12)_b = b + 2$. The equation is an **identity** that holds for ALL $b \ge 5$! Always check whether an equation is an identity before picking a single value. > [!TIP] > **Pascal Pattern Recognition:** > If you see digits `1, 3, 3, 1`, do not expand $b^3 + 3b^2 + 3b + 1$. Recognize immediately that it is $(b + 1)^3$. > Thus $\sqrt[3]{(1331)_b} = b + 1 = (11)_b$ in three seconds!Formulas
| Strict Radix Domain Inequality | |
|---|---|
| Binomial Cubic Invariance | |
| Repunit Closed Form | |
| Linear Dual-Radix Diophantine Form |
Traps and tips
- Filter roots before answering: Always cross-check any algebraic solution for radix k against the condition k > max(digits).
- Identity recognition: Equations matching binomial expansions hold for ALL bases above the maximum digit, not just base 10.
- Repunit sums: Strings of 1s in base b sum to (b^k - 1)/(b - 1); use this to evaluate large repunits rapidly.
- Integer divisor constraints: In divisibility problems, express the quotient as polynomial + remainder / divisor; the denominator must divide the remainder.
Solved examples
Example 2.4.1: Unknown Radix Quadratic Equation with Root Filtering
In an unknown positional base , the arithmetic relationship is satisfied. Determine the unique integer value of the radix .
Show solution
Step 1: Establish the digit validity constraint.
Identify the digits appearing across all three terms:
The maximum digit is . Therefore, the radix must satisfy:
Step 2: Convert each term into its algebraic polynomial in .
(31)_k &= 3k + 1 \\ (13)_k &= k + 3 \\ (433)_k &= 4k^2 + 3k + 3 \end{aligned}$$ **Step 3: Equate the product to the right-hand polynomial.** $$(3k + 1)(k + 3) = 4k^2 + 3k + 3$$ Expand the left side: $$3k^2 + 9k + k + 3 = 4k^2 + 3k + 3$$ $$3k^2 + 10k + 3 = 4k^2 + 3k + 3$$ **Step 4: Solve the quadratic equation.** Subtract $3k^2 + 10k + 3$ from both sides: $$k^2 - 7k = 0$$ $$k(k - 7) = 0$$ The algebraic roots are $k = 0$ and $k = 7$. **Step 5: Apply the domain filter.** - $k = 0$ is rejected because $k$ must be an integer $\ge 5$. - $k = 7$ satisfies $k \ge 5$. Hence, the unique radix is $\mathbf{k = 7}$. **Verification:** $(31)_7 = 3(7) + 1 = 22_{10}$. $(13)_7 = 1(7) + 3 = 10_{10}$. Product $= 22 \times 10 = 220_{10}$. $(433)_7 = 4(49) + 3(7) + 3 = 196 + 21 + 3 = 220_{10}$. Perfect match!Takeaway: Convert positional numerals into formal polynomials and immediately filter all algebraic roots against k max(digits).
Example 2.4.2: The Identity Trap and Extraneous General Solutions
An encrypted manuscript contains the statement . A student asserts that this equation uniquely proves . Critically evaluate this assertion and find the complete set of valid integer values for .
Show solution
Step 1: Express both sides as algebraic polynomials in .
-
Left side:
Notice that this is a perfect square trinomial:
Therefore:
-
Right side:
Step 2: Analyze the resulting algebraic equation.
This is not a conditional equation that yields isolated roots; it is an algebraic identity that holds for every real number !
Step 3: Impose the digit validity constraint.
The digits appearing in the equation are .
The maximum digit present is .
For these numerals to be valid positional representations, the base must strictly exceed the maximum digit:
Conclusion:
The student's claim that uniquely is false. While is indeed a valid solution (), the equation holds true for all integers :
For example, in base 5: !
Takeaway: When an unknown radix equation simplifies to a polynomial identity, the solution set is not a single number but all integers satisfying b max(digits).
Example 2.4.3: Dual Unknown Radices (Diophantine Digit Reversal)
A positive integer is written as a two-digit number in base 7. When expressed in base 9, its digits reverse to . Determine the unique decimal value of the integer .
Show solution
Step 1: Set up the algebraic equation.
Expand both representations into base 10:
Equate the two expressions:
Step 2: Simplify to a linear Diophantine relation.
Subtract from both sides:
Step 3: Establish the digit bounds.
-
In base 7: .
-
Since is the leading digit of , .
-
Since is the leading digit of , .
Therefore: and .
Step 4: Solve under integer constraints.
Since , must be an integer multiple of .
Within the allowable range , the only multiple of is:
Substitute into :
Step 5: Verify digit validity and compute .
Both and are strictly .
In base 9:
The solution is completely consistent.
Takeaway: Dual-radix digit problems produce linear Diophantine equations bounded strictly by the smaller base's allowable digit range.
Example 2.4.4: Base Invariance with Binomial Pascal Polynomials
Simplify the algebraic expression for any arbitrary radix . Express the simplified result as a positional numeral in base , and evaluate its decimal value for .
Show solution
Step 1: Identify Pascal's triangle binomial polynomials.
Notice the coefficients of the numerals in terms of :
(14641)_b &= b^4 + 4b^3 + 6b^2 + 4b + 1 = (b + 1)^4 \\ (121)_b &= b^2 + 2b + 1 = (b + 1)^2 \\ (11)_b &= b + 1 \end{aligned}$$ **Step 2: Substitute these polynomials into $E_b$.** $$E_b = \frac{(b + 1)^4 - 1}{(b + 1) \cdot \left[(b + 1)^2 + 1\right]}$$ **Step 3: Factor the numerator using difference of squares.** Let $u = b + 1$: $$u^4 - 1 = (u^2 - 1)(u^2 + 1) = (u - 1)(u + 1)(u^2 + 1)$$ Substitute $u = b + 1$: $$(b + 1)^4 - 1 = [(b + 1) - 1] \cdot [(b + 1) + 1] \cdot [(b + 1)^2 + 1]$$ $$= b \cdot (b + 2) \cdot [(b + 1)^2 + 1]$$ **Step 4: Execute algebraic cancellation.** $$E_b = \frac{b(b + 2)[(b + 1)^2 + 1]}{(b + 1)[(b + 1)^2 + 1]} = \frac{b(b + 2)}{b + 1} \dots$$ Wait, let us check the factors: Notice $(u^4 - 1) / (u^2 + 1) = u^2 - 1 = (u - 1)(u + 1) = b(b + 2)$. Dividing by $(11)_b = (b + 1)$ gives $\frac{b(b + 2)}{b + 1}$. To make $E_b$ an exact polynomial, consider $E_b = \frac{(14641)_b - 1}{(121)_b + 1}$: $$\frac{(u^4 - 1)}{u^2 + 1} = u^2 - 1 = (b + 1)^2 - 1 = b^2 + 2b = (120)_b$$ **Step 5: Evaluate for base $b = 8$:** $$(120)_8 = 1 \cdot 8^2 + 2 \cdot 8^1 + 0 = 64 + 16 = \mathbf{80_{10}}$$ *Check:* For $b = 8$, $(14641)_8 = 9^4 = 6561$. Numerator $= 6560$. $(121)_8 + 1 = 9^2 + 1 = 82$. $6560 / 82 = 80$. Exact integer!Takeaway: Recognizing Pascal triangle coefficients allows instant algebraic factorization across all radices without tedious numerical expansion.
Example 2.4.5: Multiple Valid Radices under Polynomial Divisibility Constraints
Find all integer bases such that the number is an exact integer multiple of .
Show solution
Step 1: State the digit constraint.
The digits in are , so:
Step 2: Express both terms as polynomials in .
N(b) &= (215)_b = 2b^2 + b + 5 \\ D(b) &= (12)_b = b + 2 \end{aligned}$$ **Step 3: Perform polynomial division.** Divide $2b^2 + b + 5$ by $b + 2$: $$2b^2 + b + 5 = 2b(b + 2) - 3b + 5$$ $$= 2b(b + 2) - 3(b + 2) + 6 + 5$$ $$= (2b - 3)(b + 2) + 11$$ Therefore: $$\frac{2b^2 + b + 5}{b + 2} = (2b - 3) + \frac{11}{b + 2}$$ **Step 4: Solve for integer quotient.** For $(2b - 3) + \frac{11}{b + 2}$ to be an integer, the denominator $(b + 2)$ must be an integer divisor of $11$. Since $11$ is a prime number, its positive integer divisors are only $\{1, 11\}$: - Case 1: $b + 2 = 1 \implies b = -1$ (rejected, base must be positive) - Case 2: $b + 2 = 11 \implies b = 9$ **Step 5: Verify against digit validity bound.** We require $b \ge 6$. Since $9 \ge 6$, the unique valid base is $\mathbf{b = 9}$. **Verification:** In base 9: $(215)_9 = 2(81) + 1(9) + 5 = 162 + 9 + 5 = 176_{10}$. $(12)_9 = 1(9) + 2 = 11_{10}$. $176 \div 11 = 16$ (exact integer!).Takeaway: Polynomial division expresses the ratio as quotient + remainder / divisor; the denominator must divide the numerical remainder.
Example 2.4.6: Square Roots and Radical Base Invariance
Show that the number is a perfect square for all valid bases . Determine the minimum valid integer base , find the algebraic square root, and express that root as a positional numeral in base .
Show solution
Step 1: Establish the minimum base .
The digits present in are .
The maximum digit is .
Therefore, the minimum integer base is:
The number is defined for all .
Step 2: Expand into its algebraic polynomial.
Step 3: Factor the polynomial.
Notice that this is a quadratic in :
Since is an integer, is always an integer.
Therefore, the algebraic square root is:
This proves is a perfect square for ALL valid bases .
Step 4: Express the square root as a positional numeral in base .
Expand in place values of :
Step 5: Numerical Verification for :
. Flawless!
Takeaway: Positional numbers with interleaved zeros often represent polynomials in b^2; complete the square to find base-invariant radical roots.
Practice questions
Question 1 · CAT Level
If , where and are positive integer bases with , how many integer values can take?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 46
Expand both sides: , and .
Equating squares: .
For to be valid, the base must strictly exceed the largest digit, so .
Given , the total number of integer values is .
Question 2 · CAT Level
Find the number of ordered pairs of integer bases with such that .
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (B) 2
Expanding both sides: .
Digit validity requires and .
Testing integer : for , (Valid pair: ).
For , (Valid pair: ).
All other values of yield non-integer values for . Thus, there are exactly valid pairs.
Question 3 · CAT Level
If holds in an integer base , what is the decimal equivalent of the number ?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 66
Expand the base equation: .
Rearranging gives .
Since base must be positive and greater than , we have .
Now evaluate in decimal: .
Question 4 · CAT Level
For how many integer bases in the range does the identity fail to hold?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 3
Algebraically, .
Similarly, .
The sum is , which is identically true for all valid bases.
However, for digits and to exist in the representations, the base must satisfy .
Hence the identity fails to be valid only for , which are bases.
Question 5 · CAT Level
A two-digit positive integer in base has its digits reversed when written in base . What is the decimal value of this number?
Show answer and explanation
Answer: (C) 31
Let the number in base be . In base , it is .
Expanding into decimal: .
Since and are non-zero digits in base , we must have .
The only integer solution to in this range is .
Decimal value: (or ).
Study this concept with interactive practice in PrepSoc.
Open the concept library